Plot Summary
Pirate Queen's Ruthless Justice
The notorious pirate Lady Vice, half-fae and fiercely independent, leads her crew in capturing a slaver ship. She metes out her own brand of justice, marooning the slaver officers on a deserted island, showing both her ruthlessness and her code—she despises slavery and those who profit from it. Her fae gift allows her to command the sea, making her a formidable force. Yet, beneath her bravado, Vice yearns for more than just being a first mate—she wants her own ship and the freedom of true command. This opening sets the tone: Vice is both feared and admired, a woman who makes her own rules and is haunted by a past she refuses to name.
The Hunter and the Hunted
Vice's ambitions are complicated when she learns a pirate hunter, Captain Knigh Blackwood, has arrived in Port Royal, specifically to capture her. Blackwood is disciplined, haunted by his own demons, and driven by duty and a need to provide for his family. Their first encounter is at a governor's ball, where Vice, disguised as a lady, flirts with him, both seeking information and testing her own power. The tension between them is immediate—attraction laced with danger. Vice's fae charm and Blackwood's rigid self-control set up a battle of wits and wills, with both underestimating the other.
A Ship Worth Stealing
Vice's longing for command crystallizes when she sets her sights on the Venatrix, a sleek, fast ship captained by Blackwood. The Venatrix is a pirate hunter's vessel, but Vice sees it as the perfect ship for her own ambitions. She schemes to steal it, believing it will finally earn her the captaincy FitzRoy has long promised. Her obsession with the ship mirrors her desire for autonomy and recognition. Meanwhile, Blackwood's presence in port raises the stakes, as he is both a threat and a temptation, and Vice's plans become more daring.
Masks at the Governor's Ball
Disguised as a lady, Vice infiltrates the governor's ball to gather intelligence on Blackwood. Their dance of words is charged with flirtation and hidden motives. Vice is both drawn to and wary of Blackwood, who is equally intrigued by her. The ball is a microcosm of their relationship—masks, secrets, and the ever-present risk of exposure. When Vice is forced to make a hasty escape, she leaves Blackwood—and the governor's daughter—reeling, her legend growing even as the danger mounts.
Dangerous Liaisons
Vice's reckless streak puts her at odds with her quartermaster, Perry, and her captain, FitzRoy. She is determined to prove herself, even as Perry warns her of the risks. Blackwood, meanwhile, is frustrated by Vice's elusiveness and the rumors swirling around her. Both are drawn into a web of schemes—Vice to sabotage the Venatrix, Blackwood to set a trap using rumors of Drake's treasure. Their mutual obsession drives them toward confrontation, each believing they can outwit the other.
Sails, Sabotage, and Escape
Under cover of night, Vice sneaks aboard the Venatrix, disabling its sails and stealing what she believes is a clue to Drake's legendary treasure. Her fae magic and daring make the operation a success, and she escapes just as Blackwood realizes he's been played. The next day, as the Morrigan sails past the crippled Venatrix, Vice's triumph is tempered by the realization that Blackwood is a more dangerous adversary than she thought. Their rivalry is now personal, and the stakes have never been higher.
The Bounty and Betrayal
Vice's theft of the supposed treasure clue leads to tension with FitzRoy, who is obsessed with Drake's gold. When the clue turns out to be a fake—Blackwood's trap—FitzRoy's anger boils over, and Vice's position becomes precarious. Meanwhile, Blackwood's plan to lure the pirates works, but he is unsettled by his growing fascination with Vice. Both are caught between duty and desire, and the lines between friend and foe blur as betrayals mount.
Storms, Treasures, and Traps
The Morrigan and her crew pursue rumors of treasure, leading to a series of battles and narrow escapes. Vice's leadership is tested as she faces not only external threats but also doubts from her crew and herself. Blackwood, too, is forced to confront his own limits, especially as his feelings for Vice deepen. Their encounters are charged with both violence and longing, and the sea itself becomes a metaphor for the tumult within them.
The Battle for Veritas
The Morrigan captures the Veritas, but the victory is costly. Vice's tactics are bold but dangerous, and the crew suffers losses. Blackwood, caught in the crossfire, must choose between his mission and his conscience. In the aftermath, a letter of marque is offered, turning pirates into privateers—but the alliance is uneasy, and old wounds fester. Vice's dream of command is within reach, but at a price.
Letters of Marque
The crew of the Morrigan is granted a royal pardon and a letter of marque, legitimizing their actions as privateers. FitzRoy, however, gives command of the coveted new ship not to Vice but to Perry, deepening Vice's sense of betrayal. Blackwood, now an official observer, is forced to live among those he once hunted. The new arrangement brings both opportunity and tension, as Vice and Blackwood's relationship grows more complicated, and the threat of royal politics looms.
Royal Deceptions
The arrival of the Duke of Mercia and the death of the Queen throw everything into chaos. Vice's true identity as Lady Avice Ferrers, long thought dead, is revealed to Blackwood, who is himself her former betrothed. The revelation is both a shock and a turning point, forcing both to confront their pasts and the lies they've told themselves and each other. As the crew is betrayed from within, Vice is arrested and faces execution, her legend now a weapon used against her.
The Iron Cage
Vice is sentenced to death and locked in an iron gibbet, her fae blood making the punishment torture. Isolated and betrayed by those she trusted, she is forced to confront her own vulnerability and the limits of her strength. Blackwood, wracked with guilt and realizing the full extent of his mistake, is denied access to her. Both are trapped—Vice by iron and fate, Blackwood by his own choices and the weight of duty.
The Great Escape
Blackwood, risking everything, breaks Vice out of her cage. Their escape is fraught with danger, as the city is scoured by marines and the threat of recapture looms. Disguised as a married couple, they must rely on each other to survive. The escape is both physical and emotional, as they are forced to confront the pain and betrayal between them. Their alliance is uneasy, but necessity binds them together.
Truths Unmasked
Safe for the moment, Vice and Blackwood finally speak the truths they've avoided—about their past, their feelings, and the betrayals that have shaped them. The revelation that Vice is Avice Ferrers, and that Blackwood's actions nearly destroyed her, brings both pain and the possibility of healing. Their relationship, forged in conflict, is now tempered by honesty, but forgiveness is not easily won.
Allies and Enemies
As they flee Albion, Vice and Blackwood must navigate a world where friends can become enemies and enemies, allies. The crew is scattered, and FitzRoy's betrayal still stings. Vice is determined to reclaim her power and seek revenge—not through violence, but by outwitting those who wronged her. Blackwood, now a fugitive, must find a new purpose beyond duty and vengeance. Together, they chart a course for Arawaké, uncertain of what awaits.
The Price of Freedom
The cost of escape is high—Vice's health is shattered by her ordeal, and Blackwood has lost everything he once valued. Both must come to terms with what they have sacrificed for freedom, and what they are willing to risk for each other. Their journey is one of recovery and reckoning, as they seek to rebuild not just their lives, but their sense of self.
Homecoming and Heartbreak
As they reach the open ocean, Vice and Blackwood are free but not unburdened. The wounds of betrayal and loss linger, and the future is uncertain. Vice is determined to find her crew, reclaim her place, and pursue the legendary treasure that has eluded so many. Blackwood, haunted by guilt and longing, must decide where his loyalties truly lie. Their partnership is fragile, but the sea calls them onward.
On Wilder Seas Again
The story ends with Vice and Blackwood setting sail for Arawaké, united by necessity and a shared goal: to find Drake's treasure and take revenge on those who betrayed them. Their relationship, forged in fire, is both a source of strength and a reminder of all they have lost. The horizon is uncertain, but together, they are ready to face whatever storms may come.
Characters
Lady Vice (Avice Ferrers)
Vice is the half-fae, former heiress who has remade herself as a pirate queen. Her journey is one of self-invention and survival, driven by a need to escape the constraints of her past and the pain of loss. Vice is bold, cunning, and often reckless, using humor and bravado to mask her vulnerabilities. Her fae gift—command over the sea—makes her both powerful and isolated. She craves autonomy and recognition, but her trust is hard-won and easily shattered. Her relationship with Blackwood is fraught with tension, attraction, and betrayal, forcing her to confront the parts of herself she most fears. Vice's arc is one of learning to balance strength with vulnerability, and to find connection without surrendering her independence.
Captain Knigh Blackwood (Knighton Villiers)
Blackwood is a naval officer turned pirate hunter, driven by duty, guilt, and the need to provide for his family. Haunted by past violence and the burden of responsibility, he is a man of rigid self-control, often at war with his own emotions. His pursuit of Vice is both professional and personal, complicated by a growing attraction and the revelation of their shared past. Blackwood's journey is one of learning to trust—not just others, but himself—and to accept that justice and mercy are not always the same. His betrayal of Vice is both a tragic mistake and a catalyst for his transformation, as he risks everything to save her and, in doing so, begins to heal his own wounds.
FitzRoy
FitzRoy is the captain of the Morrigan and Vice's former lover. He is charming and driven, obsessed with finding Drake's treasure and securing his own legacy. His relationship with Vice is complex—part mentor, part rival, part lover—but ultimately poisoned by jealousy and pride. FitzRoy's betrayal is a turning point, revealing the dangers of unchecked ambition and the corrosive power of envy. He is both a cautionary figure and a mirror for Vice, showing what happens when the pursuit of power eclipses loyalty and love.
Perry
Perry is the Morrigan's quartermaster and Vice's closest friend. She is the voice of reason and caution, often tempering Vice's recklessness with practical advice. Perry's loyalty is unwavering, but she is not afraid to challenge Vice when necessary. Her presence is a grounding force, providing both emotional support and strategic insight. Perry's arc is quieter but no less important, as she navigates the shifting allegiances and dangers of pirate life, always striving to protect those she cares about.
Saba
Saba is a key member of Vice's boarding team, known for her calm under pressure and her skill in battle. She is one of the few who can match Vice's daring, and her friendship is a source of strength. Saba's background as an islander gives her a unique perspective, and her loyalty to Vice is rooted in shared experience and mutual respect.
Bricus
Bricus is the Morrigan's first mate, outwardly jovial but secretly envious of Vice's influence and abilities. His eventual betrayal is a shock, revealing the dangers of unspoken grievances and the fragility of trust within the crew. Bricus embodies the theme of hidden motives and the cost of ambition.
Barnacle
The ship's cat, Barnacle, is more than a mascot—she is a symbol of home, belonging, and the small comforts that persist even in hardship. Her presence is a reminder of the bonds that tie the crew together, and her loyalty to Vice is unwavering, even in the darkest moments.
The Duke of Mercia
The Duke is a royal figure whose presence brings both opportunity and peril. His fae blood and political ambitions make him a formidable adversary, and his interactions with Vice and Blackwood are fraught with tension. The Duke represents the dangers of power without conscience and the complexities of court intrigue.
Lady Perry (Peregrina)
Perry is the heart of the crew, providing both practical support and emotional guidance. Her relationship with Vice is one of deep friendship, and her wisdom often steers the crew through crisis. Perry's role as captain of the Covadonga is both a reward and a burden, highlighting the challenges of leadership and the importance of trust.
Billy Hopper
Billy is a former naval comrade of Blackwood's, now a merchant captain. Despite past trauma and loss, he has built a new life and offers Blackwood a chance at redemption. Billy's forgiveness and generosity are a counterpoint to the betrayals that define much of the story, showing that healing and new beginnings are possible.
Plot Devices
Dual Identities and Hidden Pasts
The novel's central device is the use of hidden identities—Vice as Avice Ferrers, Blackwood as Knighton Villiers. These secrets drive the plot, create dramatic irony, and fuel the emotional arc. The gradual revelation of true identities forces characters to confront their pasts and the lies they've told, both to others and themselves. This device is used to explore themes of reinvention, forgiveness, and the possibility of change.
Enemies-to-Lovers Dynamic
The evolving relationship between Vice and Blackwood is built on the classic enemies-to-lovers trope, heightened by their shared history and conflicting loyalties. Their mutual attraction is both a source of strength and vulnerability, and their journey from adversaries to reluctant allies is marked by moments of passion, misunderstanding, and hard-won trust. This device allows for deep character exploration and emotional stakes.
Foreshadowing and Irony
The narrative is rich with foreshadowing—songs, rumors, and dreams all hint at future events and hidden truths. Irony is woven throughout, from Vice's pursuit of command only to be betrayed, to Blackwood's quest for justice leading him to betray the woman he loves. These devices create suspense and deepen the impact of key revelations.
The Treasure Hunt
The search for Drake's treasure is both a literal and metaphorical journey, representing the characters' desires for freedom, recognition, and redemption. The treasure is a MacGuffin, driving the plot and motivating characters, but its true value lies in what it reveals about their priorities and relationships.
The Letter of Marque
The granting (and revocation) of the letter of marque transforms pirates into privateers and vice versa, blurring the lines between law and outlaw. This device explores themes of authority, legitimacy, and the precariousness of power, as well as the ease with which trust can be manipulated and betrayed.
The Iron Cage
Vice's imprisonment in the iron gibbet is both a literal and symbolic low point, representing the consequences of betrayal and the limits of strength. The iron, deadly to fae-blooded, is a powerful metaphor for the ways in which society punishes those who defy its rules, and for the pain of isolation and vulnerability.
Rescue and Redemption
Blackwood's decision to rescue Vice, at the cost of his own future, is the story's emotional climax. This act of redemption is both a reversal of his earlier betrayal and a testament to the power of love and forgiveness. The escape sequence is a classic adventure set-piece, but it is also a crucible in which both characters are transformed.
Analysis
Beneath Black Sails is a swashbuckling fantasy that deftly blends high-seas adventure, political intrigue, and a deeply emotional enemies-to-lovers romance. At its heart, the novel is about identity—how we define ourselves, how we are shaped by our pasts, and how we can choose to change. Vice and Blackwood are both fugitives from their former selves, haunted by trauma and driven by the need to prove themselves. Their journey is one of mutual discovery, as they are forced to confront not only external threats but also the lies and fears that keep them apart. The novel interrogates the nature of justice and mercy, showing that the line between hero and villain is often blurred. Betrayal and forgiveness are central themes, explored through both personal and political lenses. The use of fantasy elements—fae magic, sea witches, and enchanted blood—serves to heighten the stakes and underscore the characters' otherness, their inability to fit into the worlds that made them. Ultimately, Beneath Black Sails is a story about the cost of freedom and the courage it takes to claim it, even when it means letting go of the past and risking everything for an uncertain future. The novel's modern resonance lies in its celebration of flawed, complex characters who refuse to be defined by others' expectations, and in its insistence that true strength lies in vulnerability, connection, and the willingness to chart one's own course.
Last updated:
