Key Takeaways
See Mexico as an intimate stranger already inside American daily life
Hazleton makes the connection visible. In this Pennsylvania city, Mexican immigration helped revive a declining economy, while Mexican-owned companies supplied local jobs and familiar foods. Yet growth brought conflict: in 2006, the city passed anti-immigrant ordinances, later struck down by courts. Baseball manager Joe Maddon helped launch the Hazleton Integration Project, bringing longtime residents and newcomers together through youth programs and community events. The result is neither instant harmony nor a simple story of division. It is a community learning, unevenly, to live with change.
The border is not the whole story. Cars, food, energy, investment, films, and family ties connect the countries far from the boundary. Selee calls them intimate strangers: societies deeply linked in practice, but often lacking shared understanding of that closeness.
What's striking is the gap between material connection and felt belonging. A town can rely on Mexican-owned employers and still debate whether Mexican families belong there. That is a familiar problem in social science: economic interdependence does not automatically create trust, especially when change arrives quickly and institutions do little to help residents meet as equals. The book's strongest move is to make national relations tangible through one town's restaurants, workplaces, and schools. Its optimism is most persuasive when paired with the reminder that contact needs deliberate civic investment to become solidarity.
Protect the production chains that keep North American goods competitive
Trade became joint production. Since NAFTA took effect in 1994, trade among the United States, Mexico, and Canada quadrupled. The deeper shift is that companies now make products together. A car may use US steel, Mexican brakes, and parts from Canada, crossing borders several times before assembly. About half of US-Mexico trade involves intermediate goods, or parts used to make finished products. An estimated 15 to 20 percent of Mexican exports to the United States consists of US-made content, compared with about 4 percent for Chinese exports.
Integration has costs and gains. Some US jobs moved to Mexico, but shared supply chains also helped industries compete globally. American manufacturing output more than doubled after 1980 even as employment fell, largely because automation reduced labor needs. The book argues that dismantling these supply chains would raise costs and weaken all three economies.
The production-chain lens corrects a common accounting error: treating imports as though they contain no domestic work. When components cross borders repeatedly, a national trade balance cannot capture the full distribution of wages, investment, and expertise. But aggregate gains do not compensate every worker or town that loses a plant. The book acknowledges this unevenness, though its regional story could support an even sharper policy question: who bears transition costs, and who receives the gains? Integration is not automatically fair. Its durability depends on labor protections, retraining, and credible support for communities exposed to industrial change.
Track investment by who builds the business, not by its familiar brand
Mexican capital supports American jobs. DeAcero, a Mexican steelmaker, bought Mid-Continent Nails in Poplar Bluff, Missouri, when the last large US nail factory was struggling against cheap imports. By supplying steel from Mexico, DeAcero helped the plant expand from fewer than 400 workers to about 600 and more than doubled daily production. The company picnic even gained a new menu item: tacos. The point is larger than one factory. By 2016, Mexican direct investment in the United States had reached $17 billion, and Mexican-owned companies employed at least 123,000 Americans.
Ownership is often hard to see. Bimbo owns major US bread brands, while Mexican firms operate in dairy, cement, glass, and auto parts. These companies often retain familiar American names and hire locally. Their investments can complement operations in Mexico rather than simply shift them across the border.
The Poplar Bluff example makes foreign investment legible at the human scale: capital from one country can preserve an industry in another when production inputs and markets fit together. This complicates the assumption that cross-border investment is a contest with one national winner. Still, the case should not be generalized into a guarantee that investment benefits every worker. Outcomes depend on company decisions, local bargaining power, and whether gains reach wages and public life. The useful habit is to ask what a company produces, where its inputs come from, and whom it employs, rather than infer its effects from the flag associated with its owner.
Grow innovation by solving local problems with cross-border talent
Guadalajara changed its role. The city first attracted foreign technology factories, but many assembly jobs moved to Asia after China entered the World Trade Organization. Guadalajara rebuilt around engineering, design, research, and software. When Hewlett-Packard's local team designed a printer, the city had moved from assembling technology to creating it. Silicon Valley entrepreneur Bismarck Lepe later built substantial operations there, drawn by skilled programmers, lower costs, and the same time zone. Softtek, a Mexican IT company, used that time-zone advantage to offer nearshoring: outsourcing work to a nearby country where teams can collaborate in real time.
Useful innovation starts close to real needs. Guadalajara start-ups developed online loans for people excluded from traditional banking, remote diagnostic tests for clinics, and tools to help blind users navigate. Universities, companies, investors, and government programs helped create the surrounding ecosystem.
This account challenges the idea that innovation is a rare gift concentrated in a few celebrated cities. Guadalajara's shift depended on accumulated skills, university partnerships, entrepreneurs, and access to customers and capital across the border. Economic geography helps explain the pattern: proximity can make collaboration easier even when wages are not the lowest. Yet an ecosystem is more than a cluster of start-ups. The book itself points to a difficult bottleneck: businesses need routes to grow, including investors and viable exits. Success stories show capacity, not proof that the wider labor market has become secure or broadly innovative.
Plan energy security across borders, not inside national silos
Energy already flows both ways. Mexico, once burdened by expensive electricity, increasingly imports natural gas from the United States through pipelines. By the period covered in the book, nearly half of US natural-gas exports went to Mexico, helping Mexican manufacturers reduce costs while giving American producers a nearby market. Mexico's 2013 energy reform also opened oil exploration to private investment and expanded opportunities for wind, solar, and bioenergy. In Baja California, wind turbines send renewable electricity north to California.
Shared grids add resilience. Cross-border electricity connections can help one side when the other faces a supply shortage. A link between Texas and Mexico supported both grids during severe weather in 2011. The author argues that combining North American resources could improve energy security, while acknowledging that the electricity market between Mexico and the United States remains far less integrated than the US-Canada system.
Energy cooperation illustrates how interdependence can function as insurance: a wider network offers more options when one region faces a shortage. It also shows why infrastructure and regulation matter as much as resource deposits. Pipelines and grid ties create durable relationships that outlast political slogans. The term energy security, however, can obscure a real tension. Lower-cost gas may improve industrial competitiveness while extending dependence on fossil fuels. The book notes growing renewable investment, but a robust strategy must judge the system by reliability and affordability as well as emissions, land use, and the communities affected by new infrastructure.
Judge migration by what it changes at both ends of the journey
Migration reshapes sending and receiving towns. Demetrio Juárez left rural Atzompa, Puebla, to work in New York and later opened a restaurant in Hazleton. Money he and his father sent home helped six siblings finish high school and five attend college. Across Mexico, remittances averaged roughly $21 billion to $27 billion annually in the period described, supporting education, health, and local businesses. In Zacatecas, migrant associations and government matching funds helped finance small firms, farms, and clinics. These investments helped some communities create jobs and keep residents closer to home.
The flow changed direction. Large-scale Mexican migration to the United States slowed after 2007, and more Mexicans began returning than arriving. Around a million Americans lived in Mexico, many of them children of Mexican parents who had returned. The migration hump describes a common pattern in which emigration can rise as incomes first improve, then fall as staying becomes more viable.
The two-ended view avoids reducing migrants to labor supply or border statistics. Remittances can finance schooling and businesses, while migration can also remove workers and divide families. The same person may contribute to both countries through work, investment, and family care. This resembles the idea of transnational households, whose economic and emotional lives span national boundaries. Still, community investment cannot substitute for dependable public services or good jobs, and remittances reach families unevenly. The book's account is strongest when it treats migration as one force among several, alongside education, economic change, and political reform.
Pair cross-border crime fighting with trustworthy local institutions
Cooperation became operational. After Mexico offered disaster aid following Hurricane Katrina, officials on both sides began building trust. That opening contributed to the Merida Initiative, a US-Mexico security partnership that supplied equipment, training, and technical support without placing US troops in Mexico. Agencies later shared intelligence through joint working arrangements. In one example, a binational fusion center helped map the Zetas, a violent criminal organization, and supported operations that captured its leaders and weakened its structure.
Raids cannot repair institutions alone. In Tijuana and Ciudad Juárez, journalists, civic groups, police, and government officials helped reduce violence and strengthen local responses. Yet Mexican homicide rates rose again as heroin demand in the United States increased and Mexican institutions remained vulnerable to corruption. The author argues that security requires policing and intelligence, but also courts, accountable government, and community resilience.
The security narrative resists two easy answers: that a wall can stop criminal networks, or that targeting leaders will solve the problem. Intelligence-sharing can disrupt organizations, but durable safety depends on whether local institutions can resist corruption and protect residents. This is a systems problem: demand, money, weapons, policing, courts, and community conditions interact across borders. The book also identifies an important imbalance. Cooperation against trafficking in Mexico advanced further than understanding the business and financial networks inside the United States. Shared responsibility matters most when it reaches the full supply chain, not only its most visible violence.
Expect Mexican culture to mainstream faster than political representation
Culture crosses through ordinary choices. Mexican food moved from a category many Americans considered ethnic to everyday fare, from fast-casual chains to acclaimed restaurants. Mexican filmmakers and actors also became prominent in Hollywood. The film Instructions Not Included earned about $99 million across the United States, Mexico, and other markets. Sports followed: the NFL marketed to Latino fans, while soccer expanded far beyond Latino communities. These shifts reflect a large, young consumer population, much of it Mexican American.
Political influence follows a slower route. In the book's 2018 context, Latinos made up 17.8 percent of the US population but only 9.2 percent of voters in the 2016 election. Ruben Kihuen's Nevada campaign showed why turnout and representation do not rise automatically with population. Cultural visibility can grow quickly while political power remains uneven.
Markets often recognize demographic change before political institutions do. A restaurant or sports league can test an audience and adjust its product quickly; electoral influence depends on citizenship, turnout, geography, and candidate recruitment. That difference helps explain why cultural presence should not be mistaken for equal power. Mainstreaming also has two sides: it can widen recognition while packaging a culture into marketable symbols. The book captures both the creative influence of Mexican and Mexican American communities and the lag in representation. Its distinction between consumer visibility and civic voice is especially useful for reading demographic change.
Improve the terms of interdependence instead of pretending it can be undone
Shared systems are costly to unwind. The book shows trade, investment, energy, technology, and family ties connecting the two countries even during political conflict. Cross-border delays alone were estimated to reduce economic output in the San Diego region by billions of dollars annually. In manufacturing, companies have made long-term investments in plants and suppliers on both sides. A US withdrawal from NAFTA could impose new costs without making these production relationships disappear.
Integration still needs repair. Mexico's informal businesses face barriers to registration and credit, and weak labor protections can suppress wages. Corruption and uneven rule of law remain serious obstacles. For the United States, rapid demographic change can strain local schools and services and fuel backlash. The book's conclusion is not that connection solves these problems, but that policy should improve how the connection works rather than deny its existence.
The argument is persuasive as a claim about path dependence: once firms, workers, and communities build around shared systems, reversing course is expensive and disruptive. But inevitability should not become an excuse for complacency. Political choices can still alter the rules, slow cooperation, or distribute the costs unfairly. The more useful question is not whether integration exists, but whether it produces secure work, credible institutions, efficient borders, and accountable public services. This framing recognizes both the economic logic of connection and the democratic need to make its benefits visible to people who experience its disruptions.
Analysis
Vanishing Frontiers is best read as an argument about mismatched maps. The public debate often imagines two separate economies and one directional migration stream. Selee assembles evidence that the lived relationship is more complicated: production is shared, capital moves north as well as south, migration has slowed and partly reversed, and cultural influence travels through food, film, sports, and family life. The choice of stories gives that claim unusual reach. A nail factory in Missouri, a restaurant in Pennsylvania, and a technology cluster in Guadalajara make abstractions visible without reducing the book to a single border-city perspective.
The economic case is especially strong when it distinguishes trade from production. A car assembled in one country can contain work and materials from all three North American partners, so national import-export totals miss important connections. This reframing corrects zero-sum rhetoric, but it cannot settle questions of fairness. Aggregate output and employment figures do not tell us which workers lost bargaining power, which towns suffered plant closures, or whether gains were broadly shared. The book points toward labor enforcement and community effects, though its emphasis on interdependence sometimes gives less space to the distributional conflicts that make integration politically fragile.
Its treatment of security provides an important counterweight to economic optimism. Cooperation helped authorities map and weaken major criminal organizations, while civic pressure and judicial reform improved local capacity in some places. Yet violent crime rose again, showing that enforcement gains are contingent and that drug demand, corruption, and weak institutions remain connected problems. Cooperation is therefore not a solved success story but an infrastructure that requires political attention and public accountability.
The deepest implication is that familiarity and integration are not the same as mutual understanding. Americans may eat Mexican food, buy products from Mexican-owned firms, and rely on cross-border supply chains while still perceiving Mexico mainly through migration or crime. Policy becomes brittle when its categories lag behind lived reality. The book's bridge metaphor is most convincing when treated not as proof that borders no longer matter, but as a demand to govern the connections that already do.
Review Summary
The reviews for Vanishing frontiers are generally positive, with readers appreciating its insights into the growing interdependence between the US and Mexico. Many found it informative, well-researched, and timely, highlighting economic, cultural, and social connections. Readers praised the author's balanced approach and clear writing style. Some critics felt it lacked sufficient data or was too anecdotal. Overall, reviewers recommend it for those interested in understanding the complex US-Mexico relationship, especially in the context of current political rhetoric.
People Also Read
Glossary
Intimate strangers
Connected, but poorly understoodSelee's description of the United States and Mexico after decades of growing economic, social, and cultural ties. The countries increasingly depend on one another, and many families and businesses span the border, yet people in each country often lack a clear understanding of the other's society and of their shared relationship.
shared production platform
Cross-border manufacturing networkA production system in which businesses in the United States, Mexico, and Canada contribute parts, labor, design, or assembly to the same finished goods. Components may cross borders several times before a product reaches customers. The concept explains why North American trade is not simply the exchange of finished goods between separate national economies.
nearshoring
Outsourcing to nearby countriesA term used by Softtek's Blanca Treviño and colleagues for outsourcing work to a nearby country, particularly Mexico for US companies. Shared time zones and short travel distances can make it easier for teams to communicate and work in real time than with more distant outsourcing locations.
migration hump
Emigration rises, then fallsA model describing how emigration can initially increase as a country's economy develops, then decline as prosperity and opportunity make staying more attractive. Early growth gives more people the resources to migrate while economic disruption can encourage departure. At higher income levels, more people may decide that remaining at home offers a viable future.
Merida Initiative
US-Mexico security partnershipA security cooperation agreement developed by the United States and Mexico in 2007 to address organized crime. US support included equipment, software, and training for Mexican agencies, along with assistance aimed at strengthening rule of law. Its design avoided direct cash transfers and US military personnel operating on the ground in Mexico.
Customs Trade Partnership Against Terrorism (CTPAT)
Vetted shipper security programA US customs program for companies involved in cross-border shipping. Participating firms undergo background checks and follow security procedures for packaging and transporting goods. In return, qualifying shipments can use faster border routes and may face fewer inspections, allowing authorities to focus more attention on shipments assessed as higher risk.
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.