Key Takeaways
Treat big-time football as a university business, not a self-funding side show.
A separate set of rules. The book begins with an awkward question: why did Penn State offer football players far more financial support than its top honors students? A professor’s answer was that football was treated as if it paid for itself, outside the ordinary university budget. That separation let administrators defend football spending as independent from academic priorities, even when the university supplied crucial support, such as backing for stadium debt or public subsidies for less wealthy programs.
The institution changes around it. At Texas, football became the largest and richest department on campus, with celebrity-level salaries and hundreds of employees. Its leaders described football as a source of money for everything else. Gaul’s reporting shows how that claim can obscure a deeper shift: the university increasingly acts like an entertainment business, with education competing for attention and resources.
What's striking is how much depends on the accounting boundary. When a department is labeled self-supporting, its costs can seem separate from the institution, even if it benefits from public financing, shared infrastructure, or university prestige. This resembles a familiar problem in corporate accounting: moving costs outside a division does not make them disappear. The business framing also has a real appeal. A successful team can fund other sports and draw people toward campus. The harder question is whether those gains justify giving athletics unusual independence from the academic community that lends it legitimacy.
Revenue growth can conceal an arms race that absorbs every new dollar.
Success invites more spending. The University of Texas reported about $103 million in football revenue in 2012, with $78 million left after the costs assigned to the program. Yet the larger athletic department spent nearly all its income, expanded its staff, raised coaches’ salaries, and accumulated about $243 million in facility debt by 2013. Some schools also categorized expenses in ways that made sport-by-sport comparisons difficult. The impressive headline numbers therefore did not prove the operation was efficient.
Costs rise with income. Gaul calls this pattern the revenue theory of costs: when revenue grows, spending tends to grow alongside it rather than being restrained. Texas and its rivals kept upgrading seats, suites, facilities, and support operations to stay competitive. Each school’s investment could look sensible on its own, while the collective result was an expensive contest in which no rival could safely stand still.
This is a classic ratchet: once a competitor raises the standard, matching it becomes defensive rather than ambitious. The cycle can persist even when the original investment has diminishing returns, because each institution fears losing recruits, donors, or status. Revenue is therefore a poor stand-alone measure of financial health. Debt, maintenance obligations, and the opportunity cost of spending matter too. Still, the arms-race diagnosis has limits: a facility may serve athletes well, and some investments may produce lasting value. The crucial issue is whether decision-makers test those benefits against the full long-term cost.
A tax deduction can turn premium football seats into a public subsidy.
A purchase dressed as a gift. Many schools require fans to pay an extra fee to secure a desirable seat, separate from the ticket price. Athletic departments call these fees seat donations. In 1988, Congress allowed fans to deduct 80 percent of the payment from their taxes, even though the seat is a valuable benefit received in return. Treasury estimates cited in the book put the resulting tax revenue loss at about $250 million a year.
The label reshapes the transaction. Texas fans could pay about $20,000 to secure four seats near midfield, while Georgia collected $22 million in seat payments in 2012. The book traces the deduction’s survival to lobbying and congressional support from football-minded lawmakers. The question is not only whether the arrangement is legal. It is whether treating access to entertainment as charity makes the public help finance an already commercial enterprise.
The distinction between a gift and a purchase matters because tax exemptions are a form of public spending, even when no check is written by government. Calling a payment charitable can make a subsidy harder to see and harder to evaluate. The strongest defense is that athletic departments use the money to support a range of sports, not just football. But that claim does not settle whether the subsidy is well targeted or equitable. A clear policy would disclose who benefits, what public purpose is served, and how much revenue the deduction costs.
Stop treating coach contracts as rational bets when failure carries multimillion-dollar guarantees.
Optimism gets expensive. Notre Dame hired Charlie Weis in 2004, then extended his contract after only six games, following a strong start. When the team later struggled, the school fired him but remained responsible for a large guaranteed buyout. The book estimates that Notre Dame paid him nearly $17 million after his dismissal. Kansas later hired Weis and, after firing him in his third season, owed another $5.625 million. Together, the schools paid close to $23 million for periods when he was not coaching their teams.
The market story is incomplete. Athletic directors often say they must pay more to retain a successful coach or beat rival schools to a hire. Yet the book documents contracts extended on thin evidence, steep raises, and costly buyouts. Nick Saban’s Alabama success generated substantial revenue, but the cost of the program rose too. Winning does not automatically make every salary or contract efficient.
These contracts expose a principal-agent problem: administrators make high-stakes commitments using institutional funds, while the coach receives considerable protection if the forecast fails. The incentives can reward confidence more reliably than judgment. Long contracts may be necessary to recruit coaches in a competitive market, and one bad season cannot prove a hire was foolish. But extending a deal after a handful of games is especially vulnerable to recency bias, the tendency to mistake a short run of results for durable ability. Better decisions would connect guarantees to evidence that can be assessed over time.
Build academic support around learning, not merely keeping football players eligible.
Support can become a parallel school. At Kansas, the athletic department employed tutors, learning specialists, and class checkers, the staff members who tracked whether athletes attended class. Its academic support operation cost about $3 million a year and handled roughly 1,500 to 1,600 tutoring sessions each week. Oregon built a $42 million academic center exclusively for athletes. Such help can be valuable, especially for students balancing demanding training schedules.
Eligibility is not the same as education. Gaul found football players clustered in majors that could be more flexible or require fewer demanding courses. At Baylor, 52 percent of football players were enrolled in general studies. North Carolina’s long-running fake-class scandal showed the worst version of the problem: academic machinery designed to keep players eligible could become a route around actual learning. Graduation rates alone do not reveal what students learned or how prepared they are afterward.
Specialized support can be an accommodation that helps students succeed, not evidence that they are receiving a sham education. The concern arises when support is measured by eligibility and graduation while the institution avoids asking whether students are learning. That is a measurement problem as much as an ethics problem: what gets counted becomes the operational goal. A fair comparison would also ask why athletes receive resources unavailable to other students with similar needs. The book makes a persuasive case for scrutiny, while the evidence should not be used to presume that every athlete or tutor is complicit in abuse.
Measure athletics by student opportunities, not stadium size or championships.
Budgets do not equal access. Texas spent about $170 million on athletics and sponsored 20 varsity teams with 549 athletes. Princeton, with a much smaller athletic budget of about $20 million, sponsored 36 teams and had 962 varsity athletes. Haverford, with just over 1,200 undergraduates, had more varsity teams than Texas. These comparisons reveal different priorities: some programs concentrate resources on a small number of teams competing for championships, while others try to give more students the chance to play.
Football can both help and dominate. At wealthy programs, football revenue supports sports that bring in little money themselves. But football is also exceptionally expensive, and the book finds that some departments have substantial sums left after supporting their teams. Athletic directors often treat the money as a reason to build stronger entertainment brands. The question is whether athletic success means winning more, or offering more students a meaningful educational experience.
This comparison turns the standard measure of athletic success inside out. A large budget can buy elite facilities and competitive teams without expanding participation. The smaller-school approach reflects a different conception of sport as part of undergraduate education, though it may not satisfy fans who value national titles or high-level competition. Neither model can be judged by spending alone. A useful assessment would include access, athlete experience, academic outcomes, and financial sustainability. The point is not that every university should copy Princeton, but that institutions should make their definition of success explicit.
Title IX widened women's rowing, but football kept setting the terms.
Rowing filled a numbers gap. Title IX requires schools receiving federal funds to provide equitable athletic opportunities for women and men. Large football rosters created a challenge for schools trying to balance participation, so many added women’s rowing, a sport that could accommodate large teams. From 1995 to 2000, Division I women’s rowing programs grew from 44 to 84, with nearly 5,000 athletes. Coaches often recruited tall women from other sports who had never rowed before.
Opportunity came with a contradiction. Rowing offered many women access to varsity sport, and coaches like Wisconsin’s Bebe Bryans built demanding programs that helped athletes develop. At the same time, some coaches received target roster counts because the teams helped schools meet gender-equity requirements. The book notes the vast funding gap: the average Division I football program spent eleven times as much per football player as women’s rowing programs spent per rower.
The rowing story resists a simple verdict. A policy can create real opportunity even when institutions adopt it for strategic reasons. Newcomers who learned the sport and found serious competition gained something meaningful, regardless of the administrators’ initial motive. Yet roster numbers are an imperfect proxy for equal opportunity if funding, coaching pay, and support remain dramatically unequal. The case also shows how rules shape organizational behavior: schools respond to measurable requirements, sometimes creatively. Effective oversight must therefore assess both participation and the quality of the experience, rather than treating a head count as proof of equity.
Winning records do not guarantee equal access to football's richest conferences.
The money follows membership. The five wealthiest conferences controlled the largest television deals and postseason revenues, passing most of the new money to their own schools. Robert Kustra, Boise State’s president, pointed to the imbalance: Boise State had won 145 games and lost 23 over the period discussed, yet its television income was expected to be about $2 million to $3 million. Colorado, with 64 wins and 87 losses over the same decade, was set to receive about $30 million through the Pac-12.
The system compounds advantage. Rich conferences can spend more on coaches, facilities, and recruiting, then use that capacity to strengthen their position. Smaller schools still seeking a place at the top often lose money and rely on student fees or university subsidies. The book’s central economic irony is that football is presented as a route to competitive advantage, while the distribution of revenue makes that advantage increasingly difficult for outsiders to reach.
This is a network-effects problem: a conference becomes more valuable because it already has popular teams, desirable markets, and large media contracts. The existing winners can use their resources to preserve that position, so on-field performance alone does not determine economic reward. A redistribution of revenue could broaden competition, but it would face resistance from institutions that benefit from the current arrangement. The comparison also has limits, since media markets and institutional profiles matter alongside records. Even so, the contrast makes clear that the system is not a straightforward meritocracy.
Count athlete benefits without pretending they settle the compensation debate.
Scholarships are only part of the exchange. Football players may receive tuition, room and board, books, meals, clothing, emergency assistance, personal training, and extensive academic support. Bowl participants can also receive gifts. These benefits can be substantial, and the book challenges the idea that players are simply abandoned or unsupported. But the players generate much of the value that coaches, conferences, and schools capture, and a generous scholarship does not by itself answer whether the exchange is fair.
Changing the label changes little. The book describes a proposed annual payment of roughly $4,000 to $5,000 to players, called a stipend rather than wages. That terminology would not resolve whether elite football is an educational activity or a professional enterprise. It would also raise questions about Title IX, costs for smaller schools, and the boundary between students and employees.
Benefits in kind complicate a wage debate but do not make it disappear. A scholarship provides education and can reduce debt, yet it is not interchangeable with cash, control over one’s time, or a share of revenue. Conversely, framing athletes only as exploited workers can erase genuine educational support and the value some place on playing for a university. The useful question is not whether players are victims or beneficiaries. It is who sets the terms, who bears the risks, and whether the educational promise is real enough to justify the amateur label.
Test football's enrollment promise against competing explanations.
A popular team may draw attention. University leaders often argue that winning football attracts applicants and strengthens a school’s reputation. Oregon’s president celebrated a surge of interest after the team reached the national championship game. Yet the university was also enrolling more students from California, where public universities faced funding cuts and applicants sought alternatives. Football may have helped, but the book shows why the effect is hard to isolate.
Publicity is not proof of academic gain. Alabama promoted the idea that championships had brought in more, stronger applicants, but other changes could also explain the trend, including scholarships, easier online applications, and new academic programs. Meanwhile, smaller schools such as Florida Atlantic invested in football despite weak attendance and repeated losses. A university should examine enrollment, selectivity, and financial outcomes before treating exposure as a reliable return on investment.
This is a problem of causal inference: a visible success often receives credit for changes that may have several causes. Football can generate attention, but attention is not the same as improved teaching, research, or student outcomes. A careful evaluation would compare trends against similar institutions and account for admissions changes, new programs, and shifts in regional demand. The case for football is strongest when leaders specify what success means and how they will measure it. Otherwise, branding becomes a story that protects a large investment from evidence.
Presidents cannot police a business they are expected to promote.
Reform keeps circling back. NCAA and presidential reports repeatedly warned that independent athletic departments had become too commercial and that university leaders needed to take more control. Yet presidents also promoted football, courted donors, and faced pressure from boards and fans to win. Holden Thorp’s experience at North Carolina showed how an athletic scandal could overwhelm a president who had little prior reason to investigate a supposedly successful program. When UAB proposed dropping football despite large subsidies, protests and political pressure helped reverse the decision.
The incentives remain unstable. The book closes with lavish facilities, expensive coaches, and concern that younger fans may prefer watching highlights or games on screens to attending in person. College football’s leaders saw no sign of a bubble, but rising costs and dependence on live media left schools exposed to changing audiences. The lesson is not that collapse is certain. It is that a model built on perpetual growth deserves serious scrutiny.
The president’s conflict is structural, not merely personal. The same leader may be expected to sell the football brand, satisfy trustees, and protect academic standards. Asking that person to impose restraint without changing those incentives is unlikely to produce durable reform. Nor is the answer simply to hand control to athletic directors, whose success is often judged by revenue and wins. Governance needs independent scrutiny, transparent budgets, and consequences tied to academic and institutional outcomes. The book’s warning about younger fans is plausible, but it remains a risk scenario, not proof that demand is about to collapse.
Analysis
Gaul’s investigation is strongest when it treats college football not as a collection of colorful excesses, but as an institutional system whose incentives reinforce one another. Television money supports facilities and salaries. Those investments raise expectations, invite further spending, and intensify the pressure to win. Tax preferences and separate athletic budgets help the enterprise appear financially independent, while subsidies and university guarantees reveal how porous that boundary can be. The recurring contradiction is not simply that football is commercial. It is that schools claim the authority and tax treatment of education while adopting the cost structure and promotional logic of entertainment.
The book’s most important distinction is between football’s ability to generate revenue and its ability to serve a university. The first is demonstrable at wealthy programs. The second requires judgments about student access, learning, equity, and institutional mission. Texas can produce impressive profits while supporting fewer varsity athletes than Princeton. Rowing can create genuine opportunities while also serving as a roster-balancing tool. Academic centers can help students while leaving open the question of whether they are learning. These are not contradictions to be tidied away. They are evidence that a single financial metric cannot define institutional success.
The reporting also complicates the easy story of athletes as either beneficiaries or victims. Scholarships and extensive support have real value, but they do not automatically settle questions of bargaining power, compensation, or educational quality. Likewise, reform cannot rest on presidential resolve alone when presidents are expected to promote the very programs they should oversee. Better governance would make costs and subsidies visible, assess outcomes beyond wins and graduation rates, and distinguish public educational value from brand exposure.
The book’s limits follow from its investigative focus. It offers a vivid account of financial structures and troubling cases, but the evidence is uneven across institutions, and the effect of football on admissions or campus culture is difficult to isolate. Its cautions about declining interest are forecasts rather than demonstrated collapse. Those limits do not undo the central finding: a program’s revenue is not proof that its priorities are sound, and a university should not confuse the popularity of its football brand with the success of its educational mission.
Review Summary
Billion-Dollar Ball receives mixed reviews, with an average rating of 3.87 out of 5. Readers praise its insightful look into college football's big-money culture, revealing the sport's impact on universities and education. Critics argue it's biased against football programs. Many found it eye-opening, detailing the financial aspects, including coach salaries and facility costs. Some readers felt conflicted about their fandom after learning about the industry's excesses. The book's exploration of Title IX compliance and the power dynamics between athletic departments and university administration was particularly noted.
People Also Read
Glossary
seat donations
Fees for preferred seatsPayments that fans make in addition to ticket prices to obtain or retain desirable seats at college games. Athletic departments describe them as donations, and federal law has allowed fans to deduct 80 percent of qualifying payments from their taxes. Gaul argues that the payments function more like purchases because the fan receives a valuable seat in return.
revenue theory of costs
Spending expands with incomeGaul’s term for the spending pattern at wealthy athletic departments: as revenue rises, expenses tend to rise with it, rather than being held down to preserve a surplus or redirected to academic needs. The pattern helps explain why record football income can coexist with expanding staffs, rising salaries, facility construction, and large debts.
money games
Paid games against powerhousesGames in which a smaller football program receives a payment, called a guarantee, to play a more powerful school, usually at the larger school’s home stadium. The host gets a likely win and a home game, while the visiting team gets revenue it might not earn from ticket sales. The mismatch can produce heavy losses on the field.
superconferences
The richest football conferencesGaul’s shorthand for the five major football conferences that controlled the largest television contracts and postseason payouts in the period covered: the SEC, Big Ten, Big 12, Pac-12, and ACC. Their members received most of the new money entering college football, widening the financial gap between them and schools in less wealthy conferences.
proportionality prong
Athlete numbers match enrollmentA Title IX compliance approach that compares the share of women among a school’s varsity athletes with the share of women among its undergraduate students. A school whose participation figures are sufficiently aligned with its enrollment demographics can use that alignment as evidence of equitable athletic opportunity. The approach makes roster counts central to compliance decisions.
class checkers
Staff tracking class attendanceAt the University of Kansas, class checkers were staff members who monitored whether athletes attended assigned classes and reported attendance to academic advisers. Gaul calls them walkers because much of the work involved crossing campus and waiting outside classrooms. The practice was one part of a larger academic-support system designed to keep athletes on track and eligible.
experience goods
Products valued through experienceA term from economics for offerings whose quality is understood through use or participation rather than inspection before purchase. Gaul applies the idea to college football: fans pay for the experience of a game, and athletic departments try to make that experience appealing through winning teams, premium seating, stadium amenities, and media spectacle.
Title IX
Federal sex-discrimination lawA federal law prohibiting sex discrimination in educational programs receiving federal financial assistance. In college athletics, schools use participation, scholarship, and other measures to show that women and men have equitable opportunities. Gaul focuses on how football’s unusually large rosters affect those calculations, and how some schools expanded women’s sports, especially rowing, to balance participation numbers.
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.