Start free trial
Trending New Genres Authors
EnglishEnglish
EspañolSpanish
简体中文Chinese
繁體中文Chinese (Traditional)
FrançaisFrench
DeutschGerman
日本語Japanese
PortuguêsPortuguese
ItalianoItalian
한국어Korean
РусскийRussian
NederlandsDutch
العربيةArabic
PolskiPolish
हिन्दीHindi
Tiếng ViệtVietnamese
SvenskaSwedish
ΕλληνικάGreek
TürkçeTurkish
ไทยThai
ČeštinaCzech
RomânăRomanian
MagyarHungarian
УкраїнськаUkrainian
IndonesiaIndonesian
DanskDanish
SuomiFinnish
БългарскиBulgarian
עבריתHebrew
NorskNorwegian
HrvatskiCroatian
CatalàCatalan
SlovenčinaSlovak
LietuviųLithuanian
SlovenščinaSlovenian
СрпскиSerbian
EestiEstonian
LatviešuLatvian
فارسیPersian
മലയാളംMalayalam
தமிழ்Tamil
اردوUrdu
Searching...
SoBrief
One Good Thing

One Good Thing

A Jewish woman shelters her friend's son as Nazi raids close in across wartime Italy.
by Georgia Hunter 2025 432 pages
4.26
15k+ ratings
Listen
Immersive
V2.3
Amazon Kindle Audible
Try Full Access for 3 Days
Unlock listening & more!
Continue

Plot Summary

Prologue

Lili runs through the woods with a small boy as bullets strike the trees around them. She and the others had risked leaving the forest to search an abandoned garden, finding only a few potatoes before gunfire scattered the group. Lili grips the child’s hand and keeps moving, injured and exhausted but unable to stop.

The scene gives no explanation yet for who is hunting them or why the boy depends on her. It opens on the physical truth of their lives: survival will require motion, vigilance, and a bond strong enough to carry a child through danger.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The prologue makes flight the story’s first condition, then withholds the history that produced it. Lili’s attention is narrowed to the boy’s hand, the ground underfoot, and the next stretch of cover. That focus turns danger into an intimate task rather than a distant historical spectacle. The child’s dependence also quietly reverses the expectations of the story that follows: Lili begins as a young woman who plans carefully, but the opening shows her already acting as someone responsible for another life. The narrative’s central question is not whether fear exists, but what care makes a person do while afraid.

Theo Arrives Under Fascism

Lili and Esti welcome a child as Jewish rights shrink

In December 1940, Lili Passigli stays beside her closest friend, Esti Ezratti, through a long labor in Ferrara. Esti’s Greek husband, Niko, arrives in time to meet their healthy son, Theo, while Lili shares the first hours of the new family. Their joy sits uneasily beside Italy’s Racial Laws, which already restrict Jewish life and have made Lili question whether the danger will pass.

Her friendship with Esti began at university, where the reserved aspiring writer found a bold, affectionate companion who became like a sister. When the baby sleeps against his mother, Esti admits she fears the world he has entered. Lili reassures her, but the restrictions are no longer an argument in the abstract: they are shaping the family’s future.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Theo’s birth establishes the story’s emotional stakes before persecution becomes immediate. Lili’s reassurance is sincere, but it also reveals how she manages fear: she uses planning, precedent, and hope to make uncertainty feel temporary. Esti’s unease is more anticipatory. She understands that a child’s vulnerability makes political danger personal, while Lili still believes the laws can be endured. Their different temperaments are not merely contrasting personalities; they become competing survival strategies. The friendship works because neither approach wholly replaces the other. Esti’s courage can move Lili beyond caution, while Lili’s steadiness can keep Esti’s anger from becoming reckless.

A Reservation Refused

Public hatred reaches Lili’s home and holiday memories

In Bologna, Lili visits her father, Massimo, whose property business survives only because a Catholic friend holds the deeds while Massimo secretly keeps the books. At a cinema, father and daughter sit through an anti-Semitic film as hostile notes fall from the balcony and the audience cheers the Jewish character’s death.

Months later, Lili and Esti drive to Rimini for a rare weekend away, but the hotel rejects Lili after seeing the Jewish stamp on her identity card. Esti confronts the clerk; Lili pulls her away before their protest draws the police.

On the drive home, Lili insists that public defiance could endanger Esti and Theo. Esti agrees to temper her outbursts, though the humiliation has shown them that exclusion is no longer confined to laws or newspapers.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

These episodes turn state policy into ordinary social behavior. The cinema audience and the hotel clerk make persecution visible not as a single decree but as a chain of choices by people who can deny, mock, or threaten their neighbors. Lili’s response is protective and tactical: she tries to control where and how danger can reach her friends. Esti’s protest refuses the moral bargain of appearing compliant. Neither response is simply right or wrong. The scene in the car makes their disagreement consequential, because Esti’s expressive resistance must now be weighed against Theo’s safety. The new burden of parenthood does not silence her convictions, but it changes what those convictions may cost.

The Synagogue Is Raided

Niko’s rage brings police attention to his door

During Rosh Hashanah in Ferrara, Fascists break into the synagogue, seize sacred scrolls, fire a pistol, and drag away the rabbi. Niko, already distraught by reports from his occupied hometown of Salonica, attacks one of the raiders and puts the stolen gun to the young man’s head before police pull him away.

Weeks later, the carabinieri arrive with a warrant accusing Niko of communism. He escapes to Bari, hoping to reach Greece and rescue his parents. Esti then tells Lili what she has concealed: she is helping the underground forge identity papers, using her photography skills to make false documents for Jews in danger. Esti asks Lili to house her and Theo and help care for the child. Hurt by the secrecy but unwilling to abandon her friend, Lili agrees.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The synagogue raid changes the conflict from exclusion to direct physical threat, and Niko’s violence exposes how grief and helplessness can break through a person’s self-command. His departure is both a response to police pursuit and an attempt to reclaim agency by helping his family. Esti’s disclosure complicates the intimacy between the women: she withheld information to protect Lili, but that protection also deprived Lili of the chance to choose her own risk. Lili’s agreement marks a shift from friendship as emotional refuge to friendship as shared responsibility. She does not suddenly become fearless. She chooses involvement despite fear, which is a more credible form of courage.

Villa Emma Becomes Refuge

Lili joins Esti to shelter Jewish children in Nonantola

By September 1942, Esti’s underground work has expanded beyond forged papers. Delasem asks her to help at Villa Emma in Nonantola, where Jewish refugee children from across Europe have found temporary shelter.

Lili leaves her Ferrara apartment with Esti and Theo, taking only a few possessions and moving into cramped rooms near the villa. She tutors the children and works at a blacksmith’s shop while Esti makes identity cards. Local residents bring food, clothes, and toys, accepting the story that the children are church dependents.

When news arrives that Salonica’s Jews have been rounded up, Esti still cannot reach Niko or his family. The uncertainty deepens, but the work at Villa Emma gives both women a concrete task: keep the children fed, hidden, and ready to move if the danger reaches them.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Villa Emma offers a fragile alternative to helpless waiting. The women cannot control what happens in Salonica, but they can help children who have reached their doorstep. This distinction matters psychologically: action does not erase grief, yet it gives grief a direction. Lili’s life contracts into work, care, and coded letters, while Esti’s ability to make documents turns a practical skill into an instrument of rescue. Nonantola’s local generosity complicates any simple division between a hostile society and a heroic one. Trust is built through repeated small acts, but the safety it creates remains conditional, dependent on secrecy and on neighbors who decide not to look too closely.

The Children Disappear

After Italy’s surrender, volunteers hide seventy-two refugees

Mussolini’s fall briefly fills Nonantola’s streets with celebration, but Badoglio’s surrender to the Allies brings German troops toward the village. Goffredo Pacifici, who helped smuggle the refugee children into Italy, learns that the Wehrmacht may arrive by morning.

The volunteers divide the children among local homes and the abbey, moving them under cover of darkness. Lili leads a group door to door, asking strangers to take in children without naming their religion. German soldiers arrive after dawn and raid Villa Emma, but the children remain concealed.

As searches intensify, Goffredo decides to move them toward Switzerland in small groups disguised as schoolchildren. He also asks Esti and Lili to relocate to Florence, where a larger underground network needs Esti’s skill at producing false papers.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

This escape is built from coordinated trust rather than a single heroic intervention. Goffredo’s plan depends on volunteers, local households, religious institutions, and the children’s ability to keep moving without understanding the full danger. Lili’s role at each door is especially revealing: she must persuade people to act while withholding the truth that might expose the children. Italy’s political reversal does not produce immediate safety; it makes the children’s existing refuge more dangerous by changing who controls the streets. The transition to Florence also shows how resistance work grows through networks. A local success creates a new obligation elsewhere, drawing Esti and Lili deeper into the underground.

The Convent Is Broken

Lili escapes with Theo while Esti stays behind

In Florence, Lili and Esti shelter Jewish women and children in a Franciscan convent, posing as nuns. An Allied bombing destroys nearby homes and leaves civilians dead, so the women move to the convent for greater protection.

Soon, Lili witnesses Italian Blackshirts and German soldiers conducting a roundup, separating families and loading them into trucks. Days later, a gang attacks the convent. Esti charges at the men dragging another Jewish mother away, but the attackers beat her severely and take her false papers.

Sister Lotte hides Lili until the danger passes. Esti, unable to walk and certain the gang will return, insists that Lili take Theo to Cardinal Dalla Costa and leave for Assisi. Lili resists the separation, then accepts Esti’s wedding ring and takes the boy into the night.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The convent episode turns Lili’s deepest relational commitment into a painful act of separation. Esti’s intervention for another mother is consistent with her refusal to watch others be taken, but it leaves her physically unable to protect her own child. Lili’s choice to leave is not a betrayal of Esti; it is the obedience Esti asks of her, though Lili cannot yet experience it that way. The ring converts their friendship into a portable responsibility, while Theo’s departure makes Lili’s role irreversible. The attack also dismantles the assumption that sacred space or religious disguise can guarantee safety. Protection exists, but only provisionally, and it must be carried from place to place.

Assisi Offers No Certainty

A letter reports Esti taken, then an informer drives them out

Lili reaches Cardinal Dalla Costa’s palace with Theo and receives help traveling toward Assisi, where Father Rufino Niccacci coordinates a hidden network. She meets printer Luigi Brizi, who makes matching false papers for her and Theo, then settles with Isabella and Isabella’s son, Ricardo.

Lili waits for Esti and sends letters through a courier, but Sister Lotte eventually reports that Carità’s gang returned to the convent, seized the injured women, and may have sent them to Verona.

Before Lili can learn more, a local man demands the reward for turning her in as a Jew. Isabella warns her, and Lili leaves with Theo for the monastery. Niccacci explains that Assisi is no longer safe and entrusts her with a concealed parcel for a contact in Rome. Lili agrees to carry it south.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Assisi combines the intimacy of a temporary home with the structural limits of sanctuary. Isabella’s household gives Theo companionship and gives Lili a routine, but the reward system turns a neighbor’s knowledge into a threat. The letter about Esti intensifies Lili’s guilt because it offers neither a confirmed death nor a path to rescue. Her departure is therefore doubly difficult: she is leaving the place where she hoped to reunite with Esti, and she is doing so without knowing whether her friend is alive. Niccacci’s parcel gives her a new purpose at the moment personal hope falters. Resistance work becomes a way to continue acting when answers are unavailable.

The Road Turns South

A hostile priest sends Lili toward armed partisans

Lili and Theo begin walking south, carrying Niccacci’s parcel inside her valise. At Torre del Colle, a widow named Anna gives them shelter after German motorcycles pass her farmhouse. She describes a reprisal in which German soldiers killed ten villagers, including a child, for the death of one German.

In Todi, German troops search Lili’s belongings, but Luigi’s documents and the hidden parcel survive inspection. A priest refuses to help and threatens to have her arrested; a monk instead directs her to a partisan group escorting refugees south.

At their forest camp, Lili meets Matilde, a Jewish resistance fighter. Matilde explains that Jews deported east are being murdered in extermination camps, not merely forced to labor. Lili struggles to absorb the news while deciding to travel with the partisans.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The road teaches Lili to distinguish between institutions and individuals rather than treating either as uniformly trustworthy. One priest uses his authority to threaten her; a monk quietly connects her with people outside the church’s formal structure. Anna’s shelter is another small act of protection made more consequential by the violence surrounding it. Matilde’s revelation breaks through Lili’s remaining belief that deportation might mean survival under harsh conditions. The knowledge is overwhelming, but it also clarifies why her work matters. Lili is no longer merely carrying a parcel or looking for family; she now understands that hiding people and delivering papers can interrupt a machinery designed to erase them.

A Parcel Through Fire

Theo’s injury forces a risky detour before Rome

Lili travels with Matilde’s partisan band, sharing food, sleeping outdoors, and growing stronger with each day on foot. After a shell explodes near their route, they continue through the countryside. Theo sprains his ankle badly, forcing Lili to leave the group and seek medical care in Scalo Teverina.

A doctor offers a ride to Rome in a supply truck, and Lili refuses to abandon Theo at the hospital when she realizes she had considered doing so for the sake of speed. They hide among crates as German soldiers inspect the truck.

In Rome, Lili finds Sister Natalia and hands over Niccacci’s parcel, which contains papers the underground urgently needs. Matilde has also left an address for a safehouse, giving Lili and Theo a place to stay in the occupied capital.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The journey’s physical hardship strips away Lili’s earlier reliance on planning. Her route changes because of weather, shelling, injury, and the unpredictable kindness of strangers. Theo’s sprain forces her to confront a frightening temptation: to separate herself from the child so she can move faster. Her decision to stay with him defines care not as sentiment but as a limit she chooses to honor under pressure. Delivering the parcel completes a task begun in Assisi, but the delivery is not a triumph that ends danger. Instead, it confirms Lili’s capacity to carry responsibility while exhausted and uncertain, and places her in a new city with no family waiting.

A Stranger Needs Shelter

Lili hides an escaped American and joins Matilde’s work

In Rome, Lili and Theo live quietly in Matilde’s safehouse until Theo wanders off and returns with a German-uniformed stranger. The man reveals he is Thomas Driscoll, an American Ranger who escaped a prisoner-of-war camp and needs somewhere to hide. Lili recognizes the risk but remembers how many strangers have sheltered them, so she lets him stay.

Thomas helps with Theo, shares food, and gradually becomes part of their confined household. During a card game, Lili tells him she is Jewish and explains that Theo is Esti’s son, not hers. When Matilde returns, she asks Lili to deliver an underground message. Lili completes the handoff at a newspaper stand, proving she can act beyond the safety of her flat and trust her own judgment.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Thomas’s arrival reverses the roles that have organized Lili’s journey. She has spent months asking others for shelter; now she decides whether to offer it to a fugitive whose presence could expose her and Theo. Her choice is grounded not in certainty about Thomas but in remembered experience of receiving help without having earned it. The gradual disclosure of her identity also marks a shift from survival through concealment toward selective trust. Lili does not abandon caution; she chooses a person to whom the truth can be given. Her message delivery extends this choice into public action, as she accepts a modest but real share of responsibility in Matilde’s resistance network.

Rome Opens, Thomas Leaves

A blackmailer takes Esti’s ring before Allies arrive

A GNR officer follows Lili home after a neighbor accuses her of hiding a Jewish man. To keep him from searching the flat and discovering Thomas, Lili gives him Esti’s wedding ring in exchange for her identity card and freedom. Soon afterward, Allied troops enter Rome and the German army retreats. Thomas reconnects with his American unit, but he remains in the city briefly, then receives orders to return to duty.

Before leaving, he gives Lili his military address and money to help her search for her family. Lili and Thomas acknowledge their feelings, but his departure leaves their future uncertain. With Theo, she waits for Florence to be liberated, determined to return to the convent and learn what happened to Esti.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The ring’s loss crystallizes the moral cost of survival: Lili saves Thomas by surrendering an object that carries Esti’s marriage and their shared history. Her action is not a betrayal of Esti but a desperate conversion of a symbol into protection. Rome’s liberation offers a public reversal of power, yet it does not immediately repair private losses or make the city safe. Thomas’s departure introduces love without resolution, while Lili’s decision to keep searching prevents romance from replacing her existing loyalties. The section resists a simple liberation narrative. Political freedom can arrive in the streets while the personal consequences of occupation remain active in a home, a missing friend, and an uncertain goodbye.

The Search Finds Massimo

Sister Lotte links Esti to Auschwitz, while Lili finds her father

After Florence is liberated, Lili returns to the convent with Theo. Sister Lotte explains that Esti and the other injured women were deported from Verona to Auschwitz; one survivor returned, but she never saw Esti again. Lili carries this news north to Bologna, where her apartment still stands and Massimo is waiting. Father and daughter reunite after years apart.

Massimo explains that he reached Switzerland only after repeated border refusals, using Esti’s false papers, and later returned to Bologna hoping to find Lili. Lili urges him to go back to Bern, where he has family and medical care for his illness. She stays in Bologna to keep searching for Esti and Niko, even though the news from the camp makes hope harder to sustain.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The reunion gives Lili what she has long wanted, but it does not provide a clean restoration of her former life. Massimo is alive, yet he is weakened and has returned to a devastated city; Esti’s fate remains only partly known. The contrast forces Lili to live with different kinds of uncertainty at once: confirmed separation, incomplete evidence, and the possibility of finding someone who may no longer be alive. Sending her father back to Switzerland repeats the pattern of choosing safety through separation, now by Lili’s own judgment. The decision signals growth from the young woman who once needed others to reassure her. She can care for Massimo without making herself the sole condition of his survival.

A Letter Across the Front

Thomas writes as evidence of Auschwitz reaches Bologna

In Bologna, Lili keeps asking the Red Cross and other offices for news of Esti and Niko. Thomas’s letter arrives with a cartoon of himself and Theo in the toy car they built together, reminding Lili that their connection has survived distance, even if correspondence is unreliable. Soon the papers report that Auschwitz has been liberated, but the photographs show starving survivors and the belongings taken from prisoners.

Lili searches every image for Esti and finds no trace of her. Allied forces eventually drive the Germans out of Bologna, and the city’s residents begin to emerge from hiding. Lili still cannot treat liberation as closure: she has no answer about Esti, and the people she hopes to find remain scattered across borders.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The letter and the camp photographs place private attachment beside mass evidence. Thomas’s drawing offers a small, legible sign of affection, while the images from Auschwitz resist any consoling interpretation. Lili’s search through the photographs is an effort to make history yield one identifiable person, but the scale of atrocity overwhelms that desire. The story treats hope as neither naive optimism nor a promise of reunion. It is a practice of continued inquiry, sustained by the thought that someone missing deserves not to be forgotten. Bologna’s liberation changes what Lili can do in public, but it cannot settle what happened to those who disappeared before the records were destroyed.

Peace Does Not Restore

The war ends, but Lili still waits for missing family

When Germany surrenders, Lili marks the end of the European war with Theo over milk and a rare piece of chocolate. He asks whether the good side won and whether his grandfather will come home; Lili explains that Massimo is safe in Switzerland, though they will have to visit him there. In the days that follow, she continues writing and searching.

Thomas returns to Bologna in uniform, scarred but alive, and tells Lili he has not stopped thinking of her. He asks her to come to America with him and Theo. Lili is drawn to the possibility of a secure life, but she fears leaving her father, Italy, and the search for Esti. She asks for time rather than answering immediately.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The end of the war resolves a political emergency without resolving the intimate ones that shaped Lili’s choices. The chocolate toast lets Theo experience celebration in a scale he can understand, while Lili knows peace cannot resurrect a prewar normality or supply missing names. Thomas’s return therefore arrives amid grief rather than after it. His invitation is genuinely hopeful, but it also asks Lili to place her future in another person’s hands after years of making every decision herself. Her hesitation is not simply fear of romance; it reflects the hard-earned autonomy that kept her and Theo alive. A new life can be desirable and still feel like another uncertain crossing.

Esti’s Diary Changes Everything

Her friend’s trust helps Lili choose a future with Thomas

As Thomas’s departure nears, Lili weighs the invitation against her loyalty to the people still missing. She visits her mother’s grave, grieves for Esti and for the childhood Theo has lost, and returns without an answer. Then she opens the diary Esti left behind. In her final entry, Esti records the agony of sending Lili and Theo away, but also her conviction that Lili can keep her son safe.

The words release Lili from the belief that choosing a new life means abandoning her friend. She asks Theo how he feels; he wants to go to America, meet Thomas’s family, and make friends. Lili agrees. Massimo supports her, and he gives his blessing to Thomas’s marriage intentions before the family prepares to leave Italy.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Esti’s diary does not supply new facts about her fate; it changes the meaning of a choice Lili has already been carrying. The entry confirms that Esti’s trust was not an abstract compliment but a deliberate transfer of responsibility, made while she still had agency. Lili can therefore imagine moving forward without treating movement as disloyalty. Asking Theo what he wants also recognizes him as a person shaped by the journey, not only the child she protects. The decision to leave is neither escape from grief nor proof that grief has ended. It is a choice to build stability while preserving the search and the memory of those who cannot yet come with them.

Epilogue

In Naples, Lili boards the S/S Campagna with Theo and Thomas, carrying the old valise that has traveled with them through hiding places, forests, and checkpoints. She has packed family photographs, books, Esti’s diary and jewelry, and the small comforts Theo treasures.

As the ship leaves the harbor, Lili promises inwardly to keep the boy safe and touches the pendant her mother gave her. Italy slips from view, but it is not erased: she carries its people, losses, and acts of kindness with her. Ahead lie New York and Virginia, unfamiliar places where the three of them will try to make a home.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The departure resolves the novel’s immediate question of where Lili and Theo will live, but it refuses to turn migration into a clean break. The valise still contains hidden valuables because habits formed under threat do not vanish when danger recedes. Lili carries Esti’s things alongside her mother’s photographs, keeping affection and obligation present as she begins again. Her promise to protect Theo answers the trust Esti placed in her, while the ship’s movement gives that promise a future beyond Italy. The ending’s hope is practical rather than triumphant: safety is possible, but it must be built, and memory travels with those who survive.

Analysis

One Good Thing follows survival not as a solitary feat but as a chain of decisions made by people who rarely know enough to be certain. Lili begins with a preference for preparation and predictability, yet every new danger invalidates the map she has made: the hotel can refuse her, the convent can be raided, a safe town can become occupied, and a trustworthy-looking neighbor can seek a reward. Her development is therefore not a conversion from fear to fearlessness. It is a growing ability to act while afraid, to assess risk without confusing caution with moral neutrality.

The novel’s most important relationship is Lili’s bond with Esti, which extends beyond the conventional limits of friendship into shared parenthood. Esti’s decision to send Theo away asks Lili to enact the trust between them through separation. Lili experiences that choice as guilt until Esti’s diary reveals the intention behind it. The diary does not reverse loss; it lets Lili understand that moving forward can fulfill, rather than betray, the promise she made. Theo’s care makes this moral problem concrete. He needs food, rest, reassurance, and eventually a future, not merely the preservation of an adult’s loyalty to the past. The novel also refuses to simplify Italy into rescuers and persecutors. Fascist laws and German occupation create the machinery of danger, while Italian officials, neighbors, and militias sometimes enforce it. Against them stand people whose help is specific and costly: farmers who give shelter, priests and nuns who hide refugees, printers who risk arrest, and strangers who provide food or direction. Their goodness is real but does not erase complicity elsewhere. The repeated movement through homes, convents, forests, and checkpoints makes safety a temporary relationship rather than a permanent place.

Ultimately, the title’s small scale matters. The good thing is not a cure for history. It is one person opening a door, one paper passed across a counter, one child kept beside the adult who loves him. Such acts cannot guarantee reunion, but they preserve the possibility of a life beyond immediate terror. Lili’s eventual choice of a new home does not end her search for Esti; it allows memory and hope to coexist with a future she can still build.

Summary in 60 Seconds
In fascist Italy, Lili Passiglia and her Jewish friend Esti help shelter refugee children at Villa Emma. When German forces occupy the region, volunteers hide the children, and Lili flees with Esti’s young son, Theo. Esti is badly injured during a convent raid and sends them away; Lili carries an underground parcel south, evading searches and reaching occupied Rome. She hides an escaped American soldier, Thomas, and gives up Esti’s wedding ring to protect him from a German officer. After liberation, Lili learns Esti was deported to Auschwitz and is missing. She reunites with her father, while letters from Thomas deepen their attachment. When Thomas returns and asks her to move to America, Lili hesitates until Esti’s diary helps her understand that leaving need not mean abandoning her friend. Lili, Theo, and Thomas depart for a new life together.
Contains spoilers

Last updated:

Report Issue

Review Summary

4.26 out of 5
Average of 15k+ ratings from Goodreads and Amazon.

One Good Thing receives mostly positive reviews (4.27/5) for its portrayal of Jewish women in WWII Italy. Readers praise Georgia Hunter's research, emotional storytelling, and the compelling friendship between Lili and Esti as Lili protects Theo during their perilous journey south. Many appreciate learning about Italy's Holocaust history. Common criticisms include Theo's unrealistic behavior for a three-year-old, an abrupt ending leaving questions unanswered, and some finding it less impactful than Hunter's debut. While some felt it was middle-of-the-road for the genre, most readers were deeply invested in the characters and recommend it.

Your rating:
4.63
80 ratings
Want to read the full book?

Characters

Lili Passigli

The careful protector

Lili is a young Jewish woman from Bologna, an aspiring journalist whose instinct is to observe, plan, and weigh consequences. She is deeply loyal to her father, Massimo, and to Esti, her closest friend, and she becomes devoted to Esti’s son, Theo. Her caution is not passivity: she notices danger early and tries to keep those she loves out of its reach. Yet the story repeatedly asks her to act without certainty, carrying false papers, protecting a child, and deciding whom to trust. Lili’s inner conflict comes from the gap between the orderly life she imagined and the improvisation survival demands. Her growth lies in learning that courage can be careful, relational, and chosen one step at a time.

Esti Ezratti

The defiant rescuer

Esti is Lili’s Greek-born university friend, Niko’s wife, and Theo’s mother. Confident, outspoken, and quick to act, she refuses to accept humiliation as the price of safety. Her anger at injustice can place her in danger, but it also drives her to forge identity papers and help Jewish refugees. Esti combines practical competence with emotional boldness: she photographs people for false IDs, cares fiercely for Theo, and asks Lili to share risks she once tried to conceal from her. Her friendship with Lili rests on affection strong enough to survive disagreement and secrecy. Esti represents a form of courage that begins with refusing to look away, even when the consequences are frightening.

Theo Ezratti

The child in Lili’s care

Theo is Esti and Niko’s young son. He is curious, energetic, and attached to small comforts, especially his lamb, Nello, his marble, and the stories and games adults use to steady him. His understanding of danger is partial, but he absorbs the movement, hunger, and separations that shape his childhood. As Lili cares for him, he shifts between calling her aunt and accepting the protective role she performs in public. Theo’s questions about his mother and his desire for play give the narrative a child’s scale of time: a few hours can feel enormous, and a promised reunion matters more than political explanations. He is not merely a symbol of innocence; his resilience actively shapes Lili’s choices.

Massimo Passigli

Lili’s steadfast father

Massimo is Lili’s widowed father, a property owner and painter whose quiet steadiness has long been one of her sources of security. The Racial Laws strip him of the right to operate his business openly, forcing him to rely on a trusted Catholic friend to protect his properties. He encourages Lili through letters and keeps faith in the possibility of life beyond the war, even when he cannot know what she is facing. Massimo’s grief for his wife, Naomi, is private but enduring, and his paintings and remembered habits preserve the family’s domestic life. His bond with Lili is affectionate without being controlling; he wants her safe, but recognizes that her own responsibilities will determine where she goes.

Niko Ezratti

The missing husband

Niko is Esti’s Greek husband and Theo’s father, a university student whose family remains in Salonica as German occupation tightens. Reports from home transform his earlier sociability into fear and anger, especially after he learns how precarious his parents’ position has become. He works with Delasem and the underground to find ways to move family members across borders. His response to the synagogue raid reveals how much pressure he has been containing. Niko’s story connects the intimate household in Ferrara to the increasingly dangerous world beyond Italy, while his absence weighs on Esti and Lili.

Thomas Driscoll

The fugitive American Ranger

Thomas is an American Army Ranger who escapes a prisoner-of-war camp and hides in Rome while trying to reconnect with his unit. Before the war, he studied art and writing and hoped to become an actor, traits that make him attentive to stories, play, and the details of other people’s lives. He approaches Lili and Theo with humility, offering what little help he can and accepting their limits. His humor and gentleness create a counterpoint to the violence around him, without making him unaware of it. Thomas’s presence asks Lili to consider trust and attachment at a moment when both can feel dangerous. He is also a fatherless-in-the-moment figure for Theo, though he never tries to replace the boy’s parents.

Matilde

The partisan courier

Matilde is a Jewish resistance fighter who moves through the countryside and Rome helping refugees, carrying messages, and supporting partisan operations. Direct, resourceful, and comfortable with risk, she has learned to treat danger as part of the work rather than as a reason to stop. She welcomes Lili and Theo into the partisan camp and gives Lili both practical guidance and difficult knowledge about the fate of deported Jews. Their relationship grows from a brief encounter into a working alliance, though Matilde never romanticizes what resistance costs. Her character expands Lili’s sense of what women can do within the underground, while showing that courage often depends on teamwork and improvisation.

Father Rufino Niccacci

The Assisi organizer

Father Niccacci is a Franciscan monk in Assisi who coordinates help for Jews in hiding, working with local printers and couriers. He is practical as well as compassionate, advising Lili about safer routes, false identities, and the risks of travel. Rather than promise safety, he helps her make the next decision with the information available. His trust in Lili grows into a request that she carry an important parcel to Rome. Niccacci represents the network of religious people who use their position to protect others, while the dangers around him make clear that such help is neither universal nor guaranteed.

Cardinal Elia Dalla Costa

The Florence protector

Dalla Costa is the anti-Fascist cardinal who helps connect refugees and resistance workers in Florence. He gives Lili and Theo shelter for a night, arranges their journey toward Assisi, and directs Esti toward further underground work. His assistance is concrete and often discreet, though Lili’s questions about the Church’s public response to persecution reveal the limits she sees in institutional protection. He is an important link between local rescuers and the wider network, not a figure who can simply command events to change.

Sister Lotte

The convent guardian

Sister Lotte is the mother superior at the Florence convent where Jewish women and children hide under the cover of religious life. She is firm, observant, and protective, organizing places to conceal people when raids threaten. Her practical authority helps Lili and Esti navigate the convent’s routines, while her later letters become a rare channel of information from Florence. Sister Lotte’s care is not sentimental; she makes decisions under pressure and understands that protection may mean telling someone to flee.

Isabella

The Assisi host

Isabella is a working mother in Assisi who gives Lili and Theo a room in her home. She is modest, capable, and attentive to the daily needs that make survival possible, from clothes and meals to watching the boys. Her husband, Tulio, is away with the Italian army, leaving her to manage the household and care for Ricardo. Isabella’s generosity is a deliberate risk in a town where a neighbor may trade a Jewish refugee’s identity for money. Her calm welcome gives Lili a brief experience of routine and shared domestic labor.

Goffredo Pacifici

The children’s organizer

Goffredo Pacifici is a businessman who helps smuggle Jewish refugee children into Italy and becomes a leader among the Villa Emma staff. When German troops approach Nonantola, he organizes the children’s dispersal among homes and the abbey, then plans their movement toward Switzerland. His steadiness turns a frightening emergency into a sequence of tasks that volunteers can carry out. Goffredo embodies the logistical side of rescue: routes, groups, timing, and the trust required to make each part work.

Luigi Brizi

The hidden printer

Luigi Brizi is an elderly shopkeeper in Assisi who hides a printing press behind his religious trinket business and produces false identity documents for Jewish refugees. Gruff in manner but committed to the work, he takes extraordinary care over the details that can make a paper convincing. His secret office, concealed under a floorboard, reflects the ingenuity required to turn an ordinary shop into part of a rescue network. Luigi makes practical skill a form of protection.

Adelmo Giardini

The discreet Tuscan host

Adelmo is a well-connected man who escorts Lili and Theo away from Florence and offers them refuge at his home. He understands that travel and hospitality both carry risk, so he provides a plausible cover story and practical alternatives to exposed train routes. His generosity is measured and purposeful, never demanding that Lili prove her worth before helping her. Adelmo and his wife show how private homes can become temporary links in a larger chain of protection.

Eva Giardini

The generous household anchor

Eva is Adelmo’s wife and a gracious host to Lili and Theo. She offers food, warmth, and the purple coat that becomes one of Lili’s most useful possessions on the road. When a local policeman warns her that people are questioning the refugees’ identities, Eva does not withdraw her care. Her generosity is practical rather than grand: she makes room, watches for danger, and helps Lili continue without treating her as a burden.

Gino Bartali

The helpful cyclist

Gino Bartali is a famous Italian cyclist whom Lili and Theo encounter on the road. He offers route advice and directs them to a trusted contact when they have nowhere to sleep. His easy manner conceals a wider role in the hidden network, and his visits show how public figures can move through dangerous territory while doing quiet work.

Anna

The roadside widow

Anna is a widow living alone near Torre del Colle who gives Lili and Theo shelter after they have walked all day. Her wariness comes from the violence around her, not from indifference. Once she understands their need, she shares her home and explains the danger posed by German reprisals in the area.

Giovanni and Luisa

The farming refuge

Giovanni and Luisa are farmers near San Terenziano who take Lili and Theo in without pressing them for their history. They share food and give Theo small jobs among their surviving animals, allowing him to recover some ease after months of travel. Their farm offers a brief, ordinary rhythm of work, meals, and care.

Sister Natalia

The Roman contact

Sister Natalia is the nun in Rome who receives the parcel Lili carries from Father Niccacci. She works within the network helping Jewish refugees and gives Lili a way to reconnect with Matilde. Her role is brief but consequential, because the delivery completes a dangerous journey and places Lili in contact with another safe address.

Ziggie

The partisan guide

Ziggie is an armed partisan who guides Lili and Theo from Todi into the forest camp. His manner is blunt and guarded, shaped by the hazards of moving through territory where soldiers and civilians alike may pose a threat. He helps the refugees travel south with the group, while Matilde provides the warmer welcome.

Plot Devices

False identity papers

A paper shield

Forged IDs let Jewish refugees cross checkpoints, qualify for ration cards, and pose as people the authorities are less likely to target. Esti’s photography skills, stolen forms, borrowed addresses, and carefully imitated stamps make the documents plausible. The papers do not make their holders safe; a wrong answer, a suspicious officer, or a searched bag can expose them. Their recurring presence makes identity both a bureaucratic weapon and a performance Lili must learn to sustain. In Assisi, Luigi modifies Theo’s card to match Lili’s, allowing her to present herself as the boy’s mother when necessary.

Esti’s wedding ring

A portable bond

The gold fede ring links Esti and Niko’s marriage to Lili’s promise to protect Theo. Esti gives it to Lili when she sends her away from the convent, and Lili wears it as part of her public story as Theo’s mother. Later, she surrenders it to a GNR officer to prevent him searching her home and discovering Thomas. The ring’s meaning therefore shifts with circumstance: it is an intimate keepsake, a disguise, and a price paid for another person’s safety. It carries the women’s trust even when the original owner is out of reach.

The hidden parcel

A dangerous delivery

Father Niccacci entrusts Lili with a concealed parcel for Sister Natalia in Rome, telling her only that it can save lives. Lili hides it in her valise and carries it through villages, searches, and a German checkpoint. The parcel gives her a purpose beyond her own escape and makes the journey more dangerous, since discovery could expose both her identity and the underground network. Its delivery connects Assisi’s printers and organizers to the work in Rome. Lili’s willingness to carry it marks her gradual movement from a person being protected to someone who accepts responsibility for protecting others.

The traveling valise

A life carried forward

Lili’s worn valise holds the practical and personal materials she can take as she moves through Italy: clothes, money, photographs, Theo’s belongings, and eventually a hidden parcel. It is searched by German soldiers, carried along roads and rail journeys, and repeatedly repacked as the family’s circumstances change. The bag is both a burden and a portable home, its contents preserving pieces of Lili’s former life while making room for the responsibilities she acquires. Its hidden lining also gives her a place to protect objects that cannot safely be displayed.

Letters and couriers

A thread through silence

Letters allow Lili, Massimo, Esti, and Niko to maintain relationships across borders and under censorship, but delays and missing replies turn communication into a source of anxiety as well as comfort. The underground’s couriers carry more than correspondence: they move photographs, false IDs, and other information between cities. Lili’s repeated letters to family, the Red Cross, and her contacts become acts of persistence when she cannot travel to search herself. The device emphasizes how survival depends on incomplete information, and how a message can arrive too late, not at all, or as the only available proof that someone remembers.

About the Author

Georgia Hunter is a historical fiction author based in Rowayton, Connecticut, who discovered her family's Holocaust survival story at a 2000 reunion. She spent a decade researching her grandfather's wartime experiences, resulting in her debut novel We Were the Lucky Ones, published in over twenty languages and adapted into a Hulu limited series. Her second book, One Good Thing, explores Holocaust-era Italy through a young woman's perspective, focusing on friendship, motherhood, and survival. When not writing or giving author talks, she enjoys adventures with her husband, two sons, and Australian Shepherd named Dash.

Download PDF

To save this One Good Thing summary for later, download the free PDF. You can print it out, or read offline at your convenience.
Download PDF
File size: 0.39 MB     Pages: 29

Download EPUB

To read this One Good Thing summary on your e-reader device or app, download the free EPUB. The .epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.
Download EPUB
File size: 1.43 MB     Pages: 40
Want to read the full book?
Follow
Listen
Home
Swipe
Library
Get App
Try Full Access for 3 Days
Listen, bookmark, and more
Compare Features Free Pro
📖 Read Summaries
Read unlimited summaries. Free users get 3 per month
🎧 Listen to Summaries
Listen to unlimited summaries in 40 languages
—
❤️ Unlimited Bookmarks
Free users are limited to 4
—
📜 Unlimited History
Free users are limited to 4
—
📥 Unlimited Downloads
Free users are limited to 1
—
Risk-Free Timeline
Today: Get Instant Access
Listen to full summaries of 26,000+ books. That's 12,000+ hours of audio!
Day 2: Trial Reminder
We'll send you a notification that your trial is ending soon.
Day 3: Your subscription begins
You'll be charged on Nov 24,
cancel anytime before.
Consume 2.8× More Books
2.8× more books Listening Reading
Our users love us
1M+ readers
Trustpilot Rating
TrustPilot
4.6 Excellent
This site is a total game-changer. I've been flying through book summaries like never before. Highly, highly recommend.
— Dave G
Worth my money and time, and really well made. I've never seen this quality of summaries on other websites. Very helpful!
— Em
Highly recommended!! Fantastic service. Perfect for those that want a little more than a teaser but not all the intricate details of a full audio book.
— Greg M
Save 62%
Yearly
$119.88 $44.99/year/yr
$3.75/mo
Monthly
$9.99/mo
Start a 3-Day Free Trial
3 days free, then $44.99/year. Cancel anytime.
Unlock a world of fiction & nonfiction books
26,000+ books for the price of 2 books
Read any book in 10 minutes
Discover new books like Tinder
Request any book if it's not summarized
Read more books than anyone you know
#1 app for book lovers
Lifelike & immersive summaries
30-day money-back guarantee
Download summaries in EPUBs or PDFs
Cancel anytime in a few clicks

Why one summary?

Scanner
Find a barcode to scan

⭐
⭐
⭐
We have a special gift for you
Open
38% off
DISCOUNT FOR YOU
⭐
⭐
⭐
$79.99
$49.99/year
Only $4.16 per month
Continue
2 taps to start, super easy to cancel
Settings
General
Widget
Loading...