Key Takeaways
Rebuild bipartisan field position before asking Washington for environmental victories
A proven compromise. In 1990, Republican President George H. W. Bush signed a Clean Air Act that cut acid-rain pollution through a market-based cap-and-trade system. The law passed with 89 Senate votes and a 401 to 21 House vote. Its emissions reductions were substantial, while actual industry costs proved far below early estimates. The book cites benefits estimated at roughly eight times those costs.
Politics is the playing field. Frederic Rich calls his alternative Center Green: a pragmatic approach that asks whether a proposal would meaningfully address an environmental problem and whether it can win political support. He contrasts the 1990 law with the Keystone XL fight, which he sees as a high-profile symbolic battle with little direct environmental effect.
The acid-rain example shows that policy design can make environmental protection compatible with economic incentives, rather than treating the two as automatic enemies. It also illustrates a useful distinction between a policy's technical quality and its political durability. A rule that works but cannot survive changes in government may deliver less than a modest measure with lasting support. Still, feasibility is not a complete measure of merit: powerful interests can make necessary reforms seem politically impossible. Center Green's test is strongest when political realism guides action without becoming an excuse to accept too little.
Treat polarization as a political strategy, not an unchangeable public mood
A widening divide. Rich calls the split between conservatives hostile to environmental policy and a Green movement often seen as hostile to business the Great Estrangement. The divide grew sharply after the 1990s. Pew polling cited in the book shows the gap between Republicans and Democrats on environmental regulation rising from 5 percentage points in 1987 to 39 in 2012.
Issues changed, too. In the 1970s, burning rivers, visible smog, and fouled drinking water made environmental problems local and obvious. Later priorities, including climate change and biodiversity loss, depended on complex science and predictions about distant impacts. Rich argues that political leaders helped make environmental skepticism a party marker, while the movement's own leftward drift made conservatives feel unwelcome.
The argument usefully separates voter attitudes from elite incentives. Once party leaders and media repeatedly signal which beliefs define membership, people can adopt positions as expressions of belonging, not simply conclusions drawn from evidence. That helps explain why presenting more facts may fail to move a debate. Yet political signaling is only part of the story: material interests, regional economies, and different levels of trust in government also shape views. A strategy that treats skepticism solely as identity may overlook legitimate concerns about who pays, who benefits, and whether rules are enforced fairly.
Make conservative stewardship a living principle, not a partisan relic
Conservation has conservative roots. George Perkins Marsh warned in the nineteenth century that transforming the landscape created responsibilities to the public and to future generations. Theodore Roosevelt later protected vast areas of forest and wildlife habitat, while Richard Nixon backed major environmental laws and created the EPA. Rich uses this history not to claim ownership of conservation for one party, but to challenge the idea that environmental care is inherently liberal.
Freedom brings obligations. In Rich's account, principled conservatism values continuity, prudence, personal responsibility, and limits on appetite. Those commitments can support conservation: property rights and economic freedom do not include permission to harm neighbors or pass environmental costs to descendants. This differs from programmatic conservatism, which treats fixed policy positions as tests of ideological loyalty.
The appeal to a political tradition can make an unfamiliar policy feel continuous with an audience's deeper commitments. That is often more persuasive than asking people to abandon their identity before they can consider a new argument. Intergenerational responsibility also gives environmental policy a clear moral structure: present benefits are weighed against future burdens. The limitation is that traditions are internally contested. The same conservative language of local control or property rights can support stewardship, but can also resist collective rules. Historical examples open a door; they do not settle the policy debate.
Put people inside nature, and give conservation more than one moral case
Replace the false divide. Rich argues against presenting nature as a realm separate from human life, or insisting that it deserves protection only for its own sake. His alternative is the gardener: people are part of a changing natural system, yet have unusual power to alter it and a responsibility to care for the places they inhabit. The book notes that human activity has affected 83 percent of Earth's surface, making a purely untouched-wilderness model insufficient.
Use several reasons. Conservation can protect human health and economic resources, express moral responsibility, preserve beauty and beloved places, and contribute to happiness. The example of Kirtland's warbler shows why nature should not be treated as static: suppressing fires harmed its habitat, while carefully restoring the fire cycle helped the bird recover.
This approach makes environmental responsibility concrete without reducing every natural place to a price tag. It also resembles care ethics, which emphasizes relationships and obligations formed through sustained attention to particular people and places. The gardener image leaves room for humility because stewardship means acting despite incomplete knowledge, not claiming mastery. A people-centered case, however, can still sideline species or habitats with no obvious human benefit. The strongest version combines human dependence with a moral willingness to protect life whose value exceeds its immediate usefulness.
Trade environmental purity for credible progress and public trust
Earn credibility. Rich urges environmental organizations to state facts accurately, admit uncertainty, and avoid predictions designed mainly to frighten. He recounts a scientist's objection to an environmental advertisement predicting a salmon's extinction by a particular year, despite evidence the scientist considered inconsistent with that claim. Such exaggeration can damage trust even when the underlying environmental concern is real.
Make progress appealing. The book's proposed Decalogue for Green Groups also calls for hopeful visions, compromise, incremental gains, acceptance of economic growth and capitalism, constructive business partnerships, focused missions, grassroots engagement, and attention to cities. The point is not to abandon environmental standards, but to stop treating the ideal policy as more valuable than a meaningful improvement that can actually be adopted.
Trust is a strategic asset: audiences who believe an organization is candid are more likely to hear difficult warnings and tolerate uncertainty. A positive account of what has improved can also make collective action feel effective rather than futile. But accuracy should not be confused with artificial balance, and compromise should not be praised simply because it is bipartisan. Some compromises distribute costs unfairly or lock in avoidable harm. The useful discipline is to disclose evidence and tradeoffs plainly, then judge a deal by its consequences, not by whether it preserves an organization's sense of purity.
Copy land trusts: local ownership can turn conservation into bipartisan action
A practical model. Between 1980 and 2010, land conservation groups protected about 50 million acres, while the number of land trusts grew to roughly 1,700. Their work often centers on places people know directly: farms, forests, watersheds, and community gardens. Supporters can join for different reasons, from wildlife habitat to local character, without signing on to one comprehensive political program.
A flexible property tool. A conservation easement transfers a specific land-use right, often the right to develop, to a land trust while the owner keeps the land and its other uses. Local organizations build community support, then coordinate through networks such as the Land Trust Alliance to influence national policy. Rich argues that this combination of local trust, voluntary agreements, and broad participation helps explain their bipartisan success.
Land trusts illustrate a form of polycentric governance: local groups make decisions suited to local conditions, while networks coordinate action across a wider area. That can build legitimacy and preserve room for diverse motivations. The model also shows that environmental organizing need not begin with agreement on every cause or policy. Its limits matter, though. Voluntary conservation depends on willing landowners and available funding, so it cannot substitute for public safeguards where harms cross property lines or affect communities with less political power. Local initiative and public regulation can be complements.
Treat climate uncertainty as a reason to manage risk, not freeze
Separate what is known. Rich accepts that human activity contributes to climate change while emphasizing uncertainty about the pace and local effects of warming. He argues that uncertainty about the scale of harm is not proof that no harm exists. The precautionary principle, in this context, means taking reasonable steps against serious risks before every causal detail is settled.
Start where action is possible. Rich doubts that international agreements alone can deliver durable reductions without domestic political support. He favors a mix of achievable measures, including state and regional programs, emissions rules where market tools cannot pass, research investment, and adaptation. Preparing communities for effects such as sea-level rise can make an abstract global threat locally visible, while emissions reductions and technological innovation help limit future risk.
Risk management is a productive bridge between scientific uncertainty and public decision-making. It asks not only what outcome is most likely, but how costly the worst outcomes would be and what prevention is worth paying for. That logic is familiar in fields such as public health and insurance. It still needs explicit rules for comparing costs, probabilities, and unequal exposure. Adaptation can protect communities, but those with fewer resources may be least able to prepare. A credible climate strategy therefore pairs resilience with mitigation and pays attention to who receives protection.
Choose energy fights by measurable harm, not symbolic heat
Regulate the real risks. Rich's Center Green position accepts that fracking is not going away and that natural gas produces substantially less carbon dioxide per unit of energy than coal. Rather than demand a blanket ban, he argues for stronger safeguards: sound well casings, control of methane leaks, proper wastewater treatment, scrutiny of earthquake risks, and limits on drilling near sensitive lands and water supplies.
Rank the battles. Rich criticizes the Keystone XL campaign because he believes the tar-sands oil would reach markets by other routes and the pipeline's added emissions would be small in global terms. In his account, opposition made the project a symbolic test of climate commitment while oil moved by rail, which he regards as a greater safety risk. The broader lesson is to spend political effort where it can reduce harm.
The distinction between banning a technology and governing its worst practices is valuable when societies depend on energy systems that cannot be replaced overnight. It directs attention toward standards, monitoring, and enforcement, where concrete improvements may be available. The book's argument also properly asks whether a campaign changes the underlying emissions or mainly signals allegiance. Still, infrastructure risk and climate impact are not the only relevant measures: communities may reasonably oppose projects because of land use, water, or consent. A strong priority test should include local harms as well as global carbon effects.
Join a local group, then carry its concerns into politics
Build relationships first. Rich argues that environmental support is broad but often shallow. People may recycle or say they care about nature without treating environmental issues as a voting priority. He urges readers to join an in-person local organization, such as a gardening club, land trust, or birding group, rather than limiting participation to online sign-ups and donations.
Turn attachment into influence. Local groups connect environmental concerns to places people know, then can coordinate with other organizations and bring informed citizens to public meetings and elected officials. This is not a substitute for personal conservation habits; it is a recognition that laws and public institutions shape environmental outcomes too. Rich also urges environmental groups to treat cities as essential habitats and political communities, not as the opposite of nature.
Face-to-face groups can create the trust and shared identity that make sustained civic participation possible. They also help translate broad claims into questions residents can investigate and discuss with local decision-makers. A network of such groups can combine local knowledge with wider coordination. The danger is that local engagement can become narrow or exclusionary, especially when established residents dominate the conversation. Effective grassroots work therefore needs open participation and links to broader ecological and social concerns. Local attachment is a starting point for political action, not a guarantee that the resulting policy serves everyone.
Analysis
Getting to Green is less a conventional environmental argument than a diagnosis of political failure. Its central move is to redirect attention from the size of ecological goals to the political relationships needed to reach them. Rich frames the environmental movement's loss of bipartisan support as historically contingent, not inevitable, and treats communication, organizational design, and political identity as part of environmental policy rather than as packaging around it.
The book's strongest contribution is its insistence that environmental coalitions do not require a single motive. A landowner may care about a working farm, a hunter about habitat, and an urban resident about clean water or neighborhood green space. If each can support a practical conservation measure without adopting an entire ideological program, the coalition can become broader and more durable. This pluralism also helps explain why local land trusts can succeed where national campaigns struggle.
Its pragmatic test, meaningful environmental benefit plus political feasibility, is memorable and useful. It counters the recurring trap of pursuing an ideal solution while achievable improvements expire in legislative gridlock. The proposed people-centered ethic, combining health, responsibility, place, beauty, and economic value, also avoids reducing conservation either to market price or to a claim that human interests do not matter.
The argument is less complete when political feasibility is treated as a neutral filter. Feasibility is shaped by money, institutional veto points, and whose losses count. A narrowly bipartisan compromise can preserve unequal exposure to pollution or defer costs to people with little influence. Likewise, a shift toward local action cannot by itself govern cumulative, cross-border risks such as greenhouse emissions. These are not reasons to reject Rich's strategy. They are reasons to pair coalition-building with clear standards for fairness, ecological adequacy, and accountability. Center Green is most persuasive as a method for widening participation and securing durable steps, not as a promise that consensus will resolve every conflict or deliver sufficient action on its own.
Review Summary
Getting to Green receives mostly positive reviews for its balanced approach to environmental issues and bipartisan solutions. Readers appreciate Rich's historical perspective, pragmatic suggestions, and call for a more inclusive environmental movement. Many found it insightful and compelling, praising its ability to bridge political divides. Some critics felt the writing style was dry or overly complex. The book's pre-2016 election perspective is noted as potentially outdated by some reviewers. Overall, it's seen as an important contribution to environmental discourse, encouraging dialogue between conservatives and progressives.
People Also Read
Glossary
Center Green
Pragmatic bipartisan environmentalismRich's approach to environmental policy seeks measures that both meaningfully address an environmental problem and have a realistic chance of political adoption. It draws on values shared across political groups, remains open to regulatory or market-based tools, and favors practical progress over policies judged ideal in theory but unattainable in practice.
Great Estrangement
The partisan environmental divideRich's term for the growing separation between a conservative movement increasingly hostile to environmental goals and a Green movement often perceived as hostile to business and economic growth. He traces the divide to political polarization, changing environmental priorities, strategic anti-environmental messaging, and the movement's own drift toward the political left.
market fundamentalism
Markets treated as the answerRich's label for a rigid strain of conservative thinking that treats environmental protection as a threat to growth, government regulation as inherently suspect, and private property rights as nearly absolute. He argues that this stance oversimplifies market economics and departs from conservative traditions of responsibility, stewardship, and limits on harmful conduct.
programmatic conservatism
Fixed positions as identity testsRich uses this term for defining conservatism by adherence to a set agenda of policy positions and factual beliefs. In his account, this approach turns particular stances, including opposition to environmental regulation, into tests of ideological belonging. He contrasts it with principled conservatism, which applies deeper values flexibly as circumstances change.
principled conservatism
Enduring values applied flexiblyRich's term for a form of conservatism grounded in durable principles rather than a fixed list of political positions. It emphasizes prudence, continuity, responsibility, and care for future generations. Applied to environmental questions, it can support stewardship and sensible limits on actions that harm neighbors or diminish the inheritance of those who follow.
conservation easement
A protected land-use rightA legal agreement transferring a specified right in a property, commonly the right to develop or subdivide it, to a land trust or other qualified holder. The landowner keeps the property and its remaining uses, such as farming or ranching, while the holder enforces the restriction for conservation purposes.
reconciliation ecology
Nature integrated with human placesAn approach to conservation that seeks to support biodiversity in places dominated by human activity, rather than focusing only on preserving areas untouched by people. Examples discussed in the book include changing agricultural practices to provide habitat and redesigning urban green spaces to support more wildlife.
precautionary principle
Act before risk is certainA decision principle calling for reasonable protective measures when an activity poses a threat of serious or irreversible harm, even if scientific understanding is incomplete. Rich presents it as a way to discuss climate action through prudence and risk management, while recognizing that disagreement remains over the cost and scale of appropriate measures.
Decalogue for Green Groups
Ten reforms for environmental groupsRich's ten-part proposal for improving the environmental movement's public credibility and political effectiveness. Its recommendations include telling the truth, acknowledging uncertainty, presenting hopeful goals, accepting compromise and incremental gains, engaging business, staying focused on mission, mobilizing local supporters, and giving cities greater attention.
IPAT equation
Impact as three factors multipliedA framework expressing environmental impact as the product of population, affluence, and technology. Rich notes that many environmentalists have used it to emphasize how population and consumption can increase ecological pressure. He argues that technology and affluence can also support solutions, so the equation should not be reduced to an argument against growth.
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.