Plot Summary
Prologue
Bailey reads about Hercules descending into the Underworld for his final labor. The hero expects to meet monsters and the dead, yet he goes willingly, hoping to find the people he has lost.
The story opens with a champion approaching a place from which he may not return, preparing the reader for a novel in which courage will mean more than victory.
The myth gives the novel its emotional framework before its ordinary world appears. Hercules is not simply a model of strength: he is a grieving man who accepts danger while longing for reunion. Bailey’s choice to read this story makes heroism intimate and mortal. The Underworld becomes a shadow over the characters’ lives, while the hope of meeting lost loved ones sits beside the fear that survival itself may demand a price.
The Spider’s Small Grave
In 1994, Fern Taylor, a book-loving girl with unruly red hair, sits beside her cousin Bailey Sheen as he studies a spider crossing his walk. Ambrose Young, a strong boy who assumes they are frightened, crushes it to help. Bailey weeps because the spider’s venom had become part of his fantasy of curing the muscular disease weakening his body.
Fern explains why death matters to Bailey, and Ambrose helps them bury the spider in a small box. They sing together and mark the grave with stones. The moment gives the children a shared memory: even a creature that frightens them can be beautiful, and care begins with noticing what matters to someone else.
This first encounter makes empathy an action rather than a virtue claimed in the abstract. Ambrose causes the hurt through a mistaken assumption, then repairs it by joining Fern and Bailey in their ritual. The spider’s brief life foreshadows the novel’s recurring attention to bodies that are vulnerable, frightening, or easily dismissed. Fern’s instinct is to mourn; Bailey’s is to imagine rescue; Ambrose learns to stay with grief even when he cannot undo its cause.
Bailey Writes a List
Bailey’s muscular dystrophy gradually takes his strength, first limiting what he can do and eventually ending his ability to walk. When Fern blurts out that he may die young, their mothers explain that every life ends, though Bailey’s may be shorter. He absorbs the truth without surrendering his appetite for living.
As a child, he writes down what he wants to accomplish, including becoming a hero, wrestling, and caring for Fern. He and Fern also turn their fears into jokes, imagining the many ways either might die first. Bailey’s list is not a promise that he will control the future. It is a way to give his limited time shape, while friendship lets Fern face what she cannot fix.
Bailey’s list converts mortality from a prediction into a set of chosen acts. That distinction matters: he cannot bargain with his illness, but he can decide what kind of attention he gives the present. Fern’s humor does not deny the fear; it makes the fear speakable between them. Their mothers’ honesty establishes the book’s emotional ethic, which rejects both false reassurance and despair as the only responses to loss.
The Towers on Television
On September 11, 2001, senior students watch the attacks unfold during math class. Ambrose stares at the World Trade Center because his mother works in the North Tower, and he cannot reach her by phone. Fern holds Bailey’s hand as the towers collapse and the classroom empties around them. Ambrose stays behind, praying in the wrestling room, and eventually learns that his mother survived.
The reprieve does not restore his earlier ease. The attacks make war feel close to home, especially when he remembers that Flight 93 fell near their Pennsylvania town. As senior year continues, the pressure of being Hannah Lake’s celebrated wrestling champion begins to feel less like a privilege and more like a life chosen for him.
The attacks bind public catastrophe to private uncertainty: Ambrose cannot act, cannot know, and must wait for news about his mother. His instinct to enter the Army later grows from this helplessness, as well as from a desire to serve and escape the expectations attached to his athletic fame. Fern and Bailey respond differently, one emotionally exposed and one intent on recording history. Their contrasting ways of processing danger deepen the friendship that will shape Ambrose’s return.
Letters Signed Rita
When Rita Marsden wants Ambrose’s attention, Fern writes the notes for her, giving them questions and observations far more intimate than Rita would have composed. Ambrose replies with poems and thoughtful answers, and Fern begins to know him through the words he believes he is sharing with Rita. She keeps writing even after seeing them kiss.
When Rita admits that Ambrose discovered the deception, Fern returns his letters and confesses that her own feelings were real. Ambrose is hurt and embarrassed, but he gives the letters back to Fern to keep. The exchange leaves both of them exposed: Fern has shown the depth of her affection, while Ambrose has learned that the person who understood him was not the beautiful girl he first pursued.
The letters separate attraction from recognition. Ambrose is initially drawn to Rita’s appearance, but the correspondence he values is Fern’s work: her curiosity makes room for a more complex version of him than the town’s champion. Fern’s deception is ethically imperfect, yet it is also the only route she can imagine into a conversation with someone who seems unreachable. When the truth surfaces, her vulnerability does not secure romance, but it plants a lasting question about what makes someone desirable.
Hercules Wins State
At the state wrestling tournament, Ambrose looks so distracted that an opponent takes the lead with seconds remaining. Bailey, watching from the edge of the mat, invokes the Hercules story and reminds Ambrose how the hero defeated a lion when ordinary attacks failed.
Ambrose changes position, traps his opponent, and wins by pinning him at the last moment. He completes an unprecedented fourth state championship, but slips away from the celebration rather than basking in his fame.
At prom, Fern attends with Bailey, who arranges for Ambrose’s friends to dance with her and takes Rita onto the floor himself. Ambrose still does not ask Fern to dance. His silence confirms her fear that being understood in letters has not made her visible to him in person.
Bailey’s intervention turns myth into practical knowledge: the story helps Ambrose alter his strategy at the exact moment when reputation threatens to become defeat. Yet winning does not resolve his discomfort with being treated as a symbol. At prom, the contrast between Bailey’s generous initiative and Ambrose’s avoidance exposes how fear can masquerade as indifference. Fern is not simply rejected by a boy; she is left wondering whether the self she revealed in writing can ever be recognized outside the page.
Five Leave for War
After visiting the Flight 93 memorial, Ambrose tells his four closest teammates, Beans, Grant, Jesse, and Paulie, that he has enlisted in the Army National Guard. He wants to serve after the attacks, but also wants to postpone the college decisions and public expectations that have come to burden him.
Grant joins first, followed by Beans and Jesse; Paulie, who would rather make music, eventually agrees because the others are going. Before they leave for training, Fern returns to the lakeside gathering to say goodbye.
A cruel party game revives the old letter deception, and Ambrose takes Fern away before it can humiliate her further. He kisses her, clumsily at first, then gently, but Fern leaves without knowing whether the kiss means love or apology.
Ambrose’s enlistment is both an act of conviction and an escape from an identity that has become too public to inhabit comfortably. His friends’ decision to follow gives him companionship, but it also means his private uncertainty shapes their futures. The farewell kiss offers Fern tenderness without clarity. It is a moment of genuine feeling delivered in a form that still leaves her to interpret his motives, repeating the imbalance that began with the letters.
The Roadside Bomb
In Iraq, the five friends serve together and use jokes, music, and memories of Hannah Lake to make the deployment bearable. Jesse receives news that he has a son at home, whom he has never met, and marks the child’s name on his chest. During a routine patrol in Baghdad, children run beside the convoy in a way Paulie recognizes as a warning.
A roadside bomb detonates beneath the vehicle ahead of Ambrose. Beans, Grant, Jesse, and Paulie are killed; Ambrose survives with catastrophic injuries to the right side of his face, loss of sight in one eye, and loss of an ear. He is evacuated for treatment, carrying both the physical damage and a crushing belief that he should have died with them.
The blast turns Ambrose’s chosen brotherhood into the source of his deepest guilt. His survival is not experienced as a gift because it makes him ask why the others were not spared. Jesse’s tattoo establishes the human future interrupted by war, while the children’s warning underscores how little control the soldiers possess over the danger around them. Ambrose’s injuries literalize a crisis already underway: the champion’s recognizable face and role are gone, but his sense of responsibility remains painfully intact.
Home Behind a Scar
After months in hospitals, Ambrose comes back to Hannah Lake but avoids his coach, Bailey, and the families of the men who died. He cannot bear their grief or the town’s curiosity, and he hides his face beneath a bandana while working the night shift at his father Elliott’s bakery. Fern encounters him by accident when her bicycle crashes near him.
He recognizes her only after she names herself, then leaves as soon as the streetlight reveals his scars. Fern understands that his injuries are profound, but she does not pursue him immediately. Instead, she waits for another chance to reach him. His physical return has brought him home without restoring his place in it; he remains alone inside a town that wants to see him.
Ambrose’s withdrawal protects him from scrutiny but also prevents the people around him from mourning with him. The town’s desire to welcome him cannot reach someone who experiences attention as exposure. The chance meeting with Fern makes recognition tentative: she sees enough to understand what he fears, but does not force intimacy. Her restraint contrasts with the public’s curiosity and gives Ambrose the possibility of contact without demanding that he perform recovery.
Questions on the Whiteboard
Fern begins leaving questions and Shakespeare passages on a bakery whiteboard, reviving the word games that once carried their letters. Ambrose answers, then lashes out when her kindness feels like pity, and Fern stops writing. The next time she sees him, Bailey has brought him into their late-night karaoke ritual, where Fern and Bailey’s unpolished performances make Ambrose laugh for the first time in months.
Their outings grow easier. After a rainy drive, Ambrose tells Fern that he blames himself for persuading his friends to enlist; Fern admits she has loved him since childhood. He cannot promise an answer, but lets her comfort him. Their connection begins not with his face becoming acceptable, but with both of them risking honesty.
The whiteboard makes communication visible while preserving the distance each character needs. Ambrose’s hostile response is not proof that he feels nothing; it is an attempt to reject care before it can become another obligation. Bailey’s humor interrupts that defensive pattern without erasing the grief beneath it. Fern’s confession does not cure Ambrose, and the scene wisely resists romanticizing her as a remedy. Instead, it gives him a relationship in which he can speak about guilt and remain loved.
The Wrestling Room Opens
As Fern and Ambrose grow closer, she helps expose Becker Garth’s cruelty toward Rita, her friend and the mother of Becker’s young son. Fern publicly confronts Becker at the grocery store, and Ambrose throws him out when he threatens her.
Rita later admits that she once loved Bailey but feared the demands of his illness, then married Becker and became trapped in an abusive relationship. Meanwhile, Bailey tells Ambrose that grief has isolated him from everyone who also lost the soldiers.
Ambrose visits their memorial, then returns to Coach Sheen’s wrestling room, where balance and hearing problems make practice difficult. Fern joins him at the Fourth of July fireworks; when he finally kisses her without hiding his scars, their relationship shifts from comfort toward mutual desire.
The wrestling room becomes a place where Ambrose can experience limitation without being reduced to it. Bailey’s challenge is persuasive because it comes from someone whose dependence is visible and lifelong, not from a demand to return to the old champion’s image. Fern’s intervention in Rita’s life also reveals the difference between protection and control: she supports her friend while confronting the danger directly. Ambrose’s kiss at the fireworks matters because he allows himself to be seen while wanting, not merely while suffering.
Bailey Saves Ty
One night Bailey hears a child crying near Jerry’s Joint and finds Rita unconscious in Becker’s truck. Unable to lift her, he gets two-year-old Ty into his lap and calls emergency services while driving his wheelchair toward help. Becker spots them and chases Bailey through town. Bailey swerves to protect the child, then crashes into a water-filled ditch; Ty is thrown safely onto the bank, but Bailey cannot lift himself out.
Police find him by the light on his headlamp, too late to revive him. At the hospital, Rita survives surgery for a brain bleed caused by an earlier fall during her attempt to leave Becker. Fern and Ambrose lose the friend who had spent his life finding ways to act despite what his body could not do.
Bailey’s final act is not a miraculous cure or a triumph over disability. It is an improvised rescue shaped by the precise limits he has always lived with: he can steer, call, persuade a child to climb to safety, but cannot pull himself from the water. The headlamp makes his location visible, turning a tool intended to protect him into a cruelly insufficient beacon. The sequence honors his agency without pretending that courage can guarantee survival.
Becker Faces Ambrose
After Bailey’s funeral, Becker returns to Hannah Lake searching for Rita and attacks Fern outside the grocery store, demanding to know where his wife and son have gone. Fern refuses to reveal that Rita has escaped with her mother. Ambrose hears Fern scream, runs across the field, and knocks Becker down before he can use his knife.
He restrains Becker with Fern’s bicycle lock and calls the police, then holds Fern as she recovers. The rescue echoes Ambrose’s earlier defense of Bailey against Becker, but this time Ambrose does not retreat into silence afterward. He has acted to protect someone he loves, and the police can finally connect Becker to the danger surrounding Rita, Ty, Fern, and Bailey.
This confrontation brings the book’s intimate and public forms of violence into the same frame. Becker has relied on private intimidation, while Ambrose’s intervention makes the danger impossible to conceal. The bicycle lock, an everyday object from Fern’s commute, becomes an improvised means of keeping the attacker in place. Ambrose’s anger is real, but he stops short of making vengeance the resolution; he secures Fern and involves the authorities, choosing protection over the punishment his grief might demand.
Names Carried Forward
At Bailey’s funeral, Ambrose remembers how Bailey once took him down on the mat and explains that his friend taught him to value a life beyond achievement. He commits to wrestling for Penn State, a decision reinforced by Bailey’s childhood list and the book about Hercules left for him. Fern keeps Bailey close with a small tattoo; Ambrose carries the names of his fallen friends and a fern across his chest.
He and Fern marry after her romance novels find a publisher and he establishes himself at college. The families of the dead begin to reconnect with him, though Luisa O’Toole continues to grieve at a distance. Their wedding does not erase the losses; it gives the survivors a future built alongside them.
The ending refuses the fantasy that love repairs every wound. Ambrose’s return to wrestling is a chosen practice, not a restoration of his former body or fame; his scars remain, and the dead remain dead. Tattoos turn memory into something carried on living skin, while Bailey’s list becomes a record of intention rather than a tally of completed tasks. Fern and Ambrose’s marriage gives the story a hopeful conclusion without converting survival into proof that suffering had to happen.
Epilogue
Years later, Ambrose reads Hercules’s final labor to his young son, whose red hair recalls Fern. The child asks whether his father is as strong as the hero and whether he might become one too.
Ambrose answers that heroism has many forms, then tucks him into bed. Bailey’s name now belongs to the boy, linking the family’s future to the friend whose courage helped Ambrose return to life.
The epilogue turns inheritance away from physical resemblance or athletic greatness. Ambrose does not ask his son to imitate Hercules, and the child’s name quietly carries Bailey forward without making him a substitute for the dead. The bedtime story that once framed danger now ends in a safe room, with a parent able to offer care. The novel’s idea of heroism has changed from defeating monsters to living with tenderness after loss.
Analysis
Making Faces builds its romance around the difference between being looked at and being known. Ambrose begins as the town’s ideal athlete, admired for a body and face that seem to promise an uncomplicated future. Fern begins on the opposite side of that economy of attention, convinced that her appearance makes her forgettable. Their positions change, but not neatly: Ambrose loses the face that once made admiration effortless, while Fern grows into a beauty she has trouble trusting. The book’s central question is not whether appearance matters, but how much power people grant it over intimacy and self-worth.
Bailey makes that question harder to answer. His illness is not a metaphor that exists only to teach the able-bodied characters gratitude. It shapes his daily dependence, his humor, his ambitions, and the knowledge that his future is constrained. He refuses both sentimental denial and the assumption that dependence makes a life smaller. His friendship with Fern is reciprocal even when her care is physically practical, and his influence on Ambrose comes from a clarity earned through living with limits.
The novel also treats grief as a social condition. Ambrose’s guilt isolates him, but his withdrawal leaves the town’s other mourners without a way to reach him. Fern’s presence matters because she can accompany him without claiming to explain the deaths. The repeated images of lists, wrestling, scars, and names written on skin all make memory tangible. None can reverse loss. They can, however, give survivors a practice: return to the mat, tell the truth, protect someone in danger, and let love coexist with pain. The ending’s hope is therefore not that suffering proves worthwhile, but that people can build a future without pretending the past has disappeared.
Review Summary
Making Faces is a deeply emotional and thought-provoking novel that explores themes of beauty, love, loss, and self-acceptance. Readers praise Harmon's beautiful writing, memorable characters, and powerful storytelling. The book follows Fern, an "ugly duckling," and Ambrose, a handsome athlete turned war veteran, as they navigate life's challenges and find love. Many reviewers were moved to tears by the story's emotional depth and appreciated its messages about inner beauty and resilience. The character of Bailey, Fern's cousin with muscular dystrophy, was particularly beloved for his humor and strength.
People Also Read
Characters
Fern Taylor
The observant storytellerFern is the daughter of a pastor and Bailey’s cousin, companion, and caregiver. Small and awkward as a child, she learns early to measure herself against girls whose beauty seems to open doors for them. Reading and writing romance give her a private language for desire, but her perceptiveness extends beyond fantasy: she notices what others conceal and meets pain with humor, practical care, and unusual candor. Her affection for Ambrose begins long before he recognizes her, yet she is not simply waiting to be chosen. Fern’s central drive is to see people fully and to be seen in return. Her growth involves learning that caring for someone does not mean making herself responsible for every need.
Ambrose Young
The scarred championAmbrose is Hannah Lake’s gifted wrestler, Elliott Young’s adopted son, and a young man accustomed to being admired for his strength and appearance. Beneath that public image, he fears disappointing people and longs to escape the expectations that accompany his success. His choice to enlist grows from patriotism, grief, and uncertainty about what should come next. After war changes his body and removes his friends, he struggles with survivor guilt and withdraws from people who want to help. His bond with Fern develops through humor, memory, and hard conversations rather than pity. Ambrose’s challenge is to build an identity that can include his injuries and losses without treating them as the whole of him.
Bailey Sheen
The bright-eyed tacticianBailey is Fern’s cousin and closest friend, the son of wrestling coach Mike Sheen, and a boy whose muscular disease progressively limits his movement. He compensates not by pretending his limitations do not matter, but by developing a sharp mind, a deep knowledge of wrestling and history, and a humor that can puncture self-pity without denying hardship. Bailey wants to be a hero, but his idea of heroism is rooted in helping others and living deliberately. His relationship with Fern is affectionate, teasing, and mutually protective. He sees the insecurity beneath her wit and the grief beneath Ambrose’s silence, often understanding both before they do.
Rita Marsden
The searching friendRita is Fern’s beautiful, warm-hearted friend, whose confidence in her appearance hides uncertainty about the choices she makes. She is drawn to affection and attention, but does not always know how to distinguish being desired from being understood. Her friendship with Fern gives her a place to admit fear and shame, while her connection to Bailey carries tenderness complicated by anxiety about his illness. Rita’s story reflects how vulnerability can be exploited when charm and persistence are mistaken for safety. She is not merely a rival in Fern’s love story; she is a young woman trying to find agency, make a home, and protect the child she loves.
Elliott Young
Ambrose’s steadfast fatherElliott is Ambrose’s adoptive father and the patient proprietor of the family bakery. He raised Ambrose as his own despite having no biological claim, and his quiet devotion gives his son a model of love grounded in constancy rather than appearance. Elliott works long hours and worries that he cannot compete with the handsome biological father who remains part of Lily’s past. His humility and steadiness make him a source of safety for Ambrose even when neither is good at discussing fear.
Mike Sheen
The demanding coachMike is Bailey’s father and Ambrose’s wrestling coach. He holds his athletes to demanding standards but makes room for Bailey’s expertise and presence in the team. His care is practical, often expressed through routines, training, and the work of showing up. Mike’s identity as a coach does not eclipse his role as a parent; he must repeatedly confront what he cannot change while continuing to make his son feel included.
Angie Sheen
Bailey’s clear-eyed motherAngie is Bailey’s mother and Fern’s aunt. She manages the practical demands of her son’s illness while speaking to him with honesty rather than false comfort. Her composure is not an absence of grief; it is a way of helping Bailey and Fern understand difficult truths without leaving them alone inside those truths. Angie’s care shapes both children’s ideas about mortality, friendship, and what it means to keep living.
Joshua Taylor
The community pastorJoshua is Fern’s father, a pastor whose service extends beyond the members of his church. He listens to people in crisis and offers counsel grounded in humility rather than certainty. His relationship with Fern combines warmth with a willingness to let her question the beliefs she has inherited. Joshua provides a moral center for Hannah Lake, though his faith does not shield him or his family from grief.
Rachel Taylor
Fern’s patient motherRachel is Fern’s mother and Angie’s sister. She offers tenderness and perspective, especially when Fern’s worries about her appearance or Bailey’s future become difficult to carry. Her late-in-life motherhood makes her attentive to the value of family, while her closeness to Angie gives the cousins a bond that feels almost sibling-like.
Becker Garth
The polished bullyBecker is Rita’s husband, a handsome and socially confident man whose polished exterior masks a need to dominate those around him. He targets people he expects cannot or will not fight back, using charm when it serves him and intimidation when it does not. His presence challenges Fern and Ambrose to distinguish physical attractiveness from goodness, while his behavior shows how abuse can persist behind the appearance of an ordinary marriage.
Beans
The quick-witted teammateBeans, whose given name is Connor O’Toole, is a small, outspoken wrestler and one of Ambrose’s closest friends. He uses jokes to manage tension and is fiercely loyal to the group, though his teasing can cut too close. His family ties connect him to Hannah Lake’s wider community and to the cost that military service carries for those left at home.
Paulie Kimball
The gentle musicianPaulie is a sensitive teammate who loves music more than wrestling and often expresses care by turning feeling into song. He joins his friends’ plans out of loyalty, even when they pull him toward choices that do not match his own ambitions. His softness is not weakness; it gives the group a way to speak about fear and longing without turning every emotion into a joke.
Grant Nielson
The steady scholarGrant is a thoughtful, disciplined wrestler who takes school, responsibility, and faith seriously. He has no easy route to college and considers military service partly as a way to secure an education. Among Ambrose’s friends, Grant often supplies practical judgment and quiet steadiness, even when he is swept into the group’s larger decisions.
Jesse Jordan
The restless young fatherJesse is an accomplished wrestler with a brash streak and an intense relationship with Marley. He wants to stay close to his friends while also facing the responsibilities gathering around him. His pride and humor can make him seem careless, but his attachments are deep, and the prospect of fatherhood exposes how much he wants to matter to the family he is starting.
Marley Davis
Jesse’s devoted partnerMarley is Jesse’s girlfriend and the mother of his child. She is devoted to him and tries to plan a future together despite the distance and uncertainty created by his military service. Her presence gives Jesse’s longing a concrete homecoming to imagine.
Lily Young
Ambrose’s searching motherLily is Ambrose’s biological mother, a woman who once pursued a life beyond Hannah Lake and remains entangled with her past. Her choices leave Elliott and Ambrose to build their own understanding of family, loyalty, and belonging.
Luisa O’Toole
A grieving motherLuisa is Beans’s mother, a fierce and expressive woman whose love for her son shapes her view of the friends who served beside him. Her anger and grief are inseparable, and she does not move through loss at the same pace as the rest of Hannah Lake.
Plot Devices
Hercules and the Labors
A map for courageBailey’s fascination with Hercules gives Ambrose a language for strength that changes as the story does. First, the hero is a model of physical power; later, Bailey’s account of the lion helps Ambrose recover during a match. The grieving face of Hercules becomes a way to understand guilt, while the final labor frames the novel’s opening and ending. The myth does not promise that suffering can be undone. Instead, it lets characters imagine courage as continuing after a terrible cost.
Bailey’s childhood list
A life measured by wishesBailey’s list records the experiences he hopes to have while his disease changes what his body can do. Its entries range from playful childhood ambitions to commitments such as living courageously and caring for Fern. The list gives other characters a way to remember Bailey as more than his illness, and it becomes a measure of how influence and love can help a person’s wishes travel beyond their own physical abilities.
Letters and word games
Intimacy before recognitionFern’s letters, later echoed through questions on a bakery whiteboard, let her and Ambrose communicate through preferences, poems, and difficult questions. The device links their younger selves to their adult relationship while making identity central: the words belong to Fern even when Ambrose believes they come from Rita. When they resume the exchange, the questions give them a way to approach one another without pretending that time or injury has changed nothing.
Making faces
Emotion without performanceFern and Bailey’s game asks players to communicate through expression rather than explanation. It begins as a playful activity suited to Bailey’s physical limitations, then gains new meaning as Ambrose struggles with the damage to his face. The game invites attention to what a face can and cannot reveal: a scar does not erase feeling, and a practiced expression does not guarantee honesty. Its simple rules give the characters a shared way to meet vulnerability with humor.
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.