Plot Summary
Prologue
Grant leaves Declan after a week together, buoyed by their promise to meet again in November. He carries Declan's batting advice into a game and gets a hit, imagining that their new love and his baseball career can thrive together.
In a second, separately timed opening, Declan arrives as a new Comet and finds his alcoholic father waiting on the field, already making suggestive remarks about Grant. The two scenes place hope beside danger: Grant believes their future is beginning, while Declan's family history threatens to expose and unsettle it.
The paired openings make the romance's central risk visible before either man understands it fully. Grant reads a small baseball success as evidence that love and ambition can reinforce one another. Declan, by contrast, experiences intimacy through the threat of intrusion: his father brings private feeling into a public workplace, where even a casual remark could damage Grant's prospects. Their different responses are rooted in different histories, not different levels of affection. The structure lets the reader feel the fracture forming before Grant does, turning romantic anticipation into dramatic irony.
A Father Crosses the Line
At the Comets' Florida training ground, Declan's father Jon arrives after drinking and begins treating Declan's teammates like an audience for his family life. He hints that Declan misses a boyfriend, then nearly connects Grant to the hitting advice Declan passed along. The scene recalls Declan's childhood championship, when Jon stumbled onto the field drunk and left his son exposed to the watching crowd.
Declan gets Jon away from the team, pays the large sum needed to keep his father's tow business afloat, and arranges for Jon to leave for California. When Grant later reports a successful hit, Declan decides their affair is hurting the rookie's performance. He sends Grant a breakup message and cancels their November plans.
Jon's arrival converts a private romance into an occupational threat. Declan's fear is not that being gay will be exposed, but that his father's volatility will make Grant's first professional season a spectacle. His childhood strategy of managing the room returns in adult form: he pays, redirects, and removes Jon, then makes a unilateral decision for Grant. The care in that decision is real, but it repeats the family role that has trapped Declan for years. He confuses protection with control, believing that silence is the only safe form of love.
Grant Gets the Message
Grant reads Declan's message in the middle of the night and calls, but Declan does not answer. Hurt and furious, Grant smashes his phone against a wall, replaces it the next day, and deletes Declan's contact. On the field, he turns that anger into a punishing play at home plate, taking a collision to record an out and preserve his chance at a roster spot.
At The Lazy Hammock, bartender River recognizes that Grant is grieving rather than looking for a hookup and offers him steady friendship. Grant makes a pact to focus on baseball. Three days before spring training ends, manager Fisher names him the Cougars' Opening Day catcher, giving him a future to pursue even as his first romance disappears.
Grant's first response is physical because the breakup leaves him with no explanation to work through. The broken phone makes his anger visible, but the successful play gives him a form of agency that romance has denied him. River's value is not simply consolation: he offers a relationship with boundaries and no romantic ambiguity, a new model of intimacy for someone who has barely dated. The starting job then rewards Grant's discipline, while also reinforcing his belief that baseball is the one commitment that will not withdraw without warning.
Two Opening Day Debuts
Before Grant's Major League debut, Declan calls to apologize and begins explaining that his father had appeared in Florida. Grant hears enough to understand that Declan had acted on his behalf, but not enough to feel safe reopening the relationship. He accepts the apology and ends the call before it can pull him away from the game. On Opening Day, Grant singles in two runs and helps the Cougars win.
He spends the season hitting with striking consistency, passes thirty home runs, and becomes a Rookie of the Year finalist. Declan settles into his new Comets uniform and a new life in New York, but neither man contacts the other again. Their careers advance in parallel, while the unanswered parts of their breakup remain between them.
The debut gives Grant an achievement that belongs entirely to him, not to Declan's advice or approval. His decision to stop the call is a first act of self-protection, though it also preserves the distance that both men will later regret. The baseball season functions as a clock they can read more easily than emotion: statistics accumulate, positions solidify, and public recognition arrives. Their silence is not proof that the attachment has faded. It is a shared avoidance strategy, made persuasive by the genuine demands of two careers.
The Slider Between Them
When the Cougars travel to New York, Grant and Declan meet again across the diamond. Grant doubles in his first at-bat; Declan later makes a diving stop that ends the inning. In a tense later turn, Grant remembers which pitch Declan struggles to hit and calls for a slider. Declan swings through it, and the Cougars win.
At the pool hall afterward, Declan tries to discuss the pitch, but Grant makes clear that his knowledge came from studying an opponent, not from their old intimacy. Declan follows him to the restroom, praises his game, and lets slip personal details he once kept private, including his English and poetry studies. Their almost-kiss is interrupted by another player, leaving Declan certain that he wants Grant back.
The baseball contest lets both men approach intimacy through expertise. Grant's call is at once professional judgment and evidence that he still knows Declan closely; his insistence that it was only scouting protects him from acknowledging the second meaning. Declan's disclosures in the restroom are small but consequential experiments in openness. He cannot yet offer a coherent account of his behavior, so he offers facts about himself instead. The interrupted almost-kiss preserves desire without resolving the harder issue: whether either man can trust the other with the consequences of wanting more.
An Award, Then a Refusal
After the Cougars fall short in the playoffs, Grant travels to New York as a Rookie of the Year finalist. Declan, who has sought advice from his sister Emma and her husband Fitz, asks to speak privately after the ceremony. Grant wins the award, then goes to Declan's apartment.
Declan explains that Jon's drunken visit, financial trouble, and repeated hints about Grant made him fear their relationship would become a damaging public story. He admits he ended things because he thought Grant played better without him, and tells Grant he is still in love.
Grant feels the same, but refuses to restart the relationship. He fears that a public breakup could eclipse his baseball record and distract from his advocacy for queer athletes. He leaves after giving Declan advice on hitting sliders.
The award sharpens the asymmetry between them. Grant has gained public stature, but that visibility makes him more vulnerable to being reduced to a headline about his private life. Declan finally supplies the missing causal story, yet explanation cannot reverse the harm caused by deciding for Grant. Grant's refusal is not emotional indifference; it is a considered boundary shaped by professional ambition and responsibility to young athletes who look to him. Their love becomes more explicit at exactly the moment when Grant judges that acting on it would cost too much.
Five Years Apart
In the years after their second refusal, Grant becomes a leading player and a visible advocate for LGBTQ youth. He helps River expand The Lazy Hammock into San Francisco, builds closer ties with his teammates through charity work, and eventually catches the final out of a Cougars World Series victory.
Declan keeps playing for New York, reads memoirs about addiction and its families, and begins therapy after his mother urges him to examine how he enables Jon.
His father continues to relapse, and Declan keeps paying debts until he starts questioning that pattern. After Grant's championship, the two men speak for an hour about the series. A Christmas call deepens their honesty about family and identity, and they agree to meet at a San Francisco awards event.
The separation is not empty waiting. Grant builds a public identity around the game and the young athletes who need to see an openly gay player succeed; Declan begins learning that loyalty to an addict need not mean absorbing every consequence. Their development happens in different arenas, but both are practicing a less defensive form of selfhood. The World Series call matters because Grant shares his joy with Declan without asking him to solve anything. It offers a first glimpse of connection that does not require either man to abandon his independent life.
The Not-Drink Date
At a February sports gala in San Francisco, Grant arrives with his grandfather Trevor and Declan with his mother Cyndi. Their families quietly make space for the two men to speak, and Grant later wins a sportsmanship award for his work with young and LGBTQ athletes.
They arrange to meet privately the next evening. Over virgin margaritas, Declan tells Grant that therapy has helped him confront his childhood role as his father's caretaker, and admits that he wants to become worthy of a real relationship.
He has promised himself a year to work on these patterns. Grant wants him, but refuses to demand a choice between intimacy and that work. They spend the night together, agree to proceed without premature promises, and set a date to see each other in May.
The date marks a change in method rather than a sudden cure. Declan names therapy and his own limits before asking for closeness, giving Grant information he was denied in the past. Grant, in turn, treats patience as a shared decision, not a test of devotion. Their physical reunion is important, but the more consequential act is negotiating terms: no false certainty, no pressure to abandon recovery, and a concrete next meeting. The families' presence at the gala also hints that intimacy might eventually become visible without being controlled by the media.
Coffee Without Rescue
The morning after, Jon texts Declan from a San Francisco diner and asks to meet. Declan considers canceling, but Grant encourages him to decide what he wants rather than react to guilt. Over coffee, Declan hears about Jon's new relationship and sobriety efforts without taking responsibility for managing either.
When Jon hints at needing a ride, Declan leaves without offering one. He returns to Grant with a sesame bagel and tells him he did not give his father money or a lift.
Their long-distance relationship grows through daily messages and calls as the season resumes. In therapy, Declan recognizes that contact with Grant no longer feels like a betrayal of his recovery. He calls Grant his boyfriend, and they confirm a shared day off in May.
The coffee meeting is a modest scene with a substantial psychological consequence. Declan does not punish Jon or deny their bond; he simply declines the familiar exchange in which access to his life is purchased through rescue. Grant supports him without taking over the decision, a contrast to Declan's earlier habit of deciding what was best for Grant. Their daily communication tests whether emotional closeness can coexist with separate careers and personal work. Calling Grant his boyfriend makes that emerging reality explicit, but the May plan keeps their hopes grounded in schedules they can actually meet.
The Trade to San Francisco
On the eve of their planned May reunion, Grant sees a report that Declan may be traded to a western team. Declan does not answer his messages, then appears unexpectedly at Grant's charity event a day early. Instead of heading home, Grant drives him toward the Golden Gate Bridge, where Declan reveals that the San Francisco Dragons acquired him.
The move is no accident: Declan had asked his agent to find a route to the city, accepting the possibility of a less lucrative contract to make it happen. Grant first panics that they might become teammates again, then understands that Declan will play for the rival club. They tell each other they are in love, and the distance that once protected their careers becomes a local rivalry.
The trade is a concrete answer to the question they previously could not solve: how can they be together without one person surrendering his profession? Declan does not quit baseball or join Grant's team; he chooses a rival in the same city, preserving both careers while changing their daily possibilities. His action also differs from his earlier unilateral breakup. This time he takes a risk, but brings Grant into the truth rather than deciding on his behalf. The bridge setting links a formative baseball memory to a new choice, making professional ambition part of their shared future rather than its obstacle.
A Home Chosen Twice
Declan's mother and stepfather bring his bag to Grant's home, where Grant welcomes them and introduces the people who matter to him. That night, Grant tells Declan that his biological parents treated him as unwanted, and that his grandmother and friend Reese helped him understand he was loved.
Declan answers with the intensity Grant has long needed to feel chosen. The next morning, Grant asks him to move in. Declan accepts, then admits he had deliberately pursued the trade, even agreeing to a lower salary rather than wait for free agency.
Grant understands that the move was not luck but a decision made for them. Their plan is no longer limited to occasional visits: they begin imagining one shared home and the ordinary mornings it could hold.
Grant's disclosure reveals why being actively wanted matters so much to him; the fear beneath his self-sufficiency is not merely heartbreak, but the possibility of being treated as expendable. Declan's response is meaningful because it is matched by action: he has reorganized his career around proximity, not simply offered reassurance. Grant's invitation answers that choice with a home rather than a promise made in the heat of reunion. Their intimacy becomes practical, involving space, money, and daily routines. The scene reframes commitment as a series of material decisions that make room for another person.
The Rival's First Game
For Declan's first game as a Dragon, Grant fills the first-baseline seats with family, teammates, Reese, River, and friends from their old spring-training circle. Declan walks onto the field to their support, then reaches base and drives in two runs with a late single.
Afterward, at Sierra's bar, the players gather around a pool table. Grant and Declan tell Crosby, Chance, Sullivan, Holden, and the others that they are together and living with one another.
Their friends have already noticed Grant cheering too loudly for a rival, so the announcement brings laughter rather than shock. For Declan, the game is a public welcome into a new club and city; for both men, the gathering turns a long-hidden relationship into something their chosen community can openly recognize.
The debut binds the two forms of belonging that had once seemed incompatible. Declan earns his place through performance, while Grant's invitation gives him a place among friends and family before the first pitch. The crowd in the stands is not a substitute for baseball success; it is a network that lets him play without being alone in the city. Their announcement to teammates similarly shifts secrecy into chosen disclosure. Because their friends have already read their behavior, the reveal is less a spectacle than a recognition, allowing the couple to define the moment themselves.
Help Without the Hush Money
Before joining Grant at an LGBTQ youth carnival, Declan receives a call from Jon. He agrees to meet after the next road trip, but sets a clear limit: he will not cover gambling debts, business loans, or other cash emergencies. If Jon chooses rehab, Declan will help pay for treatment. He then tells his father that he and Grant are together and that he is in love.
The decision marks a new way of loving Jon, one that leaves the consequences of addiction with the person living through them while still offering meaningful support. Declan goes to the carnival with Grant, where they can meet young athletes as partners rather than hiding behind teammates, hotel corridors, or convenient explanations.
Declan's boundary is not a cure for Jon's addiction, and the story does not pretend it can control whether Jon stays sober. Its importance lies in changing what Declan is willing to fund and what kind of help he can offer. Money had served as a shortcut around fear, guilt, and difficult conversation. Treatment support draws a different line: care remains, but it no longer protects Jon from every consequence. Telling Jon about Grant also brings Declan's private life into the family relationship on his own terms, a direct reversal of the father's earlier intrusion.
Epilogue
At the charity carnival, Declan and Grant walk hand in hand while Grant introduces Declan to young athletes who know him from baseball. One teen asks whether they are together, and Declan proudly identifies himself as Grant's boyfriend.
Later, Grant's photographer friend takes a picture of the couple, and both men share it publicly. Grant also dunks Declan in the tank, turning their rivalry into a joke they can perform in daylight. The final images belong to them: not a stolen moment caught by a fan, but a story they choose to tell together.
The carnival completes the movement from involuntary exposure to deliberate visibility. Earlier, Declan's father threatened to name the relationship before either man was ready, and Grant feared that public attention would reduce him to a romantic headline. Here, the couple controls the setting, the timing, and the image. Their public affection also takes place among young athletes, making visibility a form of practical reassurance rather than a publicity stunt. The dunk tank preserves their competitive playfulness, but the larger victory is that neither has to disguise the relationship to protect the other.
Analysis
Winning With Him treats romance not as an escape from work or family history, but as a relationship built inside those pressures. Baseball supplies a demanding external structure: games cannot be postponed because someone is heartbroken, and professional success can make private vulnerability more visible rather than less. Grant's fear that love will swallow his career is grounded in his experience of being treated as unwanted; he has learned to protect the life he built by investing in what he can measure. Declan's central difficulty is different. Growing up beside an alcoholic father taught him to anticipate crises, pay debts, and decide what other people can bear. That competence becomes control when he breaks up with Grant without giving him the truth.
The novel makes repair depend on changes in behavior, not declarations alone. Declan's apology matters only after he names what happened, seeks therapy, and begins refusing the role of financial rescuer. Grant's love does not require him to abandon his career or advocacy; instead, he gradually chooses forms of closeness that do not make him smaller. The story's most important romantic gestures are therefore practical: a phone call answered honestly, a coffee meeting without a ride home, a trade to a rival team, and an invitation to share a house. Each converts feeling into an action with consequences.
Public identity receives similarly careful treatment. Grant's visibility helps queer teenagers imagine a future in professional sport, yet he is wary of being reduced to a headline about his love life. The ending resolves that tension through agency rather than secrecy: the men decide when to be seen and share their relationship in a community where it can encourage others. Their happy ending does not erase addiction, professional pressure, or past hurt. It offers a more credible promise: that love can coexist with boundaries, ambition, and ongoing work, provided both people keep choosing honesty over protection by silence.
Review Summary
Winning With Him continues Declan and Grant's story across five years of separation and eventual reunion. Reviews are deeply divided: many praise the emotional depth, character growth, and steaminess, calling it a heartbreaking yet rewarding second-chance romance. However, critics find the separation contrived and unnecessary, questioning why the characters couldn't work through issues together. Common complaints include draggy pacing, unrealistic elements (five years apart with no other partners), and overly sweet dialogue. Most agree the audiobook narrators excel. While it ends happily, many question the need for a third book.
People Also Read
Characters
Declan Steele
Guarded star shortstopA gifted professional shortstop whose composure on the field contrasts with how carefully he manages private life. Declan grew up adapting to his father's alcoholism, learning to anticipate trouble and quietly contain its damage. That skill makes him resourceful, but it also tempts him to decide what other people can handle rather than trust them with the truth. He relies on poetry and baseball to steady himself, and values privacy as protection rather than shame. His attraction to Grant exposes the limits of his old self-sufficiency: he wants closeness, yet fears that needing someone will make him less capable of managing his family and career.
Grant Blackwood
Outspoken rookie catcherA rising catcher with a fierce competitive streak, a generous social nature, and a strong sense of responsibility to queer young athletes. Grant approaches baseball as both a lifelong ambition and a structure he can trust, especially after growing up in a family where he felt unwanted. His confidence in public does not erase his vulnerability in private; he has little dating experience and finds emotional commitment more consuming than he expects. Grant is quick to support other people, but must learn that devotion does not require surrendering his own ambitions. His humor and warmth make him easy to approach, while his discipline makes him formidable on the field.
Jon Steele
Unsteady baseball fatherDeclan's father is a former minor-league player whose charisma and baseball knowledge can win over strangers. His alcoholism and gambling make his promises unreliable, and his attempts at closeness often arrive without regard for Declan's boundaries. He loves his son, but his need for money, attention, and forgiveness complicates that love.
Reese
Grant's lifelong confidanteGrant's closest friend since childhood, Reese offers loyalty without judgment. She comforted him through family pain when they were young and remains a steady presence as his career grows. Her affection is candid and protective, but she also encourages Grant to make his own choices.
River
Bartender turned business partnerThe warm, perceptive owner of The Lazy Hammock, River recognizes Grant's heartbreak and offers friendship rather than an easy rebound. His humor softens difficult conversations, while his ambition to build welcoming gay bars gives him a life and purpose beyond serving as Grant's confidant.
Cyndi Martin
Declan's perceptive motherDeclan's mother is observant, affectionate, and willing to ask questions her son would rather avoid. After a difficult marriage, she has built a steadier life and remains attentive to the ways her son hides his distress behind competence.
Tyler
Declan's supportive stepfatherCyndi's husband, Tyler is warm, unselfconscious with affection, and comfortable teasing Declan. He provides a model of masculinity that is secure enough to be tender and openly supportive.
Trevor Campbell
Grant's guiding grandfatherGrant's grandfather is a source of steady affection and practical wisdom. Recovering from knee surgery, he remains independent and playful, while noticing emotional shifts Grant tries to conceal.
Kimberly Campbell
Grant's loving grandmotherGrant's grandmother helped give him a secure sense of belonging when his parents could not. Her care is uncomplicated and durable, and her belief in speaking up helps shape Grant's public advocacy.
Carla
Declan's thoughtful therapistCarla gives Declan a patient setting in which to examine his family patterns, his fear of vulnerability, and his tendency to rescue his father. She asks questions rather than dictating decisions, helping him develop skills he can use beyond therapy.
Emma
Declan's trusted sisterDeclan's older sister understands how guarded he can be and offers loyalty without forcing disclosure. She recognizes when he needs advice beyond her own experience and helps him seek it.
Fitz
Declan's candid friendFitz is Emma's husband and one of Declan's trusted friends. His secure relationship gives him practical insight into the courage required to admit love and ask for another chance.
Dean
Fitz's thoughtful husbandDean shares a grounded partnership with Fitz and offers Declan the perspective of someone who values honest communication. His book recommendations also encourage Declan to reflect on addiction and family.
Crosby
Grant's superstitious teammateA lively Cougars teammate, Crosby is devoted to baseball rituals, friendly wagers, and the camaraderie of the clubhouse. His teasing helps Grant feel accepted on the team.
Chance Ashford
Grant's trusted teammateThe Cougars' closing pitcher, Chance is competitive but thoughtful about friendship and community. He helps make Grant's new team feel like a place where he belongs.
Holden
A teammate with insightA professional player and friend within the baseball circle, Holden speaks candidly about second chances. His own romantic uncertainty helps prompt Declan to consider what he is willing to risk.
Sierra
Grant's teasing sisterGrant's younger sister is affectionate, spirited, and fond of teasing him through her loyalty to his rival team. Her humor keeps family connection easy and familiar.
Haven
Grant's career agentGrant's agent helps him navigate sponsorships and career opportunities after his award recognition. She is practical and attentive to the professional choices his growing profile creates.
Frank
Grant's complicated stepfatherGrant's stepfather exposed his sexuality at school before Grant could tell his own story. That breach of control informs Grant's determination to speak publicly on his own terms.
Plot Devices
The Baseball Calendar
Love under a season scheduleTraining camp, Opening Day, playoff races, awards, and road trips give the relationship its practical limits. The men repeatedly have to decide when a private conversation can fit around games and when emotional strain risks affecting performance. Baseball is not merely a backdrop: Grant fears that intense love could disrupt his rookie development, while Declan uses the game to focus when family life becomes unstable. Their eventual proximity as players on rival San Francisco teams preserves professional competition while making ordinary time together possible.
Texts and Phone Calls
Distance made tangibleMessages first carry Declan's abrupt breakup, making the lack of explanation part of Grant's injury. Later, texts and calls become a slower, safer channel through which the men rebuild familiarity while living in different cities. They exchange jokes, baseball updates, intimate photographs, and increasingly honest personal disclosures. The change in how they use the same technology tracks a change in trust: a message once used to end communication becomes a way to sustain it.
Poetry and Tattoos
Private maps of resilienceDeclan uses poems to steady himself before speaking, connecting language with the courage he struggled to find at home and in public. Grant's tattoos preserve personal commitments, including direction, balance, and equality. These private symbols reveal what each man cannot always say directly. They also give the lovers a way to recognize one another's inner lives, as they remember details and ask what the images mean rather than treating them as decoration.
Therapy and Boundaries
Care without controlDeclan's therapy gives the story a concrete process for changing his response to his father's addiction. Instead of repeating the cycle of panic, money, and temporary relief, he learns to examine what he can control and to set limits without withdrawing love. The same work affects his romance: he explains his fears, asks rather than assumes, and considers how to build a relationship without treating Grant as either a distraction or a rescuer.
Public Visibility
Choosing who tells the storyThe risk of exposure links Declan's father's careless comments, Grant's concern about media attention, and Grant's advocacy for queer athletes. Both men are already out, but public visibility still carries professional and personal consequences. Their eventual disclosure is meaningful because they choose when, where, and how to share it, especially with young athletes who may need to see a couple like them. The device distinguishes being out from surrendering control over one's private life.
Men of Summer Series Series
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.