Plot Summary
Treehouse Blood Oath
Luna Rexroth and Knight Cole, neighbors and best friends, forge a deep connection in their childhood, sharing a treehouse sanctuary and a blood oath: "Ride or Die." Luna, selectively mute after her mother's abandonment, finds solace in Knight's fierce loyalty and humor. Knight, struggling with his mother's illness and his own anger, is comforted by Luna's presence. Their friendship is marked by silent understanding, shared pain, and a promise to always be there for each other, no matter what. This chapter sets the foundation for a love story built on trauma, protection, and the unspoken language of two broken souls growing up side by side.
Moonshine and the Knight
As Luna and Knight enter adolescence, their bond deepens but also complicates. Luna's silence becomes her shield, while Knight's popularity and charm mask his inner turmoil. Both are haunted by absent mothers—Luna's by choice, Knight's by illness. Their friendship is tested by jealousy, misunderstandings, and the pressures of high school. Knight's protectiveness sometimes suffocates Luna, while Luna's inability to express her feelings leaves Knight frustrated. The treehouse remains their refuge, but cracks begin to show as they struggle to define what they mean to each other beyond childhood promises.
Broken Promises, Silent Words
Knight's feelings for Luna intensify, but every attempt to move their relationship beyond friendship ends in heartbreak. Three failed kisses, each more painful than the last, leave both wounded. Luna's fear of vulnerability and Knight's growing resentment create a chasm between them. Luna watches Knight with other girls, consumed by jealousy she cannot voice. Knight, desperate for Luna's affection, acts out with reckless behavior. Their inability to communicate honestly leads to misunderstandings, missed opportunities, and a growing sense that their love story is doomed before it begins.
Kisses, Slaps, and Distance
A drunken confrontation at a party leads to Luna slapping Knight, shattering their fragile connection. Hurt and humiliated, Knight retaliates by flaunting his relationships with other girls, while Luna withdraws further into herself. The slap becomes a symbol of their mutual pain and inability to bridge the gap between them. When Luna chooses to attend college out of state, both are left reeling. The physical distance mirrors the emotional distance that has grown between them, and both struggle to move on, haunted by what could have been.
Ride or Die Fractures
Luna's move to Boon College is both an escape and a test. She is forced to confront her fears, make new friends, and navigate life without Knight's constant presence. Knight, left behind, spirals into substance abuse and self-destruction, unable to cope with Luna's absence. Both try to fill the void with new relationships—Luna with Josh, a kindred spirit who understands her silence, and Knight with Poppy, a sweet but ultimately wrong fit. Their attempts to move on only highlight how deeply they are still entangled, and how unfinished their story remains.
College, Choices, and Jealousy
At Boon, Luna experiments with independence and intimacy, losing her virginity to Josh in a moment of heartbreak over Knight. Meanwhile, Knight's relationship with Poppy is a hollow attempt to replace Luna. Social media, rumors, and well-meaning friends only complicate matters, fueling jealousy and misunderstandings. Both are haunted by the choices they've made and the people they've hurt. The pain of watching each other with someone else becomes unbearable, forcing them to confront the reality that moving on is not as simple as finding a new partner.
New Beginnings, Old Wounds
Thanksgiving brings Luna and Knight face to face, their unresolved feelings erupting in a public confrontation. Knight's anger over Luna's relationship with Josh leads to a cruel outburst, while Luna's guilt and shame over her choices leave her feeling exposed and alone. Family dynamics, grief, and the weight of the past press in on both of them. Attempts at reconciliation are thwarted by pride, pain, and the fear of being hurt again. The cycle of breaking and mending continues, with neither willing to fully let go or fully commit.
The Other Boy, The Other Girl
As Luna and Knight try to navigate friendship, jealousy flares when Luna kisses Vaughn and Knight nearly sleeps with Poppy. Both are desperate to prove they can move on, but their actions only deepen the wounds. Luna's struggle to find her voice—literally and figuratively—culminates in a breakthrough argument where she finally speaks to Knight, confessing her pain and anger. Knight, in turn, reveals the truth about his own virginity and the lies he's told to protect himself. Their confessions lay bare the depth of their love and the damage they've done to each other.
Shattered Trust, Shaky Hearts
Knight's mother's illness worsens, sending him into a downward spiral of drinking and pills. Luna, now able to speak, tries to support him but is met with resistance and cruelty. The loss of Knight's mother is a devastating blow, leaving him unmoored and desperate. Luna's attempts to save him are met with anger and rejection, forcing her to make the painful decision to step back. Both are forced to confront their own demons—Knight with his addiction, Luna with her guilt and fear of abandonment. The path to healing seems impossible, and both are left wondering if love is enough.
Family, Grief, and Goodbye
Rosie's death brings the entire community together in grief, but also exposes the fractures in Knight and Luna's relationship. Luna fulfills Rosie's final wish by speaking at her funeral, sharing memories and lessons that help the family begin to heal. Knight, struggling with sobriety and the loss of his anchor, is forced to reckon with his own pain and the ways he's hurt those around him. The presence of his birth mother, Dixie, adds another layer of complexity, challenging Knight to redefine what family means. In the aftermath of loss, both must decide what kind of future they want—and whether they can build it together.
Spirals and Second Chances
With the support of friends, family, and Dixie, Knight begins the difficult journey of sobriety. Luna, having found her voice and her strength, sets boundaries and demands more from Knight and from herself. Both are changed by their experiences—wiser, more compassionate, and more willing to fight for what they want. Apologies are made, old wounds are tended, and the possibility of a second chance emerges. The process is messy and imperfect, but both are committed to doing the hard work of healing and rebuilding trust.
The Price of Forgiveness
Knight's public proposal to Luna is both a declaration of love and a vow to stay sober. Luna, having learned to stand up for herself, accepts on her own terms, insisting they build a life together in the place where their story began. Their engagement is a celebration not just of their love, but of their survival—of everything they've endured and overcome. The support of their families, the memory of Rosie, and the lessons of the past guide them as they step into a new chapter, determined to honor their promises to each other.
Sober Vows, Spoken Love
Knight and Luna's journey toward marriage is marked by continued challenges—sobriety, grief, and the demands of adulthood—but also by joy, laughter, and the deep comfort of being truly seen and loved. Luna's newfound voice becomes a symbol of her transformation, while Knight's sobriety is a daily act of devotion. Together, they learn that love is not about perfection, but about choosing each other every day, even when it's hard. Their wedding is both an ending and a beginning—a promise to ride or die, always.
Ride or Die, Always
As Knight and Luna build their life together, they honor the legacy of those they've lost and the lessons they've learned. The birth of their child is a testament to their resilience and hope. Surrounded by friends, family, and the memory of Rosie, they create a home filled with laughter, love, and second chances. The story comes full circle as Luna, once silent and afraid, stands before an audience, sharing her story and her voice with the world. Their love, forged in pain and tested by time, endures—ride or die, always.
Full Circle, New Sun
The final chapter finds Knight and Luna at peace, having weathered the storms of their youth and emerged stronger for it. Their journey from broken children to whole adults is complete, but their story is far from over. With a new generation on the way, they look to the future with hope and gratitude, knowing that the sun will always rise, no matter how dark the night. Their love, once fractured and fragile, is now unbreakable—a beacon for all the Lunas and Knights still searching for their own ride or die.
Characters
Luna Rexroth
Luna is the emotional core of the story—a girl marked by her mother's abandonment and her own selective mutism. Her silence is both a shield and a prison, isolating her from the world but also making her deeply observant and empathetic. Luna's journey is one of self-discovery and empowerment: she learns to find her voice, set boundaries, and demand the love she deserves. Her relationship with Knight is both her greatest comfort and her deepest source of pain, as she struggles to reconcile her fear of vulnerability with her longing for connection. Luna's growth is gradual and hard-won, culminating in her ability to speak her truth and claim her happiness.
Knight Cole
Knight is the quintessential golden boy with a broken core—handsome, athletic, and adored, but haunted by his mother's illness and his own feelings of inadequacy. His love for Luna is obsessive and all-consuming, driving him to both protect and hurt her. Knight's struggles with anger, addiction, and grief are central to his arc; he is both a savior and a saboteur, desperate for love but terrified of loss. His journey toward sobriety and self-acceptance is fraught with setbacks, but ultimately, he learns that true strength lies in vulnerability and forgiveness. Knight's evolution from reckless boy to devoted partner is the heart of the novel's emotional arc.
Rosie LeBlanc-Cole
Rosie is Knight's adoptive mother and a pillar of strength for both families. Her battle with cystic fibrosis shapes much of the narrative, casting a shadow over Knight's life and influencing his choices. Rosie's wisdom, humor, and unconditional love provide a moral compass for the younger characters. Even in death, her legacy endures—her final wishes, letters, and lessons guiding Knight, Luna, and their families toward healing. Rosie's acceptance of her fate and her insistence on living fully inspire those around her to cherish every moment and fight for happiness.
Trent Rexroth
Luna's father, Trent, is a man of few words but deep devotion. His own history of abandonment and struggle informs his parenting, making him fiercely protective of Luna while also respecting her autonomy. Trent's relationship with Edie, his second wife, is a model of blended family love and resilience. He supports Luna through her mutism, heartbreak, and eventual transformation, offering quiet guidance and unwavering support. Trent's presence is a stabilizing force in a world often defined by chaos and loss.
Edie Rexroth
Edie is Luna's stepmother and a source of warmth and understanding. She bridges the gap between Luna and the world, encouraging her to take risks, make mistakes, and embrace her own worth. Edie's love is patient and unconditional, helping Luna heal from the wounds of her biological mother's abandonment. Her partnership with Trent and her nurturing of both Luna and her half-brother Racer exemplify the power of chosen family. Edie's wisdom and kindness are instrumental in Luna's journey toward self-acceptance.
Vaughn Spencer
Vaughn is Knight's best friend and Luna's confidant—a brooding artist with a sharp tongue and a hidden heart. His own family dysfunction makes him wary of intimacy, but his loyalty to Knight and Luna is unwavering. Vaughn's interventions, though often harsh, are motivated by a desire to see his friends grow and heal. His own romantic subplot with Lenora Astalis adds depth to his character, revealing a capacity for vulnerability beneath his tough exterior. Vaughn's presence challenges both Knight and Luna to confront uncomfortable truths and make difficult choices.
Poppy Astalis
Poppy is Knight's brief girlfriend—a kind, artistic girl who represents the possibility of a simpler, less complicated love. Her relationship with Knight is ultimately doomed by his unresolved feelings for Luna, but Poppy's grace and dignity in the face of heartbreak highlight her strength. She serves as a mirror for Luna, forcing her to confront her own jealousy and the consequences of her choices. Poppy's ability to move on and find happiness elsewhere underscores the novel's theme of resilience and self-worth.
Josh Cooper
Josh is Luna's college friend and brief romantic interest—a mute young man who understands her struggles with communication and isolation. His kindness and patience offer Luna a glimpse of what a healthy, supportive relationship could look like. Though their connection is ultimately not enough to overcome Luna's feelings for Knight, Josh's presence is a catalyst for her growth. He helps Luna find her voice, both literally and metaphorically, and his forgiveness and understanding allow her to move forward without regret.
Dixie Jones
Dixie is Knight's biological mother, whose reappearance complicates his grief and sense of identity. Initially resented for her abandonment, Dixie proves herself through quiet persistence, selflessness, and a willingness to support Knight from the sidelines. Her relationship with Rosie, Knight's adoptive mother, is marked by mutual respect and a shared love for the boy they both claim. Dixie's journey from outsider to family member is a testament to the power of forgiveness and the possibility of redemption.
Dean Cole
Dean is Knight's adoptive father and Rosie's devoted husband. His struggle to cope with Rosie's illness and death is raw and unflinching, revealing the depths of his love and the pain of loss. Dean's efforts to hold his family together, support Knight's recovery, and honor Rosie's legacy are central to the novel's exploration of grief and healing. His eventual openness to new connections, including with Dixie, suggests that love can endure and evolve even in the face of unimaginable loss.
Plot Devices
Dual Narration and Time Jumps
The novel employs a dual narrative structure, alternating between Luna and Knight's points of view. This allows readers to experience the story from both sides, deepening empathy and understanding. Time jumps—from childhood to adolescence to adulthood—highlight the evolution of their relationship and the impact of past traumas on present choices. The use of flashbacks, letters, and memories creates a rich tapestry of interconnected moments, emphasizing the cyclical nature of love, loss, and healing.
Selective Mutism as Metaphor
Luna's selective mutism is more than a character trait—it is a central metaphor for the ways trauma can silence us, and the courage required to reclaim one's voice. Her journey from silence to speech mirrors the emotional arc of the novel, with each breakthrough marking a step toward healing and self-acceptance. The act of speaking—especially in moments of crisis or love—becomes a powerful symbol of agency and transformation.
Ride or Die Oath
The "ride or die" oath, made in childhood and revisited throughout the novel, serves as both a promise and a curse. It binds Luna and Knight together, even as life pulls them apart. The phrase recurs at pivotal moments—during fights, reconciliations, and declarations of love—reminding both characters (and readers) of the stakes of their relationship. The oath's evolution—from innocent pledge to hard-won vow—mirrors the maturation of their love.
Parallel Family Dynamics
Both Luna and Knight are shaped by absent mothers and complex family structures. The novel draws parallels between their experiences, exploring themes of abandonment, adoption, and chosen family. The presence of strong stepmothers (Edie and Rosie), supportive fathers, and loyal friends underscores the idea that family is not defined by blood alone. The intergenerational bonds and legacies—especially Rosie's influence—add depth and resonance to the story.
Addiction and Recovery Arc
Knight's struggle with addiction is depicted with unflinching honesty, serving as both a personal battle and a metaphor for the destructive power of unresolved pain. His journey from denial to acceptance, relapse to recovery, is marked by setbacks and hard choices. The support of loved ones, the consequences of his actions, and the promise of a better future drive his transformation. The recovery arc is intertwined with the love story, emphasizing that healing is both an individual and collective effort.
Public Declarations and Grand Gestures
The novel makes frequent use of public declarations—proposals, speeches, confrontations—to heighten emotional stakes and force characters to confront their feelings. These moments serve as turning points, pushing characters out of their comfort zones and into vulnerability. The use of social media, rumors, and community scrutiny adds pressure and urgency, making private struggles unavoidably public.
Analysis
Broken Knight is a raw, emotionally charged exploration of love's power to both wound and heal. At its core, the novel is about two broken people—shaped by abandonment, grief, and silence—who must learn to find their voices, forgive themselves and each other, and choose love in the face of pain. The story refuses easy answers: love is not a cure-all, and healing is messy, nonlinear, and often incomplete. The novel's modern relevance lies in its unflinching portrayal of mental health struggles, addiction, and the complexities of blended families. It challenges the myth of the "perfect" love story, insisting instead that true intimacy requires honesty, vulnerability, and the willingness to fight for happiness. The lessons are clear: trauma does not define us, silence can be broken, and even the most shattered hearts can find their way home—if we are brave enough to speak, to listen, and to love, ride or die.
Last updated:
