Start free trial
Trending New Genres Authors
EnglishEnglish
EspañolSpanish
简体中文Chinese
繁體中文Chinese (Traditional)
FrançaisFrench
DeutschGerman
日本語Japanese
PortuguêsPortuguese
ItalianoItalian
한국어Korean
РусскийRussian
NederlandsDutch
العربيةArabic
PolskiPolish
हिन्दीHindi
Tiếng ViệtVietnamese
SvenskaSwedish
ΕλληνικάGreek
TürkçeTurkish
ไทยThai
ČeštinaCzech
RomânăRomanian
MagyarHungarian
УкраїнськаUkrainian
IndonesiaIndonesian
DanskDanish
SuomiFinnish
БългарскиBulgarian
עבריתHebrew
NorskNorwegian
HrvatskiCroatian
CatalàCatalan
SlovenčinaSlovak
LietuviųLithuanian
SlovenščinaSlovenian
СрпскиSerbian
EestiEstonian
LatviešuLatvian
فارسیPersian
മലയാളംMalayalam
தமிழ்Tamil
اردوUrdu
Searching...
SoBrief
Smothermoss

Smothermoss

On a haunted Appalachian mountain, two sisters face a killer and a force beneath the earth.
by Alisa Alering 2024 256 pages
3.43
4k+ ratings
Listen
Immersive
V2.3
Amazon Kindle Audible
Try Full Access for 3 Days
Unlock listening & more!
Continue

Plot Summary

Prologue

The mountain describes spring as a season of waking: meltwater enters its hidden channels, plants and animals stir, and the stars turn beyond its reach. But growth is already shadowed by failure.

Eggs soften, leaves decay, and the water turns foul. Something has begun to disturb the mountain’s old boundaries, and its first signs are small enough to be mistaken for ordinary change.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The opening gives the landscape a consciousness older and broader than any human perspective, but not an omnipotent one. The mountain senses damage without understanding its source, establishing a central tension between ecological time and human time: the girls experience events as immediate, while the mountain registers them as disturbances in its body. The signs of spring carry a double meaning. Renewal is real, yet so is contamination. By framing the coming story as a breach in natural boundaries, the prologue prepares the reader to accept the supernatural without making it feel separate from the material world.

The Rope and the Room

Sheila keeps order while Angie unsettles it

Seventeen-year-old Sheila shares a cramped attic room on a poor Pennsylvania mountain with Angie, her younger half-sister, whose scattered belongings and blunt appetite seem to Sheila like daily provocations.

Their family history is marked by flight: after Sheila’s father died and Angie’s father became dangerous, their mother Bonnie brought the girls back to the mountain and the elderly Thena took them in.

Sheila remembers waking from a childhood operation with a scar around her throat, but believes the scar is a rope that has steadily grown around her neck and trails behind her, tugging her back whenever she imagines escape. She manages fear by making rules and denying her hungers. Angie ignores rules, steals small things, and seems impossible to shame.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Sheila’s visible scar and invisible rope translate trauma into a physical system she can monitor, even if she cannot control it. Her insistence on order is not simple fastidiousness; it is a defense against a life in which adults, poverty, and violence have repeatedly decided where she belongs. Angie’s disorder unsettles Sheila because it exposes another possible response to insecurity: invention rather than containment. Their shared room makes this conflict intimate. There is no private refuge, so each sister experiences the other’s habits as an intrusion into the fragile self she is trying to preserve.

Cards That Want Out

Angie gives her drawn creatures secret destinations

Twelve-year-old Angie turns her index cards into a private bestiary, drawing named monsters and sensing when one card is ready to leave her pack. She places the Tangle of Rabbits above the family table, an act that frightens Sheila because the image seems to touch the rope’s hidden pressure.

Angie also imagines herself surviving a ruined world, scavenging food and using her knowledge of the mountain to outlast outsiders. She resents having to care for Thena, whom she sees as merely old and mean, while Sheila remembers the woman as a former storyteller and forest companion.

The sisters’ different memories make family history feel less like shared inheritance than disputed territory, even as Angie’s cards suggest that her fantasies may be doing more than entertaining her.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Angie’s cards give form to an imagination that adults and peers dismiss as childish. Their apparent willfulness complicates the distinction between creative expression and supernatural agency: Angie draws them, names them, and carries them, yet does not experience herself as their sole author. Her survival games similarly turn vulnerability into a role she can rehearse. Sheila, by contrast, recognizes that the card has affected her but resists the implication. The sisters thus approach the unknown from opposite directions. Angie risks believing too much; Sheila survives by believing as little as possible.

Blood in the Creek

A dying hiker sends grief into the mountain

Before the murder reaches the family’s daily life, two women hiking the Appalachian Trail camp on the mountain. A young man attacks them with a rock, killing one and leaving the other gravely wounded. As she lies against the earth, the surviving woman gathers her last strength around a fragment of life and sends it away from her body, hoping it will carry what happened beyond the clearing.

Their blood seeps into the mountain’s channels, and the mountain trembles. Later, Sheila crosses a creek when the water abruptly surges red and carries a flood of mangled rabbits past her. The current loosens the pressure of her rope, then recedes, leaving her bruised and shaken with no explanation for what she saw.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The hikers’ murder is not presented only as a human crime. The dying woman’s act makes violence travel through the landscape, where grief becomes an ecological force rather than a private emotion. Sheila’s flood vision links her unseen burden to that force before she knows what has happened. The rabbits are not merely an eerie image: they echo her own association between care, helplessness, and harm. The water briefly relieves her rope, suggesting that the mountain can alter the burden, but not yet that it can free her from it.

The Bus Turns Cruel

A murder report brings the threat near home

At school, Angie is shoved from seat to seat while classmates mock her smell and refuse to sit beside her. Sheila initially watches in silence, following her own strategy of enduring insults until they lose their sting. When she finally defends Angie by pointing out their poverty and lack of hot water, the other students turn on her too, dumping chips over her hair.

At home, Bonnie, Sheila, and Thena hear that two women from Rhode Island have been killed at a nearby Appalachian Trail campsite and that the attacker may still be in the area. The report describes a young man with long dark hair and a blue plaid shirt. Angie decides the killer must be a Russian scout, turning a local murder into the enemy she has been rehearsing to fight.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The public response to the murder exposes a familiar social logic: people convert danger into a story that makes them feel less vulnerable. Angie’s Russian theory gives her a recognizable enemy and a starring role, while the school’s cruelty makes the actual social world feel no less threatening. Sheila’s failed defense matters because it breaks her practiced neutrality without earning acceptance. Poverty is not background here; it determines who can stay clean, who is believed, and who gets protected. The killer’s description gives Angie a concrete lead, but her fantasy will distort how she reads it.

The Tree Stand Witness

Angie finds a possible hideout, but police dismiss her

Sheila steals a magazine photograph of a smiling young woman, then hides it against her body, privately imagining closeness and escape. At home, her talk with Angie about nuclear war reveals how little either girl believes she can leave the mountain: Sheila imagines their area as a likely target, while Angie imagines herself as a survivor.

Looking for the presidential bunker she believes is hidden inside a nearby peak, Angie climbs to Earl’s tree stand and finds beer, ammunition, a sleeping bag, and other signs that someone has been using it.

When she reports the evidence to state police searching for the killer, an officer treats her as a child playing detective and sends her away. Angie is left with no official ally, and the abandoned stand remains an unresolved clue.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The stolen photograph is Sheila’s first attempt to make desire tangible, but she can only approach it through an image she controls. Angie’s investigation is similarly shaped by fantasy, yet her concrete observations are sound. The police officer’s dismissal shows how authority filters evidence through age and status rather than listening to the person who knows the terrain. This mirrors Sheila’s experience at school: both sisters are read as nuisances before they are heard. Angie’s imagination can mislead her about the killer’s identity, but it also keeps her moving when adults have already decided she has nothing useful to say.

Hunger Has Teeth

Sheila discovers desire beneath self-denial

Sheila tries to discipline herself by refusing food, convinced that wanting too much makes her unsafe. After Bonnie brings home barbecued chicken, Sheila pretends to be full, then sneaks to the trash and frantically licks grease from the discarded foil.

The episode confirms her fear that appetite hides something dangerous inside her. At school, however, she notices Juanita Herman, a quiet classmate whose brief glance leaves Sheila wondering whether she has truly been seen.

Sheila has never visited the sea or the cities pictured in magazines, and her mother’s night work at the Iron Mountain asylum offers little prospect of escape. Her private longing for Juanita joins her longing for a life beyond the mountain, though she cannot yet say either aloud.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The novel makes hunger both bodily and symbolic without reducing one to the other. Sheila’s compulsive licking of the foil reveals how deprivation intensifies the very appetite she tries to suppress; denial does not neutralize desire, it drives it into secrecy. Her attraction to Juanita is another appetite she has learned to hide, shaped by an environment where visibility invites ridicule. The parallel is not that food and sexuality are interchangeable, but that both expose Sheila to judgment and loss of control. Her first movement toward self-knowledge begins as an uncomfortable recognition, not a confident declaration.

The Card in the Flood

Angie draws Sheila’s buried appetite as a monster

Three days of rain wash out the garden and flood the cellar, forcing Sheila to organize repairs while Angie is supposed to dig drainage channels. Instead, Angie feels compelled to draw a card and presents Sheila with a gaunt, ravenous woman whose body opens into a black pit. Sheila recognizes something of her own secret hunger in the image, panics, and tears the card into pieces, letting the runoff carry them away.

Angie is devastated, but Sheila treats destruction as proof that she can control what the picture has exposed. The storm leaves the family’s food supply damaged and the ground unstable. Beneath them, the mountain’s buried barriers begin to weaken under the grief released by the murdered hikers.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The card turns Sheila’s private shame into an external figure she can attack. By tearing it up, she performs the same defense she uses against hunger: if the evidence disappears, perhaps the desire does too. But the act damages her relationship with Angie and fails to settle what the image has revealed. The flood makes that failure literal, carrying the fragments away while the supernatural consequence persists elsewhere. Angie’s drawing is not a diagnosis, and Sheila is not reducible to the monster. The scene instead shows how a person can mistake self-erasure for self-control when no one has taught her a safer way to be seen.

Thena’s Buried Door

An old story points beneath the house

Thena tells the sisters about her youth during the copper-mining boom, when a gray-skinned man stepped from the mountain and asked her to come with him. She accepted his offered hand and later reappeared after three missing days, covered in fine gray dust. Sheila remembers the usual version of the tale, in which a miner rescued Thena, but the old woman corrects it: no rescuer ever came.

While fetching Thena’s keepsake box, Sheila’s rope catches on the bed and knocks over a glass rabbit. She finds a hidden trapdoor beneath the bed, its stairs dusted with gray sand and its opening breathing cold air. Angie interrupts before Sheila can descend, leaving the passage unexplored and Thena’s story newly disturbing.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Thena’s correction unsettles the girls’ inherited account of rescue. The old story had protected them with a familiar ending; her revision makes agency more complicated, since Thena chose to follow a stranger and cannot explain what happened afterward. The trapdoor gives that uncertainty material form. Sheila’s rope physically catches on the furniture that conceals it, tying her sense of entrapment to a secret beneath the domestic space. The old woman is not simply a repository of folklore. Her memories may contain knowledge the younger generation has dismissed, while the mountain’s history presses into the house itself.

A Red Eye Sees

An unseen boy proves he can touch Sheila’s rope

After leaving school, Sheila begins washing dishes at the asylum with Bonnie. During a fire drill, she notices a teenage boy in a black sweatshirt whom the other workers seem unable to see. A red mark in his eye alarms her, and when he pins the end of her invisible rope beneath his shoe, she feels it tighten around her throat.

He releases it when she protests, then vanishes before she can understand who he is. Later, he returns to help Sheila move supplies and admits that his damaged eye lets him see the rope. The cook praises Sheila for finishing the work alone, never acknowledging the boy’s presence. Sheila realizes that he is visible to her alone and that he can perceive the burden she has hidden from everyone else.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The boy’s first appearance turns Sheila’s private metaphor into shared evidence without making it safe. His ability to see the rope offers recognition, but his casual control over it repeats the violation that defines Sheila’s fear. Her boundary is therefore crucial: she insists he may not touch it. The asylum’s failure to register him also makes perception a social question. What is real in this story is not determined solely by consensus, and what is invisible may still exert force. Sheila’s guarded curiosity begins to compete with her instinct to flee.

Work gives Sheila money and a fragile future

Angie lets a newborn rabbit fall while trying to hold it, and the family dog briefly catches it before Sheila pries it free, making Angie feel both blamed and underestimated. At Butch’s remote store, Angie discovers a survival knife she cannot afford and imagines it will make others respect her. Meanwhile, Sheila and the red-eyed boy work together in the asylum kitchen; the other staff still cannot see him.

Sheila tears up a pornographic magazine she found in Angie’s things, reacting to its images with a force she cannot explain. When her first pay arrives, she gives Bonnie most of it and hides the remainder in an old paint can in the cellar. Saving money becomes her first practical plan for a life beyond home.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The sisters pursue agency through different objects. Angie invests the knife with the promise of strength and recognition; Sheila invests cash with the possibility of departure. Both hopes are understandable, but neither object can by itself resolve the vulnerabilities that created the need. Sheila’s destruction of the magazine shows how desire can become frightening when it arrives without language or consent. Her savings, by contrast, create a small, measurable future, though the secret hiding place also reflects how little privacy she has. Their parallel ambitions deepen the contrast between Angie’s action fantasy and Sheila’s cautious preparation.

The Shirt in the Woods

Angie finds blood where the police found none

Angie explores the abandoned copper mine, hoping it will lead to the underground refuge from Thena’s story. A cave-in blocks the passage, and she finds no hidden camp, only old debris. On her walk home, she discovers a blue plaid shirt stiff with dark blood and torn as if an animal has worried it. At the asylum, Sheila presses the red-eyed boy about his ability to see her.

He lets her test his reality by touching his hand, then makes her close her eyes while he senses the fear and desire she keeps hidden. He tells her that her assumption that everyone else holds power over her is mistaken. Sheila does not accept his judgment, but she can no longer pretend he sees only the rope.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The bloodied shirt offers Angie evidence that is more reliable than her Russian theory, though she does not yet know how to use it. Her failed mine expedition also matters: the mountain refuses the secret architecture she expects, while presenting an actual clue on the ordinary path home. Sheila’s encounter with the boy shifts from fear of being physically controlled to fear of being psychologically known. His claim about her power may be perceptive, but it is also coercive, since he decides when and how to expose her. The scene leaves Sheila both challenged and wary, a combination that will shape their next encounters.

Hungry Hikers, Empty Can

Angie gives strangers cards, then Sheila loses everything

Hikers Russell and Gayle reach the family home after a bear takes their food. Sheila gives Russell garden work, and Gayle’s openness unsettles Sheila’s guarded assumptions about outsiders. Angie rummages near their packs and slips in a monster card before they leave.

Soon Sheila discovers her paint can empty: more than two hundred dollars in savings have vanished. She accuses Angie, who says she gave the thief card to the hikers and denies taking the money. Sheila sees the expensive knife Angie carries and decides her sister is lying; she pins Angie down and confiscates it.

The accusation leaves Angie crying and Sheila ashamed but unconvinced. Later, Sheila dreams of the hikers in danger, while the returned Starved Woman card appears on a tray from the asylum’s locked ward.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The hikers briefly offer Sheila a different model of contact: Gayle speaks without contempt and treats the mountain as a place she can learn rather than a spectacle to consume. Sheila cannot yet sustain that openness, and the missing money turns uncertainty back into accusation. Her attack on Angie repeats the powerlessness she despises, showing how quickly fear recruits her into the role of enforcer. The monster card’s return from a ward Angie has never visited undermines the sisters’ competing explanations. The supernatural is no longer confined to Angie’s hands or Sheila’s imagination, and neither sister can fully control what the cards carry.

Thena’s Last Story

A quartz stone connects Sheila to the mountain

As Thena weakens, she tells Angie a story Sheila has never heard: a starving girl on the mountain stopped eating, and her mother and grandmother cut into her throat to remove a quartz stone threaded to her body by fine roots. They sewed the girl back together and hid the stone, but Thena warns that the mountain eventually finds what it wants.

Soon afterward, Sheila finds Thena dead on the path near the woods, clutching a bundle containing quartz, iron nails, and dried yarrow. At the funeral, police search Bonnie’s car because the killer remains at large. Back home, Sheila opens the bundle and sees a blood-red flaw at the heart of the stone. She cannot bring herself to discard it, sensing that Thena carried it for a reason.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Thena’s story reframes Sheila’s scar and rope without yet supplying certainty. The mountain’s claim on a child is presented as neither straightforward curse nor benevolent care; survival itself may come at the cost of belonging. The quartz makes that ambiguity physical, while the iron and yarrow suggest the family has developed rituals of resistance. Thena’s death gives the story an immediate emotional weight, but her final possession also transfers an unresolved obligation to Sheila. The roadside police search sets human suspicion beside this older, stranger danger. Both forms of threat ask the family to explain what it cannot safely reveal.

The Worm King’s Claim

Angie admits the cards do not obey her

While Bonnie and her daughters clear Thena’s room, Sheila finds a card beneath the mattress showing the Worm King, a creature Angie says she deliberately kept away from Thena. Angie explains that she senses where cards want to go but cannot command them, and that she chose the Truthteller for the old woman instead. The Worm King had been angry and slipped into the room anyway.

Sheila asks whether anyone truly chooses what happens to them; Angie insists that the cards’ influence does not erase her own decisions. Sheila searches under the bed for the hidden passage she found before, but the floor is ordinary boards. Their disagreement leaves them with no clean boundary between choice, responsibility, and supernatural pressure.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The sisters’ argument marks a change in how they understand blame. Sheila wants a single agent responsible for every frightening event; Angie distinguishes between influence and authorship, insisting that limited control is not the same as no control. This is not a comforting resolution. Angie’s inability to keep the Worm King from Thena suggests that good intentions do not guarantee safety, while Sheila’s search for a literal trapdoor shows her desire to locate danger somewhere outside herself. Their conversation begins a more honest relationship by allowing disagreement without immediate ridicule.

A Room Above the Roof

Sheila follows the boy into impossible corridors

Sheila slips through the locked doors of G Ward and climbs a staircase that should not exist above the asylum’s top floor. The corridor beyond holds isolated patients, but one room is Juanita’s bedroom, complete with her clothes and diary. Sheila cannot read the diary’s blank pages before staff arrive.

The red-eyed boy pulls her through a closet that becomes a steep, underground passage, and they emerge through a crack in the mountain. In the rain, Sheila admits the depth of her feelings for Juanita. The boy offers a kiss as practice; when Sheila accepts, he appears to become Juanita in her arms, then returns to himself. Sheila leaves the encounter shaken, newly aware of how badly she wants intimacy on her own terms.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The impossible asylum corridor literalizes the distance between desire and knowledge. Sheila reaches Juanita’s private room but cannot extract the certainty she wants from the blank diary; fantasy remains more available than the real person. The boy’s transformation into Juanita provides comfort and violation at once, since he fulfills Sheila’s longing without being the person she longs for. Sheila’s admission is nonetheless a major act of self-recognition. The episode distinguishes wanting closeness from consenting to any substitute for it, a distinction Sheila is only beginning to make.

The Ravine Closes

The sisters bind the killer together

After Butch spots the suspected murderer at his store, he reports him to police and makes Angie promise to stay home. Angie breaks that promise, uses the Worm King card to find a passage through the mountain, and reaches the killer’s hidden dugout. She waits to ambush him, but he catches her and overwhelms her.

Sheila hears Angie’s cries and runs to the ravine, where the sisters fight the man together. The red-eyed boy is gone, but Sheila and Angie suddenly share a current of thought and move as one, using Sheila’s rope to bind him. Sheila then sees the killer’s memory of beating the Rhode Island hikers with a rock. The sisters drag him into his hideout; the mountain closes its entrance and seals him inside.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The climax overturns both girls’ private strategies. Angie’s weapon and heroic script fail when the killer takes her down; Sheila’s habitual retreat fails when she hears her sister in danger. Their shared bodily awareness does not erase their differences, but lets each contribute what the other lacks. The rope, once an image of helpless restraint, becomes an instrument they can direct together. Sheila’s memory confirms the killer’s crime, while the mountain’s closure makes justice strange and morally unsettled: he is contained rather than brought before human authorities. The sisters’ cooperation is the story’s clearest act of chosen kinship.

The Stone Comes Apart

Sheila chooses nourishment without surrender

After the mountain seals the killer away, Sheila’s rope grows heavier. She asks Angie to cut it, but the knife leaves it intact. A card Angie did not draw shows a mountain crossed by tunnels and a bright eye at its center. When Sheila remembers swallowing a quartz seed as a six-year-old, she understands that the stone Thena kept is tied to her rope.

She makes Angie promise Juanita a handmade vessel filled with her feelings, then takes the stone into the woods and crushes it; its red center dissolves into the rock. At the stream, Sheila immerses herself and emerges still wearing the rope, but more able to bear it. She returns home, eats freely, and begins to claim her body as her own.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The ending refuses a simple cure. Destroying the quartz does not remove Sheila’s rope, and the mountain’s continuing presence means that independence is not identical to severance. What changes is Sheila’s relation to desire: she stops treating appetite as evidence of corruption and lets herself receive pleasure without punishment. The gift for Juanita converts concealed longing into an honest offering, though it does not guarantee reciprocation. Angie’s participation matters as much as the stone’s destruction; Sheila now trusts her sister with both a secret and a choice. Their future remains uncertain, but Sheila’s body is no longer only a site of restraint.

Analysis

Smothermoss makes place more than scenery: the mountain is a living system that feeds the family, records violence, and sometimes claims what it has held. Its attentiveness is not moral omniscience. It can shelter a fugitive, overlook a wound, and answer grief in ways that endanger the people it touches. That ambiguity prevents a comforting split between human corruption and pure nature. The mountain is both home and pressure, sustenance and possession.

Sheila and Angie embody different survival strategies shaped by poverty and neglect. Sheila tries to reduce risk by controlling her surroundings and suppressing appetite; Angie turns fear into games, stories, and action. Neither strategy is sufficient. Sheila’s restraint becomes self-erasure, while Angie’s heroic fantasies leave her unprepared for physical violence. Their decisive cooperation does not make them alike. Instead, it lets their different capacities work together without requiring either sister to disappear into the other.

The rope and the cards give psychological experience a material form, but the book resists treating either as a neat allegory. Sheila’s rope remains after the quartz is destroyed, so insight does not magically dissolve trauma. Angie’s cards have power, yet she cannot guarantee their effects, complicating any simple account of responsibility. The sisters must act inside uncertainty rather than wait for perfect control.

The novel also links hunger to the right to occupy a body. Sheila has learned to treat wanting food, touch, escape, and love as evidence that she is dangerous. Her final return to eating is therefore not a minor domestic comfort. It marks a change in how she interprets need: as a human fact she can meet, rather than a force she must punish. Her offering to Juanita is similarly honest without demanding an answer. The ending’s hope is modest but earned. Sheila remains bound to her history and landscape, yet she begins to choose what she will nourish and what she will give away.

Summary in 60 Seconds
Seventeen-year-old Sheila lives with her younger half-sister Angie, their mother, and their ailing grandmother on a poor Pennsylvania mountain. Sheila feels bound by an invisible rope and suppresses her hunger and desire to escape, while Angie draws monster cards that seem to exert their own influence. After a man murders two hikers nearby, signs of violence appear around the mountain, and Angie finds a bloodied shirt. Sheila discovers a red-eyed boy only she can see, and learns her rope is connected to a quartz stone she swallowed as a child. When Angie follows the killer to his hideout and is attacked, the sisters join forces to bind him; the mountain seals him inside. Sheila destroys the stone, but the rope remains. She accepts that her past still affects her, begins eating freely, and takes a tentative step toward telling Juanita how she feels.
Contains spoilers

Last updated:

Report Issue

Review Summary

3.43 out of 5
Average of 4k+ ratings from Goodreads and Amazon.

Smothermoss by Alisa Alering receives mixed reviews (3.43/5). Readers praise its atmospheric, lyrical prose and vivid Appalachian setting, with strong character development of sisters Sheila and Angie. Many appreciate the gothic, magical realism elements and exploration of queerness. However, critics note the weak mystery plot, confusing narrative structure, and unresolved themes. The blurred lines between reality and fantasy frustrate some but captivate others. Reviewers either love its ambiguous, dreamlike quality or find it underdeveloped and meandering. The audiobook narration receives consistent praise for authentic Appalachian accents.

Your rating:
4.03
59 ratings
Want to read the full book?

Characters

Sheila

The watchful older sister

Seventeen-year-old Sheila is practical, observant, and fiercely private. Poverty and childhood trauma have taught her to value tidiness, self-denial, and low visibility; she believes restraint can protect her from humiliation and from the frightening appetite she senses inside herself. Her scarred throat and imagined rope embody the history she cannot easily explain. She cares for Angie even when resentment makes tenderness difficult, and she is drawn to Juanita while fearing what that desire might expose. Sheila’s defining conflict is not simply whether to leave home, but whether she can admit what she wants without treating wanting as a danger.

Angie

The card-making younger sister

Twelve-year-old Angie is noisy, impulsive, imaginative, and often misread as merely dirty or dishonest. She turns scraps of paper into a world of monsters, survival scenarios, and secret signals because imagination gives her a way to act when adults dismiss her. Her fantasies about war and heroism reveal a hunger for competence and recognition, not a lack of intelligence. Angie can be careless with other people’s trust, especially Sheila’s, but she also notices details others ignore and tries to protect the family in her own erratic way. She wants agency, and she is still learning the difference between courage, performance, and recklessness.

The mountain

The living Appalachian landscape

The mountain is an immense, nonhuman presence that senses feet, water, roots, wounds, and changes in its underground passages. Its perspective stretches across generations, yet it can overlook damage when other demands claim its attention. It sustains the family with springs, plants, animals, and familiar paths, while also exerting a powerful pull on Sheila. The mountain is neither a simple benevolent guardian nor a conventional antagonist. Its care can resemble possession, and its ecological memory carries both human grief and the consequences of mining, pollution, and violence.

Thena

The keeper of old stories

Thena is an elderly relative who took Bonnie and the girls in after they fled Angie’s father. Bent by age and illness, she complains freely and depends on the sisters for daily care, yet her stories hold knowledge they initially treat as repetitive folklore. She remembers the mountain as a place of work, danger, wonder, and inexplicable encounters. Her bond with Sheila reaches back to the older girl’s childhood, while Angie resents the labor her care requires. Thena’s insistence on telling stories preserves a history the younger women cannot yet interpret.

Bonnie

The exhausted working mother

Bonnie works night shifts at the Iron Mountain asylum and supports her daughters with limited money and little rest. She is resourceful and protective, but fatigue and disappointment narrow what she can offer emotionally. Her earlier dreams of travel and a different life have been buried beneath work, family obligations, and the consequences of past relationships. She tries to keep the household functioning and expects the girls to care for one another, even when she cannot see how isolated they feel.

The red-eyed boy

Sheila’s unseen witness

A lanky teenage boy in a black sweatshirt appears around the asylum, where Sheila alone seems able to see him. A red mark in one eye lets him perceive Sheila’s rope, and he can interact with it in ways no one else can. He is teasing, perceptive, and at times intrusive, pressing Sheila to face feelings she would rather keep hidden. His presence blurs the line between human and supernatural without giving Sheila a dependable guide. He recognizes her longing, but his attempts to help do not always respect the boundaries she needs.

The murderer

The fugitive on the trail

The murderer is a young man who hides in the forest after attacking two Appalachian Trail hikers. He is described publicly as long-haired and dressed in blue plaid, while the traces he leaves include a bloodied shirt, a makeshift shelter, and stolen possessions. His presence turns the mountain from a familiar refuge into a place where danger may be close and unseen. The sisters’ encounter with him tests their assumptions about bravery and the protection offered by weapons, police, or wilderness.

Butch

The wary mountain shopkeeper

Butch runs a rough roadside store used by hikers and local residents. He is gruff with Angie but treats her as a familiar presence, and his past military service has left him wary of violence and official authority. He understands more about danger than Angie’s action movies can teach her. His concern for her is expressed through limits and practical decisions, even when she would rather be treated as a capable equal.

Juanita Herman

Sheila’s quiet schoolmate

Juanita is a classmate who appears ordinary and reserved to most people at school. Sheila notices her precisely because she seems neither cruel nor conspicuously popular, and a brief glance becomes charged with possibility. Sheila’s imagined version of Juanita is more vivid than their actual acquaintance, which makes Juanita both a real person and the focus of a private hope. She represents the possibility of being known, but Sheila must learn that desire cannot substitute for knowing someone.

Gayle

The openhearted hiker

Gayle is a college student hiking the Appalachian Trail with Russell. Tired, sunburnt, and candid about the limits of the trip, she treats Sheila with warmth rather than condescension. Her willingness to admit mistakes and discomfort offers Sheila a glimpse of a life in which uncertainty can be spoken aloud. Gayle’s presence also complicates the family’s suspicion of outsiders and gives Sheila a fleeting experience of connection beyond school and home.

Russell

Gayle’s determined companion

Russell is Gayle’s boyfriend and hiking partner. He is determined to complete the long trail and generally confident that he can manage its risks, sometimes more confidently than his experience warrants. His partnership with Gayle is affectionate, though the strain of their journey reveals that shared ambition does not guarantee equal enthusiasm. He works in Sheila’s garden in exchange for food when their supplies are lost.

Sam

The imprisoned older brother

Sam is Bonnie’s son and the girls’ older brother, currently in prison. His absence shapes the family’s expectations: Angie wears his old jacket, and Bonnie imagines his return as a future that might restore the household. His history is part of the family’s difficult inheritance, even though he is not present for the sisters’ daily conflicts.

Sue

The family’s beloved dog

Sue is a friendly, unreliable hunting dog associated with Sam and adored by Angie. She follows scent with sudden enthusiasm and responds to affection more readily than commands. Her near-mishap while Angie tries to track the murderer forces Angie to confront the gap between imagined danger and consequences in the real world.

The two Rhode Island hikers

The murdered visitors

The two women are strangers from Rhode Island hiking the Appalachian Trail together. Their attack begins the central criminal threat and sends a final, grief-stricken force into the mountain. The local community’s speculation about why they came exposes its suspicion of outsiders, while Sheila and Angie gradually recognize that the women were people with lives beyond the violence done to them.

Troy Eckheart

Angie’s imagined boyfriend

Troy is a popular baseball player who mocks Angie at school. She imagines his cruelty as a performance concealing affection, hoping that being chosen by him would change her standing. Her fantasy shows how strongly she wants recognition, even from someone who treats her badly.

Plot Devices

Sheila’s rope

Makes trauma physically visible

Sheila experiences her throat scar as the beginning of an invisible rope that trails behind her and catches on people, branches, and furniture. It tightens when fear or desire presses too close, and for years she treats its weight as an unavoidable fact. The rope gives the story a concrete image for how trauma can shape movement, self-protection, and the expectation of punishment. Its meaning changes as Sheila and Angie learn to handle it together, but its persistence prevents the ending from becoming a simple cure.

Angie’s monster cards

Turn drawings into uncertain agents

Angie draws monsters on index cards, names them, and senses when a card wants to be placed somewhere. She believes she can listen to the cards, but not fully command them. Their movements connect private imagination to events in the mountain and asylum, including the return of a card Sheila destroyed. The cards make creative power feel both intimate and unsettling: Angie supplies their images, yet their apparent choices exceed her intentions. They also give Angie a language for emotions and situations she cannot explain directly.

The quartz seed

Binds Sheila to the mountain

A milk-white stone with a red flaw appears in Thena’s story about a girl whose body was connected to the mountain by hidden roots. Thena keeps the stone wrapped with yarrow and iron nails, and Sheila recognizes its resemblance to something from her own forgotten childhood. The quartz links the scar, the rope, the family’s inherited stories, and the mountain’s desire to keep what belongs to it. Its eventual destruction changes Sheila’s relationship to the mountain, though it does not erase the rope or remove every consequence of their connection.

The mountain’s passages

Join human and ecological time

The mountain contains hidden routes, ruptures, and chambers that connect places which should not physically meet. These passages respond to grief, violence, and the movement of Angie’s cards, allowing characters to emerge far from where they entered. The mountain is also a living observer whose attention is vast but imperfect; it can nurture life while overlooking damage. This device makes setting active without turning nature into a simple moral force. The same landscape that feeds the family can shelter a killer, preserve old secrets, and rearrange the sisters’ sense of distance.

The red-eyed boy

Makes hidden burdens perceptible

The boy appears around the asylum and can see Sheila’s rope, while other workers behave as if she is alone. His damaged eye marks him as a witness to realities outside ordinary perception. He challenges Sheila’s belief that she is powerless and gives her a route into the mountain’s impossible spaces, but he also tests her boundaries and manipulates her longing. Because the novel never fully settles what he is, he functions less as an answer than as a pressure point between desire, danger, and perception.

About the Author

Alisa Alering grew up in Pennsylvania's Appalachian mountains, which clearly influences their debut novel's setting. After attending the prestigious Clarion West Writers Workshop, they've published short fiction in numerous speculative fiction venues including Fireside, Lady Churchill's Rosebud Wristlet, Podcastle, and Cast of Wonders. Their work has earned recognition from the Calvino Prize. Before becoming a fiction author, Alering worked as both a librarian and a science and technology reporter. They now teach fiction writing workshops at the Highlights Foundation, a respected organization for children's and young adult writers. Alering currently resides in southern Arizona's Sonoran Desert.

Download PDF

To save this Smothermoss summary for later, download the free PDF. You can print it out, or read offline at your convenience.
Download PDF
File size: 0.37 MB     Pages: 29

Download EPUB

To read this Smothermoss summary on your e-reader device or app, download the free EPUB. The .epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.
Download EPUB
File size: 1.44 MB     Pages: 36
Want to read the full book?
Follow
Listen
Home
Swipe
Library
Get App
Try Full Access for 3 Days
Listen, bookmark, and more
Compare Features Free Pro
📖 Read Summaries
Read unlimited summaries. Free users get 3 per month
🎧 Listen to Summaries
Listen to unlimited summaries in 40 languages
—
❤️ Unlimited Bookmarks
Free users are limited to 4
—
📜 Unlimited History
Free users are limited to 4
—
📥 Unlimited Downloads
Free users are limited to 1
—
Risk-Free Timeline
Today: Get Instant Access
Listen to full summaries of 26,000+ books. That's 12,000+ hours of audio!
Day 2: Trial Reminder
We'll send you a notification that your trial is ending soon.
Day 3: Your subscription begins
You'll be charged on Nov 24,
cancel anytime before.
Consume 2.8× More Books
2.8× more books Listening Reading
Our users love us
1M+ readers
Trustpilot Rating
TrustPilot
4.6 Excellent
This site is a total game-changer. I've been flying through book summaries like never before. Highly, highly recommend.
— Dave G
Worth my money and time, and really well made. I've never seen this quality of summaries on other websites. Very helpful!
— Em
Highly recommended!! Fantastic service. Perfect for those that want a little more than a teaser but not all the intricate details of a full audio book.
— Greg M
Save 62%
Yearly
$119.88 $44.99/year/yr
$3.75/mo
Monthly
$9.99/mo
Start a 3-Day Free Trial
3 days free, then $44.99/year. Cancel anytime.
Unlock a world of fiction & nonfiction books
26,000+ books for the price of 2 books
Read any book in 10 minutes
Discover new books like Tinder
Request any book if it's not summarized
Read more books than anyone you know
#1 app for book lovers
Lifelike & immersive summaries
30-day money-back guarantee
Download summaries in EPUBs or PDFs
Cancel anytime in a few clicks

Why one summary?

Scanner
Find a barcode to scan

⭐
⭐
⭐
We have a special gift for you
Open
38% off
DISCOUNT FOR YOU
⭐
⭐
⭐
$79.99
$49.99/year
Only $4.16 per month
Continue
2 taps to start, super easy to cancel
Settings
General
Widget
Loading...