Plot Summary
The Second Jacobson Trial
At a shooting range, former NYPD partners Jane Smith and Jimmy Cunniff compete as if precision could quiet the danger circling them. Jane is also fighting advanced cancer, and her client, wealthy Rob Jacobson, is preparing for a second trial on a triple murder charge. He was acquitted of killing another family, but a newly surfaced photograph appears to place him at the Carson family home on the night they died.
Jane obtains a delay to investigate and hires veteran jury consultant Norma Banks. Then, driving to meet Norma, Jane hears Rob discussing the coming trial on a radio show, directly disobeying her warning to keep quiet. His recklessness gives the prosecution fresh ammunition before jury selection has even begun.
The opening binds two kinds of exposure: Jane's body is under attack, and her client keeps making himself more visible to the state. Her shooting skill offers a brief fantasy of problems that can be aimed at and ended, while cancer and a suspicious photograph resist that clean logic. Rob's radio appearance establishes that Jane's chief obstacle is not simply the prosecution's evidence. It is the person she has chosen to defend, whose appetite for attention repeatedly threatens her work.
A Debt Comes Due
While Jane prepares for court, her ex-husband Martin Elian is gambling again, first through legal betting sites and then with dangerous bookmakers. His revived restaurant cannot cover the losses.
Robby Sassoon, a polished enforcer working for mob boss Sonny Blum, visits the restaurant and demands payment, making Martin promise to warn other debtors. Sassoon then begins learning Jane's routines and watches her with veterinarian Ben Kalinsky, who proposes on the beach.
Jane loves Ben but cannot accept a marriage while her cancer and trial consume her, so she leaves the ring in its box. She travels to the Meier Clinic in Switzerland for experimental treatment, carrying the question of whether she has chosen work over the life Ben is offering.
Martin and Jane both mistake control for a solution. Martin treats each new wager as a way to reverse the last loss; Jane treats the trial as a task she can finish before her illness catches up. Sassoon turns Martin's private addiction into an organized system of coercion, while Ben's proposal offers a future Jane cannot yet imagine inhabiting. Her refusal is not a lack of love. It is a defensive attempt to avoid making a promise that illness might take away.
The Clinic's Last Chance
At Meier, Jane meets Fiona Mills, a British cancer patient she had thought she would never see again. Fiona has returned after an experimental treatment brought her cancer into remission, and she urges Jane to keep believing in the possibility of recovery. Jane's own scans deliver the opposite news: the tumor in her neck has grown, and her prognosis remains roughly four months.
She still intends to try the next trial. Dr. Ludwig and Jane's longtime physician, Sam Wylie, propose antibody drug conjugates and kinase inhibitors instead of another round of chemotherapy. Jane accepts the plan, knowing it may worsen her already fragile condition, and flies home to face the trial alongside treatment.
Fiona's return is emotionally powerful precisely because it cannot function as evidence that Jane will share her outcome. It offers possibility, not a guarantee, and Jane has to choose treatment without being able to convert another person's remission into certainty. Her decision to continue the legal case and accept a new medical regimen reveals the same stubborn agency in two arenas. Yet the book keeps that agency costly: hope does not erase the scan, and resolve does not make her body dependable.
Harrington's Dangerous Offer
Back on Long Island, Jane's new drugs leave her weak, and Jimmy confronts her for pretending she is improving. Meanwhile, former police commander Paul Harrington is released after evidence tying him to an attempted murder is excluded because officers mishandled a search. He later enters Jimmy's bar and offers information in exchange for protection of Rob's son, Eric, and Edmund McKenzie, Rob's former school friend.
Harrington claims that, as teenagers, Rob killed his father and McKenzie killed the father's young mistress, then Harrington's corrupt officers staged the deaths as a murder-suicide. Jane accepts the information but rejects Harrington's demand for a deal. His allegation turns the old case into a possible key to the new one.
Harrington's story gives Jane a reason to question whether her client has been violent for decades, but it is not a clean revelation. The source is a corrupt officer whose evidence has just failed in court, and whose claims serve his own bargaining needs. Jane's decision to listen without granting him control reflects her professional method: information matters, but the person supplying it remains suspect. The scene also sharpens Jimmy's conflict, as loyalty to Jane now means helping defend a man he increasingly fears may be guilty.
Warnings at Jane's Door
After Jane refuses to back away from the case, someone searches her home and Rip disappears. Jane finds the rooms ransacked and fears the worst, until Rip returns from the street after Jimmy arrives. Robby Sassoon, who carried out the break-in, treats the incident as a warning and later sprays Paul Harrington's house with gunfire to intimidate him.
Jane and Jimmy also learn that Rob has hired flashy defense lawyer Thomas McGoey as a second chair without asking her. Jane walks out, then returns, determined to remain his lawyer until she can expose him in court. As jury selection approaches, the threats, Rob's interference, and her illness make the defense feel less like a case than a trap closing around her.
The attack on Jane's home converts the abstract danger around the trial into intimate violation. Rip's temporary absence is more frightening to Jane than the overturned furniture because the dog represents a form of attachment untouched by legal strategy or performance. Rob's unilateral addition of McGoey repeats the same pattern of control from inside the defense team. Jane's brief exit and return show that commitment is both her professional strength and a vulnerability others can exploit.
The Gun in the Closet
Jimmy searches Rob's Manhattan townhouse, where the earlier murders of Rob's father and the young woman occurred. One of Rob's houseguests, Kellye, points a gun at him, then explains that she found it hidden in a bedroom closet. Ballistics testing links the weapon to the Carson killings. Jane recognizes that the gun could devastate the defense, but also that it may have been planted to make Rob look guilty.
She gives it to District Attorney Katherine Welsh rather than conceal evidence. Before trial, Jane and Norma help select a jury, including one wealthy man who believes Rob is guilty but seems receptive to Jane. In her opening statement, Jane admits Rob is sexually exploitative while insisting the murder evidence has been staged.
The gun is both an evidentiary breakthrough and a moral test. Jane's choice to turn it over sacrifices a tactical advantage and preserves the distinction between defending a client and manipulating the court. Yet the weapon's discovery does not resolve guilt, because the townhouse is accessible to many people and Rob has repeatedly treated it as a playground. Jane's opening strategy makes an equally uncomfortable calculation: she concedes the character flaw the jury can plainly see, hoping that credibility on one point will keep them open on another.
A Jury Hears the Intimate Past
Welsh opens by presenting DNA, the photograph, and the recovered gun as parts of a single trail leading to Rob. Jane counters with the possibility that evidence can be planted, but the first witnesses establish that the Carson home was carefully cleaned and that Rob's DNA was found near the bodies.
On cross-examination, Jane exposes an undisclosed history between Rob and Brooke Milligan, Morgan Carson's closest friend. Brooke had also been involved with Rob when she was seventeen, before he pursued Morgan, and Jane's attack on her credibility risks making a grieving witness look humiliated.
Jane also questions a friend who knew Lily Carson was having affairs. The evidence remains damaging, and the courtroom pressure leaves Jane physically depleted.
The defense's most effective line of attack is also its most ethically uncomfortable. Jane reveals Brooke's personal history not merely to dispute the testimony, but to show that Rob's relationships created rivalries and motives beyond the official story. The tactic exposes how easily a murder trial can turn a dead teenager's private life into courtroom currency. Jane's success is therefore ambiguous: she weakens the prosecution's witnesses while making the trial's treatment of women feel like another form of injury.
Two Illnesses, One Trial
After Jane faints at court, Norma forces her to stop for medical care, and Welsh suspends proceedings rather than let the illness become another weapon against her. Jane's scan results bring rare relief: the tumor has shrunk under the Swiss treatment. But her sister Brigid soon reveals that her own lymphoma has returned and spread to her lungs.
Brigid's attachment to Rob has also become more destructive; she arrives at Jane's home bruised after an encounter with him, and Jane makes Rob promise to leave her alone. At the same time, Harrington is found dead in his kitchen with a gun nearby and a note suggesting suicide. Jane and Jimmy suspect someone killed him to silence his testimony.
Relief and grief arrive in the same narrow stretch of time, preventing Jane from treating good medical news as a simple reprieve. Brigid's relapse makes survival feel unevenly distributed, while her relationship with Rob shows how attachment can persist even when it causes harm. Jane's instinct is to intervene, but she cannot make her sister choose safety. Harrington's apparent suicide extends that uncertainty into the legal plot: even a death that seems to close a question may be another deliberate piece of evidence.
Blum Takes the Stand
Jane calls Sonny Blum to testify about Hank Carson's gambling debt, despite threats that she will be killed if she brings him into court. Blum pretends to be a confused retiree and denies knowing Carson. Jane then plays a recording Jimmy secretly made during a meeting with Blum. On video, Blum acknowledges that Carson owed him a million dollars and says the debt had been paid before the murders.
The recording destroys Blum's courtroom act, but he feigns a heart attack and is taken to hospital. That night, Sassoon kills Martin at his restaurant and sends Jane a photograph of the body with a warning. Jane's decision to challenge Blum has given her evidence, but it has also made the threat against her personal.
The recording turns performance against itself. Blum relies on frailty and selective forgetfulness to control the courtroom, while the camera preserves a version of him that he cannot revise in real time. But exposure does not equal justice: his departure from court is followed by Martin's murder, a brutal demonstration that the criminal organization can answer legal scrutiny with violence. Jane's search for truth now carries a cost that reaches beyond her own safety to someone she once loved.
The Hummingbird Camera
As the trial worsens, Rob insists on testifying and says Thomas McGoey should question him so that lying will be easier. Jane refuses, then tells Judge Horton she is withdrawing from the case. Horton rejects her request and orders her to continue, knowing she is acting from anger and fear for the defense. While Jane steps away, Jimmy and state investigator Danny Esposito return to the Carson house.
A tiny camera hidden in Hank's hummingbird feeder survived the night of the murders, though the family's other security cameras were disabled. They obtain the stored footage and find two armed men entering the house: Eric Jacobson and Edmund McKenzie. The image transforms suspicion into a route toward proof.
Jane's attempted resignation marks the limit of her ability to convert endurance into professional virtue. Rob's plan to lie on the stand would make her complicit in a defense she no longer believes she can control. The judge's refusal keeps her in court, but the decisive change comes from Jimmy's investigation rather than her willpower. The hummingbird camera, an object associated with Jane's hope and care, records the violence that official surveillance missed.
The Frame Comes Apart
Jimmy and Esposito use the feeder footage to arrest Eric and McKenzie. McKenzie reaches for a gun, and both investigators shoot him before he can kill Esposito; Eric is taken into custody. Before dying, McKenzie confesses that he and Eric planned the Carson murders to frame Rob, whom they both hated.
Eric had collected his father's DNA and helped plant it near the bodies. They later arranged a second, simpler frame involving the Gates family, expecting Rob to be convicted after Jane's earlier acquittal.
The evidence clears Rob of the Carson murders, and the charges against him are dropped. Blum kills Sassoon, his own enforcer, while consolidating his operation. Rob is free, but the truth exposes a family and criminal world built on old violence.
The solution depends on the distinction between evidence that is real and evidence that is truthful. The DNA belongs to Rob, the gun fired at the Carsons, and the photograph appears authentic, yet each clue has been engineered to tell a false story. The hummingbird footage supplies what the other evidence lacks: an unaltered view of the perpetrators arriving. The arrest resolves the murder case, but not the moral discomfort of Rob's release, since innocence of these killings does not make him a safe or honorable man.
A Life Beyond the Verdict
After the case ends, Jane collapses from the combined effects of her treatment, dehydration, anemia, and exhaustion. Tests at the hospital show that the tumor has disappeared. Jane, Jimmy, Ben, and Sam share the news with stunned relief, while Brigid remains at the clinic for treatment of her returning cancer. Jane begins to imagine a future with Ben and considers asking him to marry her.
The legal ending is less reassuring: Rob returns to Claire, resumes abusing her, and she shoots him when he attacks her in bed. Claire calls Jane for legal help. The woman who spent the novel defending Rob is left with a new case, and with the possibility of choosing a future no longer measured only in court dates.
The vanished tumor gives Jane an opening, not a guarantee that every wound will close. Her possible future with Ben contrasts sharply with Brigid's continuing illness and Claire's sudden violence. The final call refuses a tidy moral settlement: Jane's labor helped establish that Rob did not commit these murders, but it could not make him benign. Claire's act turns the lawyer's old professional dilemma back toward her, now as a question of what justice means when a person she defended becomes the alleged victim of another crime.
Analysis
The novel makes the courtroom and the cancer clinic versions of the same unstable institution: both ask Jane to interpret evidence, wait for results, and act without certainty. In court, DNA, a gun, and a photograph seem to form a coherent account of Rob's guilt. The hidden camera reveals that coherence was manufactured. In medicine, the first scan after Jane's return delivers bad news, while later imaging contradicts the prognosis. Neither system offers certainty on demand, though each can change a life with a single result.
Jane's professional ethic is tested less by whether she likes Rob than by whether she will preserve the process when doing so damages her case. She gives the murder weapon to Welsh, challenges the mob boss in open court, and refuses to let Rob turn testimony into a license to lie. Her strongest defense is not blind loyalty. It is the insistence that evidence must be examined even when it points toward the person she represents.
The story also refuses to make survival synonymous with moral repair. Jane's tumor disappears, but Brigid remains ill. Rob is cleared of the murders, yet his entitlement and violence persist, and Claire's final appeal to Jane begins another legal crisis. The resolution therefore separates factual justice from emotional comfort. Jane learns who killed the Carsons, but no verdict can restore them, undo Martin's death, or make Rob worthy of the loyalty he demanded. The hummingbird camera offers an apt image of the book's fragile hope: a small witness survives unnoticed, but it can only preserve the truth, not prevent the harm.
Review Summary
People Also Read
Characters
Jane Smith
The Hamptons defense lawyerA former NYPD officer turned criminal defense attorney, Jane is known for precision, nerve, and a refusal to abandon difficult cases. She is living with advanced cancer while defending Rob Jacobson, and often uses jokes and sharpness to keep other people from managing her as a patient. Her fierce independence protects her sense of self, but it also makes accepting care feel like surrender. Jane's bond with Jimmy is built on decades of trust, while her growing love for Ben asks her to imagine a life beyond work. She believes every defendant deserves a defense, yet her insistence on uncovering the truth repeatedly tests the boundary between loyalty and conscience.
Jimmy Cunniff
Jane's loyal investigatorJane's former police partner, closest friend, and investigator, Jimmy combines street instincts with an old detective's patience. He is blunt, protective, and often more willing than Jane to believe that Rob is guilty. That difference strains their partnership, but it never erases their trust. Jimmy's humor masks fear, especially when Jane's health worsens or danger reaches her home. He is also a bar owner whose old police connections and investigative habits make him indispensable. His loyalty is not passive: he challenges Jane, searches for evidence, and accepts risks because he cannot treat her survival as someone else's problem.
Rob Jacobson
The dangerous clientA wealthy Hamptons real estate figure accused of multiple family murders, Rob is charming when it serves him and casually cruel when it does not. He treats restrictions as inconveniences, women as conquests, and loyalty as something others owe him. His entitlement repeatedly sabotages Jane's defense, from speaking publicly about his case to interfering with her legal decisions. Rob's relationship with Jane is transactional and provocative, yet he depends on her skill and refuses to accept that she might leave. His character forces the distinction between legal innocence and moral worth: a lawyer can defend a client without endorsing the person he is.
Ben Kalinsky
Jane's steady veterinarianA respected South Fork veterinarian and Jane's partner, Ben is patient without being passive. He cares for Rip and offers Jane a kind of intimacy that does not require her to perform toughness. His proposal unsettles her because she loves him but fears promising a future while cancer and trial work dominate her days. Ben does not try to solve every fear with advice; he often gives her room to be silent or frightened. His steadiness provides a counterweight to Jane's habit of treating every vulnerability as a problem she must manage alone.
Norma Banks
The veteran jury readerAn eighty-three-year-old jury consultant with a formidable eye for behavior, Norma helps Jane read potential jurors beyond their rehearsed answers. Her age and grandmotherly appearance conceal a combative intelligence and an unsentimental view of trial strategy. She sees Jane's fear and physical decline more clearly than Jane wants her to, but expresses concern through bluntness rather than pity. Norma's humor keeps the courtroom human, while her professional instinct helps Jane identify jurors others might dismiss. Their relationship shifts quickly from consultant and client toward a fierce, affectionate alliance.
Brigid
Jane's sister and confidanteJane's sister shares her family history of cancer and her stubbornness, though the sisters have long compared themselves through different kinds of success and misfortune. Brigid has endured illness, a damaged marriage, and a complicated attachment to Rob Jacobson. Her choices can frustrate Jane, particularly when she defends a man who has hurt her, but she is not simply a cautionary figure. Brigid's independence and desire for connection coexist uneasily, and Jane's wish to protect her cannot substitute for Brigid's own decisions.
Sam Wylie
Jane's doctor and oldest friendJane's physician and friend since high school, Sam knows how little use Jane has for comforting half-truths. She helps coordinate treatment with the Swiss clinic and monitors Jane's health as the trial approaches. Their history permits a directness that would sound harsh from anyone else. Sam's clinical role is inseparable from her personal fear for Jane, and she sometimes has to insist that Jane's body imposes limits her will cannot erase.
Robby Sassoon
Blum's polished enforcerA meticulous, theatrically cultured killer, Sassoon pairs expensive suits and Broadway enthusiasm with a chillingly practical approach to violence. He treats debt collection as a performance whose details matter, using politeness and small gestures to unsettle people before he harms them. His work for Sonny Blum brings him into contact with Jane, Martin, and a widening circle of debtors. Sassoon's self-image as a gentleman sharpens rather than softens his brutality: refinement becomes a way to make violence feel like a private craft.
Sonny Blum
The aging crime bossA long-established mob boss, Blum commands bookmakers, corrupt officials, and enforcers through money and information. Age has weakened his body but not his ability to inspire fear or manipulate people. He insists that he follows a personal code, even as his business depends on threats and violence. Blum's interest in Rob Jacobson is unusually deep, and his reasons are bound up with decades of leverage. His presence shows how criminal power can outlast individual crimes by making institutions and families part of the same debt.
Katherine Welsh
The determined prosecutorThe Nassau County district attorney prosecuting Rob, Welsh is prepared, politically aware, and confident in the strength of her evidence. She understands courtroom presentation and uses timing to make DNA, witness testimony, and the murder weapon accumulate into a persuasive case. Her rivalry with Jane is professional rather than purely personal; both women recognize the other's ability even as they try to defeat each other. Welsh's ambition does not erase her regard for procedure, and she occasionally shows concern for Jane's health without abandoning her role as prosecutor.
Edmund McKenzie
Rob's old school friendA wealthy man's son and Rob's former high-school companion, McKenzie carries old grievances and a taste for impunity. He presents himself as a confident, crude social equal to Rob, but his history with him is marked by rivalry and resentment. His connection to both the earlier Jacobson household deaths and the Carson family makes him a figure Jane and Jimmy cannot dismiss. McKenzie represents the way privileged friendships can conceal shared wrongdoing while preserving the appearance of individual respectability.
Eric Jacobson
Rob's hostile adult sonRob's son is angry, contemptuous of his father, and deeply entangled in the family's history. He resents Rob's treatment of women and the ways Rob's conduct has shaped their relationship, yet his hostility carries its own capacity for harm. Eric's appearances unsettle Jane because he treats threats as games and believes his family name offers protection. His conflict with Rob is not a simple effort to escape his father's shadow; it is also shaped by rivalry, grievance, and the power inherited from wealth.
Paul Harrington
The disgraced former commanderOnce a celebrated NYPD commander, Harrington is exposed as a corrupt official whose career depended on serving powerful criminal interests. He is proud, calculating, and skilled at bargaining with information. His past connections make him useful to Jane and Jimmy, but his self-interest makes every claim suspect. Harrington embodies the damage caused when public authority becomes a private instrument for wealthy clients and organized crime.
Martin Elian
Jane's gambling ex-husbandJane's former husband is a talented restaurant owner whose charm and appetite for risk have repeatedly become entangled with gambling. He understands that his addiction is controlling him, yet keeps convincing himself that one more wager will repair the losses. His relationship with Jane retains affection despite their failed marriage, which makes his requests for help difficult for her to dismiss. Martin's debt brings the organized crime plot into Jane's personal life.
Claire Jacobson
Rob's estranged wifeRob's wife is poised, guarded, and difficult for Jane to read. She insists on her own reasons for remaining connected to Rob, even after years of public humiliation and betrayal. Claire's controlled manner makes her appear self-possessed, but her loyalty and resentment coexist in ways that complicate her role in the trial. She is not merely a witness to Rob's behavior; she has her own history, judgments, and capacity to act.
Danny Esposito
The state investigatorA sharp, cocky state investigator, Esposito works with Jimmy on the criminal investigations surrounding the case. His confidence can irritate his colleagues, but it is matched by an ability to find overlooked evidence and follow technical leads. He balances Jimmy's older detective instincts with newer investigative methods, including digital research. Esposito's professional pride is tempered by genuine loyalty to the people working beside him.
Fiona Mills
Jane's Swiss-clinic friendA British cancer patient Jane meets at the Meier Clinic, Fiona is warm, wry, and determined to preserve hope without pretending treatment is easy. Her experience gives Jane companionship with someone who understands the clinic's uncertainty from the inside. Fiona's humor and direct encouragement offer Jane a model of courage that is grounded in shared vulnerability rather than inspirational certainty.
Thomas McGoey
Rob's celebrity second chairA high-profile criminal defense lawyer known for his publicity and flashy presentation, McGoey joins Rob's defense team at Rob's request. Jane distrusts his showmanship and resents the way he is imposed on her, but she recognizes his legal skill as they work together. His ambition and appetite for attention can look like vanity, though his courtroom conduct proves more disciplined than Jane expects.
Rip
Jane's rescued dogJane's rescue dog and constant companion, Rip is cared for by Ben and loved by Jimmy as well as Jane. His presence gives Jane a daily routine built around feeding, walks, and small acts of attention. He is not a plot-solving animal, but his dependence and affection make Jane's home feel like a life rather than a place to recover between trials.
Hank Carson
The murdered family patriarchHank Carson is the father of Morgan and husband of Lily. His gambling and dealings with bookmakers form part of the hidden history surrounding the murders, while his home becomes the center of the trial's contested evidence.
Lily Carson
Morgan's motherLily Carson is Morgan's mother and Hank's wife. Her relationships outside her marriage and her past connection to Rob complicate the prosecution's account of the family's final days.
Morgan Carson
The teenage victimMorgan Carson is a high-school student whose friendship with Brooke and relationship with Rob become central to the prosecution's case. Her yearbook and bedroom preserve fragments of a young life the trial repeatedly reduces to evidence.
Plot Devices
The hidden murder weapon
A clue with two meaningsThe Glock found in Rob's Manhattan townhouse matches the bullets used to kill the Carson family. Its location appears to implicate Rob, but the house is accessible to other people, and Jimmy's discovery begins a dispute over whether the weapon was planted. Jane turns it over to the prosecution rather than suppress it, making the gun both a major piece of evidence and a test of her professional ethics.
The timestamped photograph
A manufactured alibi breakerA photograph appears to show Rob leaving the Carson home on the night of the murders. The prosecution treats its timestamp as decisive, while Jane's expert explains how digital images can be altered through device settings and editing. The photograph establishes the trial's central problem: seemingly objective evidence can be authentic in appearance yet unreliable in origin.
The hummingbird camera
A hidden witnessHank Carson hides a tiny camera inside the family's hummingbird feeder, outside the ordinary security system that the killers disable. Jimmy notices the camera while searching the property and works with Esposito to recover its stored footage. The device connects Jane's recurring hummingbird motif to the investigation, while providing an unaltered record that overturns the trial's false narrative.
Jane's cancer treatment
A clock with uncertain handsJane's cancer prognosis shapes her decisions throughout the trial, from refusing Ben's proposal to accepting experimental treatment at the Meier Clinic. The antibody drug conjugates leave her weak and vulnerable to collapse, but later scans show the tumor shrinking and then disappearing. The treatment does not remove uncertainty from her life; it makes every legal choice and emotional commitment feel pressed against an unpredictable deadline.
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.