Plot Summary
Storms and Shipwrecks
Vice and Knigh, once lovers and now uneasy allies, find themselves aboard the Swallow, a ship crossing the treacherous ocean. Their relationship is strained by betrayal and secrets, but the sea is indifferent to their pain. When a storm threatens to destroy the ship, Vice's magical gift—her ability to command the sea and weather—becomes both a blessing and a curse. The crew's survival depends on her, but her powers are weakened by recent trauma. As the storm rages, the boundaries between friend and foe blur, and the ocean's fury becomes a crucible for all aboard.
Enemies in Disguise
Vice and Knigh must maintain the façade of a married couple to avoid suspicion among the Swallow's passengers and crew. Their charade is a daily torment, forcing them into close quarters and constant performance. The tension between them is palpable, fueled by unresolved anger and lingering desire. Each small act—cheating at cards, a touch too long, a word too sharp—becomes a battleground. The Pevenseys, their fellow passengers, are oblivious to the truth, but the act is exhausting. Beneath the surface, both Vice and Knigh are haunted by what they've lost and what they still want from each other.
The Weight of Betrayal
Vice cannot forgive Knigh for his betrayal—arresting her and delivering her to the Navy, even after sharing her bed and her trust. Knigh, wracked with guilt, tries to make amends, but every attempt is met with Vice's scorn. Their shared cabin becomes a prison of memory and regret. The pain of the past is ever-present, coloring every interaction. Yet, beneath the anger, there is a deeper ache: the fear of vulnerability, the terror of loving and losing again. Both are trapped by their own choices, unable to move forward or let go.
Overboard and Underwater
When a young sailor falls overboard during the night, chaos erupts. Most of the crew cannot swim, and the sea is merciless. Knigh dives into the black water, tethered by a rope, risking his life to save the boy. Vice, weakened but determined, uses her magic to halt the ship and calm the waves, straining herself to the brink. The rescue is harrowing, a test of courage and endurance. In the aftermath, both are left shaken—Knigh by the brush with death, Vice by the limits of her power. The event binds them, if only for a moment, in shared exhaustion and relief.
Surviving the Dark
The crew celebrates Yule, a festival of surviving the longest night. Vice and Knigh are drawn together by tradition and the forced intimacy of the festivities. A kiss under the mistletoe, a game of musical chairs, laughter and wine—all are tinged with longing and regret. The night culminates in a moment of passion, but the old wounds reopen in its aftermath. Words meant to heal only deepen the hurt. The darkness outside mirrors the darkness within, and both are left raw, exposed, and more alone than before.
The Pirate Queen's Weakness
Vice's magic, once formidable, is diminished by her recent imprisonment and torture. She struggles to regain her strength, pushing her body and her gift to their limits. The frustration of weakness gnaws at her, fueling her anger at Knigh and herself. She is determined to reclaim her power, not just for herself but for her crew and those she loves. Yet, every attempt is a reminder of what she has lost and the cost of survival. The sea, once her ally, now feels distant and indifferent.
A Ship-Killer Approaches
A monstrous storm, possibly conjured by another sea witch, bears down on the Swallow. Vice senses its unnatural speed and ferocity, but her magic is not strong enough to divert it. The crew scrambles to prepare, but the storm is relentless. Vice and Knigh must work together, combining skill and magic, to steer the ship through the tempest. The ordeal is brutal, testing the limits of endurance and trust. In the aftermath, the survivors are changed—some bonds strengthened, others frayed to breaking.
Lightning and Lies
The storm's aftermath brings revelations and confessions. Vice and Knigh confront the truth of their feelings and the lies they've told—to each other and themselves. The search for Drake's treasure intensifies, with cryptic clues and hidden messages fueling obsession and rivalry. Allies become suspects, and every gesture is loaded with meaning. The line between love and hate blurs, and the quest for power and revenge threatens to consume them both. The sea, ever watchful, holds its own secrets.
The Longest Night
The forced intimacy of the voyage, the shared trauma, and the ever-present danger culminate in a night of passion between Vice and Knigh. For a moment, old barriers fall and they find solace in each other's arms. But the morning brings regret and recrimination. The wounds of betrayal are too deep, and forgiveness remains out of reach. Both are left questioning what they truly want—and whether they can ever have it. The night is long, but the dawn brings no easy answers.
Fractures and Forgiveness
As the Swallow reaches Nassau, Vice is reunited with her crew, but old tensions flare. A stand-off threatens to turn deadly, and only Vice's intervention prevents bloodshed. The search for Drake's treasure continues, but the real prize is reconciliation. Vice and Knigh, battered by loss and regret, begin the slow, painful work of forgiveness. It is a process of confession, vulnerability, and the acceptance of imperfection. The journey is far from over, but the first steps are taken.
The Kraken's Shadow
The Duke of Mercia, a fae-blooded prince with his own dark agenda, enters the game. His control of a kraken—a legendary sea monster—raises the stakes for everyone. Vice is captured, betrayed by those she thought allies, and forced into a deadly game of obedience and resistance. The kraken becomes a symbol of power, fear, and the unknown depths within each character. As the battle for survival intensifies, the true nature of heroism and monstrosity is revealed.
The Duke's Game
Vice becomes a pawn in Mercia's quest for Drake's treasure and the throne of Albion. Treated as both guest and prisoner, she is forced to use her magic for his ends. Mercia's cruelty is matched only by his charm, and Vice must navigate a web of threats, bargains, and psychological warfare. The search for the treasure becomes a battle of wits, with Vice's freedom and the lives of her friends hanging in the balance. Every choice is fraught with danger, and trust is a luxury she cannot afford.
Prisoners and Parleys
Knigh, Perry, and the crew of the Respair risk everything to rescue Vice. Parleys with old friends and enemies alike test loyalties and force hard decisions. The line between captor and captive blurs, as Vice finds unexpected allies and Knigh confronts the cost of his choices. The pursuit of the treasure leads them into ancient ruins, deadly traps, and moral quandaries. The past is never far behind, and every step forward is shadowed by the threat of betrayal.
The Cipher's Secret
The key to Drake's treasure lies in a cipher, hidden in poetry and stone. Vice and Knigh, each with a piece of the puzzle, must work together to unlock its secrets. The journey through the ruins is perilous, with traps claiming lives and the weight of history pressing down. The true nature of the treasure is revealed—not gold, but knowledge and power. The quest becomes a test of character, demanding sacrifice, ingenuity, and trust.
Sinking and Salvation
The Respair, battered by battle and storm, begins to sink. The crew faces death in the water, surrounded by enemies and the lurking kraken. FitzRoy, once an ally, abandons them. Salvation comes from an unexpected quarter, as Vice, newly empowered, commandeers the Venatrix and rescues her friends. The cost is high—lives lost, a ship gone, and the scars of trauma deepened. Yet, in the midst of despair, a new beginning emerges.
The Rescue Gamble
Vice's escape from Mercia is a gamble, relying on quick thinking, old friendships, and the willingness to risk everything. Munroe, once Knigh's subordinate, becomes an unlikely accomplice. The crew, battered but unbroken, must trust in each other and in the possibility of redemption. The rescue is a triumph of courage and cunning, but the wounds of the past linger. The future is uncertain, but for the first time, hope feels possible.
Power Unleashed
Vice's mastery of her gift reaches new heights, but the power comes at a price. The wellspring of magic is both intoxicating and dangerous, threatening to consume her. The kraken, once a monster, is revealed as a sentient being, blurring the line between enemy and victim. The true treasure is not gold, but the knowledge of self and the acceptance of one's own limits. Vice and Knigh, changed by their journey, must decide what kind of future they want—and what they are willing to risk for it.
Hard-Won Peace
The adventure ends not with a grand victory, but with a hard-won peace. Vice and Knigh, no longer enemies but not yet lovers, find solace in friendship and the promise of more. The crew, united by loss and survival, sets sail on a new ship, the Venatrix, with the clues to Drake's treasure in hand. The wounds of the past are not forgotten, but they are no longer the only story. The horizon beckons, and with it, the hope of healing, adventure, and perhaps, one day, love.
Characters
Vice (Lady Avice Ferrers)
Vice is the half-fae, half-human Pirate Queen, renowned for her cunning, magical prowess, and unyielding will. Her journey is one of survival, betrayal, and the search for belonging. Vice's relationship with Knigh is central—he is both her greatest wound and her deepest longing. She is driven by a need to prove herself, to reclaim her power after trauma, and to protect those she loves. Her magic is both a gift and a curse, reflecting her inner turmoil. Vice's arc is one of learning to forgive—not just others, but herself—and to accept vulnerability as strength.
Knigh Blackwood (Knighton Villiers)
Knigh is a former naval officer, once a pirate hunter, now a fugitive and outcast. His betrayal of Vice—arresting her for the Navy—haunts him, and his journey is one of atonement. He is disciplined, controlled, and deeply moral, but struggles with anger and self-doubt. Knigh's love for Vice is both his weakness and his salvation. He is torn between duty and desire, haunted by past mistakes, and desperate to make things right. His arc is about learning to forgive himself, to trust his instincts, and to find a new sense of purpose beyond the Navy.
Perry (Berit Peregrina)
Perry is Vice's closest friend and, for a time, captain of the Respair. She is the emotional anchor of the crew, offering counsel, comfort, and a steady hand. Perry's leadership is marked by empathy and pragmatism. She is not without her own doubts, especially about her ability to lead and her place in Vice's life. Perry's relationship with Vice is sisterly, marked by deep loyalty and occasional tough love. She is the voice of reason, urging reconciliation and growth.
The Duke of Mercia
Mercia is a fae-blooded prince with ambitions for the throne of Albion. He is both a seducer and a tyrant, wielding power with a velvet glove and an iron fist. His control of the kraken symbolizes his mastery over both magic and fear. Mercia's interest in Vice is both personal and political—he sees her as a tool, a threat, and a prize. His cruelty is matched by his intelligence, making him a formidable antagonist. He embodies the dangers of unchecked ambition and the seductive allure of power.
Saba
Saba is a key member of Vice's crew, known for her swordsmanship and unwavering support. She is practical, quick-witted, and deeply protective of her friends. Saba's relationship with Vice is one of mutual respect and camaraderie. She is often the first to act in a crisis and the last to abandon hope. Saba's presence is a reminder of the strength found in chosen family.
Aedan
Aedan is another of Vice's loyal crew, marked by his physical strength and emotional intensity. He harbors feelings for Vice, which complicate his relationship with Knigh. Aedan's impulsiveness is both a strength and a liability, leading to moments of heroism and near-tragedy. His arc is one of learning to channel his passion into loyalty and purpose.
FitzRoy
FitzRoy is a former ally turned rival, driven by ambition and a desire for control. His relationship with Vice is fraught with history—part mentor, part adversary, part lover. FitzRoy's actions are often motivated by self-interest, but he is not without moments of genuine care. He represents the dangers of unchecked ego and the complexity of old loyalties.
Munroe
Munroe is a naval officer caught between duty and conscience. Once Knigh's subordinate, he becomes an unlikely ally in the rescue of Vice. Munroe's struggle is one of identity—torn between the Navy's code and his own sense of justice. His willingness to risk everything for what is right marks him as a man of quiet courage.
The Kraken
The kraken is both monster and victim, a creature bound by magic and fear. Its presence is a constant threat, but also a symbol of the unknown depths within each character. The revelation of its sentience blurs the line between enemy and ally, forcing Vice and the others to confront the consequences of power and the ethics of control.
George Villiers
George is Knigh's younger brother, drawn into Mercia's orbit by charm and deception. He represents the innocence lost in the pursuit of power and the collateral damage of ambition. George's relationship with Knigh is strained by misunderstanding and betrayal, but beneath it lies a deep familial bond.
Plot Devices
Dual Protagonists and Shifting POV
The novel alternates between Vice and Knigh's points of view, allowing readers to experience the story's emotional complexity from both sides. This duality heightens tension, as misunderstandings and secrets are revealed to the reader before the characters themselves. The shifting perspectives also mirror the characters' internal struggles—each is both hero and antagonist in the other's story, and the narrative structure reinforces the theme of reconciliation.
Magical Realism and Symbolism
Vice's sea magic and the presence of the kraken are not just fantasy elements—they symbolize trauma, power, and the struggle for control. Storms, shipwrecks, and the ever-changing sea reflect the characters' emotional turmoil. The kraken, in particular, serves as a metaphor for the monstrous aspects of humanity and the possibility of redemption.
Betrayal and Forgiveness
The central conflict is not just external (the search for treasure, the battle with Mercia) but deeply personal. Betrayal—by Knigh, by FitzRoy, by fate—shapes every relationship. The slow, painful process of forgiveness is the true treasure, hard-won and never complete. The narrative structure, with its repeated confrontations and reconciliations, mirrors the cyclical nature of trauma and recovery.
Puzzles, Ciphers, and Quests
The search for Drake's treasure, with its cryptic clues and ancient ciphers, provides the external plot engine. But the real quest is for identity, belonging, and peace. Each puzzle solved brings the characters closer to understanding themselves and each other. The treasure, when found, is not gold but knowledge and the possibility of a new beginning.
Foreshadowing and Repetition
The narrative is rich with foreshadowing—songs, traditions, and repeated phrases ("enough's enough," "I can't change the past") signal future events and emotional turning points. The repetition of storms, betrayals, and reconciliations reinforces the theme that healing is not linear, and that the past is never truly gone.
Analysis
Against Dark Tides is a sweeping, emotionally charged fantasy that uses the trappings of a pirate adventure to explore the depths of trauma, forgiveness, and the search for belonging. At its heart, the novel is about the cost of survival—what we lose, what we cling to, and what we must let go. Vice and Knigh's journey is as much internal as external, a dance of anger, regret, and hope. The sea, with its storms and monsters, is both setting and symbol—a force that tests, destroys, and ultimately renews. The novel's structure, with its shifting perspectives and cyclical plot, mirrors the process of healing: progress is hard-won, setbacks are inevitable, and peace is always fragile. The true treasure is not found in gold or power, but in the willingness to forgive, to trust, and to risk loving again. Against Dark Tides reminds us that home is not a place, but the people who weather the storms with us—and that even in the darkest night, the promise of dawn endures.
Last updated:
