Key Takeaways
Recover enchantment by giving ordinary details your undivided attention.
Wonder begins nearby. May opens in a state of pandemic-era disorientation: her attention skitters, books go unread, and life feels reduced to managing threats. She calls enchantment the recovery of meaning through close attention, not a special effect or escape from reality. As a child, she found it in ordinary scenes: London fireworks glimpsed from her grandparents’ window, lights across the river, and a possible animal track that might have belonged to a badger or a dog. These were not grand landscapes. Their power came from the way she attended to them.
Notice before dismissing. Growing up, she learned to treat beauty as impractical and local nature as second-rate. Adulthood deepened that forgetfulness. Yet the capacity for wonder remains available in a shaft of light, a stone in the hand, or a familiar place seen anew. Enchantment is the meaning made possible by attention and memory.
The book’s most useful move is to make wonder a practice of perception rather than a rare event reserved for spectacular scenery. That shift lowers the threshold: a reader does not need a wilderness trip or a sudden spiritual revelation to begin. It also suggests that attention is not passive reception. What gets noticed becomes part of a person’s remembered world. The limit is that attention alone cannot resolve material causes of distress, including illness, isolation, or overwork. May’s claim is more persuasive as a way to live alongside those conditions than as a cure for them.
Treat attention as a resource, not an endless public utility.
Vigilance has a cost. May describes a mind trapped in cycles of news, social media, and anticipatory worry. Even when no immediate danger arrives, constant scanning consumes the capacity to read, think, and rest. She recognizes a familiar pattern of autistic burnout: exhaustion and overwhelm accumulating after too long spent ignoring personal needs. Her recovery begins not with greater discipline, but with noticing what has quietly disappeared: meditation, reading, solitude, walks, and silence.
Make room to recover. A meditation instruction to sit twice daily had seemed simple until work, parenting, and household care filled the day. May questions a spiritual ideal built around uninterrupted time that some caregivers do not have. A smaller practice, such as taking off her shoes and feeling the ground, is not a failure of seriousness. It is a workable way to restore contact when time and energy are scarce.
This account reframes depletion as an accumulation of losses, not a personal defect. That distinction matters because self-blame often asks an exhausted person to solve overload by exerting more effort. The section also treats care work as a real constraint on contemplative practice rather than an inconvenient interruption. Its challenge is practical: naming attention as precious does not create more of it. The insight becomes most actionable when paired with changes in expectations and shared responsibilities, not only with brief personal rituals.
Turn places into sacred ground through small, repeatable acts of care.
Meaning gathers through ritual. May uses the term hierophany for an ordinary object or place experienced as revealing the sacred. Her grandmother’s slow ritual of peeling and eating an orange becomes sacred in memory through its smell, light, and unhurried attention. The Black Prince Well, a medieval spring near Canterbury, offers another example. May visits with a friend, then returns with flowers, herbs, shells, and bread made for Lammas, an early harvest festival. These gestures do not prove the well has supernatural powers. They renew a relationship with a place where people have sought healing for centuries.
Care makes contact. The well provides no instruction or guaranteed answer. The visitors give it attention and tending, and receive a sense of continuity in return. Ritual gives the body something meaningful to do when abstract belief feels uncertain. Repetition can make a place a container for memory, shared intention, and responsibility.
The well scene offers a grounded account of ritual: meaning is neither simply discovered in an object nor arbitrarily imposed on it. It emerges through a meeting between a place’s history and the actions people bring to it. This resembles how shared customs make public spaces legible and cared for. The distinction between ritual and guaranteed supernatural effect is important. A ceremony can shape attention and obligation without establishing that the place answers prayers. That modesty keeps the practice open to believers and skeptics alike.
Let bodily contact teach what abstract thought cannot reach.
The body also knows. May argues that understanding is not confined to words or deliberate reasoning. Taking off her shoes becomes a small act of contact with the ground; listening closely to layers of sound becomes another way to notice what routine filters out. She describes knowledge carried through sensation, muscle, and touch, recalling how her baby’s foot pressed into her hand during car journeys. These exchanges conveyed reassurance without language.
Practice makes perception. Walking gives May shifting states of attention: first bodily discomfort, then a rush of thought, and sometimes a quieter state beyond words. Her interest in tides likewise turns a scientific fact into an embodied one. The moon’s gravity becomes visible in the sea’s repeated rise and retreat. Paying attention does not replace explanation. It lets an idea become something felt, not merely stored as information.
The section resists a narrow picture of intelligence as verbal analysis. Touch, movement, and sensory attention can reveal patterns that are hard to formulate in advance, especially in relationships where comfort is communicated nonverbally. This is a useful complement to intellectual learning, not an argument against it. Bodily impressions can also mislead, so sensation is not automatically a source of truth. May’s stronger point is that experience and explanation can inform each other, and that neglecting the body leaves part of understanding unused.
Become a beginner again when competence is built on faulty habits.
Old skill can obstruct learning. May returns to swimming lessons believing she can swim well enough, then discovers that her familiar strokes are inefficient and that front crawl quickly exhausts her. Her instructor breaks the movements into parts. Each correction makes the whole stroke feel less coordinated before it begins to improve. May calls this unlearning: not simply adding facts, but loosening muscle memory and assumptions that once felt reliable.
Accept the awkward middle. For a while, arms, legs, and breathing refuse to work together. Then, briefly, the movements align. When pandemic restrictions interrupt her lessons, she finds that the old ease has faded too. The sea now feels unfamiliar, partly because her body and health have changed. The experience shows why restarting may require humility and patience rather than a demand to perform at the level of a remembered self.
This is a vivid account of how procedural knowledge differs from knowing a rule. A swimmer can understand each instruction and still struggle to coordinate the whole action, because learned movement is integrated and difficult to edit one piece at a time. The story also makes room for changed capacity: returning to an activity does not guarantee a return to the former self. That nuance prevents the familiar beginner narrative from becoming a promise that persistence always restores what was lost.
Witness painful realities before rushing to explain, comfort, or fix them.
Attention creates responsibility. May joins an online retreat run by the Zen Peacemakers, a community organized around three practices: Not-Knowing, Bearing Witness, and Taking Action. Participants first set aside ready-made opinions, then attend to painful realities, and only after that consider how to respond. During a retreat on race in America, May listens to firsthand accounts of slavery, lynching, and police violence. Resisting the impulse to interrupt, explain, or console allows her to hear more fully.
Listen without taking over. In a Way of Council session, one person speaks while others listen without analysis or approval. The practice leaves space for silence and difficult reactions, including limits to what a listener can bear. The retreat ends with a ceremony of care for people who have died violently or been forgotten. For May, witnessing creates an obligation to learn and act, even when the exact action is not immediately clear.
The sequence guards against a common failure of moral attention: turning someone else’s testimony into a prompt to display one’s own insight or virtue. Listening can complicate a person’s prior understanding before action is chosen. The approach also resists treating empathy as a substitute for change. Its difficulty is that prolonged exposure to traumatic material can overwhelm people, and a retreat cannot by itself remedy structural harm. The section recognizes capacity as a condition of responsible attention, while leaving action as a continuing obligation rather than a ceremonial ending.
Defend deep play from the demand that everything be useful.
Absorption has value. May broadens deep play beyond conventional games. It is an activity that absorbs a person so completely that its importance comes from the experience itself, not its usefulness to outsiders. As a child, she loved a Japanese tale about a boy who kept drawing cats despite being sent away from a monastery. His drawings eventually save him from a demon rat. May sees the boy’s persistence as a model of creative attention that survives disapproval.
Make room for the work. May’s own writing began as play, then was abandoned after adults and peers made the ambition feel foolish. She describes years of trying to return to it, including the awkwardness of producing imperfect work. Deep play requires time, solitude, and permission to pursue an interest that may not look productive. It is not always effortless. Sometimes it means continuing through uncertainty because the activity matters from within.
The account challenges the assumption that adult pursuits deserve time only when they produce income, status, or measurable progress. A self-chosen activity can be serious without becoming a career, and skill can grow through periods of clumsy practice. The boy’s story also exposes the social power of ridicule: interests often fade not because they lack meaning, but because they are made embarrassing. Still, play cannot always be protected by individual resolve alone. Time, money, and caregiving demands shape who gets space to pursue it.
Learn your place by name, then repay it with care.
Knowledge grows through contact. May learns plant names by returning to familiar paths and consulting field guides. Naming does not exhaust a plant’s meaning; it helps her notice differences and recognize familiar species. Her beekeeping lessons add knowledge through touch and sound: lifting a honeycomb frame, feeling its weight, hearing the colony’s rising hum, and learning how smoke affects the bees’ response.
Stewardship is reciprocal. May draws on the idea that tending a place involves both learning its needs and responding to them. Small skills, from mending clothes to identifying ripe fruit, connect knowledge to care and sharing. She recalls navigator Mau Piailug, who learned to travel by attending to stars, wind, and sea, and taught knowledge that had once been carried orally. The lesson is not to reject modern life, but to recover forms of knowing that depend on attention, practice, and responsibility.
This section makes ecological care concrete by linking it to competence. Knowing what grows locally, how bees respond, or when fruit is ready can turn a landscape from scenery into a set of relationships. The emphasis on learning from others also counters the fantasy of solitary self-sufficiency. At the same time, naming and stewardship are not neutral acts: knowledge can support care, but it can also become a claim of ownership. May’s emphasis on reciprocity helps keep local expertise oriented toward obligation rather than possession.
Keep scientific explanation and symbolic wonder in the same room.
Explanation need not flatten. May recounts the Leonid meteor storm of 1833, when witnesses described the sky as filled with falling fire. Some feared an omen; astronomers gradually connected the display to a recurring meteor shower. The scientific account explains the event without erasing its force as a shared experience. May also describes the Brocken Spectre, a person’s shadow projected onto mist and surrounded by a rainbow-like halo. Knowing its optical cause does not prevent it from feeling uncanny.
Seek, do not wait. On a trip to watch the Lyrids, May and her family do not clearly see the meteor shower. Instead, moonlight reveals their shadows on the cliffs. The unexpected sight matters because the journey has made them look closely. Enchantment is not guaranteed by a dramatic event. It grows when people deliberately seek attention, remain open to what they did not expect, and allow explanation and imagination to coexist.
This is the book’s clearest defense of intellectual pluralism. A causal explanation can answer how a phenomenon occurs without deciding what it means to the person encountering it. That distinction avoids the false choice between credulity and disenchantment. The account also makes a useful case for seeking experiences that are not optimized for certainty or spectacle. Its caution is that symbolic interpretations can become projections mistaken for evidence. Wonder remains strongest when imagination is allowed to enrich observation, not overwrite it.
Analysis
Enchantment is a memoir of recovery, but its central problem is not simply fatigue. May describes a loss of contact: with her own attention, with bodily sensation, with inherited rituals, with other people, and with the natural world. Her answer is not a conversion to a fixed doctrine. It is a set of practices that make contact possible again: noticing, walking, touching, learning names, returning to particular places, listening in groups, and making small rituals with available materials.
The book’s structure mirrors that search. Earth, water, fire, and air are not merely organizing labels. Each element gives May a different way to examine a human difficulty. Stones anchor a scattered self. Water exposes vulnerability and changing capacity. Fire makes danger and transformation visible. Air offers both disorientation and a view of what perception cannot ordinarily catch. The recurring movement is from depleted or uncertain attention toward a fresh encounter, followed by reflection rather than a final answer.
The strongest idea is that meaning is neither wholly discovered nor freely invented. A well has a history before May visits it, but its present significance also depends on the care people give it. A meteor has a physical explanation, but its appearance can still shape memory and collective storytelling. This middle position lets the book make room for scientific understanding without treating it as the only kind of human response.
There is a productive tension in the argument. Attention and ritual can deepen life, but neither substitutes for social support, medical care, or material change. May’s account of burnout and caregiving is most convincing when it recognizes that personal practices depend on time and circumstances. Her insistence on tenderness toward the world works best as an invitation, not a demand that exhausted readers make their suffering meaningful. The book’s final emphasis on seeking is therefore less about chasing transcendence than cultivating readiness: meaning may arrive through ordinary details, but noticing them takes practice.
Review Summary
Enchantment receives mixed reviews, with ratings ranging from 1 to 5 stars. Many readers appreciate May's poetic writing and exploration of finding wonder in everyday life, particularly in nature. Some find the book thought-provoking and a balm for post-pandemic anxiety. However, others feel it lacks direction, is too ethereal, or falls short of expectations set by May's previous work, "Wintering." Critics note the book's personal focus and limited applicability to broader audiences. Overall, readers' responses vary widely based on their connection to May's introspective style and themes.
People Also Read
Glossary
Enchantment
Meaningful attention to everyday lifeMay uses enchantment for an experience of wonder made from close attention, memory, and a sense of connection with the living world. It does not require spectacular scenery or a supernatural event. Ordinary things can become meaningful when a person notices them, attends to their histories, and allows them to matter.
Hierophany
A revelation of the sacredA term Mircea Eliade used for the appearance of the sacred through an object, place, or natural feature. In May’s discussion, a tree, stone, spring, or familiar room can become a hierophany when it is experienced as holding layers of meaning beyond its surface appearance. The experience may depend on belief, attention, and ritual.
Deep terrain
A place rich in layersMay’s term for an environment that offers complexity, variation, and continuing discovery. A forest, for example, changes with seasons and weather, contains histories and living systems, and invites both sensory attention and learning. Deep terrain differs from a narrowly designed space that offers a limited range of experiences and meanings.
Deep play
Absorbing, self-chosen activityMay adapts the term to describe play that absorbs a person completely, even when it appears unimportant or unproductive to others. It can include writing, searching for a hidden tower, or pursuing an intricate interest. Deep play supports experimentation and meaning, but often requires time, solitude, and protection from ridicule.
Not-Knowing
Setting aside prior assumptionsOne of the Zen Peacemakers’ three tenets. It asks participants to loosen their opinions and ready-made explanations so they can meet a situation with direct attention. In May’s account, Not-Knowing is not ignorance as an ideal. It is a deliberate openness that makes more careful observation possible.
Bearing Witness
Attentive, compassionate observationA Zen Peacemakers tenet that asks practitioners to attend to people and events as they are, including painful realities they might prefer to avoid. It emphasizes listening and presence before response. Bearing Witness can reveal complexity that quick explanations, reassurance, or attempts to solve a problem may conceal.
Taking Action
Responding after careful attentionThe third Zen Peacemakers tenet, following Not-Knowing and Bearing Witness. It means responding to what has been observed, without prescribing one universal form of action. The practice may involve a concrete intervention or a smaller commitment to care. It is treated as part of a repeating process, not a final conclusion.
Way of Council
A practice of reflective listeningA group practice described by May in which one person speaks at a time while others listen without analysis or approval. Participants aim to speak honestly and briefly, and silence is allowed. The practice creates a setting for people to sort through difficult experiences without immediately debating, correcting, or consoling one another.
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.