Key Takeaways
Treat a campaign promise to kill as policy, not theatrical excess.
A promise enters homes. In the first months of Rodrigo Duterte’s presidency, masked men entered eleven-year-old Love-Love’s home. One called her father a confirmed target, then shot him. When her mother pleaded that the family had stopped using drugs, the men returned and killed her too. Love-Love tried to shield her mother and begged to be shot instead. The family’s deaths were not an abstraction to her, or to the reporter interviewing her. They were the consequence of a political climate in which killing suspected drug users had been publicly promised and excused.
The reporter is implicated. Evangelista had spent years recording other people’s deaths while keeping herself outside the story. She admits that the professional pose of neutrality also protected her from fear and responsibility. The book is her effort to account for both the dead and the society that permitted their deaths.
What's striking is how the opening replaces a debate about political style with the immediate consequences of a threat. Political communication research often finds that repeated elite messages can shift what audiences regard as acceptable, especially when leaders signal that violence is sanctioned. The family's story makes that mechanism concrete without claiming that rhetoric alone explains every killing. The journalism also rejects the fantasy that a reporter can stand wholly outside a national crisis. Still, a single family's experience cannot represent every victim; its force lies in making one life specific, not in making it statistically typical.
Democracy can authorize violence when heroic myths replace scrutiny.
The past is contested. Evangelista grew up with the People Power Revolution of 1986 as a national origin story: Filipinos stood before tanks and helped topple Ferdinand Marcos. But the story has complications. Her grandfather, journalist Mario Chanco, signed a 1986 manifesto supporting Marcos, and he chose not to join the mass protest. He described himself as part of a majority committed to survival. His choices helped provide the comfortable life and education his granddaughter inherited.
Memory can be reused. The author also traces how Spanish and American rule, the Marcos dictatorship, and the return of Marcos family power shaped Philippine politics. The 1986 revolution did not make democratic habits permanent. In 2022, Ferdinand Marcos Jr. won the presidency alongside the Duterte family’s political machine. A heroic national past can inspire resistance, but it can also become a comforting story that conceals present-day compromise.
What's striking is the refusal to make family history a simple morality tale. Political memory works less like a public archive than a set of usable stories: each generation selects heroes, omissions, and lessons that fit present needs. Research on collective memory similarly shows that commemorations can unite people while obscuring disagreements over what actually happened. The grandfather’s decision to survive adds an important distinction: caution under authoritarianism is not identical to enthusiastic collaboration, though it can still carry consequences. Democracy depends not only on remembering resistance, but on examining the compromises made in its name.
Make the target group seem monstrous before accepting its mass punishment.
A label becomes a threat. Duterte described suspected drug users as violent, irredeemable dangers, often linking drug use to rape and murder. But the categories and numbers were unstable. A 2015 government survey estimated 1.8 million current illegal drug users, less than half of them using methamphetamine. The survey counted people who had used an illegal drug within thirteen months; it did not establish that every person was addicted or violent.
The numbers grew in public. Duterte’s estimates ranged from roughly three million to six million, and he claimed drug users had caused 77,000 deaths in a few years. The book contrasts that claim with official murder and homicide totals that were far lower. Police lists also labeled a village drug-affected if even one suspected user or dealer was present. When uncertain categories and inflated claims become the basis for policy, broad suspicion can be made to look like proof.
This section exposes a familiar political sequence: define a threatening population, exaggerate its scale, then present extraordinary force as ordinary protection. Criminology distinguishes drug use from substance-use disorder, and both from violent offending; collapsing these categories encourages policy to target identity rather than demonstrated conduct. Numbers can lend a policy scientific authority even when their methods are weak or mismatched. The book's comparison is especially useful because it asks readers to inspect how estimates were produced, not merely which figure sounds most alarming. That scrutiny should not imply that addiction or drug markets cause no harm; it challenges the claim that collective punishment is a reliable remedy.
Track who acts whenever official language makes killing sound passive.
Words conceal the actor. In the Philippines, salvage can mean the extrajudicial killing of a suspected criminal. During the drug war, police reports also used phrases such as deaths under investigation, neutralized, and nanlaban, meaning the suspect fought back. These terms can turn a deliberate action into an impersonal event or a justified police outcome.
Grammar carries responsibility. A report saying a body was found records a fact while leaving the killer unnamed. Evangelista contrasts that passive construction with direct sentences naming the person or institution that killed someone. The distinction matters especially when reporters face libel threats or state pressure. Repeated official descriptions can turn a pattern of deaths into separate, apparently routine incidents, while the people killed disappear from public view a second time.
What's striking is the treatment of grammar as part of political infrastructure, not decoration. In discourse analysis, euphemism and passive phrasing are understood to distribute or obscure agency; the same sentence can make state violence seem natural, accidental, or ownerless. The book’s close attention to local meanings is essential: salvage does not carry the same implication everywhere, and translating it as mere rescue would erase its Philippine history. Yet active voice is not a substitute for verification. Naming an accused actor responsibly requires evidence, attribution, and room for response, precisely the disciplines the reporter describes.
Demand evidence when police reports presume every officer acted properly.
A legal presumption can shield power. The presumption of regularity treats public officers as having performed their duties properly unless evidence shows otherwise. During Duterte’s drug war, police repeatedly said suspects resisted arrest, or nanlaban, and presented killings as justified encounters. Official reports sometimes shifted in detail, but the standard explanation remained that the officers had no choice.
One survivor disrupted the script. In Payatas, police said five men had fired at officers. Four died; Efren Morillo survived a chest wound and said the men had been restrained before police shot them. Forensic reviewers found that the available evidence supported his account, and a court acquitted him of assaulting police. His survival made it possible to challenge the official story, though the Ombudsman later dismissed his complaints against the officers. Evidence exposed contradictions but did not guarantee accountability.
What's striking is that a legal doctrine intended to support orderly administration can become dangerous when it is treated as a substitute for investigation. In criminal justice, the presumption of innocence and the obligation to test evidence protect against the state’s considerable power. Morillo’s case shows why independent witnesses, forensic review, and records matter: an official narrative can be internally consistent and still be false. The outcome also cautions against equating exposure with justice. A survivor can disprove a charge and still face a system that declines to prosecute the people who shot his companions.
Outsourced violence lets officials deny responsibility while killings continue.
The method predates Duterte. In Davao, paramilitary groups such as Alsa Masa fought suspected Communists during the post-Marcos period, with government support and reported human rights abuses. Later, witnesses described a Davao Death Squad that targeted alleged criminals and drug users. Rodrigo Duterte denied that the group existed, while the Commission on Human Rights found circumstantial evidence of systematic killings and official tolerance. Investigations stalled, and testimony was disputed.
The pattern traveled. In Manila, members of a civilian group called CSG Chapter 2 described surveillance, target lists, and payments for killings. Some said police officers knew of or directed the operations; officials denied responsibility. The book carefully leaves disputed allegations disputed. Its broader point is that a state can benefit from violence performed by auxiliary groups, while the distance between order-giver and gunman makes accountability harder.
What's striking is the continuity between formal institutions and informal violence. Political science describes this as delegated coercion: states can use armed intermediaries to pursue goals while preserving plausible deniability. The Philippine examples show how delegation may also blur organizational boundaries, since former insurgents, police personnel, local officials, and civilian volunteers can overlap. That complexity requires precision. Testimony, human-rights findings, and disputed claims are not interchangeable proof, and a responsible account must mark their different evidentiary status. The central insight remains powerful: deniability is not the same as absence of state involvement.
A promise of safety can make other people's deaths feel acceptable.
Support had ordinary motives. Duterte’s voters did not all share one ideology. Jason Quizon, an overseas engineer with liberal views, backed Duterte partly because the president addressed the airport bullet-planting scam that frightened travelers. Joy Tan, whose family struggled with addiction and whose community experienced neglect, saw Duterte as a protector. Ann Valdez, who had grown up without her father, embraced the president as a substitute parent. Their hopes were real, even as the promised violence was explicit.
Distance made the bargain easier. Some supporters assumed that only dangerous criminals would die, or that the president was exaggerating for effect. Poor suspects and people already stigmatized as drug users seemed remote from their own lives. Evangelista does not excuse those choices, but she shows how promises of order can turn the suffering of a marked group into a tolerable price for everyone else’s security.
What's striking is the book’s refusal to reduce political support to ignorance or cruelty. People often judge policies through the risks they personally face, the services they lack, and the credibility of available alternatives. That helps explain why a strongman can appear responsive where ordinary government feels absent. But empathy for voters should not erase the consequences of their choices, especially when lethal promises are public. The useful question is not whether supporters were good or bad people; it is how fear, neglect, and social distance made a policy of killing seem like practical problem-solving.
Record names before institutions reduce victims to statistics.
The totals are uncertain. The Philippine government reported 6,252 suspects killed in police operations by May 2022, while other estimates were substantially higher. The Commission on Human Rights suggested the broader toll could reach 27,000, and the International Criminal Court prosecutor cited estimates of 12,000 to at least 20,000 killings. These figures count different things and cannot be treated as a single settled total.
Names restore what totals erase. Evangelista records people such as Djastin Lopez, whose police report misspelled his name and described his death as a justified encounter. His mother, Normy, pursued a case, faced threats, and eventually accepted settlement money under family pressure. The book does not turn her into a perfect symbol; she regrets the settlement. Her account shows that the aftermath includes grief, fear, money, and difficult choices, not only a number in a report.
What's striking is the book’s use of names as a form of evidence and a form of resistance. Data can reveal patterns that individual stories cannot, while testimony can reveal the costs and institutional failures that aggregate totals hide. The two forms of knowledge should correct each other. Uncertain death counts must be presented with their definitions and limits, not inflated into certainty for rhetorical force. At the same time, a victim’s story should not be asked to prove an entire national pattern by itself. Good public memory needs both careful counting and attention to singular lives.
Treat political regret as responsibility, not instant absolution.
Some supporters changed their minds. Jason’s turning point came when he saw evidence that Kian delos Santos, a seventeen-year-old student, had been dragged by police and killed despite their claim that he fought back. Dondon Chan began Kwentong Ex-DDS, a social-media group where former Duterte supporters could admit regret. It grew to more than 70,000 members. Ann Valdez stopped defending the president online and had the house bearing her tribute to him demolished.
Contrition changes the story. Joy Tan later acknowledged that she had supported a leader whose violence she once welcomed. She began speaking publicly and helping victims. These confessions do not undo harm, and the book does not offer remorse as a clean escape. They matter because admitting error can interrupt the loyalty that keeps political identities intact and can create a basis for action rather than denial.
What's striking is the difference between regret as self-punishment and regret as civic learning. Moral psychology suggests that admitting a mistaken choice is difficult when it threatens a person’s sense of identity; people often defend the original decision instead. These accounts show a different route: reconsider the evidence, name the error, and accept some responsibility for persuading others. Yet apology alone cannot repair institutional damage or restore lives. Contrition becomes politically meaningful when it leads to sustained attention, support for accountability, and resistance to the same reasoning in future campaigns.
Treat Duterte's killings as a national choice, not one mad cop's exception.
The viral video did not begin the pattern. In 2020, off-duty officer Jonel Nuezca shot Sonya Gregorio and her son Frank Anthony during an argument recorded by a relative. The video made it impossible to claim that the victims had fought back. The government condemned Nuezca, called him an isolated case, and promised justice. He was convicted of murder, then died in prison in 2021.
The exception can hide the rule. Evangelista argues that the video shocked many viewers because it removed the official story that had accompanied thousands of earlier deaths. Her closing returns to the 1986 question of whether soldiers would shoot fellow Filipinos, and to the 2022 return of the Marcos name. The point is not that every citizen ordered a killing, but that elected leaders, police institutions, supporters, and bystanders helped make violence permissible.
What's striking is the distinction between direct guilt and collective political responsibility. A citizen who did not pull a trigger is not equivalent to a police officer who did, but democratic consent still shapes which actions institutions can carry out with impunity. The video made violence undeniable; it did not make earlier victims more deserving of belief. This is a general problem of visual evidence: vividness can trigger attention while leaving less visible testimony neglected. The stronger civic test is whether outrage extends beyond a shocking clip to sustained scrutiny of policy, institutions, and the people harmed without cameras.
Analysis
This memoir argues that mass violence is not only a sequence of killings. It is a social arrangement that makes those killings legible as security, routine, or deserved punishment. Evangelista traces that arrangement across presidential rhetoric, police procedure, vigilante networks, public language, media practice, and voter expectation. The connective thread is not simply Duterte’s personality. It is the conversion of suspicion into a target, a target into a threat, and a death into a bureaucratic event with no accountable subject.
The book’s most distinctive method is to treat words as evidence. Salvage, neutralized, encounter, and nanlaban do not merely describe events; they shape which explanations seem plausible and who bears the burden of proof. The grammatical discussion is especially effective because it translates institutional evasion into a form readers can inspect sentence by sentence. Its narrative method complements that analysis: a national death toll is placed beside a child’s memory, a misspelled name, a family’s fear, or a voter’s changed mind. The result is neither a detached policy report nor an uncomplicated denunciation. It exposes how violence can feel reasonable to people who believe they are outside its reach.
The work also takes care to distinguish evidence from allegation. Police accounts, witness testimony, forensic analysis, human-rights findings, and official denials do not have identical status. That distinction matters because the book’s subject is precisely a state that contested the record. The uncertainty around total deaths therefore strengthens the case for careful documentation rather than weakening it.
Its hardest implication is democratic: elections do not cleanse the policies they authorize, and voters’ motives do not erase foreseeable consequences. Yet responsibility is not evenly distributed. Leaders who order or normalize violence, officers who execute it, institutions that fail to investigate, and citizens who support it occupy different positions. By retaining those distinctions while refusing collective innocence, the memoir makes accountability more demanding, and more credible.
Review Summary
Some People Need Killing is a powerful memoir detailing Patricia Evangelista's coverage of Rodrigo Duterte's violent drug war in the Philippines. Readers praise Evangelista's courageous journalism, precise language, and ability to humanize victims. The book provides historical context and personal reflections, offering a scathing critique of Duterte's regime. While some found the writing style repetitive or confusing at times, most agree it's an important, eye-opening work. The graphic content and heavy themes make it a challenging but necessary read for understanding recent Philippine history and the human cost of extrajudicial killings.
People Also Read
Glossary
Extrajudicial killing
Killing outside legal processA deliberate killing carried out outside a lawful judicial process. In the book, the term covers executions by state agents or non-state actors that occur without trial and violate legal protections. The author emphasizes that naming such deaths accurately matters, because official alternatives can recast targeted killings as ordinary homicides or legitimate police operations.
Salvage
Philippine term for executionIn Philippine English, salvage can mean apprehending and executing a suspected criminal without trial. The word contrasts with its more common meaning of rescuing or saving something. The book traces its local use to an older history of state violence and shows how the term became ordinary language for bodies found after targeted killings.
Tokhang
Police drug-surrender visitsA police procedure during the Duterte drug campaign, named by blending the Visayan words toktok, meaning knock, and hangyo, meaning plead. Officers visited people suspected of drug activity and urged them to surrender or promise to stop. The program was presented as persuasion, although the book describes it within a campaign whose leaders also threatened suspects with death.
Nanlaban
Claim that suspects fought backA Filipino term meaning that someone fought back. During the drug war, police used it to describe suspects said to have resisted arrest, often as the explanation for fatal shootings. The book shows how the word became a compact justification: it suggested resistance, danger, and the legitimacy of the killing without independently establishing what happened.
Presumption of regularity
Assumption of proper official conductA legal presumption that public officers performed their duties properly unless evidence contradicts it. The book explains that the principle can be rebutted, but argues that it was repeatedly invoked to support police accounts of fatal encounters. When treated as a conclusion rather than a starting point for investigation, it can make official claims harder to challenge.
Drug personality
Catch-all suspected drug categoryAn official category used for people suspected of involvement with illegal drugs, including users, dealers, and other alleged participants. The book describes how local watchlists gathered names through community reporting and informal claims. Because the category could cover people with very different conduct and levels of evidence, it helped turn suspicion into a basis for police attention and potential danger.
Davao Death Squad
Alleged Davao killing networkThe name used for a group or network accused of killing suspected criminals and drug users in Davao City during Rodrigo Duterte’s years as mayor. Former members and witnesses described police involvement and orders from officials; Duterte denied the group’s existence. The Commission on Human Rights found circumstantial evidence of systematic killings and official tolerance, while investigations remained inconclusive.
Doublethink
Acceptance of contradictory beliefsA term from George Orwell’s Nineteen Eighty-Four for holding contradictory beliefs and accepting both. Evangelista uses it to interpret the drug war’s competing claims: the government could praise legal procedure while encouraging lethal force, or condemn police abuses while protecting police power. The concept helps explain how contradictions can be absorbed rather than resolved.
Pseudo-event
Event staged for public reportingA term introduced by historian Daniel J. Boorstin for an event created or shaped primarily to be reported. Such an event may be real, but its public meaning is managed through staging and presentation. The book applies the concept to official performances of accountability that can supply persuasive images without establishing meaningful responsibility.
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.