Start free trial
Trending New Genres Authors
EnglishEnglish
EspañolSpanish
简体中文Chinese
繁體中文Chinese (Traditional)
FrançaisFrench
DeutschGerman
日本語Japanese
PortuguêsPortuguese
ItalianoItalian
한국어Korean
РусскийRussian
NederlandsDutch
العربيةArabic
PolskiPolish
हिन्दीHindi
Tiếng ViệtVietnamese
SvenskaSwedish
ΕλληνικάGreek
TürkçeTurkish
ไทยThai
ČeštinaCzech
RomânăRomanian
MagyarHungarian
УкраїнськаUkrainian
IndonesiaIndonesian
DanskDanish
SuomiFinnish
БългарскиBulgarian
עבריתHebrew
NorskNorwegian
HrvatskiCroatian
CatalàCatalan
SlovenčinaSlovak
LietuviųLithuanian
SlovenščinaSlovenian
СрпскиSerbian
EestiEstonian
LatviešuLatvian
فارسیPersian
മലയാളംMalayalam
தமிழ்Tamil
اردوUrdu
Searching...
SoBrief
Born Again This Way

Born Again This Way

Coming out, coming to faith, and what comes next
A box of love letters confronts a Yale convert with faith's demands on desire.
by Rachel Gilson 2020 163 pages
4.47
1k+ ratings
Listen
Immersive
V2.3
Amazon Kindle Audible
Try Full Access for 3 Days
Unlock listening & more!
Continue

Key Takeaways

Let Jesus, not desire alone, define what is good.

A changed center. Gilson describes arriving at Yale as an atheist convinced that Christianity was intellectually weak and hostile to people like her. After reading C. S. Lewis, she became Christian, but her attraction to women did not disappear. She still had to decide whether to trust Jesus when his teaching seemed to conflict with what felt loving and natural to her. Her faith did not make the questions painless; it gave her a reason to keep asking them.

Years later, a box of letters and keepsakes from an earlier relationship showed her how strongly she remained attached to that former life. A friend's gentle challenge helped her let the mementos go. For Gilson, the central issue was not whether desire felt real, but whether Jesus was trustworthy enough to guide her through it.

Analysis

The narrative distinguishes emotional certainty from moral certainty without pretending that the distinction is easy. Gilson's conclusion depends on a prior Christian conviction: that Jesus has shown God's character through self-giving love. That makes trust more than blind rule-following within her framework. At the same time, an appeal to trust cannot settle a disagreement about what a sacred text means. Readers may share her belief in Jesus yet interpret particular teachings differently. The story is strongest as an account of how she lives with that tension, rather than as proof that every reader must reach the same conclusion.

Read biblical sexual ethics as a story of gifts, not a list of bans.

A wider biblical frame. Gilson and her friend Jane study sexuality across the Bible, rather than relying only on passages that prohibit same-sex sexual behavior. Gilson presents three gifts in that wider story: sex difference, which she sees as part of humanity's diversity; sexual union's capacity for new life; and marriage as an image of God's relationship with the church. She argues that the biblical story moves from creation toward a future in which God's people are united with him.

She also treats church community as a place where people can share spiritual kinship and care, including those who are unmarried or cannot have children. The account acknowledges that sex, bodies, and family are not experienced as uncomplicated blessings by everyone, including people facing oppression, dysphoria, or intersex conditions.

Analysis

A whole-story approach can reveal the positive purpose a tradition assigns to its rules, rather than leaving its ethic as a bare prohibition. Gilson's account also gives singleness and spiritual family a place in the picture, rather than treating marriage and biological parenthood as the only worthwhile outcomes. The central claim, that sex difference is necessary for marriage to represent Christ and the church, is a theological interpretation, not a conclusion established by the metaphor itself. Readers can assess the coherence of that interpretation while recognizing that the book's account is not a neutral summary of all Christian views.

Measure faithfulness by resisting sin, not by becoming heterosexual.

Conduct, not orientation change. Gilson uses the Greek term epithumia for desire, explaining that in the passage from James she discusses, it describes desires that entice people toward sin. She applies that idea to same-sex sexual behavior while distinguishing temptation from acting on it. The distinction matters: the book does not promise that attraction patterns will change, and Gilson says her own attractions remained.

Her first year as a Christian included a relationship with Anna, a woman she loved and continued to see despite believing the relationship violated her convictions. A trusted friend, Sylvia, urged her to end it. The breakup was painful, but Gilson presents it as a choice about obedience, not as a technique for producing heterosexual attraction. She argues that changing the object of desire would not, by itself, make someone holy.

Analysis

The distinction between an experience a person did not choose and an action they choose is important to the book's pastoral argument. It makes room to discuss temptation without treating attraction itself as evidence of hypocrisy or failure. The framework remains specific to Gilson's theological reading of Scripture, especially her view of which relationships count as sinful. That interpretive premise should be made clear rather than smuggled in as a clinical fact. Her rejection of heterosexuality as the measure of holiness also guards against promising a change that the book says God does not guarantee.

Make costly obedience a witness without turning anyone's story into a weapon.

A public, imperfect witness. Gilson believes that faithful lives can challenge both cultural assumptions that desire should always be acted upon and church practices that add shame, stereotypes, or pressure to change attractions. She does not present her own life as a perfect example. In one episode, she sleeps with a former girlfriend, regrets it, and considers hiding what happened. Instead, she calls Sylvia, confesses, and is welcomed back into the Christian community.

For Gilson, that experience shows why churches need both moral clarity and restoration. She also argues that sexual choices affect other people: secrecy can undermine trust, while teaching that a behavior is acceptable can influence others. The witness she describes is not moral superiority. It is a life shaped by conviction, dependence, repentance, and forgiveness.

Analysis

The section's strongest safeguard is its refusal to equate a public witness with personal flawlessness. Confession and welcome make the standard more credible than a performance of purity that hides failure. Its double critique also matters: churches can fail through permissiveness, but they can also harm people through stigma, coercion, or unequal scrutiny. Accountability is most useful when it is voluntary, confidential, and aimed at repair. When it becomes surveillance or public exposure, a practice meant to support faithfulness can instead deepen fear and isolation.

Build church life like family, not a collection of isolated friends.

Belonging with boundaries. Gilson draws on Jesus' promise that disciples who lose family or possessions for his sake will receive a large spiritual family. At Yale, she learned faith through ordinary shared life: Bible study, conversation, prayer, and friends who showed affection. She argues that the church should offer deep, chaste intimacy, especially to people who are single, rather than leaving them to seek all emotional closeness in a romantic partnership.

Her model includes both close friendships and a wider, unchosen community. Broad relationships can help people notice when one friendship is becoming possessive or romantic, while older and younger church members offer perspective across generations. Gilson is clear that attraction can still arise and sometimes calls for distance. The answer is not to avoid closeness altogether, but to build relationships with care and support.

Analysis

The proposal treats community as more than a warm idea: it makes belonging, touch, practical help, and accountability part of ordinary religious life. Its emphasis on a wider circle also offers a counterweight to the expectation that one partner should meet every emotional need. But spiritual family cannot be created by vocabulary alone. Churches need to make room in homes, schedules, and decision-making for people who are single or socially vulnerable. The sibling analogy can encourage trust, but it should not be used to dismiss attraction, override boundaries, or presume that every church is a safe place.

Enter marriage for honest covenant partnership, never as treatment or proof.

No guaranteed cure. Gilson married Andrew at 22, despite not having the overwhelming romantic feelings she had experienced in relationships with women. Their friendship and shared Christian commitments deepened, and she describes developing affection and enough attraction for the marriage they chose. She is explicit that marriage did not make her heterosexual, prove her faith, or serve as a reward for obedience.

The book also tells of Greg and Brodie, who took time to discuss his same-sex attraction and pornography use before marrying. Gilson argues that any couple considering marriage should be honest about sexual desire, motives, and expectations, and should seek wise support. She cautions against assuming a marriage will work, or that one partner can change the other's attractions. Marriage may be a good path for some, but singleness remains equally honorable.

Analysis

The book usefully resists two pressures at once: treating marriage as the expected prize for religious faithfulness and treating it as a means of changing someone's sexuality. The stories model direct conversation before commitment, which supports informed choice for both partners. They cannot predict another couple's future, and the author's marriage is not a template. In any relationship, consent, compatibility, honest expectations, and freedom from pressure matter. A faith-based account of marriage should not make a spouse responsible for producing attraction or shouldering every part of a partner's support.

Honor singleness as a calling while taking its grief seriously.

A real life, not a consolation. Gilson reads Isaiah's promise to a eunuch, a man excluded from marriage and biological descendants, as a picture of God's recognition and belonging for those without a conventional family future. She shares the story of Ed, a single pastor who longs for children and feels the pain of not having them. Later, seeing a man he had discipled resemble him in character gives him a glimpse of spiritual fatherhood and lasting influence.

The chapter does not say that spiritual family removes every loss. Gilson names loneliness, the difficulty of maintaining friendships, and the lack of a dependable partner for everyday support. She points to three needs for single Christians: a deep relationship with Jesus, meaningful companions, and an honest view of singleness as a possible life of service, not a lesser status.

Analysis

This account holds two truths together: singleness can be meaningful, and it can involve grief that should not be hurried away. Ed's story makes spiritual legacy concrete, but it does not make that legacy equivalent to having children. Churches can honor single adults more credibly by offering practical companionship, shared responsibility, and invitations that do not assume a spouse or family will provide support. The distinction matters because celebrating a calling can unintentionally become pressure to be content. Acknowledging sorrow is not a failure of faith.

Acknowledge attraction without letting it become your whole identity.

Experience and identity differ. Gilson argues from Galatians that belonging to Christ is more fundamental than any other true feature of a person's life. She does not say that attractions should be hidden; she says they need not be the defining fact about someone. The label a person chooses can affect how they understand themselves and communicate with others, so she favors language that helps her describe her experience without making it her central identity.

The chapter recounts Emily's story. Emily identified as gay, became Christian, and later experienced a substantial, unexpected shift toward attraction to men. That change did not make her earlier relationships or feelings unreal. Gilson also discusses Lisa Diamond's ten-year study of 100 women, in which many changed the labels they used. These accounts show varied experiences, not a promise that anyone's attractions will change.

Analysis

The distinction between a person's experience and the language used to describe it is helpful because labels can offer community while also narrowing how others interpret a life. Emily's account supports humility about predicting any individual's future, not a general expectation of change. Diamond's study, as presented here, concerns a particular group of 100 women and should not be generalized to everyone. The book's preference for a Christian identity is one theological position; people may use other labels to communicate honestly. Respectful care begins by listening to what a person means by their chosen words.

Analysis

Born Again This Way is both a spiritual memoir and a pastoral argument. Gilson moves from her conversion story to a Christian account of sexuality, then tests that account against practical questions about desire, friendship, marriage, singleness, and identity. Her narrative is the book's main method: theological claims are attached to actual choices, including her relationship with Anna, her marriage to Andrew, and the stories of friends whose paths differ from hers.

The book's most valuable distinction is between enduring attraction and chosen conduct. That distinction enables Gilson to reject the promise that faithfulness must produce heterosexuality, while still asking readers who share her biblical convictions to resist behavior they believe Scripture prohibits. Her attention to both church cruelty and cultural pressure also prevents the story from becoming a simple tale of individual discipline. Community can provide support, but it can also create shame or impose expectations.

The argument is not a neutral survey of Christian sexual ethics. Its conclusions depend on Gilson's interpretation of Scripture, particularly her claim that sex difference is essential to marriage's symbolic meaning. Readers who do not share that interpretation may not find the analogy persuasive, even if they value her emphasis on care, honesty, and belonging. The personal stories offer evidence of possibility, not prediction: one person's marriage, singleness, or attraction change cannot determine another's future.

The book's ethical challenge is therefore two-sided. It asks readers not to treat desire as a complete moral compass, and it asks churches not to confuse moral conviction with permission to shame, isolate, or coerce. Its strongest practical vision is a community where people can speak honestly, receive support, admit failure, and remain more than the issue that brought them through the door.

Summary in 30 Seconds
Attraction can remain unchanged after conversion, so faithfulness is not measured by becoming heterosexual. Christian sexual ethics, in this account, rests on a broader biblical vision of sex, marriage, and spiritual kinship. Churches should offer honest friendship, care, and restoration without shame or pressure to change. Marriage requires candid motives and expectations, while singleness can be a meaningful calling that does not erase loneliness. Attraction matters, but need not define a person's whole identity.
Contains spoilers

Last updated:

Report Issue

Review Summary

4.47 out of 5
Average of 1k+ ratings from Goodreads and Amazon.

Born Again This Way receives mostly positive reviews for its biblical approach to same-sex attraction. Readers appreciate Gilson's honesty, theological depth, and compassionate tone. Many find it helpful for Christians experiencing same-sex attraction and those seeking to understand the issue. The book is praised for its gospel-centered perspective and practical wisdom. Some readers note its focus on female experiences, while a few disagree with certain theological points. Overall, it's recommended as a valuable resource for Christians grappling with sexuality and faith.

Your rating:
4.69
127 ratings
Want to read the full book?

Glossary

epithumia

Desire, especially sinful desire

A Greek word used in the New Testament for desire. Its meaning depends on context: it can describe a desire for something good or something sinful. In her discussion of James, Gilson interprets it as a desire that entices a person toward sin, and uses the term to explain temptation without treating changed attraction as the measure of spiritual growth.

Sexual Fluidity

Changing patterns of attraction or labels

The term used in Lisa Diamond's book and study, which Gilson describes as following 100 women over ten years. The research examined women's reported attractions and the labels they used for themselves. As presented in this book, some participants changed labels, often choosing broader or no labels. Gilson uses the study to show that identity language and attraction patterns can vary, not to promise change for any individual.

reparative therapy

An effort to create heterosexuality

A therapeutic or ministry approach discussed by Gilson that aims to produce heterosexual attraction in people with same-sex attraction. She rejects its promise that heterosexuality is the required sign of spiritual change, arguing that Scripture does not make such a promise. The book distinguishes seeking faithfulness in conduct from trying to manufacture a different pattern of attraction.

FAQ

What’s "Born Again This Way" by Rachel Gilson about?

  • Personal journey of faith: The book is Rachel Gilson’s memoir of coming out as same-sex attracted, her unexpected conversion to Christianity, and her ongoing journey of faith.
  • Navigating sexuality and belief: It explores the tension between her sexual orientation and the traditional Christian sexual ethic, offering a candid look at her struggles and choices.
  • Scriptural engagement: Gilson grounds her story in biblical teaching, aiming to show how Scripture speaks to issues of sexuality, identity, and discipleship.
  • Broader application: While focused on same-sex attraction, the book addresses universal Christian themes of obedience, trust, and finding identity in Christ.

Why should I read "Born Again This Way" by Rachel Gilson?

  • Unique perspective: Gilson offers a rare, honest account of being both same-sex attracted and a committed evangelical Christian, a voice often missing in the conversation.
  • Compassionate and practical: The book is praised for its pastoral tone, theological depth, and practical advice for those wrestling with sexuality and faith.
  • Encouragement for many: It’s written for same-sex-attracted Christians, their loved ones, and anyone seeking to understand the intersection of faith and sexuality.
  • Scriptural focus: Readers will find a strong emphasis on the sufficiency and goodness of Scripture, making it valuable for personal growth and church ministry.

What are the key takeaways of "Born Again This Way"?

  • Jesus is worth everything: Gilson’s central message is that Christ is more beautiful and satisfying than romance, sex, or any other earthly desire.
  • Obedience before understanding: She emphasizes trusting God’s commands even when they don’t make sense, drawing parallels to the Garden of Eden.
  • Holiness over heterosexuality: The goal for same-sex-attracted Christians is not to become straight, but to pursue faithfulness and holiness in Christ.
  • The church as family: Gilson highlights the importance of Christian community, friendship, and spiritual family for all believers, especially singles and those with same-sex attraction.

How does Rachel Gilson define and address same-sex attraction in "Born Again This Way"?

  • Not chosen, but real: Gilson describes her same-sex attraction as unchosen and persistent, but not the defining feature of her identity.
  • Desire vs. action: She distinguishes between experiencing same-sex attraction (desire) and acting on it, emphasizing that temptation itself is not sin, but acting on it is.
  • Biblical framework: The book consistently refers to Scripture’s teaching that same-sex sexual relationships are outside God’s design, but that all Christians battle sinful desires.
  • Compassion and clarity: Gilson offers both empathy for those who struggle and clear guidance on resisting temptation and living faithfully.

What is Rachel Gilson’s advice for Christians experiencing same-sex attraction?

  • Trust God’s goodness: She encourages believers to trust God’s character and commands, even when they feel counterintuitive or painful.
  • Pursue community: Gilson stresses the need for honest, supportive Christian friendships and church family, rather than isolation.
  • Focus on faithfulness: The goal is not to become straight, but to say “no” to sinful desires and “yes” to Christ, relying on the Holy Spirit’s power.
  • Seek accountability and support: She recommends confession, accountability, and practical steps to avoid temptation, while rejecting shame and secrecy.

How does "Born Again This Way" by Rachel Gilson address the question: “Do I have to become straight to be a faithful Christian?”

  • Holiness, not heterosexuality: Gilson argues that the Bible never commands same-sex-attracted Christians to become straight, but to pursue holiness and obedience.
  • Temptation may persist: She acknowledges that many believers never experience a change in their attractions, but can still live faithfully.
  • Crucify sinful desires: The focus is on resisting and “crucifying” sinful desires, not on changing orientation.
  • God’s power is sufficient: Gilson assures readers that God provides the strength to say no to temptation, regardless of whether attractions change.

What does "Born Again This Way" say about identity and labels like “gay Christian” or “same-sex-attracted Christian”?

  • Primary identity in Christ: Gilson insists that a Christian’s core identity is being “in Christ,” not in their sexual orientation or attractions.
  • Language matters: She discusses the pros and cons of labels like “gay Christian” and “same-sex-attracted Christian,” urging caution and charity in language choices.
  • Acknowledging reality: While not denying the reality of same-sex attraction, she warns against making it the central truth about oneself.
  • Unity and witness: Gilson encourages language that promotes unity in the church and helps believers fight sin and love Jesus more deeply.

How does Rachel Gilson describe the role of friendship and community for same-sex-attracted Christians in "Born Again This Way"?

  • Church as true family: Gilson elevates the biblical vision of the church as a spiritual family, offering belonging and intimacy beyond biological ties.
  • Value of same-sex friendships: She affirms the goodness of deep, non-romantic same-sex friendships, while warning against unhealthy emotional dependency or romanticization.
  • Sibling language: The book advocates for reclaiming “sibling” language in the church to foster chaste, affectionate, and supportive relationships.
  • Accountability and boundaries: Gilson provides practical advice on navigating attraction within friendships, including honesty, accountability, and sometimes setting boundaries.

What does "Born Again This Way" teach about marriage and celibacy for same-sex-attracted Christians?

  • Marriage is possible, not required: Gilson shares her own story of marrying a man, but clarifies that marriage is not the goal or reward for faithfulness.
  • Celibacy as a calling: She affirms the dignity and value of celibacy, drawing on biblical examples and the promise of spiritual family and fruitfulness.
  • Realistic expectations: The book warns against entering marriage to “fix” one’s attractions or to prove faithfulness, and encourages discernment and honesty.
  • Both paths are honored: Gilson emphasizes that both marriage and singleness can be faithful, fruitful ways to serve God.

How does "Born Again This Way" by Rachel Gilson address the church’s role in supporting same-sex-attracted believers?

  • Compassion and truth: Gilson calls the church to offer both grace and truth, avoiding both harshness and revisionism regarding biblical sexuality.
  • Avoiding extra burdens: She warns against adding to God’s word by demanding heterosexuality or treating same-sex-attracted believers as second-class.
  • Creating safe spaces: The book urges churches to be places where people can honestly share their struggles and receive support, not shame or exclusion.
  • Equipping for ministry: Gilson highlights the unique witness and ministry that same-sex-attracted Christians can offer the church and the world.

What are the best quotes from "Born Again This Way" by Rachel Gilson and what do they mean?

  • “Jesus is the best lover.” – Emphasizes that Christ’s love surpasses all human romance or sexual fulfillment.
  • “Holiness does not equal heterosexuality.” – Reminds readers that the Christian life is about faithfulness, not changing one’s orientation.
  • “We are free to use our bodies as the good gifts they are designed by their Creator to be.” – Encourages stewardship of sexuality in line with God’s design.
  • “You only give up something awesome for something even better.” – Highlights the cost and reward of following Jesus over personal desires.

What practical steps and methods does Rachel Gilson recommend in "Born Again This Way" for living faithfully as a same-sex-attracted Christian?

  • Root yourself in Scripture: Gilson urges regular engagement with the Bible to understand God’s design and find strength for obedience.
  • Build honest relationships: She recommends seeking out trustworthy friends, mentors, and church family for support and accountability.
  • Practice confession and repentance: Regularly confessing struggles and failures, and receiving forgiveness, is key to spiritual health.
  • Embrace your purpose: Gilson encourages believers to see their unique story as a means to serve others, witness to Christ, and glorify God.

About the Author

Rachel Gilson is a Christian author and speaker who serves on the leadership team of Theological Development and Culture with Cru. She holds a Master of Divinity from Gordon-Conwell Theological Seminary and lives in the Boston area with her family. Gilson's writing has been featured in prominent Christian publications such as Christianity Today, Desiring God, and The Gospel Coalition. She regularly speaks at churches and college campuses, addressing topics related to faith, sexuality, and Christian living. Her work focuses on helping individuals navigate the intersection of same-sex attraction and Christian faith, drawing from her personal experiences and biblical understanding.

Download PDF

To save this Born Again This Way summary for later, download the free PDF. You can print it out, or read offline at your convenience.
Download PDF
File size: 0.35 MB     Pages: 18

Download EPUB

To read this Born Again This Way summary on your e-reader device or app, download the free EPUB. The .epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.
Download EPUB
File size: 1.41 MB     Pages: 23
Want to read the full book?
Follow
Listen
Home
Swipe
Library
Get App
Try Full Access for 3 Days
Listen, bookmark, and more
Compare Features Free Pro
📖 Read Summaries
Read unlimited summaries. Free users get 3 per month
🎧 Listen to Summaries
Listen to unlimited summaries in 40 languages
—
❤️ Unlimited Bookmarks
Free users are limited to 4
—
📜 Unlimited History
Free users are limited to 4
—
📥 Unlimited Downloads
Free users are limited to 1
—
Risk-Free Timeline
Today: Get Instant Access
Listen to full summaries of 26,000+ books. That's 12,000+ hours of audio!
Day 2: Trial Reminder
We'll send you a notification that your trial is ending soon.
Day 3: Your subscription begins
You'll be charged on Nov 25,
cancel anytime before.
Consume 2.8× More Books
2.8× more books Listening Reading
Our users love us
1M+ readers
Trustpilot Rating
TrustPilot
4.6 Excellent
This site is a total game-changer. I've been flying through book summaries like never before. Highly, highly recommend.
— Dave G
Worth my money and time, and really well made. I've never seen this quality of summaries on other websites. Very helpful!
— Em
Highly recommended!! Fantastic service. Perfect for those that want a little more than a teaser but not all the intricate details of a full audio book.
— Greg M
Save 62%
Yearly
$119.88 $44.99/year/yr
$3.75/mo
Monthly
$9.99/mo
Start a 3-Day Free Trial
3 days free, then $44.99/year. Cancel anytime.
Unlock a world of fiction & nonfiction books
26,000+ books for the price of 2 books
Read any book in 10 minutes
Discover new books like Tinder
Request any book if it's not summarized
Read more books than anyone you know
#1 app for book lovers
Lifelike & immersive summaries
30-day money-back guarantee
Download summaries in EPUBs or PDFs
Cancel anytime in a few clicks

Why one summary?

Scanner
Find a barcode to scan

⭐
⭐
⭐
We have a special gift for you
Open
38% off
DISCOUNT FOR YOU
⭐
⭐
⭐
$79.99
$49.99/year
Only $4.16 per month
Continue
2 taps to start, super easy to cancel
Settings
General
Widget
Loading...