Key Takeaways
1. Work's True Nature: Beyond Definitions, It's Purposeful, Effortful, and Socially Recognized
To the extent that what we consider to be work informs how much economic value it has, whether it is socially recognized, and how we feel about doing it, determining what is work is inseparable from what work is worth.
Defining work. Work is not merely an activity but a concept deeply intertwined with its perceived value. The authors propose that work generally shares three formal characteristics: it is purposeful, effortful, and recognized by society, often implying it's worth getting paid for. This definition helps distinguish work from leisure or play, even if the lines can blur.
Beyond the obvious. While some work, like manual labor, is clearly effortful and purposeful, its recognition and valuation vary historically and culturally. Ancient thinkers privileged mental activity over physical toil, a bias that persists in the pay disparity between knowledge work and manual labor. However, "bullshit jobs" (pointless, unnecessary paid employment) highlight that not all recognized work is genuinely purposeful, while "shit jobs" (necessary but poorly paid) show that essential work can be devalued.
Unrecognized contributions. Much necessary and effortful work, particularly housework and caregiving, often goes unrecognized and unpaid, largely because it is feminized. This devaluation creates a recursive cycle: not paid because not seen as work, and not seen as work because not paid. Economic forces, alongside historical and cultural norms, heavily influence what society deems "work" and how it's compensated, often failing to reflect its true societal worth.
2. Why We Work: A Complex Tapestry of Needs, Fairness, and Personal Fulfillment
We work, perhaps most often, because we can’t afford not to work.
Beyond the paycheck. While providing for basic needs and family is a primary driver for work, as seen in the 9/11 "Portraits of Grief," money is rarely an end in itself. It's a means to other worthwhile ends like homeownership, supporting loved ones, or funding passions outside of work. The "hedonic treadmill" suggests that increased wealth often leads to only short-term happiness, as we quickly adapt to new circumstances.
Motivation's layers. Psychological theories challenge the simplistic view that more money equals more motivation. Maslow's hierarchy, often misinterpreted as a strict pyramid, suggests that multiple needs can be satisfied simultaneously, and people seek meaning even in dire circumstances. Herzberg's two-factor theory distinguishes between extrinsic factors (pay, benefits) that prevent dissatisfaction, and intrinsic factors (achievement, recognition, growth) that truly motivate and satisfy.
Equity and purpose. Fairness is crucial; we compare our rewards and efforts to others. If we perceive inequity, dissatisfaction arises. The "job, career, calling" typology describes how individuals relate to their work:
- Job: Instrumental, a means to an end (e.g., to live life outside work).
- Career: Focus on advancement and status within a hierarchy.
- Calling: Meaningful end in itself, a passion.
The authors' 9/11 research found that all three orientations could be equally "heroic" and other-oriented, challenging the societal hierarchy that often undervalues jobs and careers compared to callings.
3. The Work-Life Equation: Balancing When and How Much to Work Against Life's Stages
Even if you are not acutely aware that our time on Earth is limited, you face a choice about how to spend your waking hours.
Time's precious balance. The story of Michelle Obama and her friend Suzanne Alele highlights the tension between prioritizing productivity and pleasure. The FIRE (Financial Independence, Retire Early) movement embodies the desire to work intensely early to gain leisure later, but this strategy carries risks, as life's uncertainties (like Suzanne's early death) can negate such plans. Our ability to predict future happiness (affective forecasting) is often flawed, leading us to overestimate the impact of future events.
Life's predictable passages. Gail Sheehy's "Passages" describes predictable life stages, each with unique challenges and opportunities for work and personal growth. While these stages offer a framework, individual paths vary greatly, as exemplified by Kristine Enea's decision to pursue medical school at 53. The "not yet halfway" mindset encourages continuous ambition, contrasting with the "counting down" to retirement.
The overwork dilemma. The traditional "9 to 5" workweek, a legacy of industrialization, persists despite technological advancements. "Time macho" culture glorifies long hours, leading to burnout, workaholism, and negative impacts on health and relationships. Experiments with four-day workweeks show promising results in productivity, well-being, and reduced stress. The pandemic further blurred work-life boundaries, with remote work often leading to more hours, not less, highlighting the need for conscious boundaries and organizational policies that support employee well-being.
4. Love vs. Money: The Market's Imperfect Valuation of Work's Intangible Worth
To confuse wealth with worth is to conflate pleasure with happiness.
The price of illusion. Guy de Maupassant's "The Necklace" illustrates how the pursuit of perceived wealth can lead to a lifetime of misery, highlighting the cruel irony of market value. The story underscores that money, while buying pleasure, doesn't guarantee lasting happiness or true worth. The market for goods like diamonds, influenced by irrational human behavior and marketing, demonstrates that price doesn't always reflect intrinsic value.
Market's leverage. Accounting firms, like Adam Smith's pin factory, operate on a "leverage model" where partners (capitalists) profit from the specialized labor of staff (laborers). This system, driven by "revenue per partner," can lead to high salaries but also intense pressure, long hours, and a conflation of personal worth with financial output, as experienced by Kathleen Gluck. The "golden handcuffs" of high pay can trap individuals in unfulfilling roles.
Undervalued contributions. There's a growing chasm between CEO and average worker pay, and a consistent inverse relationship between a job's societal meaningfulness and its salary. Professions like clergy or teachers, deemed highly meaningful, often earn significantly less than financiers. This pay inequity, exacerbated by factors like the gender pay gap and discrimination, reveals that market compensation is an imperfect, often unfair, indicator of a job's true worth. The "intangible value" of work, like its emotional or symbolic significance, often transcends monetary measure.
5. The Double-Edged Sword of Calling: Passion Can Lead to Fulfillment or Exploitation
Your work is going to fill a large part of your life, and the only way to be truly satisfied is to do what you believe is great work. And the only way to do great work is to love what you do.
The allure of destiny. The concept of a "calling," secularized from its religious origins, promises deep personal fulfillment and is romanticized in popular culture, often linked to figures like Steve Jobs. This ideal suggests that work should be a consuming passion, integral to identity, and worth pursuing at any cost, as exemplified by musician Colin Huggins. This cultural pressure can make those without a clear calling feel like failures.
The dark side of devotion. Research reveals that callings are a "double-edged sword." While they can lead to higher job satisfaction and engagement, they also make individuals vulnerable to exploitation. Strongly called zookeepers, for instance, sacrificed personal well-being and worked unpaid overtime, earning less than their peers, because the "mission" mattered more than compensation. This suggests employers can leverage employees' passion to extract more work for less pay.
Unfulfilled aspirations. The pursuit of a calling can lead to "career tunnel vision," where individuals cling to inflated self-appraisals and ignore advice, resulting in unfulfilled expectations. Paul Gauguin's legendary abandonment of his family for art, while producing masterpieces, highlights the extreme personal cost of an all-consuming calling. For many, "unanswered occupational callings" lead to stress, regret, and lower well-being, sometimes even worse than having no calling at all. However, "job crafting" offers hope, showing how individuals can find meaning even in seemingly mundane roles, like hospital custodians.
6. Essential Work: Society's Most Critical Contributions Often Misalign with Market Value
Essential work should pertain to what society cannot do without, but who decides what we need?
Crisis reveals truth. The COVID-19 pandemic, like 9/11, forced society to confront what truly constitutes "essential work." While health-care workers, food producers, and sanitation staff were deemed critical, their roles often came with significant personal risk and low pay. This designation highlighted a stark contrast between work necessary for survival and work valued by the market or social hierarchy.
Contested values. "Essential work" is an "essentially contested concept," reflecting political and social values. During the pandemic, debates raged over what was truly essential, from meatpacking plants to professional wrestling, revealing that societal needs extend beyond basic survival to include entertainment, social justice, and economic stability. The 9/11 Victim Compensation Fund's formula, tying awards to earning power, further exposed the disparity between the social value of first responders and the economic value of financiers.
Self vs. society. The question of whether to prioritize "self-realization or service to others" in career choice is a long-standing philosophical debate. While the ideal is to achieve both, a world in need often presents a moral imperative to choose service. The "Ant and the Bee" fable illustrates that work benefiting society (like the bee's honey) is often deemed more worthy than work hoarded for personal gain (the ant's food). However, the business world has historically prioritized profit, though there's a growing shift towards "stakeholder capitalism" and "shared value" that seeks to align economic and social progress.
7. Finding Higher Purpose: A Lifelong Quest Beyond Simple Answers and Personal Gain
A purpose worth dying for had best be worth living for.
The promise and pitfalls of purpose. Work can offer a profound sense of purpose, connecting us to something larger than ourselves, as exemplified by Bess Hargreaves's dedication to public interest law. This "objective attractiveness" of worthy work, however, doesn't always align with market rewards, leading to resentment when "do-gooders" are paid a pittance while others profit. The "cult of self-martyrdom" in some purpose-driven fields can lead to burnout and exploitation.
Heroism's daily reality. While heroic professions like firefighting or aid work are alluring due to their self-transcendent nature, the daily reality is often mundane, frustrating, and emotionally taxing. Corporate purpose statements, like those of consulting firms, often promise heroic possibilities ("building a better working world") but can be marketing ploys rather than substantive commitments. True higher purpose, as seen in Welles Crowther's actions on 9/11, often emerges in moments of crisis, transcending professional roles.
The four-question dilemma. A popular model for finding purpose asks: What do you love? What will the market pay for? What are you good at? What does the world need? While each question is valuable, finding a perfect alignment is rare. Stories like Linnea Komba Dahl's (from corporate to chaplaincy), Sawyer Michaelson's (neuroscience to psychometrist), Dennis Curley's (paralegal to musician), and Shawn Wong's (novelist creating Asian American literature) illustrate that purpose is often found in a portfolio of activities over a career, or by making trade-offs, rather than in one ideal job.
8. A World Without Work: The Looming Challenge of Leisure, Meaning, and Identity
If our work gives our lives more meaning, what happens when it goes away? Can something fill this void?
The automated future. For centuries, economists predicted that machines would free humans for leisure. Disney's "Carousel of Progress" optimistically portrays technological advancements leading to a life of convenience, but the rise of AI and automation now poses an existential threat to jobs, particularly lower-paid ones. This future, whether a utopia of leisure or a dystopia of meaninglessness, forces us to consider what we would do if work were no longer a necessity.
The stigma of idleness. In work-obsessed cultures, "doing nothing" or being underemployed is often stigmatized as laziness, contrasting with Depression-era films that glorified unemployment as a path to authentic self-discovery. The "quiet quitting" phenomenon reflects a modern desire to reclaim boundaries, but the cultural pressure to work remains strong. Even high-profile women like Serena Williams and Jacinda Ardern face scrutiny when choosing family over career.
The gig economy's paradox. The gig economy, exemplified by Robert Guest's "bus life" and Turo rentals, offers flexibility and autonomy but often comes with precarity, low pay, and a lack of benefits. While some embrace it for adventure, others are forced into it, blurring the lines between work and leisure. The Marienthal study showed that prolonged unemployment can lead to apathy and a loss of personal will, suggesting that a world without work, if not managed well, could be profoundly destabilizing, requiring societal solutions like universal basic income to ensure meaningful lives.
9. Crafting Your Legacy: Work's Enduring Impact Shapes Who Tells Your Story
Life can only be understood backwards, but it must be lived forwards.
Beyond the epitaph. Legacy is not just about posthumous fame but about the enduring impact of our lives and work. Chad Sokol's journey from a cult's "prophecy mechanic" to a corporate executive and award-winning poet illustrates a self-chosen legacy, distinct from inherited paths. Socrates and Joan of Arc's deaths, integral to their legacies, highlight that how a life ends can define its meaning. Terror management theory suggests that our fear of death motivates us to create legacies through children, faith, or enduring achievements.
The unexamined work. Clayton Christensen's "How Will You Measure Your Life?" urges us to prioritize "eulogy virtues" (character, relationships) over "résumé virtues" (skills, achievements). He argues that true life success is measured by the individuals we help, not by quantifiable metrics. Tolstoy's "The Death of Ivan Ilych" powerfully critiques a life spent pursuing career prestige for the wrong reasons, reducing a man's existence to a "tiny frame" of regret. This underscores that unexamined work, focused solely on external validation, may ultimately prove worthless.
Who tells your story? Eliza Hamilton's story in "Hamilton" emphasizes that legacy is ultimately shaped by "who tells your story," highlighting the power of narratives to define history and individual worth. Our choices about work—its purpose, effort, and recognition—influence not only our own lives but also the world we leave for future generations. A lasting legacy is not just about personal achievement but about contributing value to a world that continues to need work, whether paid or unpaid, essential or inspiring.
Last updated:
Similar Books
