Key Takeaways
1. Fractional Reserve Banking: The Engine of Money Creation
The actual process of money creation takes place primarily in banks.
Banks create money. Contrary to popular belief, money isn't solely printed by the government. In a fractional reserve system, banks play a pivotal role by creating new deposits when they extend loans or make investments. This unique attribute, discovered centuries ago by goldsmiths, allows banks to issue more promises to pay (notes or deposits) than the physical reserves they hold.
Modern money's form. Today, "money" (M1) primarily consists of currency in circulation and checkable deposits at depository institutions. While currency is used for small transactions, the vast majority of payments are made through checks or electronic transfers between deposit accounts. These transaction deposits are the modern equivalent of the goldsmiths' bank notes, representing liabilities of the banking system.
Confidence is key. The value of this money, whether paper currency or book entries, stems from public confidence in its acceptance for goods, services, and debts. Its scarcity relative to its usefulness is what gives it purchasing power. Maintaining this value requires careful control over the quantity of money in circulation, ensuring it aligns with the economy's output to prevent inflation or deflation.
2. The Federal Reserve: Master of the Monetary Base
The major control, however, rests with the central bank.
Central bank's role. While banks create deposit money, the Federal Reserve System, as the central bank, holds the ultimate control over the total amount of reserves in the banking system. These reserves, comprising vault cash and deposits at the Fed, are often called "high-powered money" or the "monetary base" because they underpin a much larger volume of deposit liabilities.
Influencing the system. The Fed influences banks' decisions regarding assets and deposits by varying both the total volume of reserves and the required ratio of reserves to deposit liabilities. Its primary responsibility is to provide the total amount of reserves consistent with the economy's monetary needs, aiming for stable prices and considering changes in money usage and public demand for cash.
Reserves are liabilities. Crucially, bank reserves are, for the most part, liabilities of the Federal Reserve Banks. This means the Fed can effectively create or destroy these reserves through its actions, thereby setting the foundation for the banking system's capacity to expand or contract the money supply.
3. Open Market Operations: The Fed's Primary Lever
One way the central bank can initiate such an expansion is through purchases of securities in the open market.
Direct reserve impact. Open market operations, the buying and selling of government securities by the Federal Reserve, are the most frequent and flexible tool the Fed uses to manage bank reserves. When the Fed buys securities, it pays by crediting the seller's bank account and simultaneously crediting that bank's reserve account at the Fed, directly injecting new reserves into the banking system.
Contraction in reverse. Conversely, when the Fed sells securities, the buyer pays from their bank account, leading to a debit in that bank's reserve account at the Fed. This action directly withdraws reserves from the banking system, initiating a contractionary process. These operations are often conducted to offset other factors affecting reserves or to achieve specific monetary policy objectives.
Electronic transactions. In today's financial landscape, these transactions are largely electronic. The Fed's payment for securities is an "electronic check" that instantly credits the dealer's bank account and the bank's reserve account. This seamless digital process underscores the direct and immediate impact of open market operations on the banking system's reserve levels.
4. The Multiplier Effect: How Banks Expand Money
The multiple expansion is possible because the banks as a group are like one large bank in which checks drawn against borrowers' deposits result in credits to accounts of other depositors, with no net change in the total reserves.
Fractional reserves enable expansion. The magic of money creation lies in the fractional reserve system. Banks are only required to hold a fraction (e.g., 10%) of their deposits as reserves. When the Fed injects new reserves, banks find themselves with "excess reserves" – funds beyond what's legally required. These excess reserves earn no interest, creating a strong incentive for banks to lend or invest them.
Loans create deposits. When a bank with excess reserves makes a loan, it doesn't pay out existing money; instead, it credits the borrower's transaction account. This act simultaneously increases the bank's assets (loans) and liabilities (deposits), effectively creating new money in the banking system. The borrower then spends this newly created deposit, which eventually lands in another bank.
Chain reaction. As the funds move through the banking system, each receiving bank retains a portion as required reserves and lends out the remaining excess. This process continues, stage after stage, with each loan creating new deposits, until the initial injection of reserves is fully absorbed as required reserves against a much larger volume of new deposits. Under a 10% reserve requirement, $10,000 in new reserves can theoretically support $100,000 in new deposits.
5. Money Contraction: The Reverse, Often Mandatory Process
But when the System acts to reduce the amount of bank reserves, contraction of credit and deposits must take place...
Reserve drain initiates contraction. Just as reserve injections fuel expansion, reserve drains trigger contraction. When the Federal Reserve sells securities, it removes reserves from the banking system. The bank whose customer buys the securities loses both deposits and reserves. This loss of reserves creates a reserve deficiency for that bank, as the reduction in deposits only frees a fraction of the reserves lost.
Forced adjustment. Unlike expansion, which is optional (banks may lend excess reserves), contraction is often mandatory. Banks facing reserve deficiencies must acquire reserves or reduce their need for them. They typically do this by selling securities or reducing new loans, which in turn reduces deposits in other banks, propagating the contraction throughout the system.
Cumulative effect. The contraction process mirrors expansion in its cumulative nature. A $10,000 reduction in reserves, with a 10% reserve requirement, can ultimately lead to a $100,000 reduction in total deposits and $90,000 in loans and investments. While banks prefer to sell securities first, they may also cease making new loans or renewing maturing ones, allowing deposits to be extinguished as loans are repaid.
6. Public & Treasury Actions: Unintended Reserve Shifts
It is apparent that bank reserves are affected in several ways that are independent of the control of the central bank.
External influences. Beyond the Federal Reserve's direct policy actions, several "independent" factors can significantly impact bank reserves. These include actions by the public, the U.S. Treasury Department, and foreign institutions. These factors can cause fluctuations in reserves that are often temporary or seasonal, but still require the Fed's attention.
Treasury's impact. The U.S. Treasury's management of its cash balances is a notable independent factor. When the Treasury transfers funds from commercial banks (Treasury Tax and Loan accounts) to its accounts at the Federal Reserve, it drains reserves from the banking system. Conversely, when the Treasury spends these funds, they flow back into commercial banks, increasing reserves.
Fed's offsetting role. Because these independent factors can cause abrupt and undesired changes in credit availability, the Federal Reserve continuously monitors them. The Fed often undertakes open market operations to "offset" or "sterilize" these fluctuations, ensuring that the net reserve effects align with its monetary policy objectives.
7. Currency Flows: A Constant Dance with Bank Reserves
When deposits, which are fractional reserve money, are exchanged for currency, which is 100 percent reserve money, the banking system experiences a net reserve drain.
Currency drain. When the public withdraws currency from banks (e.g., cashing a check for a holiday), bank deposits decrease, and the bank's vault cash (a form of reserve) also decreases. If the bank replenishes its vault cash from the Federal Reserve, its reserve account at the Fed is debited. This exchange is critical: a $100 deposit only required $10 in reserves, but a $100 currency withdrawal drains a full $100 of reserves, creating a reserve deficiency.
Reserve deficiency. This direct, dollar-for-dollar drain on reserves means that a currency withdrawal can quickly lead to a reserve shortfall for banks. Unless new reserves are provided, this deficiency can trigger a multiple contraction of deposits, as banks are forced to reduce assets to meet their reserve requirements.
Currency return. The reverse happens when currency returns to banks. Deposits and vault cash increase. If the currency is sent to the Federal Reserve, bank reserve accounts are credited. This influx of reserves, with only a fraction required against the new deposits, creates excess reserves that can support further deposit expansion. The Fed typically offsets these currency-driven reserve changes to maintain monetary stability.
8. The Discount Window: Banks' Temporary Reserve Lifeline
When a bank borrows from a Federal Reserve Bank, it borrows reserves.
Temporary reserve acquisition. The discount window allows depository institutions to borrow reserves directly from the Federal Reserve. Banks typically use this "adjustment credit" to cover temporary reserve deficiencies or overdrafts, often arising from unexpected deposit outflows or prior lending that outpaced reserve availability.
Not for expansion. Unlike reserves injected through open market operations, discount window borrowing is generally not intended to create excess reserves for new lending. Instead, it provides a safety valve, allowing individual banks to meet their reserve requirements without immediately liquidating assets or calling in loans, which could disrupt financial markets.
Fed's control. While banks initiate borrowing, the Federal Reserve controls the amount and conditions of these loans through its administration of the discount window and by setting the discount rate. A higher discount rate makes borrowing more expensive, discouraging banks from relying on this source of funds and encouraging them to seek reserves elsewhere or reduce their lending.
9. Reserve Requirements: Shaping the Money Multiplier's Power
The authority to vary required reserve percentages for banks... is an instrument of monetary policy.
Direct leverage. Changing the required reserve percentage is a powerful monetary policy tool that directly alters the banking system's capacity for deposit expansion or contraction. It doesn't change the total dollar volume of reserves but changes how much deposit money those reserves can support.
Lowering requirements. When the Fed lowers reserve requirements, a portion of banks' existing required reserves instantly becomes excess reserves. These newly freed reserves can then be loaned or invested, initiating a multiple expansion of deposits throughout the banking system. For example, reducing the requirement from 10% to 8% frees up $2 for every $10 of reserves previously held.
Raising requirements. Conversely, an increase in reserve requirements absorbs additional reserve funds. Banks that were fully loaned up will suddenly face a reserve deficiency, forcing them to acquire more reserves or reduce their loans and investments to comply. This action can lead to a significant contraction of the money supply. Because of its broad and immediate impact, changes in reserve requirements are used infrequently.
10. Global Interplay: Foreign Transactions and Reserve Management
The key point to remember, however, is that the Federal Reserve routinely offsets any undesired change in U.S. bank reserves resulting from foreign-related transactions.
Intervention's initial impact. When the Federal Reserve intervenes in foreign exchange markets, for instance, by selling dollars for its own account, it acquires foreign currency assets and initially increases U.S. bank reserves. Conversely, buying dollars reduces U.S. bank reserves. These transactions, whether for the Fed's account or the Treasury's Exchange Stabilization Fund, directly affect the domestic monetary base.
Treasury's financing. The U.S. Treasury's foreign-related transactions also influence reserves. For example, if the Treasury finances an intervention sale of dollars by calling on Treasury Tax and Loan accounts at commercial banks, the reserve drain from the call can offset the reserve injection from the intervention, leading to no net change in bank reserves.
Sterilization is key. Despite these potential impacts, the Federal Reserve routinely "sterilizes" or offsets any undesired changes in U.S. bank reserves stemming from foreign-related transactions. This ensures that international financial operations do not inadvertently disrupt domestic monetary policy objectives or cause unwanted fluctuations in money and credit growth.
11. The Dynamic Multiplier: Why Money Creation Isn't Always Simple
Such an assumption is an oversimplification of the actual relationship between changes in reserves and changes in money, especially in the short-run.
Real-world complexities. The theoretical money multiplier, based on a fixed reserve-to-deposit ratio, is a simplification. In reality, the relationship between changes in reserves and changes in the money supply is dynamic and subject to several "slippages" that cause the multiplier to vary, especially in the short term.
Key slippages:
- Excess reserves: Banks don't always lend out all their excess reserves, holding some for liquidity or due to lack of loan demand. If new reserves are offset by rising excess reserves, actual money growth falls short of the theoretical maximum.
- Currency conversions: Public preferences for holding currency versus deposits constantly shift. A conversion of deposits to currency drains reserves dollar-for-dollar, while a deposit only required a fraction of reserves.
- Differing reserve ratios: While simplified, reserve requirements can still vary by institution size or type of liability, affecting how reserves are utilized across the banking system.
- Non-money liabilities: Shifts between transaction deposits (money) and other reservable liabilities (not money) can also influence the effective multiplier.
Policy implications. These variations mean that the Federal Reserve cannot always predict the precise impact of its reserve actions on the money supply. The time lag between policy action and its effect, combined with these slippages, makes monetary policy implementation a continuous process of monitoring and adjustment.
Last updated:
Similar Books
