Key Takeaways
Build a legal career for scalable service, not the billable-hour past
Three forces converge. Susskind sees the profession being reshaped by clients demanding more legal work for less money, rules allowing new kinds of businesses to provide legal services, and information technology that changes how knowledge can be delivered. At the time he wrote, some corporate legal departments faced pressure to cut budgets by 30 to 50 percent while handling growing workloads. In England and Wales, the Legal Services Act 2007 opened the door to businesses with non-lawyer owners and outside investment.
The delivery model shifts. The book predicts a move away from one-to-one advice, delivered by lawyers in person and billed by the hour, toward services that make legal knowledge available to many people through systems, online tools, and new providers. Its central challenge to young lawyers is to prepare for the market taking shape, not simply inherit the one that trained their predecessors.
The argument is strongest when these forces are treated as mutually reinforcing rather than as separate trends. Cost pressure creates demand for new delivery models, regulatory change makes room for new providers, and technology makes those models practical. That interaction explains why small adjustments to pricing may not be enough. Yet scalable service is not automatically better service: legal help depends on trust, context, and accountability. The strategic question is therefore not whether technology replaces human judgment, but which parts of legal work need judgment and how the rest can be delivered reliably.
Stop selling hours; redesign how legal work gets done
Hours reward slowness. Susskind illustrates the flaw in hourly billing with a summer job: when his young daughter was offered payment by the hour, she recognized that taking longer would earn her more. The same incentive can reward delay in legal work, even when clients care about results, certainty, and cost. A large matter may also consume many hours of junior lawyers’ time without creating value proportional to the bill.
Different prices are not enough. Firms responded to cost pressure with fixed, capped, or value-based fees, collectively called alternative fee arrangements. But firms often calculate these fees from their old hourly estimates and retain the same work methods. Susskind reports that competitive tendering and new fee arrangements were producing only about 10 percent overall savings, far short of clients’ needs. His conclusion: lasting savings require changing the production of legal service, not just the invoice.
The distinction between price and production is a useful diagnostic well beyond law. A fixed fee can hide the same inefficient process behind a tidier number, while a genuine redesign changes the amount of effort needed. But hourly billing is not only a bad incentive. It can also make uncertain work easier to price and give clients access to expertise without defining every deliverable in advance. Replacing it responsibly requires clear scope, quality measures, and a fair way to handle unexpected complexity, not simply a cheaper-looking contract.
Automate repeatable legal work without pretending every case is routine
Legal work has a spectrum. Susskind challenges the idea that every matter must be either handcrafted or reduced to a generic commodity. In practice, lawyers reuse precedents, standard processes, and accumulated know-how. Technology can take this further: a workflow can guide routine steps, and document assembly can produce a tailored draft after users answer questions about their circumstances. The result is not necessarily a one-size-fits-all form. It can be one of many possible outputs generated from a structured process.
Package expertise where it fits. Deloitte’s UK tax practice, in the book’s example, encoded the expertise of about 250 specialists in a system clients could use for tax compliance. The service could cost less and reach more users than bespoke work. Susskind reserves commoditization for routine legal help made readily available online, often at low or no cost. Difficult, unusual matters still call for experienced judgment.
This account replaces a misleading choice between artisanal work and mass production with a more useful question: which parts of a service are genuinely variable, and which only appear variable because no one has organized the knowledge? Structured tools can make expert practice more consistent and reveal where human attention matters most. The risk is that a template may encode yesterday’s assumptions or fail when a user’s facts fall outside its design. Good automation therefore needs explicit limits, escalation routes, and maintenance by people accountable for the underlying legal content.
Break deals into tasks, then choose the right provider for each
A legal matter is divisible. Susskind’s term for breaking a deal or dispute into separate tasks is decomposing. Litigation, for instance, may involve document review, legal research, project management, strategy, negotiation, and advocacy. A law firm need not perform every task simply because it leads the matter. In the book’s example, document review could be outsourced for around one-seventh the cost of using lawyers in the traditional way.
Combine sources deliberately. Work might be handled internally, by paralegals, specialist contractors, lower-cost offices, external providers, shared services, or software. Using several sources within one matter is multi-sourcing. For example, lawyers might retain responsibility for strategy while specialist providers handle document processing and a project manager coordinates the pieces. The aim is not to split work indiscriminately, but to match each task with an effective source and assemble the result into a coherent service.
This is a shift from asking which firm should receive a whole matter to asking what capabilities the matter actually requires. It can reduce waste and make responsibility clearer, especially when routine processing is mistaken for specialized legal judgment. Yet decomposition introduces coordination costs: separate providers may miss context, duplicate work, or disagree about quality. A strong lead provider must therefore preserve the narrative of the case, maintain confidentiality, and know when a task that looks routine has become legally consequential.
Use technology to invent legal services, not merely speed old routines
Automation is only the beginning. Susskind distinguishes systems that make existing work faster from systems that enable services that were previously impractical. Automated document assembly can generate customized drafts; legal search tools can classify large document collections; online guidance can help people understand legal questions; and online dispute resolution can help parties settle claims without conventional court proceedings. He also points to big data and artificial intelligence as emerging sources of legal insight and problem-solving.
Change arrives in stages. The forecast is not that every lawyer disappears at once. Susskind expects organizations first to resist major change, then move routine work to lower-cost sources, and eventually face technology that can outperform human labor on repeatable tasks. His example of IBM’s Watson, which defeated leading human contestants on a television quiz show, is a signal of technical possibility, not proof that machines can decide every difficult legal question.
The distinction between improving a workflow and creating a new service is strategically important. A digital form that merely reproduces a paper form online changes convenience; a system that helps people recognize a legal problem or settle it without a court changes access and institutional design. Still, prediction about technical capability is not the same as evidence of dependable legal performance. A system may process information quickly while misunderstanding a person’s circumstances. The sensible test is not novelty, but whether the tool improves accuracy, access, and accountability for a defined task.
Make justice accessible before disputes reach expensive courtrooms
Access begins before advice. Many people do not know when a life event has legal consequences, how to find suitable help, or how to afford it. Susskind broadens access to justice beyond resolving disputes. It also includes preventing disagreements from escalating, avoiding disputes in the first place, and helping people use legal rights and protections before a crisis.
Online services open routes. A person might use online guidance, a standard document, a community resource, or a lawyer found through price and reputation information. Online dispute resolution can handle some claims without a physical hearing. The book cites Money Claim Online in England and Wales, which handled more than 60,000 claims a year, and eBay’s online processes for a volume of disputes that conventional courts could not practically absorb. These examples show how digital services can make help available at scale, especially when conventional advice is unaffordable.
The broader definition of justice changes the unit of analysis from courtroom access to people’s ability to navigate legal life. Early guidance may prevent a conflict from becoming more expensive and entrenched, while clear online processes can help people who would otherwise do nothing. But access is not merely the presence of a website. Users need understandable language, reliable information, privacy, and a way to reach a human adviser when the problem exceeds the system’s competence. Digital service expands the doorway only if the doorway leads somewhere safe.
Redesign legal departments around risk, value, and informed purchasing
In-house counsel can shape the market. General Counsel often say their proper role is to manage legal risk, yet daily demands can leave them reacting to problems rather than preventing them. Susskind argues that legal departments should identify recurring risks, use standard processes and shared knowledge, and decide which work truly needs specialist advice. He also urges clients to assess their total legal needs from a blank slate rather than choosing only between internal lawyers and outside firms.
Buy on purpose. Clients can reduce unnecessary spending by changing work methods, sourcing routine tasks differently, or sharing common services with other organizations. Their purchasing power can also encourage firms to improve cost, service, and collaboration. The pressures reach law firms unevenly: exceptional expertise and high-stakes bespoke work may endure, while generalist practices built around routine work and large junior teams face stronger competition. Niche expertise and personal service can remain valuable when clients will pay for them.
This reframes the General Counsel from a gatekeeper of legal questions into a designer of organizational capability. Risk management, knowledge systems, and procurement become part of legal work because they determine whether problems arise and how expensive they become. The approach also exposes a conflict of incentives: a provider paid for each hour may not be rewarded for preventing demand. Yet clients need more than aggressive cost-cutting. If a department removes capacity without understanding the risks it serves, savings can simply defer costs until a problem becomes harder to contain.
Build expertise where law meets technology, operations, and risk
New work surrounds legal knowledge. Susskind predicts roles that translate law into usable systems, connect legal and technical teams, analyze processes, manage projects, guide online dispute resolution, advise legal departments, and identify risks before they become disputes. These jobs need legal understanding alongside skills in technology, management, communication, or risk analysis. He cautions against claiming expertise in another discipline after only a short introduction: genuine hybrid work requires serious training.
Employers diversify too. Future legal jobs may be found not only in firms or corporate legal departments, but also in accounting businesses, publishers, legal technology companies, process outsourcers, online service providers, flexible-lawyer agencies, retailers, and new-model law firms. Susskind’s advice is not to assume that a legal career has failed if a traditional training place is unavailable. The work of turning legal knowledge into reliable services can take place in many kinds of organization.
These roles point to a broader professional identity: legal expertise can shape products, processes, and institutions, not just answer a client’s immediate question. That makes interdisciplinary skill valuable, but breadth is not a shortcut around competence. A lawyer who claims to be a technologist or management consultant without deep training risks becoming a translator who cannot deliver either discipline well. The strongest hybrid professionals are likely to know where their expertise ends and how to work with specialists rather than borrowing their vocabulary.
Replace billable busywork with apprenticeship, simulation, and deliberate training
Routine work is not a full education. Firms have often treated document review and due diligence as the training ground for young lawyers. But trainees interviewed by Susskind said they could learn the mechanics of reviewing documents in hours, not months. He warns against confusing useful training with routine labor that supports a firm’s traditional profit model. Clients increasingly resist paying high rates for junior lawyers who are still learning.
Teach the work that matters. Susskind proposes closer apprenticeship with experienced practitioners, supervised samples of work assigned to outside providers, and technology-enabled learning. One example is Ardcalloch, a simulated town where students practise law in a virtual environment, interacting with fictional clients and institutions and handling simulated transactions and disputes. Online tutorials and supervision can also make focused instruction easier to revisit. Training should teach judgment and client service, not depend on endless low-value repetition.
The training problem is real: if routine tasks disappear, firms cannot assume that expertise will somehow emerge without structured practice. The book’s answer shifts learning from passive repetition toward observation, simulation, and feedback. That model treats training as an investment the employer must consciously provide rather than a by-product charged to clients. Its success depends on thoughtful design, however. Simulations can rehearse procedures, but they cannot fully reproduce the moral pressure, ambiguity, and responsibility of real client work. Graduates still need supervised opportunities to make consequential judgments.
Measure legal innovation by client value and public access, not tradition
Sell the outcome, not the tool. Susskind tells a story about a power-tool company that reminds new executives that customers want holes in wood, not drills. The legal equivalent is that clients need useful knowledge, sound decisions, and problems resolved or prevented, not necessarily a meeting with a lawyer or a bill measured in hours. New delivery methods should be judged by whether they provide that value more conveniently, affordably, and reliably.
Protect the public purpose. The book distinguishes lawyers who steward legal knowledge for society from those who guard professional territory for its own sake. Its closing challenge is to identify honestly which activities require qualified lawyers, then make other services accessible through responsible alternatives. For a young lawyer assessing an employer, this means asking whether it has a credible long-term strategy, invests in useful technology, and is willing to rethink its services rather than relying on the habits that once made it profitable.
The customer-value lens helps separate a profession’s public purpose from its familiar rituals. It also makes innovation answerable to a concrete question: does this method help people solve a legal problem, or does it merely preserve the provider’s preferred way of working? The analogy has limits. Legal services are not ordinary consumer goods, because rights, procedural fairness, and confidentiality cannot be reduced to convenience. The strongest version of the argument therefore pairs access with safeguards, expanding service without treating professional judgment as an obstacle to be removed.
Analysis
Tomorrow’s Lawyers is best understood as a systems argument, not a prediction that software will simply replace attorneys. Its central claim is that legal service is a production model: knowledge is gathered, interpreted, organized, and delivered through particular institutions. When clients cannot afford the dominant delivery method, and technology makes other methods feasible, the profession must reconsider how the work is assembled. This explains the book’s progression from cost pressure, through alternative sourcing, to digital services and new occupations.
The most durable insight is the separation of legal value from the familiar form of legal work. A client may need judgment, but not every task surrounding that judgment requires a lawyer. Decomposing work makes that distinction operational. It also reveals the book’s major institutional challenge: legal expertise must be preserved even as routine work moves elsewhere. Training, quality control, professional responsibility, and coordination are not peripheral concerns; they determine whether efficiency becomes better service or simply cheaper risk.
The argument is compelling, but its forecasts require caution. The book’s technological examples and dates reflect its 2012 vantage point, and technical capability alone does not establish reliable performance in law. Legal decisions involve incomplete facts, conflicting values, and consequences for people who may have little power to challenge an automated error. Similarly, digital access can widen availability while leaving some users unable to navigate online systems. These limitations do not defeat the case for innovation. They make governance, human escalation, and evidence of quality essential parts of innovation.
The ethical conclusion follows from the practical one. A profession cannot justify restricting access merely because its members have historically delivered a service. Nor should efficiency be treated as the only measure of justice. The book’s enduring challenge is to redesign the delivery of legal knowledge while protecting the judgment, fairness, and trust that make law socially valuable.
Review Summary
Tomorrow's Lawyers predicts major changes in the legal profession due to technology and economic pressures. Readers find Susskind's insights thought-provoking, especially for law students and young lawyers. Many praise the book's readability and relevance, though some criticize its focus on big law firms. Opinions vary on the depth and practicality of Susskind's predictions. Overall, reviewers consider it an important read for understanding the future of legal services, despite some finding parts repetitive or lacking detail on specific skills needed.
People Also Read
Glossary
More-for-less challenge
More service, lower costThe pressure on legal departments, businesses, and individuals to obtain more legal work and support while spending less. The challenge is especially acute for General Counsel, who may face shrinking budgets alongside growing workloads and compliance duties. Susskind argues that it cannot be solved simply by negotiating lower fees; legal work itself must be delivered differently.
Liberalization
Broader access to legal marketsThe relaxation of rules that limit who may own legal businesses or provide legal services. Susskind distinguishes liberalization from removing all regulation: new providers and business structures can be permitted while remaining subject to oversight. He uses England and Wales, where alternative business structures became possible under the Legal Services Act 2007, as a prominent example.
Commoditization
Routine legal help at scaleSusskind uses this term for legal work so common and repeatable that it can be made readily available, often online and at low or no cost. He distinguishes it from simply using templates or standard procedures. In his account, commoditization can reduce the commercial value of some routine legal services while making basic help accessible to people who could not afford traditional advice.
Decomposing
Breaking matters into tasksThe analysis of a legal matter as a collection of separate tasks rather than one indivisible assignment. A dispute, for example, may include document review, research, strategy, negotiation, and advocacy. Once tasks are identified, each can be assigned to the provider or method best suited to it. Decomposing is the basis for sourcing work selectively rather than sending an entire matter to one firm.
Multi-sourcing
Combining several service providersThe coordinated use of multiple sources to complete one legal matter. These sources might include a client’s own staff, a law firm, paralegals, specialist contractors, offshore teams, or software. The aim is to match each task with an appropriate provider while maintaining responsibility for the completed service. This approach requires coordination, quality control, and a clear understanding of how the separate contributions fit together.
Online dispute resolution (ODR)
Resolving disputes through the InternetMethods in which some or most of a dispute’s resolution takes place online. ODR can include electronic negotiation, online mediation, or structured settlement systems. Susskind points to online platforms handling large volumes of disagreements and to Money Claim Online, which lets users pursue eligible money claims without attending a conventional court. ODR may involve human decision-makers, automated processes, or a combination.
Expert trusted adviser
Personal counsel for complex mattersSusskind’s description of a lawyer whose expertise is needed for complex, high-value, or unusual legal problems. The expert trusted adviser can develop a tailored strategy and communicate it with judgment, integrity, and attention to the client’s circumstances. This is a continuing role in his forecast, but it should not be used to describe every routine task performed within a legal matter.
Legal knowledge engineer
Structuring law for usable systemsA lawyer who analyzes and organizes legal knowledge so that it can be represented in standards, procedures, online services, or computer systems. The work involves legal research and judgment, not merely technical implementation: the specialist must determine how legal rules and experience can be expressed accurately enough to support many users or situations. Susskind sees this as a demanding role in technology-enabled legal services.
Legal risk management
Preventing legal problems proactivelyThe systematic identification, assessment, monitoring, and control of legal risks facing an organization. Rather than responding only after a dispute or compliance failure occurs, legal risk management uses tools such as audits, standard documents, procedures, and legal education to reduce the chance of problems. Susskind presents it as a central responsibility for in-house legal teams and a potential specialist career.
FAQ
What's "Tomorrow's Lawyers: An Introduction to Your Future" about?
- Future of Legal Profession: The book explores the future of the legal profession, predicting significant changes in how legal services will be delivered over the next two decades.
- Drivers of Change: It identifies three main drivers of change: the more-for-less challenge, liberalization, and information technology, which will reshape the legal landscape.
- New Opportunities: Susskind discusses new roles and opportunities for lawyers, emphasizing the need for adaptation and innovation in legal practice.
- Target Audience: The book is aimed at young and aspiring lawyers, as well as experienced practitioners interested in the future of legal services.
Why should I read "Tomorrow's Lawyers"?
- Insightful Predictions: Richard Susskind provides a clear and compelling vision of the future of legal services, which is essential for anyone in the legal profession.
- Practical Advice: The book offers practical strategies for adapting to the changes in the legal market, making it a valuable resource for legal professionals.
- Career Guidance: It highlights new career opportunities and roles that will emerge in the legal field, helping readers prepare for the future.
- Engaging and Accessible: Written in an engaging and accessible style, the book is suitable for both newcomers to the legal field and seasoned professionals.
What are the key takeaways of "Tomorrow's Lawyers"?
- Embrace Change: Lawyers must be open to change and willing to adapt to new technologies and business models to remain relevant.
- New Roles: The legal profession will see the emergence of new roles such as legal knowledge engineers, legal technologists, and legal project managers.
- Client-Centric Approach: Legal services will need to focus more on client needs, offering more efficient and cost-effective solutions.
- Collaboration and Innovation: Collaboration among legal professionals and the use of innovative technologies will be crucial for success in the future legal market.
What are the best quotes from "Tomorrow's Lawyers" and what do they mean?
- "We are on the brink of fundamental change in the world of law." This quote highlights the imminent and significant transformations expected in the legal profession.
- "The future of legal service is neither Grisham nor Rumpole." Susskind emphasizes that traditional images of lawyers will be replaced by new, technology-driven roles.
- "The best way to predict the future is to invent it." This encourages lawyers to actively shape the future of their profession rather than passively waiting for changes to occur.
- "Lawyers should work in the law in the interests of society and not of lawyers." This quote underscores the importance of prioritizing client needs and societal benefits over personal gain.
How does Richard Susskind define the "more-for-less" challenge?
- Client Pressure: Clients are demanding more legal services at lower costs, putting pressure on legal professionals to find more efficient ways of working.
- Economic Conditions: The challenge is driven by difficult economic conditions, which require legal services to be delivered more cost-effectively.
- Impact on Law Firms: Law firms must adapt by adopting new technologies and business models to meet client demands and remain competitive.
- Central Theme: The more-for-less challenge is a central theme in the book, highlighting the need for innovation and change in the legal profession.
What is the role of technology in the future of legal services according to "Tomorrow's Lawyers"?
- Disruptive Technologies: Technologies such as AI, online legal services, and automated document assembly will fundamentally change how legal services are delivered.
- Efficiency and Cost-Effectiveness: Technology will enable more efficient and cost-effective legal services, meeting the demands of the more-for-less challenge.
- New Opportunities: The rise of technology will create new roles and opportunities for legal professionals, such as legal technologists and knowledge engineers.
- Pervasive Influence: Information technology will be a pervasive influence, affecting all aspects of legal practice and the administration of justice.
What are the new roles for lawyers discussed in "Tomorrow's Lawyers"?
- Legal Knowledge Engineers: These professionals will organize and model complex legal materials and processes, often using technology.
- Legal Technologists: They will bridge the gap between law and technology, helping to implement IT solutions in legal practice.
- Legal Project Managers: These individuals will oversee the delivery of legal services, ensuring efficiency and quality in multi-sourced projects.
- ODR Practitioners: With the rise of online dispute resolution, new roles will emerge for specialists in this area.
How does "Tomorrow's Lawyers" address the issue of access to justice?
- Online Legal Services: Susskind advocates for the use of online legal services to make legal help more accessible and affordable.
- Dispute Resolution: The book discusses the potential of online dispute resolution (ODR) to provide efficient and cost-effective solutions.
- Legal Exclusion: It highlights the problem of legal exclusion, where many people cannot afford traditional legal services.
- Innovative Solutions: Susskind emphasizes the need for innovative solutions to improve access to justice for all.
What is the significance of liberalization in the legal market according to "Tomorrow's Lawyers"?
- New Business Models: Liberalization allows for new business models, such as alternative business structures (ABS), which can offer legal services in innovative ways.
- Increased Competition: It introduces new competitors into the legal market, challenging traditional law firms to adapt and innovate.
- Global Impact: The ripple effect of liberalization in some countries will influence legal markets worldwide, driving further change.
- Client Benefits: Clients will benefit from increased choice and potentially lower costs as a result of liberalization.
How does "Tomorrow's Lawyers" suggest law firms should adapt to the future?
- Alternative Sourcing: Law firms should explore alternative sourcing strategies, such as outsourcing and off-shoring, to reduce costs.
- Embrace Technology: Firms need to adopt new technologies to improve efficiency and meet client demands.
- Focus on Clients: A client-centric approach, focusing on delivering value and meeting client needs, will be essential for success.
- Innovative Thinking: Law firms should foster a culture of innovation, encouraging new ideas and approaches to legal service delivery.
What are the challenges and opportunities for in-house legal departments in "Tomorrow's Lawyers"?
- More-for-Less Challenge: In-house legal departments face the same pressure to deliver more services at lower costs.
- Risk Management: They will need to focus on legal risk management, anticipating and preventing legal issues before they arise.
- Collaboration: In-house departments can benefit from collaborating with external law firms and other organizations to share resources and expertise.
- Strategic Role: In-house lawyers will play a more strategic role within their organizations, contributing to overall business success.
How does "Tomorrow's Lawyers" propose to train future lawyers?
- New Skills: Training should include new skills such as project management, risk management, and technology proficiency.
- E-Learning: The use of e-learning and simulation-based training can provide more effective and flexible learning experiences.
- Practical Experience: Apprenticeship models and hands-on experience will be crucial for developing practical legal skills.
- Future-Focused Curriculum: Law schools should offer courses that prepare students for the future legal market, including emerging roles and technologies.
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.