Key Takeaways
Treat culture as a second evolutionary process, not a decorative layer on biology.
A second replicator. Blackmore’s central claim is that humans transmit culture through imitation, creating a new kind of replicator alongside genes. A meme is cultural information copied between people, broadly including words, stories, skills, and instructions. Like genes, memes vary, get copied at different rates, and persist or disappear. The evolutionary principle behind this is Universal Darwinism: whenever copying, variation, and differential survival occur, selection can build complexity without a designer.
Different interests. Genes spread through biological reproduction; memes spread through minds and other carriers, and may help, harm, or matter little to the people carrying them. A popular custom can therefore succeed without improving anyone’s health or reproductive prospects. Blackmore asks readers to consider cultural change as evolution in its own right, not merely as a by-product of genetic advantage.
This framework makes cultural change easier to compare with biological evolution without pretending that ideas are literally DNA. Its most useful shift is from asking only what a practice does for people to asking how it is transmitted and retained. That question fits research on cumulative culture, where learners inherit and modify skills across generations. The analogy still needs careful boundaries: cultural practices often have several possible versions, and researchers must identify what counts as a copied unit before testing its spread. The book offers a productive lens, but the lens is not itself proof that every cultural pattern behaves like a gene.
Distinguish imitation from learning before calling a behavior cultural inheritance.
Copy the action. In Blackmore’s account, imitation means learning the form of an action by observing someone else. It is different from conditioning, where experience links a cue to a response, and from social learning, where another animal merely draws attention to a place or object. The distinction matters because imitation can pass along a behavior that later learners can copy and refine.
A misleading bird. English tits learned to open milk bottles, and the habit spread between birds. Yet they may have discovered how to peck by trial and error after noticing the bottles, rather than copying another bird’s technique. The behavior looks cultural, but Blackmore argues it is not a meme in her strict sense. Human infants, by contrast, readily copy gestures and sounds, supporting her claim that humans are unusually capable imitators.
Separating imitation from other forms of social learning prevents the word culture from becoming a catch-all label. It also focuses attention on what is transmitted: a specific behavior, a cue to explore, or merely a tendency to learn in a particular setting. The strict definition gives the theory a cleaner mechanism, but risks excluding traditions that clearly accumulate through social influence without precise copying. Current work on animal culture often treats learning as a spectrum rather than a yes-or-no capacity. That broader view complicates Blackmore’s line between humans and other species, while preserving her key point that copying fidelity affects what can accumulate.
Ask what gets copied, not only who benefits from an idea.
A meme’s advantage. The meme’s-eye view asks which cultural patterns are most likely to find a place in minds and be passed on again. Success does not require truth, usefulness, or benefit to the host. Blackmore illustrates this with a widely retold story about a pet accidentally killed in a microwave oven. Versions differ in the animal and other details, but the basic tale travels because it is memorable and startling, not because it is reliable.
Replication is not welfare. A meme is called successful when it is copied, not when it improves human lives. Some ideas spread because they solve problems; others take hold through novelty, fear, or a good story. The same process can bring beneficial knowledge and damaging misinformation into circulation, so popularity alone cannot tell a reader whether an idea deserves trust.
This perspective usefully separates an idea’s popularity from its accuracy, much as epidemiology distinguishes a pathogen’s transmissibility from its effect on health. It helps explain why vivid claims can outrun careful evidence. Yet calling an idea a replicator does not explain its success by itself. A strong account must specify measurable factors, such as attention, memory, social trust, or access to communication channels, and show that they predict transmission. Otherwise, the theory risks explaining an idea’s survival after the fact by simply calling it catchy. Its value lies in prompting causal questions, not in treating spread as a complete explanation.
Protect attention from memes that recruit thought and speech for free.
Thought takes space. Blackmore argues that thoughts can compete for limited mental attention. Ideas that trigger repeated rehearsal have an advantage: they remain easy to recall and are more likely to be spoken or shared. Catchy tunes are a small, familiar example. Her garden metaphor is that an idle mind does not necessarily stay empty; thoughts readily take up available attention.
Speech multiplies copies. Talking also gives ideas more chances to spread. News about Princess Diana’s death moved rapidly through conversations in 1997, while ordinary, forgettable remarks rarely travel beyond the people who hear them. Blackmore suggests that social habits encouraging conversation can themselves spread because talkers give their ideas more opportunities to be heard. Thinking and speaking may sometimes help their hosts, but the memetic account explains why they can also feel excessive or hard to stop.
The idea connects cultural transmission with a basic constraint in cognitive science: attention is limited, and emotionally salient material is easier to rehearse and recall. In modern media environments, recommendation systems can intensify this competition by repeatedly presenting content that attracts a response. That does not mean every intrusive thought is a meme, or that all conversation serves replication. Stress, memory, and social needs also shape what occupies the mind. Blackmore’s account is strongest as a way to ask why some material keeps resurfacing, while leaving open the psychological mechanisms that make particular thoughts difficult to disengage from.
Consider imitation as a possible engine of the costly human brain.
A costly puzzle. The modern human brain averages about 1,350 cubic centimetres, roughly three times the size of an ape brain at comparable body size. It also requires substantial energy, takes years to develop, and makes childbirth hazardous. Blackmore argues that toolmaking and social competition alone may not fully explain this costly expansion.
Memetic driving. Memetic driving is her hypothesis that cultural competition altered the conditions under which genes were selected. Once imitation spread useful skills, individuals who learned from the best imitators could gain an advantage. If they also tended to choose those people as mates, genes supporting imitation could become more common. More imitation would then enable more cultural innovation, creating further pressure for brains capable of learning and copying. The proposal is explanatory, not established: the book presents it as a testable account of brain expansion.
The hypothesis offers a feedback loop between culture and biology, a useful alternative to explanations that treat the brain as an adaptation to one fixed task. It also makes a testable prediction: stronger imitation abilities should be associated with brain structures that support them. The challenge is separating this mechanism from other plausible pressures, including social coordination, ecological change, and tool use. Fossils can show changes in brain size and anatomy, but they cannot directly reveal why selection favored those changes. The theory’s strength is its causal ambition; its evidential status remains speculative, especially where mate choice is assumed to track imitation skill.
Read language and technology as increasingly powerful copying infrastructure.
More copies, more accurately. Blackmore proposes that speech helped memes spread to many listeners at once. Words divide continuous sounds into more recognizable units, while grammar allows more messages to be assembled and retained. In her account, language benefits the copying process through fidelity, the accuracy of copies; fecundity, the number of copies; and longevity, how long information persists.
From voice to network. Writing gave language a durable form, printing increased the number of copies, and digital communication made information quick to duplicate across distance. Each invention created new ways for ideas to circulate. Blackmore extends the same logic to computers and the Internet, arguing that communication tools are not merely conveniences for humans. They also expand the channels through which cultural information can reproduce, sometimes at a pace that strains people’s time and attention.
This account joins the history of media to the evolution of culture: each new channel changes not only how fast ideas travel, but which kinds can survive. It also resembles infrastructure economics, where a network becomes more useful as more people and tools connect to it. The explanation should not reduce every invention to a meme’s advantage, however. Human needs, institutions, political power, and commercial incentives help determine which technologies are built and adopted. The framework is most persuasive when it tracks how a medium changes the conditions of transmission, rather than treating the medium’s appearance as inevitable.
Track who transmits beliefs when culture outruns biological generations.
Two transmission routes. Vertical transmission passes ideas from parents to children; horizontal transmission carries them between peers or unrelated people. In relatively slow-changing societies, parent-to-child transmission links cultural practices closely to family survival. In modern societies, schools, books, television, and other channels let ideas spread rapidly among people who are not related.
Different incentives. Blackmore argues that this shift can weaken the connection between cultural success and genetic advantage. She applies the idea to contraception, celibacy, adoption, and smaller families. For instance, a person may spread beliefs or pursue work without having children, while the associated ideas continue to reach new people. This is a proposed explanation, not a claim that media alone determines family size. The key question is whether the route of transmission helps explain why a practice persists even when it does not maximize reproduction.
The distinction between vertical and horizontal transmission remains useful for studying how beliefs move through families, schools, peer groups, and mass media. It also highlights that a cultural practice can persist even when its carriers have fewer descendants. Still, reproductive behavior depends on more than imitation: access to contraception, economic conditions, gender roles, and personal preference all matter. A memetic account can help explain how norms spread, but it cannot substitute for those mechanisms. Its strongest contribution is to show why the identity of transmitters and the structure of a network can matter as much as the content of a belief.
Notice how kindness can spread both generosity and unrelated ideas.
Likeable transmitters. Blackmore’s theory of meme-driven altruism starts with a social observation: people tend to spend time with, trust, and imitate those they like. Helpful behavior can therefore make someone a more effective transmitter of ideas. If observers copy the person, they may acquire not only generosity but also the person’s other habits and beliefs.
The altruism trick. This is the book’s name for using visible kindness to help other memes spread. A religious group that assists strangers, for example, may earn attention and goodwill that also expose people to its beliefs. The account does not require deliberate manipulation; a practice can spread because it happens to make its carriers attractive models. Blackmore argues that this process can support altruistic behavior even when the behavior is not easily explained by genetic advantage alone.
The argument links prosocial behavior to social learning: people often learn from those they trust, admire, or find cooperative. It captures a genuine tension in social life, where care can be sincere and still have consequences for influence. But popularity is not the same as imitation, and altruism has other explanations, including kinship, reciprocal help, and shared institutions. The idea is best treated as one transmission pathway among several, not a replacement for biological or social accounts. It also invites an ethical distinction: recognizing how kindness spreads does not make kindness less valuable to the people who receive it.
Ask how religious beliefs spread before deciding what their popularity proves.
Beliefs travel in bundles. A memeplex is a group of mutually supportive memes that spread more effectively together than separately. Religions are Blackmore’s central example. They can combine answers to difficult questions, shared rituals, community, moral rules, promises of comfort, and warnings about punishment. Those elements may reinforce one another and give the belief system staying power.
Spread is not proof. Blackmore also examines alien-abduction accounts, near-death experiences, fortune-telling, and alternative therapies. A frightening or confusing experience may prompt a search for explanation; familiar stories can then shape how the event is remembered and described. Beliefs may use claims of special truth or visible compassion to win trust. Yet persistence does not show that a claim is false, any more than popularity proves it true. The book’s point is that transmission helps explain why beliefs endure.
The memeplex idea is a useful corrective to explanations that isolate one belief from the rituals, identities, and institutions that support it. It also fits research on social identity: group belonging can make a set of claims more durable than any claim considered alone. The account must not confuse a belief’s cultural function with its factual status. A story can spread because it comforts people and still contain truth; a scientific claim can spread for social reasons and still be well supported. Understanding the mechanisms of belief transmission should sharpen evaluation, not replace evidence.
Treat the inner self as a constructed story, not a hidden operator.
No single control room. Blackmore draws on neuroscience and philosophy to challenge the sense of a separate inner self that watches experience and initiates every action. The brain, she argues, processes information through many interacting systems rather than sending everything to one central observer. In Libet’s experiments, brain activity associated with preparing a movement began before participants reported deciding to move, a result Blackmore uses to question conscious will as the starting point of action.
The selfplex. A selfplex is the network of memes that organizes a person’s self-story, including ideas about identity, beliefs, preferences, and ownership. Blackmore suggests that meditation can weaken self-focused thought by directing attention to immediate experience. Her conclusion is radical: the self is constructed, not an independent commander. That is her philosophical interpretation of the evidence, not a settled scientific finding.
The account resonates with contemporary views of the self as an ongoing model assembled from memory, bodily signals, and social feedback. It is especially useful for distinguishing the experience of agency from the mechanisms that produce action. But experiments showing that some brain activity precedes reported intention do not, by themselves, establish that conscious reflection has no causal role. Nor does a constructed self become unreal in every practical sense. Identity can still organize commitments, responsibility, and relationships. The strongest insight is that agency need not require a mysterious inner spectator; the broader claim that consciousness has no influence remains contested.
Analysis
The book’s most important achievement is to make cultural transmission part of evolutionary explanation rather than treating culture as a passive reflection of genetic interests. Its recurring question, which patterns get copied, reframes language, technology, religion, altruism, and identity as outcomes of competition among transmissible information. That lens is powerful because it accommodates cultural practices that persist despite costs to their carriers.
Its central weakness is also clear: the proposed replicator is difficult to delimit. A meme may mean an instruction in a brain, an action, a story, or its written form. Those versions do not necessarily have the same fidelity or lineage. Without an operational unit, claims about selection can become retrospective: whatever spreads is identified as the successful meme, and its success is then explained by its supposed copying advantages. The book recognizes this boundary problem but often proceeds with the broad definition anyway.
The strongest empirical program would measure transmission directly, specify variants before examining their spread, and compare memetic explanations with alternatives such as prestige-biased learning, social coordination, economic incentives, or ecological adaptation. Several of Blackmore’s largest proposals, especially that memes drove brain expansion and grammatical language, are imaginative hypotheses rather than conclusions established by the examples presented.
The final argument about the self is best read as a challenge to the idea of a single inner controller, not as proof that persons, intentions, or responsibility are meaningless. A distributed brain can still support organized agency. Overall, the book is most valuable as a disciplined change of perspective: cultural success and human benefit are not identical, and explanations of human behavior should account for both transmission and biological inheritance.
Review Summary
The Meme Machine presents Susan Blackmore's theory of memes as cultural replicators, expanding on Dawkins' concept. Reviews are mixed, with praise for its thought-provoking ideas and clear writing, but criticism for overreaching claims and lack of scientific evidence. Some readers find the book fascinating and paradigm-shifting, while others view it as pseudoscientific. The theory of memetics is seen as intriguing but controversial, with debates over its explanatory power and validity as a scientific framework for understanding cultural evolution and human behavior.
People Also Read
Glossary
Meme
Copied cultural informationA meme is cultural information transmitted through imitation, understood broadly to include copying by language, instruction, reading, or observed behavior. Examples include words, stories, skills, fashions, and customs. In Blackmore’s theory, memes vary in how accurately and often they are copied, allowing some to spread more successfully than others.
Memeplex
Mutually supporting memesA memeplex is a cluster of memes that replicate more effectively together than separately. Members may reinforce one another, make a shared belief system easier to remember, or encourage behavior that spreads the whole package. Blackmore uses religions and other organized belief systems as examples, while emphasizing that their persistence does not establish that their claims are true.
Universal Darwinism
Evolution beyond biologyUniversal Darwinism applies the logic of evolution wherever information or entities are copied with variation and differential retention. Biological genes are one example; Blackmore argues that memes are another. The process does not require foresight or a designer, although its application to a new domain requires identifying what is copied and how selection operates.
Meme-gene coevolution
Cultural and genetic feedbackMeme-gene coevolution describes reciprocal influence between cultural transmission and genetic evolution. Genes produce brains capable of imitation, while transmitted memes alter the environment in which genes are selected. Blackmore argues that this feedback may have favored greater imitation ability and contributed to changes in brain size and language capacity.
Memetic driving
Memes shape genetic selectionMemetic driving is Blackmore’s proposed process in which successful memes change selection pressures on genes. If people preferentially learn from or mate with effective meme transmitters, genes associated with those abilities may become more common. The concept is a hypothesis about cultural influence on biological evolution, not a claim that every genetic change is directed by culture.
Fidelity, fecundity, and longevity
Replicator success criteriaThese are three properties used to describe a replicator’s copying success. Fidelity is how accurately it is copied, fecundity is how many copies are made, and longevity is how long copies persist. Blackmore applies the criteria to memes and argues that speech, writing, printing, and digital media expanded different aspects of cultural transmission.
Copy-the-product and copy-the-instructions
Two copying routesCopy-the-product means reproducing an observed result, including its accidental flaws. Copy-the-instructions means learning or transmitting a procedure that can generate new results, so execution errors need not be inherited. Blackmore uses the distinction to clarify why cultural transmission does not map neatly onto genetic inheritance.
Selfplex
Memes forming a self-storyA selfplex is Blackmore’s term for a memeplex organized around the idea of a persisting inner self. It includes self-descriptions, beliefs, preferences, memories, and the sense that an inner agent owns experience and directs action. The book argues that this self-story can shape behavior, while rejecting the idea that it requires a separate central controller.
Altruism trick
Kindness that spreads memesThe altruism trick is the use, deliberate or incidental, of helpful behavior to make a person or group more likeable and therefore more likely to be copied or trusted. Other beliefs can travel alongside the kindness. The concept explains one route by which altruistic practices and unrelated cultural ideas may spread together.
FAQ
What's The Meme Machine about?
- Exploration of Memetics: The Meme Machine by Susan Blackmore explores memes as units of cultural transmission, similar to genes in biological evolution. It examines how memes replicate through imitation and influence human behavior and culture.
- Human Uniqueness: The book discusses what makes humans unique, focusing on our ability to imitate, which has led to the development of complex language and culture.
- Meme-Gene Coevolution: Blackmore posits that memes and genes coevolve, suggesting that human brain and language evolution is driven by the need to spread memes, not just genetic survival.
Why should I read The Meme Machine?
- Understanding Human Behavior: The book provides insights into human behavior, particularly in communication and cultural practices, challenging traditional views with the concept of memetic selection.
- Interdisciplinary Approach: Blackmore combines psychology, evolutionary biology, and cultural studies, offering a rich resource for those interested in these fields' intersections.
- Provocative Ideas: It encourages readers to rethink consciousness, identity, and the nature of ideas, making it a thought-provoking read.
What are the key takeaways of The Meme Machine?
- Memes as Replicators: Memes are cultural elements passed on by imitation, highlighting imitation's role in cultural evolution.
- Imitation Drives Culture: Human ability to imitate sets us apart, leading to language and complex social structures.
- Meme-Gene Interaction: Memes influence genetic evolution, suggesting cultural factors significantly shape human biology.
What are the best quotes from The Meme Machine and what do they mean?
- "Imitation comes naturally to us humans.": This highlights imitation's fundamental role in human learning and cultural transmission.
- "The function of language is to spread memes.": Language evolved as a tool for idea replication, not just communication or survival.
- "Memes are selfish like genes.": Memes, like genes, are driven by replication and survival, often at the host's expense.
What is a meme according to The Meme Machine?
- Definition of a Meme: A meme is a cultural element passed on by imitation, emphasizing imitation's role in spreading ideas.
- Types of Memes: Memes include ideas, behaviors, skills, and cultural practices transmitted and evolved through imitation.
- Memetic Selection: Memes compete for attention and replication, with successful ones being easily imitated and remembered.
How does The Meme Machine explain the evolution of language?
- Language as a Memetic Tool: Language evolved to facilitate meme spread, crucial for cultural transmission.
- Imitation and Language Development: Imitating sounds and structures allowed early humans to develop complex language systems.
- Coevolution of Language and Brain: Language evolution created selection pressures for larger brains, leading to unique human brain structures.
How does The Meme Machine explain the concept of the self?
- Selfplex as a Construct: The self is a collection of memes creating the illusion of a coherent identity, shaped by cultural influences.
- Illusion of Control: The belief in a controlling self is an illusion, as thoughts and actions are driven by memes.
- Impact on Behavior: Understanding the self as a memeplex can lead to awareness of cultural influences on identity and behavior.
How does The Meme Machine relate to evolutionary psychology?
- Critique of Evolutionary Psychology: Blackmore challenges the idea that all human behavior is explained by genetics, emphasizing cultural influences through memes.
- Memes as Cultural Replicators: Memes operate independently of genes, creating a second evolution layer influencing behavior and social structures.
- Interplay Between Genes and Memes: While genes provide biological behavior bases, memes shape the cultural context of that behavior.
What role do memes play in human sexual behavior according to The Meme Machine?
- Mate Choice Influences: Memes influence mate choice and sexual behavior, dictating preferences and behaviors in relationships.
- Sexual Selection: Memes shape perceptions of attractiveness and desirability, affecting sexual selection.
- Cultural Variability: Sexual behaviors are influenced by cultural memes, leading to variability across societies.
How does The Meme Machine address the concept of altruism?
- Meme-Driven Altruism: Altruistic behaviors are spread and reinforced through social interactions and cultural norms, driven by memetic selection.
- Reciprocal Altruism: Individuals help others expecting help in return, benefiting both parties and enhancing meme survival.
- Cultural Context: Altruistic behaviors are shaped by societal norms and values, indicating cultural influences on altruism.
What is the significance of the Internet in The Meme Machine?
- Accelerated Meme Transmission: The Internet revolutionizes meme transmission, allowing rapid and widespread information sharing.
- New Memeplexes: The Internet facilitates new memeplex creation, leading to diverse cultural phenomena and trends.
- Impact on Society: Rapid meme spread through the Internet influences social behavior, beliefs, and values, highlighting memetic dynamics' importance.
How does The Meme Machine relate to the concept of free will?
- Illusion of Free Will: The self is an illusion, and decisions are driven by memes, raising questions about personal agency.
- Decision-Making Process: Decisions result from complex meme and environmental interactions, not a singular self.
- Moral Implications: Understanding the lack of a controlling self can lead to reevaluating moral responsibility, as actions may be seen as culturally influenced.
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.