Key Takeaways
Let strangers matter without demanding that love become perfectly impartial.
A demanding kind of goodness. MacFarquhar’s do-gooder is not simply a kind person who volunteers. This is someone who treats helping as a central duty, deliberately arranging work, money, and relationships around the needs of others. Such a life can inspire awe and discomfort at once: its discipline is beautiful, but its sacrifices may leave little room for pleasure, family, or ordinary spontaneity.
The central conflict is not whether suffering matters. It is how far that fact should govern a life. The people in these stories take distant strangers seriously, sometimes as seriously as their own relatives. Yet the book does not settle whether that impartiality is admirable, inhuman, or both. Their actual lives, including the costs and doubts, make the question harder to dismiss than an abstract rule.
What's striking is that the book treats moral seriousness as a lived temperament, not just a theory. That distinction matters: two people can endorse equal human worth while experiencing obligations very differently. Moral psychology also suggests that vivid, nearby need captures attention more readily than distant suffering, so impartial concern requires deliberate effort. But effort alone cannot settle what is owed. A duty that consumes every other attachment may preserve abstract fairness while damaging the relationships through which people learn care, trust, and responsibility.
Live as if the emergency is real, while remembering that emergencies never end.
A permanent state of duty. A hero encounters a crisis and responds; a do-gooder knows crises are always happening and seeks them out. MacFarquhar describes this outlook as living as if it were always wartime. In war, sacrifice for strangers is widely understood as honorable. In ordinary life, the same choices can look excessive, intrusive, or like an accusation against everyone who carries on as usual.
Dorothy Granada moved from anti-nuclear protest to nursing in Nicaragua because she wanted work that directly served women. Her activists criticized the change as a retreat from a higher cause. Dorothy instead found that practical care suited her and made her more effective. Her story shows that duty can call someone away from dramatic sacrifice toward less glamorous work, even when fellow idealists mistake spectacle for seriousness.
The wartime comparison explains why the same sacrifice can seem noble in one setting and unnerving in another. Shared danger creates a common identity and makes extraordinary demands feel normal. In peacetime, a person who treats every distant crisis as personal can appear to reject the social agreements that make ordinary life possible. The metaphor also has a limit: emergencies differ in urgency, solvability, and the helper's competence. Constant mobilization can blur those differences and make rest look like betrayal rather than a condition for sustained service.
Ask where duty ends before morality turns every pleasure into a crime.
The problem of enough. In his influential famine argument, philosopher Peter Singer compares distant children in danger with a child drowning nearby. If muddy clothes are no reason to let the nearby child die, he asks, why should distance excuse ignoring children who could be saved through a donation? The argument makes ordinary spending feel morally consequential and leaves an unsettling question: if one rescue is required, why not many more?
MacFarquhar sets this against the idea that some actions are praiseworthy but beyond what anyone can reasonably be required to do. Philosopher Bernard Williams warns that impartial calculation can crowd out the attachments that give life its shape. The clash is not simply generosity versus selfishness. It is a dispute over whether duty has a limit, and whether love must answer to the same calculus as charity.
Singer's argument powerfully exposes how distance can mute moral attention. It also raises a demandingness problem: if every available resource must go to the greatest good, ordinary commitments become difficult to defend. One useful distinction is between judging a choice as less than optimal and judging it as wrong. Those are not identical verdicts. A society that treats every failure to maximize benefit as culpable may produce guilt rather than durable generosity, while a society that excuses all private preference risks making preventable suffering invisible.
Judge giving by lives improved, not by how dramatically the giver suffers.
Results over moral theater. Aaron Pitkin chose chicken advocacy because industrial farming harmed enormous numbers of birds, many of them neglected because they were neither cute nor familiar. His work helped shift company policies and laws, including commitments to improve poultry conditions. He learned to value practical improvements over personal purity: reducing suffering mattered more than following a rule for its own sake.
Julia and Jeff Wise applied similar reasoning to charitable donations. They researched organizations, favored evidence about what actually improved lives, and eventually gave away half their joint pretax income. In 2014, they donated $127,556. Their approach contrasts with Charles Gray’s strict World Equity Budget, which limited his own spending to a tiny share of global income. For Julia and Jeff, self-denial was useful only when it helped someone.
The distinction between sacrifice and impact is a valuable corrective to moral self-display. In public health and program evaluation, a good intention is only a hypothesis about benefit; outcomes need checking. Yet measurement can narrow the field of vision. Easily counted interventions may eclipse slower work such as building trust, changing institutions, or protecting local knowledge. Quantification is most useful as a discipline against wishful thinking, not as proof that whatever is measurable matters most.
Help people recover agency, not merely receive your compassion.
Dignity is part of help. Baba Amte began working with people with leprosy after confronting his own fear of them. Medicine could cure the disease, but many cured patients were still rejected by their families and unable to earn a living. At Anandwan, Baba built a community where residents worked, learned skills, and produced goods. His aim was not to make people permanent recipients of charity, but to restore the means to live with self-respect.
His son Prakash faced a different challenge among the Madia Gond people in the forest. He established a clinic and school, learned the local language, and accepted that people sometimes declined treatment. The stories complicate the idea that a helper always knows what improvement should look like. Care can meet urgent needs while leaving people room to shape their own lives.
This emphasis connects to the capabilities approach, which evaluates well-being by what people are genuinely able to do and become, rather than by resources alone. Work, education, and choice can matter as much as medical treatment. Still, self-sufficiency should not become a test recipients must pass to deserve care. Severe disability, illness, or structural exclusion can make dependence unavoidable. The strongest version of Baba's insight is that assistance should protect dignity, whether or not it can eliminate the need for assistance.
Good intentions need boundaries, feedback, and permission to stop.
Care can consume its carer. The book traces how helping came to be treated with suspicion. In writing about codependency, some therapists and recovery advocates warned that rescuing another person can become a way to control them, evade one's own problems, or sustain a destructive relationship. But that critique can overreach: a sense of responsibility is not automatically a disorder, and some people genuinely want to serve.
Buddhist priest Ittetsu Nemoto answered suicidal people by email and phone for years, until his health collapsed and he faced serious heart problems. He eventually required people to meet him at his temple and began taking notes to keep their stories from overwhelming him. The new limits reduced the number of requests and made conversations more focused. Setting boundaries changed the work; it did not mean he had stopped caring.
Nemoto's shift resembles a basic principle in crisis work: a helper who becomes depleted loses the capacity to respond well. Boundaries can also make responsibility clearer by distinguishing listening, referral, and direct intervention. The codependency critique is useful when it identifies coercion disguised as care, but it can stigmatize necessary mutual dependence or discourage people from responding to genuine need. A practical test is whether the help respects the other person's agency and whether the arrangement remains sustainable for both parties.
Give family special care without pretending strangers have no equal worth.
Love and fairness collide. Julia Wise believed that strangers' lives counted as much as those of people close to her. Before having a child, she worried that parenthood might change her priorities. After Lily was born, she found that reports of children being hurt affected her physically, yet her commitment to effective giving remained. When her mother-in-law became ill, Julia still believed that scarce resources should go where they could help the most people.
The story does not prove that family attachment is morally irrelevant. Rather, it shows that people can hold an impartial principle while experiencing particular love intensely. MacFarquhar presents the tension without treating either side as an easy answer: a person's family has claims grounded in intimacy and dependence, while strangers have lives and loved ones of their own.
This tension resembles the distinction between impartial justice and special obligations. Care ethics emphasizes that relationships create responsibilities that cannot always be translated into equal units, while impartial theories remind people that familiarity is not the same as greater human worth. Both insights matter. A parent cannot replace attachment with a spreadsheet, but attachment can also become a convenient reason to discount anonymous suffering. The difficult work is not eliminating partiality, but noticing when it is a genuine responsibility and when it is merely bias.
Treat chosen commitments as serious, but test them against dependents' needs.
Promises create family. Sue and Hector Badeau planned to have two children and adopt two. They eventually adopted twenty-two, including sibling groups and children with severe disabilities. Their promise to each child was that adoption meant permanence, not another temporary placement. That commitment gave children who had been moved between homes a stable family and a large network of siblings.
The costs were real. The household lived with chronic financial pressure, the children sometimes felt they had to share their parents, and Sue's work often took her away. Some children struggled with pregnancy, addiction, crime, or abuse, and one son went to prison. The Badeaus could not control these outcomes. Their story honors chosen responsibility without claiming that love guarantees success or that every family can take on more.
The Badeaus make a compelling case that family can be formed through sustained obligation, not only biology. Their experience also shows why good intentions require attention to the people already affected by a decision. Children in a large household may gain siblings and security while losing individual attention. Neither consequence cancels the other. In social policy, this is a reminder that family-based care should be judged by children's actual safety and development, not by the inspirational force of a caregiver's commitment.
Suspect the culture that calls altruism either pure virtue or hidden pathology.
Helping has a contested history. In the eighteenth century, Bernard Mandeville argued that private vices could serve public prosperity, and Adam Smith's account of the invisible hand helped popularize the idea that self-interest can benefit society. Later, Nietzsche attacked selflessness as hostile to human greatness, while psychoanalytic writers often interpreted extreme helping as disguised need, control, or self-punishment.
The skepticism was not the whole story. Research on non-Jews who rescued Jews during the Holocaust emphasized differences in character and upbringing, while psychologist C. Daniel Batson examined whether empathy can motivate genuinely other-directed help. The changing theories reveal that altruism is never judged in a vacuum. Suspicion may expose manipulation, but it can also make selfless action seem impossible, leaving ordinary selfishness looking like the only honest motive.
The history matters because explanations of motive can shape behavior. If every generous act is dismissed as concealed self-interest, people may have less reason to attempt difficult generosity at all. Conversely, describing helpers as pure can protect them from scrutiny when their interventions cause harm. Contemporary behavioral science often treats motives as mixed rather than mutually exclusive: warmth, identity, empathy, and concern for outcomes can coexist. Mixed motives do not invalidate assistance, but they make accountability essential.
Accept that meaningful help is uncertain, relational, and vulnerable to luck.
Even concrete gifts have complications. Kimberly Brown-Whale donated a kidney to a stranger after seeing a local appeal. Her surgery went smoothly, and the recipient recovered. Paul Wagner chose his recipient, Gail Tomas, and their donation created an emotionally complicated relationship. Some doctors had once treated such donors as psychologically suspect; over time, safer procedures and changing expectations made donation more acceptable. The act could save a life, but it also carried risks, gratitude, and disagreements about who should receive the organ.
Across the book, outcomes depend on more than intention. Dorothy's clinic sometimes failed to prevent tragedy; the Badeaus could not control their children's adult choices; Nemoto's listening work nearly destroyed his health. Help is not a guarantee of rescue. It is a decision made under uncertainty, with effects on both the recipient and the person offering care.
This is a useful corrective to the fantasy that ethical action can be made consequence-proof. Medical ethics and disaster response both rely on informed consent, risk assessment, and review because good intentions cannot predict every result. Still, uncertainty should not become an all-purpose excuse for inaction. The appropriate standard is not certainty of success, but a reasonable fit between need, competence, consent, and risk. A helper's willingness to be corrected is part of the help.
Let moral exemplars enlarge possibility without making ordinary life seem worthless.
Admiration is not an instruction. MacFarquhar notes that novels often distrust characters devoted to abstract moral causes, favoring intimate loyalties and flawed human beings. That suspicion guards against sanctimony and the belief that one person can remake the world by force of will. Yet moral exemplars reveal choices that ordinary expectations can hide. Dorothy treated people across enemy lines; Baba built a community around people others excluded; the Badeaus made a family for children unlikely to find one.
The closing question is not whether everyone should live this way. If everyone treated every need as an overriding claim, the result would be a radically different society, not simply a kinder version of the present one. But without people who stretch the limits of expected duty, fewer may believe that strangers can become their responsibility at all.
The book's most persuasive stance is neither imitation nor dismissal. Exemplars can function as moral probes: they reveal what a culture treats as normal, and what it has quietly decided not to notice. Their lives also show how luck affects moral judgment. The same choice may be praised when it succeeds and condemned when it harms dependents. That instability calls for humility, not paralysis. Admiration can widen the imaginable range of action while leaving room for proportion, plural values, and ordinary attachments.
Analysis
Strangers Drowning is less a manual for altruism than an inquiry into the limits of moral demand. Its stories refuse the comfort of a single verdict. Dorothy Granada's work suggests that practical service may be more humane and useful than permanent political mobilization. Aaron Pitkin and Julia Wise show how consequence-focused giving can turn compassion into measurable action, while their examples also expose the sacrifices and social friction such reasoning creates. The Amtes and the Badeaus reveal another problem: care is not a clean transaction between helper and recipient. It changes households, institutions, and identities, and outcomes remain partly outside anyone's control.
A useful way to read these accounts is to separate four questions that moral arguments often collapse: Who deserves consideration? What intervention is likely to help? Who bears its costs? And who gets to decide what counts as improvement? Singer's impartiality argument is strongest on the first question. Effective altruism sharpens the second. Dorothy's respect for local choices and Baba's emphasis on dignity speak to the fourth. The conflicts around family, burnout, and adoption bring the third into view. No single answer settles all four.
The book's insistence on ambivalence is a strength, but its portraits are not a representative sample of ordinary giving. Extreme lives are illuminating precisely because they are unusual. Their vividness can make regular, collective forms of care seem small, even though public services, competent institutions, and shared responsibility can relieve suffering at a scale individual sacrifice cannot. Personal virtue can expose neglect and model possibilities, but it cannot substitute for political accountability. Nor does the failure of a project automatically prove that attempting it was wrong.
The lasting lesson is therefore not that readers should become saints or retreat into self-protection. It is that moral seriousness requires both an expanded field of concern and a clear-eyed account of limits. Admiration should prompt questions about efficacy, agency, and cost, rather than erase them. Skepticism should test care, not discredit it in advance. The book leaves readers with a demanding but productive uncertainty: how to honor strangers without destroying the bonds and capacities that make sustained help possible.
Review Summary
Strangers Drowning explores extreme altruism through profiles of individuals who dedicate their lives to helping others, often at great personal cost. The book examines philosophical and psychological perspectives on altruism, challenging readers to consider their own moral obligations. While some reviewers found it thought-provoking and well-written, others criticized its lack of clear conclusions. Many readers appreciated MacFarquhar's nuanced approach and compelling storytelling, though some felt uncomfortable with the extreme examples presented. Overall, the book sparked reflection on the nature of goodness and human responsibility.
People Also Read
Glossary
human sublime
awe mixed with uneaseMacFarquhar's description of the response prompted by radically self-sacrificing lives. Such a life can appear beautiful and morally impressive, yet also frightening or alien because its discipline and demands seem impossible to sustain. The term captures the reader's simultaneous admiration and resistance, rather than labeling the do-gooder simply a hero or a fool.
World Equity Budget
a self-imposed spending limitCharles Gray's attempt to restrict his personal spending to an amount he considered a fair share of global wealth. He calculated a very low annual budget and gave away the rest. For Gray, the limit expressed economic justice and a refusal to live comfortably amid poverty, though others questioned whether choosing poverty directly helped poor people.
effective altruism
evidence-guided charitable actionA movement that combines a commitment to helping others with research into which actions produce the greatest benefit for the resources used. In the book, members compare charities and interventions using evidence, including randomized trials where available. The approach also asks how careers and donations can be directed toward reducing suffering, rather than relying only on emotional appeal.
earning to give
earning more to donate moreA career strategy associated with effective altruism. Instead of choosing only direct service work, a person may enter a better-paid job and donate a substantial portion of the resulting income to effective causes. The strategy treats career choice as a way to help indirectly, while raising questions about whether the work itself causes harm or supports unjust systems.
Disability-Adjusted Life-Year
years weighted by healthA measurement used to compare the effects of illness and intervention on people's lives. It accounts not only for whether a person survives, but also for how long and in what condition. A year in full health counts differently from a year lived with a serious disability. GiveWell used the measure as one way to assess which problems and programs deserved priority.
codependency
harmful control through helpingA term that became widely used for patterns in which someone focuses excessively on managing another person's behavior, often in a relationship affected by addiction. In the book's account, the concept reframes some forms of self-sacrificing care as attempts to control, avoid one's own needs, or maintain a rescuer role. The critique is influential but does not mean all intense helping is pathological.
altruistic donation
organ donation to a strangerThe donation of a living person's organ, especially a kidney, to someone who is not a relative or close friend. Such donations once seemed psychologically suspicious to many transplant professionals, but changing medical practice and social expectations made them more acceptable. The book emphasizes that the gift can save a life while also creating questions about consent, gratitude, donor risk, and recipient selection.
supererogation
good beyond required dutyA term in moral philosophy for actions that are admirable and morally good but not obligatory. The concept preserves a distinction between basic duties, such as keeping a promise, and exceptional sacrifices that people may praise without demanding from everyone. The debate over do-gooders tests whether that distinction protects ordinary human limits or excuses avoidable indifference.
FAQ
What is Strangers Drowning by Larissa MacFarquhar about?
- Exploration of extreme altruism: The book investigates the lives of people who dedicate themselves to helping others, often at great personal cost, and examines the moral, psychological, and social complexities of selflessness.
- Profiles and philosophy: Through detailed narratives and philosophical inquiry, MacFarquhar presents individuals who embody the overpowering urge to help strangers, revealing both their motivations and the consequences of their actions.
- Themes of duty and sacrifice: It grapples with questions about how much morality can demand from a person, the tension between caring for family versus strangers, and the psychological and social consequences of extreme idealism.
- Cultural critique: The book situates personal stories within broader social and historical contexts, including skepticism about altruism and the rise of concepts like codependency.
Why should I read Strangers Drowning by Larissa MacFarquhar?
- Insight into moral extremity: The book offers a rare, nuanced look at people who push moral ideals to their limits, helping readers understand the psychological and ethical dimensions of radical altruism.
- Challenges assumptions: It questions everyday beliefs about morality, family loyalty, and the limits of duty, encouraging readers to reflect on their own values and actions.
- Engaging storytelling: MacFarquhar’s detailed profiles and vivid storytelling make complex philosophical ideas accessible and emotionally resonant.
- Relevance to modern dilemmas: The book addresses contemporary issues about helping others, codependency, and the limits of charity, making it timely and thought-provoking.
What are the key takeaways from Strangers Drowning by Larissa MacFarquhar?
- Complexity of selflessness: Extreme altruism is both inspiring and troubling, raising questions about the costs and limits of living for others.
- Ambivalence toward do-gooders: Society admires but also feels uneasy about those who devote themselves to strangers, reflecting deep-seated ambivalence about morality and human nature.
- Limits of helping: The book explores how helping can sometimes be harmful or self-destructive, and how the urge to help must be balanced with self-care and respect for others’ autonomy.
- Philosophical debates: It presents a range of philosophical arguments about duty, family, and the demands of morality, showing that there are no easy answers.
Who are some of the real-life do-gooders featured in Strangers Drowning by Larissa MacFarquhar, and what are their stories?
- Dorothy Granada: A nurse and activist who worked in Nicaragua, enduring war and personal sacrifice to provide healthcare to marginalized communities, transitioning from radical activism to hands-on nursing.
- Aaron Pitkin: An animal-rights advocate who lives frugally and dedicates his life to reducing suffering, especially for chickens, balancing pragmatism with moral rigor.
- Baba Amte and family: Indian social workers who founded leper colonies and rural health projects, showing generational legacies of moral commitment and ascetic discipline.
- Sue and Hector Badeau: A couple who adopted and fostered 22 children, many with severe trauma or disabilities, illustrating the joys and challenges of extreme altruistic parenting.
- Kimberly Brown-Whale: A pastor and altruistic kidney donor whose story intertwines faith, family, and the practical realities of helping others.
What are the key characteristics of do-gooders as described in Strangers Drowning by Larissa MacFarquhar?
- Unyielding sense of duty: Do-gooders possess a strong, often inflexible commitment to moral principles, living lives marked by discipline and sacrifice.
- Moral extremity and isolation: Their standards and emotions can seem inhumanly lofty, creating distance from others and sometimes unease or reproach.
- Not solely compassion-driven: Many do-gooders plan their actions coldly and commit to helping before encountering those in need, making their good deeds a way of life rather than occasional acts.
- Emotional control: They often suppress overwhelming emotions to maintain their commitments, which can make them seem detached or austere.
How does Strangers Drowning by Larissa MacFarquhar address the tension between caring for family and strangers?
- Moral conflict: Do-gooders often face the difficult choice of balancing obligations to family with duties to strangers, challenging the common belief that family always comes first.
- Historical and religious context: The book discusses how various traditions, from Abraham to Gandhi, have grappled with or rejected family claims to pursue larger moral causes.
- Societal ambivalence: Most people find it natural to prioritize family, and do-gooders’ impartiality can seem unnatural or even monstrous, fueling discomfort and suspicion.
- Philosophical implications: The tension highlights the limits of moral impartiality and the deep-rooted value of familial loyalty.
What philosophical arguments about morality and duty are explored in Strangers Drowning by Larissa MacFarquhar?
- Peter Singer’s shallow pond argument: The book explains Singer’s utilitarian view that if you would save a drowning child nearby, you should also help distant strangers, as distance carries no moral weight.
- Utilitarianism’s radical demands: It discusses how utilitarianism requires maximizing well-being impartially, often demanding extreme sacrifice and rejecting special duties to family.
- Critiques and alternatives: Philosophers like Bernard Williams argue that morality cannot override all other human concerns, such as loyalty and love, which give life meaning.
- Ambivalence and complexity: The book presents the ongoing debates and the psychological difficulty of living up to such demanding moral standards.
How does Strangers Drowning by Larissa MacFarquhar explore the concept of "codependency"?
- Origins in Al-Anon: Codependency emerged from the families of alcoholics, particularly through Lois Wilson, who recognized the compulsive need to control and help.
- Definition and evolution: By the 1980s, codependency described anyone preoccupied with controlling another’s behavior, often seen as a disease of excessive selflessness and control.
- Psychological dynamics: The book explores how codependency can stem from childhood trauma, leading to confusion between love, suffering, and control.
- Critiques and expansions: Melody Beattie and others expanded the concept, emphasizing the dangers of helping without consent and the risk of bitterness and victimhood.
What challenges do professional helpers face according to Strangers Drowning by Larissa MacFarquhar?
- Emotional overinvolvement: New social workers and therapists often work obsessively, sacrificing personal life and becoming emotionally entangled with clients, leading to burnout.
- Need for detachment: Over time, they learn to develop a "thick skin" to protect themselves, but too much detachment can lead to cynicism and loss of care.
- Complexity of change: Helpers confront the difficulty of effecting real change in others, often facing client resentment and systemic obstacles.
- Moral and psychological toll: The work is grueling, sometimes leading to self-destructive behaviors like drinking or apathy.
What criticisms of humanitarian aid and foreign aid workers are presented in Strangers Drowning by Larissa MacFarquhar?
- Moral delusions and powerlessness: Aid workers often impose help without understanding local contexts, leading to unintended harm and self-delusion about their effectiveness.
- Addiction to crisis: Some aid workers become addicted to the adrenaline of emergency work, paralleling the violence they seek to alleviate.
- Economic and political consequences: Aid can prolong conflicts, undermine local markets, and relieve governments of responsibility, perpetuating systemic problems.
- Accountability issues: NGOs may prioritize publicity and funding over actual impact, sometimes resembling a new form of colonialism with little scrutiny of results.
How does Strangers Drowning by Larissa MacFarquhar differentiate between harmful and healthy helping, especially in the context of AA and Al-Anon?
- Lois Wilson’s realization: Lois learned that trying to control her alcoholic husband prevented his self-change, and that relinquishing control was essential.
- AA’s mutual support: Bill Wilson’s sobriety was sustained by helping others like himself, emphasizing shared experience rather than control.
- Helping from above vs. alongside: The book distinguishes between imposing help and offering support as a fellow sufferer, with the latter being more healing.
- Codependency critique: Helping that stems from compulsion and control is often a disease, but a freely chosen moral life with duty and love is not pathological.
What are the best quotes from Strangers Drowning by Larissa MacFarquhar and what do they mean?
- On the nature of do-gooders: “The life of a zealous do-gooder is a kind of human sublime—by which I mean that, although there is a hard beauty in it, the word ‘beautiful’ doesn’t capture the ambivalence it stirs up.” This highlights the awe mixed with discomfort that do-gooders inspire.
- On duty and morality: “Love in action is a harsh and dreadful thing compared with love in dreams.” —Fyodor Dostoevsky. This underscores the difficult reality of living a moral life beyond idealized notions.
- On moral demands: “If you don’t do that, then you have to say that it’s permissible to value yourself more than a thousand times as much as you value strangers. Does that sound plausible? I don’t think that sounds very plausible.” —Toby Ord, illustrating the radical demands of utilitarian morality.
- On the cost of helping: The book is filled with reflections on the psychological and social costs of extreme altruism, challenging readers to consider the true meaning of selflessness.
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.