Start free trial
Trending New Genres Authors
EnglishEnglish
EspañolSpanish
简体中文Chinese
繁體中文Chinese (Traditional)
FrançaisFrench
DeutschGerman
日本語Japanese
PortuguêsPortuguese
ItalianoItalian
한국어Korean
РусскийRussian
NederlandsDutch
العربيةArabic
PolskiPolish
हिन्दीHindi
Tiếng ViệtVietnamese
SvenskaSwedish
ΕλληνικάGreek
TürkçeTurkish
ไทยThai
ČeštinaCzech
RomânăRomanian
MagyarHungarian
УкраїнськаUkrainian
IndonesiaIndonesian
DanskDanish
SuomiFinnish
БългарскиBulgarian
עבריתHebrew
NorskNorwegian
HrvatskiCroatian
CatalàCatalan
SlovenčinaSlovak
LietuviųLithuanian
SlovenščinaSlovenian
СрпскиSerbian
EestiEstonian
LatviešuLatvian
فارسیPersian
മലയാളംMalayalam
தமிழ்Tamil
اردوUrdu
Searching...
SoBrief
PS

PS

I Hate You
An estranged pair must scatter a brother's ashes across eight states; can grief bring them together?
by Lauren Connolly 2024 432 pages
4.01
72k+ ratings
Listen
Immersive
V2.3
Amazon Kindle Audible
Try Full Access for 3 Days
Unlock listening & more!
Continue

Plot Summary

The Envelope Says Both

Josh assigns his sister and best friend eight journeys

At her brother Josh’s funeral, Maddie Sanderson hides in a supply closet to work, then is discovered by Dominic Perry, Josh’s best friend and her old heartbreak. Josh has named Dom executor and left a letter addressed to them both. It asks them to carry his ashes to eight states he never visited, opening a fresh letter at each destination and following its instructions.

Maddie is furious that Josh chose Dom, but the trip is her last way to be close to her brother, so she agrees. She also discovers her mother Cecilia and grandmother Florence still judge her, while Dom’s family offers the affection she rarely received at home. Josh’s final request turns grief into a journey neither Maddie nor Dom can refuse.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The will makes grief procedural: Maddie and Dom must travel, carry, and obey, because an itinerary feels more manageable than an ending. Yet the shared assignment also refuses Maddie’s preferred division between past and present. Dom belongs to both her childhood and its deepest wound, while Josh’s instructions make avoidance impossible. The funeral’s competing forms of care establish the emotional terrain: Cecilia curates grief for an audience, Florence criticizes, and the Perrys offer ordinary warmth. Maddie’s task begins as obedience to Josh, but its deeper pressure is whether she can let another person witness her grief without turning that witness into an enemy.

Rehoboth in Winter

Their first farewell exposes Dom’s divorce and Maddie’s old hurt

Maddie and Dom divide Josh’s ashes at the Perry family home, then drive to Delaware. Before they leave, Dom tells her that he and Rosaline are divorced, a fact Maddie missed by avoiding news of their lives. At Rehoboth Beach, Josh’s letter asks them to wade into the ocean, scatter his ashes, toast him with local beer, and take a picture.

The ashes float on the water until both press them beneath the waves. At a bar, Maddie drinks gin and needles Dom about his marriage; their shared drinking ends with a drunken kiss outside a motel. Dom stops it, and Maddie hears rejection in his restraint. She slips away before dawn, returning to Seattle convinced their old wound has simply opened again.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The ocean makes the first goodbye physically unruly: ashes do not dissolve on cue, and grief does not become beautiful simply because the setting is. Maddie’s anger gives her a brief sense of agency, but she mistakes Dom’s refusal to continue a drunken kiss for the same abandonment she remembers from youth. His divorce unsettles the idealized couple she had kept in mind, yet she cannot ask what happened without exposing how closely she has watched from afar. Their first journey therefore establishes a pattern: Josh’s tasks create intimacy, and Maddie’s old expectations immediately interpret it as danger.

Seattle Sets the Distance

Maddie hides Dom from friends while agreeing to Alabama

Back in Seattle, Maddie studies the photo taken in Delaware and tries to work through bereavement leave rather than tell her friends how badly she is coping. Her ex-boyfriend Jeremy, now her close friend, and their friend Tula bring comfort and urge her to stop working, but Maddie tells them only that Josh requested several trips. She leaves Dom out of the story.

When Dom emails travel plans, she refuses to give him her number and insists on booking her own flights. They argue by email over who controls the arrangements, then settle on Alabama in April. Maddie’s job offers a familiar refuge: she is the only logistics associate, and being indispensable lets her avoid the helplessness she feels everywhere else.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Maddie treats information as a boundary. She withholds Dom’s identity from Jeremy and Tula, and withholds her phone number from Dom, hoping that controlled access will prevent emotional exposure. Her work performs the same function: Redford’s dependence on her appears to prove that she cannot be discarded. This strategy protects her from immediate vulnerability but also deepens her isolation. The trip proceeds because she can distinguish compliance with Josh’s wishes from trust in Dom. That distinction will become harder to maintain as each destination asks them to share more than ashes.

Glowworms in Alabama

A night canyon tour turns their cold truce gentler

In Alabama, Maddie finds that Dom has booked a secluded cabin, chosen because she dislikes hotels and because Josh’s coordinates lead to Dismals Canyon. During the night tour, Dom helps her navigate the narrow passages and gets stuck when his belt loop catches on a root. Maddie frees him, then mistakes his offered hand for a request to pass Josh’s ashes.

At the end of the tour, they scatter the remains among glowing larvae. Dom has kept the opened letters in a safe, and Maddie demands the combination in case anything happens to him. He gives her the numbers 0718, her birthday. Later, she finds a cabin puzzle and deliberately resets its many clocks, a small act of defiance against Dom’s need to correct everything.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The canyon’s dim light lets Maddie experience closeness without having to name it. She helps Dom, accepts his practical care, then retreats when a handhold seems to carry more meaning than she intended. The safe combination is a quiet contradiction of her assumptions: Dom has placed her birthday in a private place of protection, though he does not explain why. The clocks extend their conflict into comic scale. Maddie resists his control by changing them, but the gesture also shows that she is beginning to engage him playfully rather than only wound him. Their truce is not trust yet, but it has acquired room for humor.

Josh Gets Under Their Skin

A Kansas tattoo links their bodies to his handwriting

Josh’s Kansas letter sends them to Ink Ever After, where Reggie and Carmen honor a tattoo favor Josh earned by photographing their engagement. He had left the design to Maddie and Dom, knowing they would resist a permanent choice. Dom admits he has the matching half of a joke tattoo he and Josh got as teenagers: Josh has peanut butter on one cheek, Dom jelly on the other.

Maddie laughs, then grieves the fact that Josh’s half is gone. She chooses to tattoo Josh’s handwritten sign-off on her wrist, and Dom chooses the same design. While holding Josh’s watch during Dom’s session, Maddie discovers an inscription showing Dom gave it to Josh. They later scatter more ashes in lavender fields, where Dom remembers Rosaline’s perfume.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The tattoo converts memory from an object that can be lost into a mark carried on the body. Maddie chooses her brother’s handwriting rather than a symbolic image because his particular presence matters more than a generalized memorial. Dom’s matching choice makes their connection visible, even as neither explains what it means. The watch inscription complicates Maddie’s belief that Dom merely received a keepsake: he had given it to Josh as a sign of brotherhood. Her grief now includes the recognition that Dom’s bond with Josh was not secondary to hers. Lavender, meanwhile, exposes how easily Maddie measures herself against Rosaline, even in a landscape chosen for her brother.

Cecilia Wants the Story

Maddie bars her mother from turning grief into content

Before the Arizona trip, Cecilia calls Maddie after hearing about the ash-spreading journeys from Emilia Perry. She wants to join the trips and publicize them, presenting the project as a story that could help people. Maddie recognizes the familiar appetite for attention and refuses: Josh assigned the task to her and Dom, not to his mother.

When Cecilia insists that she deserves a role as his blood relative, Maddie blocks her number and tells her to stop treating the journey as material for her online audience. She has spent years trying to win care from Cecilia, but now draws a boundary instead. The choice leaves Maddie without the mother she hoped for, while protecting the private meaning of Josh’s letters.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Cecilia frames access to Josh as a right of biological kinship, while Maddie understands it as an obligation to honor his expressed wishes. Their conflict reveals that privacy itself is an act of care: Maddie refuses to let a public narrative replace the intimate relationship she had with her brother. Blocking her mother is not emotional indifference, but an attempt to stop a familiar cycle in which Maddie’s needs are dismissed and Cecilia’s image takes precedence. It also prepares Maddie to defend the journey from anyone who might claim authority over it, including, later, her own fear of needing Dom.

Vulture City Remembers

Arizona’s ghost town makes them trade private Josh stories

In Arizona, Josh’s letter sends Maddie and Dom through Vulture City, where they must exchange stories about him, including regrets. Dom recalls how he and Josh once got Cecilia’s car towed after she discarded Maddie’s treasured books.

Maddie remembers Josh helping her search for a prom dress, and they fill the abandoned town with comic memories. Dom admits he regrets declining Josh’s invitations to travel, believing there would always be another chance. Maddie recognizes the same mistake in herself.

When Dom tries to eat a granola bar he dislikes, she knocks it away and gives him Cheez-Its, then apologizes for scolding him. They scatter Josh’s ashes in the desert and take a photo beside a cactus, having begun to share both laughter and regret.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The letter shifts their role from executors to witnesses. Each must give the other a version of Josh that was not equally available to both, so mourning becomes an exchange rather than a private possession. Their regrets reveal a shared error in time perception: both treated future invitations as renewable, while Josh lived with less time than they understood. Maddie’s angry intervention over Dom’s food seems disproportionate until he explains that he learned to deny himself while caring for his younger brothers. Her apology marks a new kind of intimacy, one in which she can challenge him and then repair the harm instead of using anger as an exit.

The File on Josh

A New York detour reveals Dom’s futile search for treatment

During a work conference in New York, Maddie secretly attends the Perry twins’ swim meet. Adam and Carter are delighted, and Dom drives up after she tells him she cannot stay long. Before they meet, she sees a folder on Dom’s laptop containing more than a hundred research papers about Josh’s lung cancer and treatment options.

She understands that Dom had tried to study his way toward a cure. When airport delays threaten her connection, Dom carries her bags across the terminal and gets her to the gate in time. Maddie kisses him before boarding. Afterward, she finally gives him her number, and their teasing texts become a regular way to check on one another and keep Josh present between trips.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The medical folder reveals the cost of Dom’s control without requiring him to describe it. His research is both love and an attempted defense against helplessness, a form of care that cannot produce the outcome he wanted. Maddie sees that his practical attention is not merely a bid to manage her; it is how he responds when someone he loves is in danger. The airport kiss grows from that recognition, though she still does not know how to trust what it means. Giving him her number is a modest but consequential change: she allows contact beyond the scheduled journeys, making friendship possible in the ordinary spaces between grief rituals.

The Badlands Break Open

A storm traps them, and their friendship becomes physical

On the South Dakota hike through the Badlands, Maddie struggles with the distance and Dom reads Josh’s request that he sing on the return trail. A sudden storm forces them to hurry; when Maddie cannot keep pace, Dom carries her through falling snow after winning a playful bet. They reach their bed and breakfast and must share a room.

Dom stops Maddie from drinking a hot toddy until she can be sure she wants him sober. She confronts him, and he admits he has wanted a clear, uninebriated kiss. They kiss, then negotiate intimacy around Maddie’s asthma and past fears. The next day, they stay snowbound, sleep together, and share easy conversation, but leave the unspoken history between them untouched.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The storm turns Dom’s caretaking into something Maddie can accept because he explains the danger and respects her limits. His refusal to treat an intoxicated kiss as consent distinguishes desire from entitlement, giving Maddie a safer basis for choosing him. Their sexual intimacy is therefore not just romantic payoff: it is a test of whether old closeness can be rebuilt with explicit communication. Yet their silence about the past leaves the new relationship suspended. They can inhabit a temporary bubble of pleasure, but neither has yet explained the wound that made Maddie flee in the first place.

Rosaline at Graduation

A family celebration stirs Maddie’s fear of being second choice

Maddie flies to Philadelphia for Adam and Carter’s college graduation and stays at Dom’s townhouse. She and Dom continue their physical relationship, then agree to present themselves to his family as friends. Rosaline, Dom’s former partner and Josh’s close friend, joins the family for the ceremony and lunch.

Maddie watches Dom and Rosaline share easy memories and fears that their old relationship could resume. Rosaline offers to talk about Josh, but Maddie cannot accept the kindness without comparing herself to her.

Dom reassures her that he invited no one and that Rosaline is simply part of the family’s life. He repeats that Maddie is the person he sees, and they leave together. The reassurance helps, but Maddie still measures herself against a past she does not understand.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Rosaline functions less as a rival than as a screen onto which Maddie projects the judgments of her mother and grandmother. Her kindness should soften the comparison, but instead makes Maddie feel more deficient because she cannot receive it without suspicion. The graduation gathers a family that has remained connected despite Dom and Rosaline’s changed relationship, exposing Maddie’s fear that belonging can be revoked at any moment. Dom’s reassurance is real, but it cannot by itself undo the learned expectation that she will be the person left outside the circle. Her insecurity is not irrational in origin, even when it misreads the present.

A Future at Alpine Lake

Maddie hikes farther, then lets Dom choose her openly

For Idaho, Maddie trains her lungs and completes the demanding hike to Alpine Lake without needing Dom to carry her. Josh’s letter asks them to describe the futures they hope for; Dom says his includes Maddie and remembers her birthday.

Later, Maddie struggles up twelve flights of stairs when Redford’s elevator breaks. Dom sings to distract her, then worries over the phone and asks what their relationship means. He tells her he wants a committed partnership, and Maddie agrees.

The next trip brings them back together in Seattle, where Dom visits her home and they resume their intimacy. Maddie still hides the relationship from Jeremy and Tula, afraid that naming it will make its loss more real, but Dom’s consistent effort begins to make commitment feel possible.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The hike gives Maddie evidence of competence that does not depend on Dom’s strength, while his birthday memory makes care feel specific rather than managerial. Their relationship becomes explicit only after she struggles alone at work and he stays present through the phone. His singing does not solve the physical barrier, but it gives her companionship while she crosses it herself. Maddie’s continued secrecy from her friends shows that commitment has not erased fear; she still divides her life into compartments to limit possible loss. Dom’s steadiness matters precisely because it is repeated behavior, not a single declaration.

Cecilia Strikes Again

A surprise visit revives Maddie’s oldest shame

A week before North Dakota, Cecilia appears at Maddie’s workplace and invites her to lunch. Maddie briefly hopes for reconciliation, but Cecilia quickly demands access to Josh’s letters and accuses her daughter of clinging to her brother instead of living. She blames Maddie for her father’s departure and compares her unfavorably with Josh, Dom, and Rosaline.

Maddie leaves the restaurant and calls Dom, then asks Jeremy to spend the evening with her. The visit exposes how completely Cecilia’s judgments have shaped Maddie’s sense of worth: even as an adult, she fears that people leave because she is not worth staying for. She ends the contact again, but carries the old wound with her into the final journey.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Cecilia’s attack is effective because it speaks in the grammar Maddie already uses against herself. The accusations do not create her fear of being unlovable; they give that fear a familiar voice and apparent authority. Maddie’s call to Dom and her plan to see Jeremy show that she has begun reaching outward, but she still struggles to trust support enough to name what hurts. The scene also clarifies why work has become so important: being indispensable offers a temporary rebuttal to the idea that she can be discarded. It is a fragile substitute for belonging, and the final journey will expose that fragility.

The Ashes Scatter Alone

Dom misses North Dakota while helping Rosaline at home

When a pipe bursts in the house Rosaline once shared with Dom, he helps her save her belongings and misses his flight to North Dakota. A storm then grounds the remaining planes. Maddie, already at the Enchanted Highway, hears his explanation as proof he will choose Rosaline over her again.

She drives to the giant pheasant sculpture alone and asks Dom to read Josh’s letter by phone. Dom refuses, insisting they should hear it together. Maddie hangs up, opens the ashes, and accidentally drops the container.

Wind carries Josh’s remains into the roadside dust. Her asthma flares as she searches for her inhaler without anyone beside her. She returns to Seattle furious and devastated, convinced Dom’s care was only responsibility and that relying on him was another mistake.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

This rupture is driven by a real failure and an old interpretation acting at once. Dom does miss the journey, but Maddie’s history turns his absence into certainty that she is disposable. His insistence on reading the letter together may be an effort to preserve the ritual, yet from her isolated roadside it feels like withholding the last access she has to Josh. The spilled ashes make the cost material: grief escapes her control, and she cannot retrieve what the wind has taken. The scene breaks the fantasy that love can be proven through caretaking alone; reliability matters most when circumstances are difficult, and Dom has failed to appear.

The Twins Come Looking

Adam and Carter return Maddie to a wider circle

After Maddie withdraws at home, Adam and Carter arrive in Seattle and take her to Taco Bell, choosing the familiar food and music that once belonged to their shared summers. Adam explains that when Maddie disappeared from their lives years earlier, he wanted to find her; Dom told him Maddie had left because of something he had done.

Maddie admits that she abandoned the twins as well as Dom, and promises to answer them and visit Adam’s furniture workshop. The next day, Jeremy, Tula, Carlisle, the twins, and Dom gather at her apartment. Their noise and games pull Maddie briefly out of isolation. The twins have not stopped considering her family, even when she stopped acting as though she belonged to them.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The twins’ visit reverses Maddie’s private account of her departure. She thought leaving Dom meant escaping one painful attachment, but Adam reveals that her silence injured people who had offered her uncomplicated affection. The recognition does not erase her reasons for leaving; it broadens the consequences she can now acknowledge. Taco Bell and the old soundtrack matter because repair arrives through familiar rituals rather than a grand speech. Maddie’s chosen family becomes visible as a network of people who continue to approach her, even when she withdraws. Their persistence challenges her belief that every relationship is conditional on her being useful or easy to love.

The Letter Explains Everything

Dom reveals the marriage began with a pregnancy and loss

When Dom arrives at Maddie’s gathering, he reads the North Dakota letter, which asks him to explain why he and Josh stopped speaking for a month. Dom says Josh had urged him to reconcile with Rosaline; he finally admitted that he married her after she became pregnant, not because he was in love.

The pregnancy ended in miscarriage shortly after the wedding. Dom tells Maddie that he had fallen in love with her before choosing the responsible course and that he never stopped.

Maddie reveals she witnessed his proposal and believed their night together meant nothing. She cannot trust his declaration, so she ends the relationship. Dom says he will not leave her city, has found a townhouse, and is interviewing at Redford, leaving the next choice to her.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The revelation corrects the story Maddie has lived inside without making the past harmless. Dom’s marriage was shaped by responsibility and loss, not a simple preference for Rosaline, yet he still failed to tell Maddie the truth when it mattered. His love cannot retroactively give her the security she lacked at nineteen. Maddie’s refusal is therefore not a rejection of the new information but a defense against repeating an attachment where she must guess what she means to someone. Dom’s decision to move nearby changes the conditions without demanding instant forgiveness. He offers continued presence, but leaves her agency intact.

A Hug on Death Day

Friends help Maddie name grief and loosen work’s grip

On the second anniversary of Josh’s death, Maddie spends the day working through a data report rather than asking anyone to sit with her. Jeremy and Tula arrive with pizza and tell her plainly that their friendship does not depend on her hiding difficult parts of herself. Maddie finally explains her childhood, her history with Dom, and her fear that people leaving her is contagious.

Tula challenges Maddie’s belief that Redford cannot function without her, while Jeremy assures her that she does not have to earn their loyalty. They bring Dom to her door. He asks only for a hug because he misses Josh and needs company in his grief. Maddie embraces him, then says she needs time to work on herself before Alaska.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Maddie’s recovery begins not with a dramatic cure but with a change in what she permits others to know. Her workaholism and emotional secrecy share a logic: if people need her, they cannot leave. Tula exposes the cost of that bargain, while Jeremy offers a relationship that can survive her anger and imperfection. Dom’s request for a hug is crucially modest. He does not ask for forgiveness or a promise, and Maddie can meet him in shared grief without pretending the romantic conflict is resolved. Her request for time is a boundary rather than a disappearance, a first step toward trust that does not require self-erasure.

The Last Letter

A glacier farewell triggers Maddie’s first full grief

Months later, Maddie and Dom fly to Pika Glacier in Alaska carrying the final portion of Josh’s ashes. They hold hands on the small plane, but remain careful with each other. At the glacier, Dom reads Josh’s brief goodbye, including his belief that Maddie and Dom belong together. Maddie stops breathing and collapses into an asthma attack.

Dom helps her use her inhaler, refuses to rush the ritual, and promises they can return whenever she is ready. They do not spread the ashes. Back in town, Maddie admits her anger at Josh for leaving, and Dom shares the feeling instead of correcting her. A compass logo on the letter matches a nearby stationery shop; its owner gives them a puzzle Josh left behind, opening a final path to more of him.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The final letter does not deliver closure so much as remove the structure that postponed it. Maddie has treated each destination as another opportunity to hear Josh, and the last words make the end of that arrangement unavoidable. Her body expresses what her dry eyes have concealed: grief overwhelms her breathing before she can narrate it. Dom’s most important act is not to complete the ashes task, but to suspend it. By allowing the farewell to remain unfinished, he refuses to turn Josh’s wishes into another obligation imposed on Maddie. The stationery clue then reframes finality: Josh has left not only an ending, but one more invitation to discover what she did not know.

The Puzzle Finds Its Pieces

Rosaline explains her love for Josh, and Maddie chooses Dom

The puzzle reveals a photograph of Josh and Rosaline together on the Alaskan glacier. Maddie visits Rosaline, who explains that they loved each other briefly after Rosaline and Dom separated, then reunited during Josh’s final year. Years earlier, Rosaline had ended her relationship with Josh after discovering she was pregnant by Dom; she chose the steadier future, and Dom married her after she asked.

After the miscarriage, they stayed together out of habit and responsibility. Maddie understands that Rosaline’s life held its own losses and no longer treats her as a rival. On the Perrys’ porch swing, Dom offers to take love one day at a time. Maddie chooses all their days, and, for the first time since Josh’s diagnosis, she cries.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Rosaline’s account dismantles Maddie’s old triangle of comparison. The woman she imagined as effortless perfection was also afraid, grieving, and constrained by decisions made under pressure. Hearing the truth does not diminish Josh’s importance; it gives Maddie a fuller sense of the people he loved. The porch swing, once the site of Maddie’s formative hurt, becomes a place where she can choose a future without demanding certainty about every day in it. Her tears arrive not as proof that she is finally grieving correctly, but as one form of feeling among many. Trust becomes possible when she accepts uncertainty without mistaking it for inevitable abandonment.

Epilogue

A few summers later, Maddie, Dom, Rosaline, Adam, and Carter revisit Josh’s destinations with their wider circle of friends. They share the letters, stories, laughter, and tears, and return to the glacier together. Rosaline cannot release all the remaining ashes, so the family scatters only a pinch and agrees they can come back.

Maddie also gives Cecilia one chance to hear about the Delaware beach, on the condition that she keep it private. Cecilia posts about it anyway, and Dom comforts Maddie at home. The trip does not erase betrayal or grief, but Maddie is no longer carrying either alone.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The return journey changes the original ritual from a private assignment into a shared family practice. Rosaline’s decision to release only a pinch matters: the group does not force a complete goodbye merely because the itinerary says the final destination has arrived. They can preserve the possibility of returning without pretending the ashes contain Josh’s whole identity. Cecilia’s broken promise shows that Maddie’s growth does not make her immune to old injuries, nor does forgiveness require granting unlimited access. What has changed is the response around her. Dom comes to hold her, and the others continue remembering Josh aloud. The ending locates survival in repeated acts of connection, not in forgetting.

Analysis

The novel treats bereavement not as a single emotional event but as a sequence of encounters with absence. Josh’s letters make that sequence literal: each destination gives Maddie another task, another version of her brother, and another deadline approaching the last words. The structure captures an ambivalence common to grief. She wants the next letter because it restores contact, yet fears the moment when the letters run out. The ashes provide a visible object for that attachment, but their physical instability repeatedly undermines the hope that a ritual can make loss orderly.

Maddie’s relationship with Dom is shaped by the same tension between dependence and self-protection. She learned early that family members could leave, criticize, or make affection conditional, so she tries to become indispensable at work and hides vulnerable truths from friends. Dom’s compulsive caretaking initially resembles control, but the story gradually reveals its roots in responsibility assumed too young and in his fear of failing people he loves. Their romance becomes credible not because he makes grand promises, but because they learn to negotiate consent, asthma, emotional boundaries, and the difference between helping and deciding for someone else.

The book also complicates the language of responsibility. Dom’s marriage, Maddie’s overwork, and Rosaline’s early choices all emerge from attempts to do what seems safest or most necessary. Those choices can be loving and still cause harm. The decisive repair comes when people tell the truth about why they acted, rather than relying on others to infer it. Rosaline’s history breaks Maddie’s idealized comparison, while Jeremy and Tula challenge her belief that she must earn loyalty by being useful.

Ultimately, the story rejects a clean cure for grief. Maddie cries, but grief remains; she forgives some people, while Cecilia’s later betrayal still hurts. What changes is not the fact of loss but the distribution of its weight. Shared memories, repeated visits, honest boundaries, and a family chosen through care allow Maddie to keep living without pretending that love guarantees safety.

Summary in 60 Seconds
After her brother Josh dies, Maddie is shocked to learn that he named her and Dominic, her former best friend and heartbreak, to carry his ashes through eight states. At each stop, a letter gives them a task and reveals another piece of Josh's life. Their arguments soften into intimacy, but Maddie fears Dom will choose his former wife again. When he misses a trip to help that ex, Maddie scatters ashes alone and ends their relationship. Dom later explains that his marriage began with a pregnancy and miscarriage, while Maddie faces the family wounds that make her expect abandonment. On the final trip, they postpone scattering the last ashes. A puzzle leads Maddie to Rosaline, whose history clarifies the tangled past. Maddie chooses a future with Dom, and, years later, their wider circle returns to Josh's destinations together.
Contains spoilers

Last updated:

Report Issue

Review Summary

4.01 out of 5
Average of 72k+ ratings from Goodreads and Amazon.

PS: I Hate You received mixed reviews. Many readers loved the emotional journey and character development, praising the author's handling of grief and romance. The story follows Maddie and Dom as they fulfill her late brother's wish to scatter his ashes across eight states. Some found Maddie frustrating and immature, while others appreciated her growth. The book's humor, pacing, and depth resonated with many readers, though some criticized the lack of communication between characters. Overall, it's a polarizing but impactful read that elicited strong emotional responses.

Your rating:
4.49
107 ratings
Want to read the full book?

Characters

Maddie Sanderson

The guarded grieving sister

Maddie is a book-loving, puzzle-making introvert whose humor sharpens when she feels exposed. Raised by an often absent mother and a critical grandmother, she learned to depend on her brother Josh and to treat self-sufficiency as protection. She works hard enough to become indispensable, while her asthma makes some of Josh’s outdoor adventures physically demanding. Her attraction to Dom carries years of longing and injury, so she often uses sarcasm to keep him at a distance even as she seeks his attention. Maddie is neither naturally demonstrative nor emotionally simple: grief can arrive as irritation, silence, or a frantic need to finish tasks. Her central struggle is learning that accepting care does not require surrendering her choices.

Dominic Perry

The caretaker who cannot let go

Dom is Josh’s best friend, Maddie’s longtime crush, and the eldest Perry sibling. Responsible from childhood, he tends to show affection by anticipating needs, making plans, and solving practical problems. The same instinct that makes him dependable can turn controlling, especially when he fears someone may be harmed. He is quiet and disciplined, but Josh and Maddie draw out his dry humor, competitiveness, and playful side. Dom’s romantic history with Maddie is complicated by choices he made from obligation rather than honest self-knowledge. He values loyalty deeply and struggles to distinguish caring for someone from deciding what is best for them. His challenge is learning to state what he wants and remain present without demanding that care be accepted as proof.

Josh Sanderson

The restless brother

Josh is Maddie’s older brother, Dom’s closest friend, and a successful travel photographer with an appetite for new places and people. Funny, generous, and fond of elaborate scavenger hunts, he draws his homebody sister into experiences by making them personal and playful. He offers Maddie the loyalty she rarely receives from their mother or grandmother, while also creating an expansive chosen family around himself. Josh’s letters combine humor with direct emotional challenges, encouraging the people he loves to share stories, take risks, and ask for what they need. His charisma does not make him flawless: he knows he has regrets and wants those closest to him to learn from them.

Rosaline

The gracious old friend

Rosaline is a gifted, composed young woman who has been close to Josh and Dom since their school years. Her intelligence, beauty, and social ease make her an easy point of comparison for Maddie, especially because Cecilia praises her. Yet Rosaline is not simply an idealized rival. She is loyal, compassionate, and capable of asking for what she wants, even when fear complicates her choices. She shares a long history with the Perry family and carries her own private understanding of Josh. Her kindness toward Maddie is genuine, though their relationship has never been as intimate as her bond with the two men. Rosaline represents both the past Maddie envies and a person she has not yet learned to know.

Jeremy Hassan

The loyal chosen brother

Jeremy is Maddie’s handsome ex-boyfriend and devoted best friend. Their romantic relationship ends amicably when both recognize that friendship suits them better, and he continues showing up with comfort, food, and humor. He is perceptive enough to notice when Maddie retreats, but he tries to support rather than force her to explain herself. His own painful history makes him especially attentive to trust and the fear of being judged. Jeremy’s warmth gives Maddie a model of intimacy that is not romantic and not conditional on her being cheerful.

Tula

The blunt, steady friend

Tula is Maddie’s close friend, an engineer who is direct, capable, and unafraid to challenge a bad arrangement. She brings margaritas, practical advice, and a willingness to cross a continent for Maddie. Her bluntness can feel uncomfortable, but it is grounded in genuine concern rather than judgment. Tula recognizes when Maddie uses work to avoid grief and pushes her to make room for a life beyond being useful. She represents a form of friendship that can withstand disagreement and still remain close.

Adam Perry

The exuberant twin

Adam is one of Dom’s younger twin brothers. Flirtatious, funny, and impulsive, he brings levity to tense family moments and has long adored Maddie. His warmth makes him easy to approach, though his teasing can overshoot when he forgets the setting. Adam is also creative and drawn to woodworking, even as he weighs that interest against his swimming ambitions. He remembers Maddie’s place in his adolescence and is willing to seek her out when she withdraws, showing that his affection is more durable than his jokes suggest.

Carter Perry

The observant twin

Carter is Adam’s twin and Dom’s younger brother. Quieter and more observant than Adam, he often communicates through a shared look or a well-timed practical choice. He is thoughtful, creative, and interested in writing and design. Carter’s experiences at school reveal how easily a quiet person’s difficulties can go unnoticed, even by people who care. He values Maddie’s presence and has a gentle way of reconnecting with her that does not require her to perform enthusiasm.

Cecilia Sanderson

The image-conscious mother

Cecilia is Maddie and Josh’s mother, skilled at presenting a polished public face and attentive to how other people see her. She often gives her daughter criticism where Maddie needs warmth, and she treats personal events as potential material for her online following. Her relationship with her children is strained by absence and self-involvement. Cecilia’s desire to be seen as a grieving mother conflicts with Maddie’s wish to protect the private meaning of Josh’s last requests.

Florence Sanderson

The critical grandmother

Florence is Maddie’s grandmother and the adult who largely raised her when Cecilia was away. Her household runs on rules and punishment rather than emotional reassurance, and she frequently criticizes Maddie’s appearance and prospects. Florence’s treatment helps explain why Maddie learned to minimize her needs and retreat into books. She is also part of a family history in which harshness is normalized and care is confused with basic provision.

Emilia Perry

The welcoming Perry matriarch

Emilia is Dom, Adam, and Carter’s mother, a warm and generous presence who treats Maddie as part of the family. Her hugs and invitations contrast with the emotional distance Maddie experiences at home. Emilia balances affection with a busy professional life, and her household’s openness gives Maddie a glimpse of the dependable family life she longs for. She remains connected to Rosaline and encourages the Perry family to stay close.

Nathanial Perry

The steady Perry father

Nathanial is Dom’s father, a neurologist and devoted member of the Perry family. His demanding work sometimes leaves Dom carrying more responsibility at home, but his affection for his children is clear. He offers Maddie practical help and welcomes her into family gatherings.

Carlisle

Jeremy’s loving partner

Carlisle is Jeremy’s partner and a familiar presence in Maddie’s chosen circle. He joins the friends’ gatherings, shares their care for Maddie, and helps make her home a place where people can arrive without ceremony.

Pamela

Maddie’s demanding boss

Pamela directs logistics at Maddie’s accounting firm and relies heavily on her sole logistics associate. Her confidence in Maddie is genuine, but the company’s dependence encourages Maddie to overwork and avoid taking leave. Pamela represents the workplace structure Maddie mistakes for secure belonging.

Reggie and Carmen

The tattoo shop couple

Reggie and Carmen own Ink Ever After, the Kansas tattoo shop where Josh once earned a favor by photographing their engagement. They honor his request to pass that favor to Maddie and Dom, treating the memorial tattoos as a meaningful continuation of their friendship with him.

Harold

The keeper of Josh’s clue

Harold owns the North Pole stationery and camera shop in Alaska. He knew Josh through photography and protects a puzzle Josh prepared for Maddie, trusting that she will recognize the trail he left behind.

Mary

Maddie’s therapist

Mary is the therapist Maddie eventually trusts enough to discuss grief and fear. She does not solve Maddie’s problems for her; she helps her examine the beliefs that make closeness and uncertainty feel dangerous.

Plot Devices

Josh’s travel letters

A map made of goodbyes

Josh leaves a sequence of sealed letters for Maddie and Dom, each tied to a destination by coordinates. They may open each one only after arriving, and its instructions shape what they do there. The letters provide structure for a journey neither would have chosen, while giving Josh a continuing presence in their decisions. Their changing tone moves from playful requests to emotional disclosures and finally a goodbye. The dwindling supply of letters gives each trip both comfort and dread, since hearing from Josh again also means approaching the point when no more messages remain.

The divided ashes

Grief made portable

Josh’s ashes are divided into portions and carried in reusable containers from state to state. Maddie and Dom must physically bring him to places he never saw, making each farewell concrete but incomplete. The ashes sometimes behave in ungainly ways, floating on the ocean or scattering in the wind, which resists the fantasy of a perfectly composed goodbye. The containers become a focus for Maddie’s attachment, but the story gradually distinguishes the physical remains from the memories and relationships that sustain Josh’s presence.

Josh’s wrist inscription

Memory worn in ink

At a Kansas tattoo shop, Maddie chooses to have Josh’s handwritten sign-off inked on her wrist, and Dom chooses the same design. The tattoo turns his writing into a lasting, visible mark that accompanies them beyond the trips. It contrasts with the ashes and letters, which are finite, fragile, or subject to loss. The paired tattoos also make the bond between Maddie and Dom visible before either is ready to define their relationship. Their significance grows as Maddie learns that Dom’s care for Josh was intimate and longstanding.

The 0718 safe code

A hidden sign of care

Dom stores Josh’s letters in a safe and uses 0718, Maddie’s birthday, as its combination. Maddie initially demands the code so she can protect the letters if anything happens to Dom, then learns that the numbers are personal rather than practical. The safe makes trust tangible: she needs access to what remains of Josh, while Dom has already placed her date at the center of a private safeguard. Its meaning is revealed gradually, connecting Dom’s quiet acts of care to feelings he has not yet admitted.

The Alaskan puzzle

A final clue beyond goodbye

After the last letter is read at Pika Glacier, Maddie notices that its compass emblem matches the sign of a nearby stationery shop. The shopkeeper recognizes Josh and gives them a bag of puzzle pieces he had left for Maddie. Completing the puzzle reveals a photograph of Josh and Rosaline together, giving Maddie a reason to hear Rosaline’s account of their shared history. The clue prevents the final letter from closing the story too neatly: even after the planned messages end, Maddie can still discover more about her brother through the people he loved.

About the Author

Lauren Connolly is an accomplished author known for her contemporary and paranormal romance novels. Her writing has garnered awards and a dedicated readership. Connolly's nomadic lifestyle influences her work, as she draws inspiration from various landscapes and settings. Her home is often filled with pets, including a dog and twin cats, reflecting her love for animals. Connolly's passion for literature is evident in her extensive book collection, featuring works by authors she admires. Her ability to craft emotionally resonant stories that blend romance with deeper themes has established her as a notable figure in the genre.

Download PDF

To save this PS summary for later, download the free PDF. You can print it out, or read offline at your convenience.
Download PDF
File size: 0.43 MB     Pages: 30

Download EPUB

To read this PS summary on your e-reader device or app, download the free EPUB. The .epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.
Download EPUB
File size: 1.51 MB     Pages: 39
Want to read the full book?
Follow
Listen
Home
Swipe
Library
Get App
Try Full Access for 3 Days
Listen, bookmark, and more
Compare Features Free Pro
📖 Read Summaries
Read unlimited summaries. Free users get 3 per month
🎧 Listen to Summaries
Listen to unlimited summaries in 40 languages
—
❤️ Unlimited Bookmarks
Free users are limited to 4
—
📜 Unlimited History
Free users are limited to 4
—
📥 Unlimited Downloads
Free users are limited to 1
—
Risk-Free Timeline
Today: Get Instant Access
Listen to full summaries of 26,000+ books. That's 12,000+ hours of audio!
Day 2: Trial Reminder
We'll send you a notification that your trial is ending soon.
Day 3: Your subscription begins
You'll be charged on Nov 24,
cancel anytime before.
Consume 2.8× More Books
2.8× more books Listening Reading
Our users love us
1M+ readers
Trustpilot Rating
TrustPilot
4.6 Excellent
This site is a total game-changer. I've been flying through book summaries like never before. Highly, highly recommend.
— Dave G
Worth my money and time, and really well made. I've never seen this quality of summaries on other websites. Very helpful!
— Em
Highly recommended!! Fantastic service. Perfect for those that want a little more than a teaser but not all the intricate details of a full audio book.
— Greg M
Save 62%
Yearly
$119.88 $44.99/year/yr
$3.75/mo
Monthly
$9.99/mo
Start a 3-Day Free Trial
3 days free, then $44.99/year. Cancel anytime.
Unlock a world of fiction & nonfiction books
26,000+ books for the price of 2 books
Read any book in 10 minutes
Discover new books like Tinder
Request any book if it's not summarized
Read more books than anyone you know
#1 app for book lovers
Lifelike & immersive summaries
30-day money-back guarantee
Download summaries in EPUBs or PDFs
Cancel anytime in a few clicks

Why one summary?

Scanner
Find a barcode to scan

⭐
⭐
⭐
We have a special gift for you
Open
38% off
DISCOUNT FOR YOU
⭐
⭐
⭐
$79.99
$49.99/year
Only $4.16 per month
Continue
2 taps to start, super easy to cancel
Settings
General
Widget
Loading...