Key Takeaways
Follow observable price trends instead of pretending to know what markets will do.
React, do not forecast. Trend following is a trading approach that waits for prices to move, then takes a position in that direction. It aims to participate in a substantial part of a move, not to identify its exact beginning or end. The strategy can go long in rising markets or short in falling ones, across many kinds of markets.
A revealing contrast. The book pairs John W. Henry, whose systematic trading made money during the collapse of Barings Bank, with trader Nick Leeson, whose bets helped bring the bank down. Covel also cites the Barclays CTA Index, which returned 2,805 percent from 1980 to 2008, or a reported 12.2 percent annualized. These historical figures illustrate the case, not a promise of future performance.
The central appeal is its shift from prediction to feedback: act on what the market has done, then adjust as new information arrives. That resembles adaptive control systems, which respond to measured conditions rather than relying on a perfect forecast. The tradeoff is that reacting means accepting delay. A signal can arrive after a move has begun, and a market that reverses repeatedly can generate losses and costs. The idea is not that uncertainty disappears, but that a method can make decisions without pretending uncertainty has been solved.
Let market price outrank the story you tell about what should happen.
Stories explain; prices decide. Fundamental analysis tries to interpret forces such as earnings, supply, demand, or policy to judge what an asset ought to be worth. Covel argues that such explanations rarely answer the practical trading questions: when to enter, how much to risk, and when to leave. A company can make a product people love while its stock falls sharply, so liking the business is not a trading rule.
Use price as the signal. The book distinguishes reactive technical trading from chart patterns presented as forecasts. A trend follower does not need a persuasive account of why a market is rising. The relevant evidence is that its price is rising according to the chosen rules. The same logic applies when prices fall, even if the move seems irrational or temporary.
This is a useful antidote to narrative bias. People often mistake a coherent explanation for predictive power, especially when a story fits events after they occur. Price is also a disciplined, observable input, which makes rules easier to test than judgments about what an asset should be worth. Still, price is not a complete account of value or risk. The approach is most coherent for trading decisions, not as a universal replacement for the questions a long-term owner, company, or policymaker must ask.
Write entry, position-size, and exit rules before the market tests your nerve.
Make the process explicit. A trading system answers what markets can be traded, when to enter, how large a position to take, and when to exit losing or winning trades. One simple example in the book enters long when price exceeds its previous 100-day high and short when it falls below its previous 100-day low. Other systems use different thresholds, but the point is to make decisions repeatable.
Size for volatility. Position size should reflect both the account’s equity and the market’s volatility. The Average True Range is one measure used to estimate that volatility. A system can also include a neutral position, where the trader is out of the market. Covel stresses that a signal is not a system unless its user follows it consistently rather than accepting only the advice that feels comfortable.
Rules turn a vague intention into a procedure that can be examined, repeated, and challenged. This is valuable beyond trading: precommitted choices can reduce the influence of stress and hindsight. Yet a precise rule is not automatically a good rule. A 100-day threshold is an example, not a universal setting, and the right position size depends on an investor’s finances and tolerance for loss. The system must be evaluated as a whole, including implementation, rather than judged by how elegant its entry signal sounds.
Keep each loss small enough to survive a run of bad trades.
Losses are part of the method. A drawdown is a period in which losses reduce the value of an account from a previous level. Trend followers expect drawdowns because a system cannot know in advance which signals will work. The book recounts Japanese visitors who were surprised to hear a trader describe losses as normal. The surprise captures a common trap: expecting a legitimate strategy to win every time.
Set the limit in advance. Covel describes risking about 1 percent of account value on a trade as a cautious starting point and warns that risking more than 5 percent can be dangerous. These are the author's rules of thumb, not a guarantee or a prescription for every trader. The governing idea is to decide how much can be lost before entering, then exit when the rule says the trade has failed.
This is a practical application of the mathematics of ruin: a loss hurts more when it consumes a large share of the capital needed to keep participating. Small, defined risks preserve the option to continue, while an unplanned commitment can turn a temporary setback into a permanent one. The percentages should not be treated as universal safety thresholds. Gaps, leverage, correlated positions, and execution conditions can make realized losses exceed a planned limit, so risk must be considered at both trade and portfolio level.
Let occasional large trends compensate for many modest losing trades.
Winning often is not the goal. The book contrasts a high win rate with a favorable payoff structure. A hypothetical system wins 90 of 100 trades, earning $100 on each winner, but loses $1,000 on each of the 10 losing trades. The winners make $9,000; the losers cost $10,000. Despite being right most of the time, the system loses money.
Leave room for outliers. Trend following tries to cut losing trades while allowing successful ones to continue as long as the trend persists. The book compares this with baseball: a hitter can strike out frequently and still excel if the home runs are valuable enough. A preset profit target may feel reassuring, but it can close a winning trade before an unusually large move has done its work.
The deeper lesson is to evaluate the size and distribution of outcomes, not just their frequency. This runs against the intuitive desire to be right and the emotional relief of quickly locking in a gain. It also explains why a trend strategy can feel unpleasant even when its long-run logic is sound: many small setbacks may precede a rare large payoff. The difficulty is that no one can know in advance which apparent winner will become an outlier, so the exit rule must balance staying power against the risk of giving back gains.
Search many markets because nobody knows where the next trend will emerge.
Broaden the opportunity set. The book’s proposed markets span currencies, bonds, stock indexes, agricultural products, metals, energy, and livestock. A price-based approach can be applied across them because the system responds to movement rather than requiring a different economic story for every market. The portfolio still needs limits: position sizes and combined risk matter, not just the risk of each trade considered alone.
Crises can create trends. Covel describes trend followers making money during the 2008 turmoil through positions in multiple markets and in both directions. The point is not that they predicted the crash. A trend in one market can be absent in another, so broad exposure creates more chances to encounter a sustained move. The book also gives a fund record with strong gains in some years and substantial losses in others, underscoring that results are uneven.
Diversification here means spreading the search for opportunity, not assuming every holding will protect the others. That distinction matters: in a crisis, assets can move together, and a broad portfolio can still experience concentrated losses if positions share underlying exposures. The strongest version of the argument is that an unknown future makes a narrow market focus fragile. The necessary counterpart is measuring portfolio-wide risk and checking whether apparent diversification survives real market stress.
Judge the process across many trades, not by its latest outcome.
Think in probabilities. A single trade says little about whether a method has an edge. The book uses a coin toss to illustrate that a long history of results does not determine the next result, and compares traders with short and long records to show why small samples can mislead. A hot streak, one winning tip, or one bad month is not enough evidence to judge a strategy.
Expect uneven returns. Trend following does not aim to produce smooth monthly gains. The book describes its return pattern as positively skewed: many modest losses or gains may be outweighed by a few unusually large winners. Its argument is that normal-distribution assumptions can understate the importance of extreme market moves. A trader must therefore evaluate results over a meaningful record and understand how much of performance comes from rare events.
This is a defense against both recency bias and the seduction of smoothness. A short record can make luck look like skill, while a steady sequence of tiny gains can conceal risks that have not yet appeared. The claim that extreme outcomes matter is especially important in financial markets, where a small number of events can dominate aggregate returns. But a long record is not automatically proof either: the rules, market coverage, fees, and changes in implementation must be examined before attributing performance to skill.
Automate tested rules, but never mistake a backtest for proof.
Use computers as tools. A computer can apply a proposed rule to extensive historical price data much faster than a person can inspect charts manually. This helps make results less dependent on memory or emotion and lets a trader compare possible rules. Covel’s point is that human judgment should define the question and the system; automation then applies those decisions consistently.
Beware curve fitting. Testing many variations can produce a strategy that looks excellent on past data simply because it was tailored to that history. The book calls out this overoptimization as a danger: a polished historical result may fail in live markets. Simplicity helps, but it does not eliminate the need to test whether a system remains credible across different markets and conditions.
Automation is most useful when it makes a hypothesis falsifiable, not when it lends a scientific costume to a weak idea. The distinction is central to research in any data-rich field: repeated searches increase the chance of finding accidental patterns. A robust process needs evidence beyond the sample used to design the rule, as well as realistic treatment of costs and execution. The computer can enforce discipline, but it cannot decide whether the original question was sensible or whether the test resembles the real world.
Ignore market theater; verify a strategy's rules, risks, and full record.
Confidence is not evidence. Covel criticizes financial media, market gurus, and sales pitches that offer predictions without clear rules for timing, position size, or exit. He contrasts their confident explanations with systematic traders who admit they do not know what a market will do next. The book’s warning is practical: if a source can never be shown to be wrong, its claims cannot be evaluated meaningfully.
Inspect the whole record. A strategy should be judged by its actual returns, losses, drawdowns, and behavior across changing markets, not by a famous name or one spectacular year. The book also points to the Turtles, a group of novices trained in systematic trading, as evidence that trading skill need not depend on a mystical gift or elite credentials. It still requires study, discipline, and the ability to follow a plan.
The call for verification is a strong defense against authority bias, especially when financial commentary rewards certainty and attention. A transparent process gives readers something concrete to assess: what triggers action, what limits loss, and what results occurred under those rules. Skepticism should also apply to advocates of trend following. A persuasive philosophy and selected success stories do not establish that a particular product is suitable, affordable, or honestly represented. The same evidentiary standard should be applied to every trading claim.
Analysis
Trend Commandments is both a case for systematic trend following and a polemic against prediction-driven finance. Its most valuable move is methodological: stop asking what markets ought to do, and instead define what observable price behavior will trigger a position, how much capital is exposed, and what condition ends the trade. That shift links the book’s trading advice to broader disciplines of feedback, decision science, and behavioral control. A trader does not need certainty about outcomes if the decision process can be repeated and its risks bounded.
The book’s narrative turns that abstract idea into a contrast between traders who adapt and institutions or investors who cling to explanations. John W. Henry and the Turtles represent process and apprenticeship; Nick Leeson, failed forecasts, and media gurus illustrate the costs of ego, leverage, and confident storytelling. The history section adds depth by tracing the gradual articulation of trend following through figures such as Jesse Livermore, William Dunnigan, and Richard Donchian. Across these examples, the memorable principle is not that every trend can be captured, but that repeated rules can exploit movements no one can reliably forecast in advance.
Covel’s rhetoric is deliberately combative, and that makes the argument vivid while sometimes overstating it. Historical performance examples, including the CTA index and named traders, are evidence that some practitioners have succeeded, not proof that all implementations will. The book was published in 2011, and its performance numbers belong to that historical context. Any strategy requires scrutiny of fees, leverage, liquidity, execution, and the possibility of long drawdowns. The author also treats price as the decisive trading input; that is coherent for a rule-based trading method, but it does not make fundamental analysis useless for every investment purpose.
The adaptation’s practical synthesis is therefore disciplined rather than heroic: define rules, size positions conservatively, diversify the search for trends, accept uneven outcomes, and evaluate a full record rather than a persuasive story. Trend following replaces forecasting with a structured response to uncertainty. It does not remove uncertainty, guarantee exceptional returns, or make losses painless.
Review Summary
Trend Commandments receives mixed reviews, with ratings ranging from 1 to 5 stars. Some readers find it insightful and entertaining, praising its psychological approach to trading and investment strategies. Others criticize it as repetitive, lacking in technical details, or merely a promotional tool for the author's other works. The book is generally viewed as an introduction to trend following and trading psychology rather than a comprehensive guide. While some appreciate its anecdotes and quotes, others find the content shallow or difficult to get through.
People Also Read
Glossary
Trend following
Trading in price directionA trading approach that enters positions after prices begin moving in a direction and attempts to remain in them while that movement continues. It can trade rising or falling markets and can be applied across many asset classes. It reacts to observed prices rather than relying on a forecast of why a market should move.
Systematic trend following
Rule-based trend tradingA form of trend following in which rules specify the markets to trade, entry and exit signals, position sizes, and risk limits. Those rules are applied consistently rather than overridden whenever a trader dislikes a signal. Systems differ in their mechanics, but are intended to respond to price movement without requiring a market forecast.
Drawdown
Decline from an account peakA period in which trading losses reduce an account from a previous high. In trend following, drawdowns can arise because signals frequently fail before a sustained trend appears. Their size depends on the strategy, position sizing, market conditions, and portfolio exposure. A trader needs to consider both the likelihood of losses and the ability to withstand them.
Average True Range
Measure of market volatilityA price-based measure used to estimate how much a market typically moves over a period. In the book, it serves as a way to compare market volatility and help determine position size. More volatile markets can require smaller positions to keep the risk of a trade in line with the account’s overall risk plan.
Fat tails
More extreme outcomesA statistical description of a return distribution in which very large gains or losses occur more often than a normal distribution would suggest. The book argues that large, unexpected market moves can dominate trend-following results. This is why smooth returns and standard assumptions about typical outcomes may give an incomplete picture of risk.
Portfolio heat
Combined open-position riskThe total amount of risk carried across a portfolio’s open positions. Risk on individual trades can add up: several modest positions may expose an account to substantial combined loss. The book uses heat to emphasize that risk management must consider the portfolio as a whole, not just the planned loss on each separate trade.
Positive skew return profile
Few outsized winning tradesA pattern in which a relatively small number of unusually large gains contribute substantially to total performance, while many other trades may produce smaller gains or losses. The book presents this as characteristic of trend following: losses are cut, while profitable positions are allowed to continue. Consequently, returns can be uneven and difficult to judge over short periods.
FAQ
1. What is "Trend Commandments: Trading for Exceptional Returns" by Michael W. Covel about?
- Focus on Trend Following: The book is a comprehensive guide to the philosophy, principles, and practicalities of trend following trading, a systematic approach to profiting from market trends.
- Challenging Conventional Wisdom: Covel critiques traditional investment strategies like buy-and-hold, fundamental analysis, and prediction-based trading, advocating for a rules-based, reactive approach.
- Accessible and Inspirational: Written in an accessible, storytelling style, the book aims to inspire readers to think differently about markets, risk, and wealth-building.
- Real-World Examples: It draws on decades of performance data, interviews with top traders, and historical context to illustrate how trend following works in practice.
2. Why should I read "Trend Commandments" by Michael W. Covel?
- Proven Track Record: The book presents evidence of long-term, exceptional returns achieved by trend following traders, offering an alternative to strategies that often fail during market crises.
- Actionable Philosophy: Covel provides a clear, actionable philosophy for trading and investing that emphasizes discipline, risk management, and adaptability.
- Debunks Myths: It debunks common myths about trading, such as the need for prediction, special talent, or insider knowledge, making success seem more attainable.
- Broad Applicability: The lessons extend beyond trading, offering insights into decision-making, psychology, and personal growth.
3. What are the key takeaways from "Trend Commandments" by Michael W. Covel?
- Follow Trends, Don’t Predict: Success comes from reacting to price movements, not trying to forecast the future.
- Systematic, Rules-Based Approach: Use clear, tested rules for entry, exit, and risk management—discipline trumps intuition or gut feeling.
- Risk Management is Crucial: Limiting losses and letting profits run is central; small losses are inevitable, but big wins pay for them.
- Markets Are Unpredictable: Accept that markets are chaotic and ever-changing; adaptability and agnosticism to market direction are essential.
4. How does trend following work according to "Trend Commandments" by Michael W. Covel?
- Reactive, Not Predictive: Trend following waits for a market to move and then follows that movement, rather than trying to anticipate it.
- Universal Application: The same rules are applied across all markets—stocks, commodities, currencies, etc.—based solely on price data.
- Defined Rules: Traders use specific, systematic rules for when to enter, how much to trade, and when to exit both winning and losing positions.
- Risk and Money Management: Position sizing and risk limits are set in advance, ensuring no single trade can ruin the account.
5. What are the main differences between trend following and traditional investment strategies in "Trend Commandments"?
- No Prediction vs. Forecasting: Trend following does not attempt to predict market direction, unlike fundamental or technical analysts who try to forecast.
- Price Action vs. Fundamentals: Decisions are based on price movements, not on economic indicators, news, or company fundamentals.
- Absolute Returns vs. Benchmarks: Trend followers aim for absolute returns, not just beating a benchmark or index.
- Adaptability vs. Rigid Beliefs: Trend following is designed to adapt to changing markets, while traditional strategies often rely on fixed beliefs or narratives.
6. What are the essential components of a trend following trading system as described by Michael W. Covel?
- Market Selection: Decide which markets to trade, ensuring diversification across asset classes.
- Entry and Exit Rules: Use objective, rule-based criteria (like breakouts or moving averages) to determine when to enter and exit trades.
- Position Sizing: Calculate how much to buy or sell based on account size and market volatility, typically risking a small percentage per trade.
- Risk Management: Employ stop-losses and predefined exit strategies to limit losses and protect capital.
7. How does "Trend Commandments" by Michael W. Covel address risk and drawdowns?
- Embrace Small Losses: Accept that losses are a natural part of trading; the key is to keep them small and manageable.
- Drawdowns Are Inevitable: Even the best trend followers experience periods of losses (drawdowns), but sticking to the system allows recovery when trends reappear.
- Risk Per Trade: Covel recommends risking a small, fixed percentage (often 1-2%) of capital per trade to avoid catastrophic losses.
- Portfolio Risk: Manage not just individual trade risk, but also the total risk across all open positions to avoid excessive exposure.
8. What psychological and behavioral principles are emphasized in "Trend Commandments" by Michael W. Covel?
- Discipline Over Emotion: Success requires following the system regardless of emotions, news, or market noise.
- Emotional Intelligence: Covel argues that EQ (emotional intelligence) is more important than IQ for trading success.
- Avoiding Herd Mentality: Trend followers must be willing to act independently, often going against the crowd.
- Patience and Commitment: Long-term success comes from patience, perseverance, and unwavering commitment to the process.
9. What are some of the most important quotes from "Trend Commandments" and what do they mean?
- "You don’t need to know what will happen next in order to profit from whatever happens next." – Emphasizes reacting to price, not predicting.
- "Limit losses and ride profits, irrespective of all other rules." – The core of risk management and trend following.
- "Markets are never wrong, opinions often are." – Trust price action over personal beliefs or expert opinions.
- "If you don’t know what’s going on, don’t do anything." – Advocates for inaction over impulsive, uninformed decisions.
10. How does "Trend Commandments" by Michael W. Covel critique Wall Street, the media, and conventional financial wisdom?
- Media Distraction: Covel argues that financial media and Wall Street often promote noise, predictions, and stories that mislead investors.
- Conflict of Interest: He highlights how mutual funds and financial institutions profit from keeping investors in the dark or selling hope.
- Benchmark Obsession: The book criticizes the focus on quarterly performance and benchmarks, which can lead to poor long-term decisions.
- Hero Worship: Covel warns against blindly following gurus, experts, or famous investors, advocating for independent thinking.
11. What historical context and real-world examples does "Trend Commandments" provide to support trend following?
- Performance Data: The book presents decades of performance from top trend followers like John W. Henry, Bill Dunn, and David Harding.
- Market Crashes: Covel shows how trend followers profited during major market crashes (e.g., 2008), while most investors lost money.
- Origins of Trend Following: The book traces the roots of trend following back to early traders and the development of systematic methods.
- Case Studies: Real-life stories of traders, both successful and unsuccessful, illustrate the principles and pitfalls of different approaches.
12. How can readers apply the lessons from "Trend Commandments" by Michael W. Covel to their own trading or investing?
- Adopt a Systematic Approach: Develop or use a rules-based trading system that removes emotion and subjectivity from decisions.
- Diversify Broadly: Trade a wide range of markets using the same rules to capture more opportunities and reduce risk.
- Focus on Process, Not Outcome: Prioritize following the process over obsessing about individual trade results or short-term performance.
- Continuous Learning: Stay curious, question conventional wisdom, and be willing to adapt as markets and personal understanding evolve.
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.