Key Takeaways
Treat angry customers as unpaid auditors, not threats to your brand
A complaint is evidence. Jeff Jarvis’s public feud with Dell began after his faulty laptop and repeated service failures went nowhere through official channels. His blog post gathered thousands of similar complaints, turning private frustration into a public diagnosis of a broken company. Dell eventually began contacting dissatisfied bloggers, answering publicly, and inviting customers to propose products through IdeaStorm. Customers asked for Linux computers, and Dell began selling them. The shift was not simply better public relations. Dell also changed its service operation: it reduced customer transfers from 45 percent to 18 percent and measured time to resolve problems, rather than time spent on calls.
Repair the system. A loud complaint may expose a problem affecting many quieter customers. The company’s job is to investigate, fix the individual case, and address the underlying cause. Dell’s negative online coverage fell from 49 percent to 22 percent after its outreach began.
The story reframes customer service as an early-warning system. A complaint is not automatically representative, but repeated reports can reveal failures that internal metrics miss, especially when those metrics reward quick call handling over actual resolution. Public responses also make follow-through observable, which can rebuild credibility more effectively than a polished apology. The harder question is whether the company can convert the lesson into routine operations. A heroic executive reply is useful; a service system that stops producing the same complaint is better.
Build a platform others can improve, then let the network grow
Links change structure. Jarvis’s experience blogging after September 11 showed him that a link could connect people discussing an event across separate sites. Online, the basic unit is not only a publication or destination. Individual pieces of information can have their own permanent addresses, making them discoverable, discussable, and reusable. This encourages specialization: an organization can focus on what it does unusually well and link readers to stronger work elsewhere.
Enable other builders. A platform supplies tools or infrastructure that others can use to create value. Google Maps became more useful when outsiders could embed it in their sites and combine it with other information. One early map mashup paired apartment listings with maps. Facebook similarly invited outside developers to build applications, adding features without requiring the company to produce each one. The platform grows when others benefit from building on it.
The platform idea changes the measure of competitive strength. A company need not own every useful feature if it can become the dependable foundation others choose to build upon. That creates a reinforcing cycle of adoption and improvement, but it also creates dependence: developers and users may invest heavily in a platform whose owner sets the rules. Openness is therefore not simply generosity. It is a strategic bargain, and its credibility depends on whether contributors retain enough freedom and value to keep participating.
Stop selling to an imaginary mass; serve niches that find each other
Choice replaces uniformity. The internet makes it easier for small sellers, writers, and communities to reach people with specific interests. Jarvis calls the combined market a mass of niches: many small audiences whose total scale can matter more than a single broad audience. In 2007, eBay’s 547,000 online stores sold $59.4 billion in goods, more than the revenue of America’s largest department-store chain at the time. A small creator could also reach customers through search, online marketplaces, and inexpensive publishing tools without owning a store or printing press.
Abundance changes the bet. When nearly limitless products and information are available, success depends less on controlling scarce shelves or channels and more on helping people find what suits them. Google’s search ads illustrate this shift: advertisers could target specific searches and pay for clicks, rather than buying access to a broad audience whether or not it acted.
The useful distinction is between fragmentation and discoverability. A niche business can survive with a modest audience only if people can find it and the cost of serving them stays low. Search and marketplaces help with both, while also intensifying competition and making visibility dependent on platform rules. The mass market does not simply vanish: large shared events and popular products remain. The strategic lesson is to stop assuming that scale requires sameness, not to assume that every niche is automatically profitable.
Make every useful answer searchable, shareable, and easy to trust
Design for the question. People often arrive through a search result or link rather than a company’s home page. A useful web presence therefore puts clear answers on separate, readable pages: a restaurant’s menu and hours, a manufacturer’s support information, or a candidate’s policy positions. Jarvis points to About.com, whose writers used search queries to discover what readers wanted to know and then created focused articles to answer those questions.
Visibility compounds. Googlejuice is Jarvis’s informal term for the advantage a site gains when links, mentions, and user activity help it rank more highly in search. That visibility can attract more visitors and additional links. Publicness, another specialized term in the book, means making information and activity visible by default where appropriate, so others can find, respond to, and share them. Flickr’s public-by-default photos attracted comments and tags, helping communities form around images.
Searchability makes clarity both a technical and civic virtue. Plainly labeled information helps machines retrieve it and helps people understand what they have found. Public visibility can also let outsiders correct errors or contribute missing knowledge. But more visibility is not always better: personal information can expose people to risks they did not choose. A sound version of publicness therefore pairs openness with meaningful control over what is shared, rather than treating disclosure as an unquestioned good.
Give customers a role in making the products they care about
Invite useful participation. Jarvis argues that customers can contribute more than purchases and feedback after launch. They can help identify problems, suggest features, test ideas, and support one another. Dell’s IdeaStorm let customers submit and vote on proposals. Starbucks created MyStarbucksIdea, where customers proposed improvements and discussed one another’s suggestions. One thread about slow lines produced concrete proposals, including ordering ahead and speeding up simple coffee purchases.
Make contribution consequential. A gift economy is an arrangement in which people contribute because they value helping, learning, recognition, or shared ownership, rather than receiving a direct payment for every contribution. Wikipedia shows that a small fraction of users can produce much of a community’s work. Companies need not turn every decision into a vote. They must show what they heard, explain what they will act on, and give contributors a real path to influence.
Participation works best when the organization treats contributors as collaborators rather than a free labor pool. The exchange can benefit both sides: customers gain influence and a better fit, while the company gains ideas and insight. Yet a popular suggestion is not necessarily feasible, safe, or representative of all customers. Good participation therefore requires visible selection criteria and feedback. Listening without explaining what happened to the input can turn an invitation into a polished suggestion box.
Redefine your business around the value you create, not the object you ship
Look beyond the product. Jarvis urges companies to ask what business they are really in. Amazon sells physical goods, but its broader value includes recommendations, customer reviews, fulfillment services, and computing infrastructure used by other businesses. A publisher may be more than a printer; a car company may be in the business of moving people, not merely manufacturing cars.
Remove needless tolls. Middlemen remain valuable when they reduce confusion, improve matching, or provide expertise. They become vulnerable when they profit mainly by restricting information or controlling access. The book uses real-estate agents and newspaper classifieds to illustrate how online listings and price information can weaken such control. Free can also be a business model: Google offered services without charging users directly, while making money through advertising and other indirect value. The point is not that every service should be free, but that charging may obstruct growth or relationships.
This is a strategic test of where value actually resides. The product may be only the visible part of a larger system involving data, convenience, trust, or coordination. Separating value creation from revenue collection can reveal unexpected business models, but it does not eliminate costs. Free services still require funding, and indirect monetization can create incentives to collect data or favor advertisers. A sound redesign names both sides clearly: who benefits, who pays, and what new dependency the model creates.
Release imperfect work early, learn in public, and correct fast
Iteration beats prolonged guessing. Google often labeled products as beta, signaling that they were unfinished and inviting users to help identify what mattered. Before Google News launched, its engineers could add one of two features. They added neither, released the service, and received hundreds of emails, almost all asking for the same missing function. Users answered a question that the team could not settle internally.
Make errors recoverable. Jarvis’s examples contrast Dan Rather’s slow, defensive response to questions about questionable documents with Reuters’ swift investigation after bloggers demonstrated that a photographer had altered an image. Reuters withdrew the photos, dismissed the photographer, changed procedures, and acknowledged the outside fact-checking. The principle is not to celebrate mistakes. It is to reduce the time between experiment, evidence, correction, and improved practice.
Fast iteration is powerful when feedback arrives quickly and the cost of a failed test is limited. It can reduce the risk of building elaborate products around untested assumptions. But speed is not a universal virtue: errors in medicine, infrastructure, or financial systems can impose serious harm before correction is possible. The practical distinction is between reversible experiments and consequential decisions. Public testing should be paired with safeguards proportionate to the stakes, not used as an excuse to ship carelessly.
Redesign institutions as networks that help people solve shared problems
Organize what already exists. Mark Zuckerberg told media executives that organizations cannot simply manufacture communities. People already gather around their interests; a useful institution helps them coordinate. Jarvis calls this elegant organization: giving a group tools that make its existing activity easier. His example of Zuckerberg’s art-course study page shows classmates supplying and improving shared notes, helping the whole class prepare.
Apply the principle widely. A newspaper could become a network supporting local reporting instead of relying only on its own staff. Patients could share treatment experiences through services such as PatientsLikeMe. In education, students might learn from teachers and courses beyond one campus. In energy, Google.org’s renewable-energy work aimed to make cleaner power cheaper through research and investment, rather than relying only on conservation. These examples recast institutions as enablers of participation, information, and coordination.
The common thread is institutional humility: the organization supplies infrastructure, while participants bring local knowledge and motivation. This can widen access and make collective knowledge more useful. Still, tools do not erase differences in expertise, resources, or authority. A medical community can share experience, but personal reports cannot replace clinical judgment. A public platform also needs moderation and accountability. The strongest institution is not absent; it makes participation possible while remaining responsible for decisions that require expertise or protection.
Treat openness as a strategy, not a substitute for excellent products
Trust follows agency. Jarvis draws on David Weinberger’s idea that greater organizational control can weaken public trust, while sharing information and decision-making can help rebuild it. Companies that invite customers into conversations must accept that those customers may criticize them or organize against them. That is the cost of treating people as participants rather than captive audiences.
Openness is not the only route. Apple serves as the book’s counterexample: it keeps tight control over design and distribution, yet customers value its products and often promote them enthusiastically. Jarvis suggests that exceptional quality and a distinctive vision can make this centralized model work. The exception does not erase the broader case for openness. It shows that copying Google’s visible practices is less important than understanding why customers trust or value a particular organization.
This qualification prevents the book’s advice from hardening into a slogan. Openness can improve learning and legitimacy, but it is not inherently ethical, and participation does not guarantee good decisions. A tightly curated product may deliver coherence that a committee cannot. The deeper question is whether control serves users or merely protects the organization from scrutiny. Trust rests not on maximum disclosure or maximum choice, but on a credible fit between promises, governance, and the experience people actually receive.
Analysis
Jarvis’s central argument is less about copying Google than adopting a new model of power. In the older model, organizations controlled distribution, information, and access, then treated customers as an audience to attract or a market to segment. Networked communication weakens those chokepoints. People can publish complaints, connect with one another, compare alternatives, and contribute knowledge. Google’s advantage, in Jarvis’s account, comes from organizing those connections and making participation useful to users and businesses alike.
The book’s strongest evidence is practical rather than theoretical. Dell’s public customer-service crisis shows how an isolated complaint can reveal a wider operational failure, while Google Maps and Facebook illustrate how platforms can expand through outside contributions. Its many industry sketches extend one recurring question: if an organization stopped defining itself by its inherited product or asset, what customer problem could it solve instead?
The framework is persuasive when it links openness to concrete mechanisms: searchable information, public feedback, low-friction participation, and better matching. It is less persuasive when it implies that transparency and networks reliably produce trust or quality. Platforms can concentrate power even while appearing open. Data can improve decisions while also enabling surveillance. Crowds can contribute useful knowledge, but popularity is not a substitute for expertise, and free services still need sustainable funding.
The book was published in 2009, and many of its company examples and market figures belong to that moment. Its durable contribution is therefore not a prediction about which named company will dominate. It is a diagnostic habit: identify the bottleneck, ask who has gained the ability to bypass it, and redesign the organization around the value people create together. Its most useful lesson is to treat technological change as a shift in relationships, incentives, and control, not merely as a new communication channel.
Review Summary
What Would Google Do? receives mixed reviews, with readers praising its innovative ideas about applying Google's principles to various industries. Many find it thought-provoking and relevant, especially for entrepreneurs. However, some criticize its repetitiveness and outdated information. The book is lauded for exploring the concept of "Googlethink" and how it can transform businesses. While some view it as overly optimistic about technology, others appreciate its insights into the digital economy and its potential impact on traditional industries.
People Also Read
Glossary
Googlejuice
Search visibility gained through linksJarvis’s informal term for the visibility and traffic a site can gain when people link to, mention, and use it. Those signals can help a page appear more prominently in search results, attracting further visitors and links. The idea captures a reinforcing loop between public attention and discoverability, rather than a guaranteed ranking formula.
elegant organization
Tools that help groups coordinateA way of creating value by helping an existing community organize itself more effectively. The institution does not invent the group or dictate its goals. It provides a useful structure, platform, or set of tools that members can adapt to their own needs, as Facebook did for social connections and a shared study page did for classmates.
mass of niches
Many small markets adding upJarvis’s description of an economy in which many specialized audiences and markets collectively create substantial demand. The internet lowers the cost of making, distributing, and finding products for these groups. Rather than forcing every customer into one mass-market offering, businesses can serve narrower interests and connect those communities through search and networks.
publicness
Useful activity made visibleA practice of making information and activity visible so others can discover, respond to, and share it. Jarvis presents publicness as a source of connection and opportunity for individuals and organizations, not merely as having a website. The idea is most useful when people retain control over sensitive information and can decide what should remain private.
link economy
Value created through connected informationAn online economy in which links help information travel, audiences find sources, and specialized providers build visibility. In this model, a reference or link can benefit the linked source by directing readers and improving discoverability. Organizations gain by producing distinctive work, making it searchable, and using the resulting audience and connections to create revenue or new services.
Jarvis’ First Law
Give people meaningful controlJarvis’s principle that people use the control the internet gives them, and that organizations risk losing customers when they withhold that control. Applied to business, it means involving customers in conversations, choices, and sometimes product development. It does not require handing every decision to a vote, but it does require treating customers as capable participants.
Weinberger’s Corollary
Control can undermine trustDavid Weinberger’s extension of Jarvis’s customer-control principle: greater institutional control can reduce trust, while sharing authority and information can help earn it. Jarvis applies the idea to companies, media, and government. It describes a tendency, not an automatic law; openness builds trust only when the organization acts consistently and respects the people affected.
DIO
Do it ourselvesAn abbreviation used in the book for collective self-organization: people working together directly rather than depending entirely on centralized institutions or professional intermediaries. Jarvis applies the idea to possibilities such as community-based insurance. DIO does not mean that expertise or formal organizations become unnecessary; it emphasizes that connected groups can participate in managing shared needs.
FAQ
What's What Would Google Do? about?
- Exploring Google's Influence: The book examines how Google's innovative practices have transformed industries and societal norms, using the question "What would Google do?" as a framework for understanding modern challenges.
- New Business Rules: Jeff Jarvis outlines new rules for businesses in the internet age, focusing on customer control, transparency, and collaboration as essential elements for success.
- Case Studies and Examples: Real-world examples, such as Dell's turnaround and Craigslist's rise, illustrate how companies can learn from Google's approach, blending theory with practical applications.
Why should I read What Would Google Do??
- Relevance to Modern Business: Essential for understanding the internet's impact on business and society, offering insights into navigating the digital age's complexities.
- Actionable Insights: Provides practical advice applicable across sectors, valuable for entrepreneurs, marketers, and leaders aiming to thrive in a competitive environment.
- Cultural Shift Understanding: Helps readers grasp technology-driven cultural shifts affecting consumer behavior and expectations, encouraging openness and collaboration.
What are the key takeaways of What Would Google Do??
- Customer Control is Crucial: Businesses must empower customers to succeed in the digital age, emphasizing user control and engagement.
- Embrace Openness and Collaboration: Encouraging innovation through collaboration leads to better products and services, fostering an environment of creativity.
- Simplicity is Key: Simplifying processes and communications enhances user experience and engagement, making businesses more effective.
What are the best quotes from What Would Google Do? and what do they mean?
- "Your worst customer is your best friend.": Highlights the importance of learning from dissatisfied customers, whose feedback can drive improvements.
- "There is an inverse relationship between control and trust.": Suggests that excessive control diminishes trust, advocating for transparency and openness.
- "Get out of the way.": Encourages businesses to facilitate rather than obstruct customer interactions, empowering users to create value.
How does What Would Google Do? suggest businesses should adapt to the digital age?
- Embrace Technology and Innovation: Leverage technology to enhance operations and customer interactions, adopting new tools and platforms.
- Listen to Customers: Actively incorporate customer feedback into decision-making, building loyalty and improving products.
- Simplify Processes: Streamline operations and communications to make customer engagement easier, leading to increased satisfaction.
What role does collaboration play in What Would Google Do??
- Co-Creation with Customers: Involving customers in product development leads to offerings that better meet their needs.
- Building Communities: Creating platforms for customer connection fosters community and loyalty, enhancing brand engagement.
- Leveraging Collective Intelligence: Tapping into shared knowledge and creativity drives innovation and improves performance.
What does What Would Google Do? say about the future of media?
- Transition to Digital: Traditional media must adapt to digital realities, embracing new technologies and distribution methods.
- Importance of Searchability: Ensuring content is easily discoverable online is crucial for attracting and retaining audiences.
- Collaboration with Audiences: Engaging audiences in the news-gathering process enhances credibility and relevance.
How does What Would Google Do? address the concept of trust?
- Building Trust through Transparency: Openness and honesty are essential for building trust with customers, including admitting mistakes.
- Trust as a Two-Way Street: Excessive control reduces trust; companies should empower customers and listen to their feedback.
- Empowering Customers: Giving customers control fosters a trusting relationship, leading to greater loyalty and advocacy.
What is the significance of the "new economy" discussed in What Would Google Do??
- Shift from Scarcity to Abundance: The digital age moves from scarcity to abundance, changing business operations and competition.
- Niche Markets are Rising: Businesses should focus on serving specific niches rather than appealing to the mass market.
- Free as a Business Model: Offering free services can increase engagement and revenue through alternative means, like advertising.
How does What Would Google Do? apply to the media industry?
- Disruption of Traditional Models: Media companies must adapt to digital realities, embracing openness and collaboration.
- Audience Engagement: Engaging with audiences meaningfully and involving them in content creation is crucial.
- Shift to Niche Markets: The media landscape is moving towards niche markets, where specialized outlets can thrive.
What insights does What Would Google Do? provide about the future of education?
- Shift to Online Learning: Online education can democratize learning, providing access to diverse resources and expertise.
- Personalized Learning Experiences: Tailoring education to individual needs and interests leads to more engaged learners.
- Collaboration Among Students: Peer-to-peer learning and collaboration enhance knowledge sharing and motivation.
What does What Would Google Do? say about the importance of data?
- Data-Driven Decision Making: Using data to inform decisions provides insights into customer behavior and preferences.
- Transparency in Data Use: Organizations should be transparent about data collection and use, building consumer trust.
- Collective Intelligence: Sharing data can harness collective intelligence, enabling communities to solve problems and innovate.
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.