Plot Summary
Storms and Shipmates
The Venatrix sails under the command of Lady Vice and her close-knit, diverse crew, now joined by former Royal Navy men. Tensions simmer between pirates and Navy, threatening to boil over as they share cramped quarters and uncertain loyalties. Vice, determined and impatient, is fixated on the next clue to Drake's legendary treasure, but the crew's unity is tested by old wounds and new rivalries. Amidst the heat and sweat of the Caribbean, Vice's leadership is challenged, and her heart is pulled between duty and desire. The sea is both home and battleground, and every day brings a new test of trust, skill, and the bonds that hold the crew together.
Sparks on Deck
Vice's feelings for Knigh Blackwood, her brooding, fae-touched companion, simmer beneath the surface. Their sparring—both physical and verbal—crackles with unspoken longing, but both are determined to remain "just friends" after past betrayals. The tension is palpable as they navigate the blurred lines between camaraderie and something more. Vice's heart aches with want, but fear of loss and the pain of old wounds keep her from reaching out. The ship is a stage for their dance of attraction and restraint, each touch and glance charged with possibility and regret.
Blood and Brotherhood
When pirates attack the island of Redland, Vice and her crew are thrust into a brutal fight to defend their allies. The chaos of battle forges new bonds between former enemies, as Navy and pirates fight side by side. Knigh's loyalty is tested, and Vice's leadership is put on display as she risks everything to protect her friends. The aftermath is bittersweet—victory comes at a cost, and the lines between friend and foe blur further. The crew's unity is strengthened, but the scars of violence and loss linger, deepening the emotional rifts among them.
Fire in Redland
As Redland burns, Vice calls upon her sea witch powers to summon rain and douse the flames. The effort drains her, leaving her vulnerable and exposed. Knigh, ever protective, risks his life to guard her, and their connection deepens in the crucible of crisis. The town is saved, but the cost is high—Vice's magic exacts a toll, and the emotional aftermath leaves her questioning her worth and the burden of her gift. The crew celebrates their survival, but beneath the revelry, Vice and Knigh's unresolved feelings smolder, threatening to ignite.
Tides of Loyalty
The crew's time in Redland is marked by feasts and farewells, as old friends part ways and new bonds are tested. Vice's jealousy flares when Saba expresses interest in Knigh, forcing Vice to confront her own feelings. The lines between friendship and love blur, and the crew's loyalty is tested by secrets and unspoken desires. As they set sail once more, the promise of Drake's treasure looms, but so do the dangers of divided hearts and shifting allegiances. The sea is a mirror for their inner turmoil, reflecting both hope and fear.
Feasts and Farewells
The crew's victory in Redland is marked by a raucous feast, where palm wine flows and inhibitions fall away. Vice and Knigh's flirtation grows bolder, but both are haunted by the fear of loss and the ghosts of their pasts. Saba's plans for a new life on land remind Vice that everyone leaves eventually, deepening her sense of isolation. The night is filled with laughter and music, but beneath the surface, the crew's future is uncertain, and Vice's heart aches with the knowledge that happiness is always fleeting on the high seas.
Cipher and Closeness
With the Copper Drake in hand, Vice and Knigh work side by side to unravel its coded messages. Their shared intellect and determination bring them closer, and the intimacy of their collaboration stirs old feelings. The process is slow and frustrating, but each breakthrough is a victory. As they piece together the clues, the promise of treasure becomes real, and so does the possibility of something more between them. The line between partners and lovers grows ever thinner, and the weight of unspoken words presses on them both.
Caves and Confessions
The search for Drake's treasure leads the crew into a labyrinthine cave, where physical peril mirrors emotional risk. Traps and cave-ins test their trust in one another, and Knigh's struggle with his own darkness comes to the fore. Vice is forced to confront her fear of loss as Knigh narrowly escapes death, and their shared ordeal strips away their defenses. In the darkness, confessions are made—of guilt, of longing, of the pain that binds them. The cave becomes a crucible, forging a deeper connection between Vice and Knigh, even as it threatens to break them.
Traps and Trust
The aftermath of the cave ordeal leaves Vice and Knigh raw and exposed. Knigh's battle with his own rage and guilt reaches a breaking point, and Vice must decide whether to trust him—and herself—enough to move forward. Their friends rally around them, offering support and wisdom, but the decision to risk their hearts is theirs alone. The treasure hunt becomes a metaphor for their emotional journey, as they learn that true riches lie not in gold, but in the courage to be vulnerable and the strength to trust.
Treasure's False Face
The crew's quest leads them to a chest overflowing with gold and jewels, but Vice is not satisfied. She senses that this is not Drake's true treasure, and her obsession with finding the real prize alienates her from her friends. The crew is divided—some are content with riches, while others are drawn into Vice's relentless pursuit. The cost of obsession becomes clear, as relationships fray and the line between ambition and self-destruction blurs. Vice must confront the possibility that the treasure she seeks may not exist—or may not be what she expects.
The Kraken's Shadow
As the crew faces the legendary kraken, the line between external threats and internal demons blurs. Knigh's struggle with his own darkness mirrors the battle against the beast, and Vice's magic is both a weapon and a burden. The fight for survival is brutal and costly, forcing the crew to confront their deepest fears and the limits of their strength. The kraken is vanquished, but the scars it leaves—physical and emotional—are lasting. The victory is hollow, as the true enemy remains elusive and the cost of survival grows ever higher.
Nassau in Ruins
The crew returns to Nassau to find it under siege, its streets reduced to rubble by cannon fire and treachery. Allies become enemies as pirates turn on their own, and the town's destruction is a stark reminder of the fragility of safety and belonging. Vice's leadership is tested as she must choose between saving her friends and saving the town. The cost of loyalty is steep, and the pain of loss is overwhelming. Nassau's fall marks the end of an era, and the beginning of a new, uncertain chapter for Vice and her crew.
Sacrifice and Survival
As Nassau burns, Vice makes the ultimate sacrifice, staying behind to ensure the crew's escape. Her magic is pushed to its limits, and the cost is nearly her life. Knigh is forced to lead the survivors to safety, torn between his duty to the crew and his love for Vice. The pain of separation is acute, and the future is uncertain. The crew's survival is a hollow victory, as the price paid is measured in blood and heartbreak. The lesson is clear: true leadership means putting others first, even when it means losing everything.
The Great Wave
In a final act of defiance, Vice unleashes a tidal wave to destroy Mercia's fleet and cover the crew's escape. The power of her magic is awe-inspiring, but the cost is catastrophic. The wave obliterates Nassau and scatters the survivors, leaving Vice stranded and alone. The act is both triumph and tragedy—a testament to her strength and a reminder of the price of power. The sea, once her ally, becomes her prison, and the future is as uncertain as the shifting tides.
Lost and Found
In the aftermath of the wave, Knigh and the crew search desperately for Vice, clinging to hope even as evidence mounts that she is lost. The pain of her absence is a wound that will not heal, and the crew is left to pick up the pieces of their shattered lives. The search for treasure is replaced by the search for meaning, as each character grapples with loss, guilt, and the question of what comes next. The journey is not over, but the path forward is shrouded in uncertainty.
The Cost of Obsession
Vice's relentless pursuit of Drake's treasure alienates her from those she loves, and the cost of obsession becomes clear. The true treasure is revealed to be not gold, but sanctuary—a place of safety and belonging. The lesson is hard-won, as Vice must confront the pain she has caused and the relationships she has damaged. The journey is as much about self-discovery as it is about riches, and the cost of ambition is measured in love lost and found.
Love in the Undertow
In the wake of disaster, Vice and Knigh's love is tested as never before. Their journey from enemies to lovers is marked by pain, forgiveness, and the courage to be vulnerable. The sea, once a symbol of freedom, becomes a crucible for their relationship, forcing them to confront their deepest fears and desires. Healing is possible, but only through trust, honesty, and the willingness to risk everything for each other. Their love is both anchor and sail, guiding them through the storm.
Alone on the Shore
Washed ashore on an unknown island, Vice is alone, battered but alive. The journey has cost her everything—her home, her crew, her love—but she is not defeated. The sea is both grave and cradle, and as she surveys the empty horizon, she is filled with both grief and hope. The story is not over; the adventure continues. Alone on the shore, Vice faces the future with the same determination and courage that have carried her this far, ready to begin again.
Characters
Lady Vice (Avice Ferrers)
Vice is the heart and soul of the Venatrix, a pirate queen whose sharp wit and sharper blade mask deep wounds. Born Avice Ferrers, she is half-fae, marked by magic and a legacy of loss. Her leadership is both her strength and her burden—she is driven by a need to protect her crew and prove herself, but haunted by guilt over past failures and the fear that everyone she loves will leave or die. Vice's journey is one of self-discovery, as she learns that true strength lies in vulnerability and trust. Her relationship with Knigh is a crucible for her growth, forcing her to confront her fears and open her heart. Vice's arc is a testament to the power of resilience, the cost of obsession, and the redemptive potential of love.
Knigh Blackwood
Knigh is Vice's equal in strength and complexity—a former Navy officer, fae-touched, and marked by a violent past. His struggle with berserking rage is both a literal and metaphorical battle, as he fights to control the darkness within and earn forgiveness for past betrayals. Knigh's loyalty is unwavering, but his self-doubt and guilt threaten to consume him. His relationship with Vice is fraught with tension, desire, and the fear of causing harm. Through vulnerability and the support of his friends, Knigh learns to accept himself and trust others. His journey is one of healing, as he moves from self-loathing to self-acceptance, and from isolation to intimacy.
Saba
Saba is Vice's confidante and anchor, a skilled whittler and dreamer of a life beyond piracy. Her dual heritage—Albionic and Arawakéan—mirrors her internal conflict between the freedom of the sea and the desire for a home on land. Saba's plans to leave the crew for a new life test Vice's fear of abandonment and force both women to confront the inevitability of change. Saba's wisdom and warmth are a balm to the crew, but her own journey is one of self-assertion and the courage to pursue her dreams.
Perry
Perry is the steady hand at the helm, balancing Vice's impulsiveness with caution and care. Her leadership is marked by empathy and a deep sense of responsibility for her crew. Perry's role as mentor and mediator is crucial, guiding Vice and Knigh through their emotional storms and helping the crew navigate the treacherous waters of both the sea and their own hearts. Perry's wisdom is hard-won, and her presence is a reminder that true leadership is as much about listening as it is about commanding.
Aedan
Aedan is the crew's heart, quick with a joke and quicker with a blade. His easy charm masks a longing for acceptance and love, and his flirtations with both Vice and Saba highlight the complexities of desire and friendship within the crew. Aedan's loyalty is unwavering, but his own wounds run deep, and his journey is one of learning to value himself and find his place in the found family of the Venatrix.
Lizzy
Lizzy is the ship's physic, a woman of few words but deep convictions. Her dedication to her craft and her friends is matched only by her willingness to speak hard truths, even when they hurt. Lizzy's confrontation with Vice over the use of supplies is a turning point, forcing Vice to confront the consequences of her actions and the importance of valuing every member of the crew. Lizzy's strength is quiet but unyielding, and her presence is a reminder that healing is as much about honesty as it is about medicine.
Wynn and Effie
Wynn and Effie are inseparable, their bond forged in hardship and strengthened by the found family of the Venatrix. Their journey is one of survival and self-discovery, as they navigate the dangers of piracy and the complexities of love and loyalty. The sisters' unwavering support for each other and their friends is a source of strength for the crew, and their story is a testament to the power of chosen family.
FitzRoy
FitzRoy is both rival and reflection for Vice—a former lover whose ambition and obsession with Drake's treasure serve as a warning of what Vice could become. His betrayal is a wound that never fully heals, and his presence is a constant reminder of the cost of unchecked ambition. FitzRoy's charm and wit mask a deep insecurity, and his journey is one of regret and the search for redemption. His interactions with Vice are fraught with tension, desire, and the pain of what might have been.
Lady Isabel Villiers
Isabel is Knigh's sister, a woman of intelligence and resilience who navigates the dangers of exile with grace and determination. Her relationship with Knigh is marked by both affection and challenge, as she pushes him to confront his feelings for Vice and his own worth. Isabel's presence is a reminder of the world Knigh left behind, and her journey is one of adaptation and the search for safety and belonging in a world turned upside down.
Mercia
Mercia is the shadow over the crew's journey—a prince, a sea witch, and a man whose ambition knows no bounds. His control over the kraken and his willingness to destroy Nassau for his own ends make him a formidable foe. Mercia's relationship with Vice is complex, marked by both fascination and enmity. He is a mirror for the dangers of unchecked power and the cost of obsession, and his presence is a constant threat to the crew's safety and freedom.
Plot Devices
Dual Protagonist Perspective
The novel alternates between Vice and Knigh's points of view, allowing readers to experience both the external adventure and the internal emotional journeys of its leads. This duality deepens the narrative, as each character's fears, desires, and growth are mirrored and contrasted. The shifting perspectives also heighten tension, as misunderstandings and secrets are revealed to the reader before the characters themselves, creating dramatic irony and emotional resonance.
Found Family and Chosen Loyalty
The Venatrix's crew is a tapestry of backgrounds and personalities, united by choice rather than blood. The theme of found family is central, as characters grapple with the pain of abandonment, betrayal, and the longing for belonging. Loyalty is both a strength and a vulnerability, and the crew's unity is tested by external threats and internal divisions. The motif of "everyone leaves" is challenged and ultimately subverted as characters learn to trust and rely on one another.
Magic as Metaphor
Vice's magic is both gift and burden, a source of strength and a symbol of her isolation. The use of magic in battle and in healing mirrors the characters' internal struggles—control, vulnerability, and the cost of power. The kraken, as both monster and victim, serves as a metaphor for the monstrous within, and the battle against it is as much about self-mastery as it is about survival.
Obsession and the Red Herring
The chest of gold and jewels is a classic red herring, tempting the crew to settle for material wealth and abandon the true quest. This device tests the characters' values and ambitions, forcing them to confront the cost of obsession and the meaning of true treasure. The real prize is revealed to be sanctuary—a place of safety, belonging, and self-acceptance—rather than gold.
Sacrifice and Leadership
The novel explores the burdens of leadership through Vice's journey, as she learns that true strength lies in trusting others and accepting help. The willingness to sacrifice for the greater good is a recurring motif, culminating in Vice's decision to stay behind and ensure the crew's escape. The cost of leadership is measured in loss, but also in the forging of deeper bonds and the possibility of redemption.
Foreshadowing and Symbolism
The novel is rich with foreshadowing—dreams, repeated phrases, and symbolic objects (like the dagger earring and the abalone shell) signal future events and emotional turning points. The sea itself is a living symbol, representing both freedom and danger, and the journey across it mirrors the characters' internal voyages. The motif of "everyone leaves" is echoed and challenged throughout, culminating in the realization that true belonging is found not in place, but in people.
Analysis
Under Black Skies is a sweeping, emotionally charged fantasy that uses the trappings of pirate adventure to explore the deepest currents of the human heart. At its core, the novel is about the search for belonging, the cost of obsession, and the redemptive power of vulnerability and trust. Through the intertwined journeys of Vice and Knigh, Clare Sager crafts a story that is as much about healing as it is about heroism. The novel subverts the traditional treasure hunt by revealing that the true prize is not gold, but sanctuary—a place and a state of being where one is seen, accepted, and loved. The found family of the Venatrix is both haven and crucible, testing each character's capacity for loyalty, forgiveness, and growth. The use of magic as both weapon and wound deepens the metaphorical resonance, as characters grapple with the monstrous within and the dangers of unchecked ambition. The destruction of Nassau is a powerful commentary on the fragility of home and the necessity of resilience in the face of loss. Ultimately, Under Black Skies is a story about the courage to risk everything for love, the strength to lead by letting go, and the hope that, even in the darkest storms, we can find our way back to each other—and to ourselves.
Last updated:
