Key Takeaways
Judge art by the feeling it shares, not the pleasure it sells
Art connects people. Tolstoy rejects the idea that art is simply beauty, technical skill, or enjoyable entertainment. He defines it by what happens between people: an artist revives a feeling and gives it outward form, and an audience experiences that feeling too. Art matters because it lets people share emotional experience across distance and time.
A boy and a wolf. Tolstoy imagines a boy describing a frightening encounter with a wolf. If listeners feel the fear the boy remembers, his story is art. It can even be invented, provided the boy truly feels the fear he conveys. Art resembles language, but carries feelings where speech carries thoughts.
What's striking is the shift from art as an object to art as a relationship. The work succeeds not simply because it is well made, but because it changes what an audience feels alongside its maker. Social psychology likewise treats emotional contagion as a basic feature of group life, helping explain why a song or story can create closeness. Yet shared feeling is not automatically wise or humane. A crowd can be swept up by fear or hostility, so emotional connection needs a separate ethical test.
Trust sincerity, clarity, and specificity more than polish
Three signs of art. Tolstoy judges how strongly a work communicates by the particularity of its feeling, the clarity of its expression, and the artist's sincerity. A vague feeling, confusing presentation, or insincere performance weakens the connection. Sincerity matters most in his account: a genuine need to express a feeling tends to make it both distinctive and clear.
A telling comparison. Tolstoy recalls peasant women singing together while striking scythes. Their song lifted the mood of listeners, including him. That evening, a celebrated musician performed a late Beethoven sonata. The guests praised it, but Tolstoy thought the song had communicated a definite feeling while the sonata had not. For him, reputation and virtuosity could not substitute for felt communication.
The three tests resemble a communication model: there must be something distinctive to say, a form an audience can grasp, and a sender who appears to mean it. This makes sincerity more than a private virtue; it becomes a condition of credibility. But sincerity is difficult to verify from outside, and performers can learn to display it convincingly. The useful question is not whether a work looks earnest, but whether its details and choices sustain a coherent emotional experience.
Separate emotional contagion from spectacle, borrowing, and cleverness
Four substitutes for feeling. Tolstoy argues that works can imitate art without communicating an experience of their own. They may borrow familiar plots and symbols, pile up lifelike details, shock the senses with dramatic effects, or keep audiences busy with puzzles and technical ingenuity. These devices can attract attention, but attention is not the same as emotional connection.
His Wagner example. Tolstoy attends a performance drawn from Wagner's Ring cycle, a sprawling mythic drama with dwarfs, gods, magic objects, and elaborate musical motifs. He sees borrowed legend, theatrical machinery, sensory spectacle, and riddling plot working together to simulate artistic depth. His verdict is deliberately severe: the performance holds attention, he says, without conveying a unified feeling from composer to audience.
The distinction between attention and emotional communication remains useful in a culture built around spectacle and rapid novelty. A special effect can startle without deepening experience, just as a complicated plot can keep an audience guessing without changing its sympathies. Still, Tolstoy's attack on Wagner shows the danger of turning a criterion into a veto. Formal complexity can itself carry feeling, and an audience's effort may be part of the experience rather than an obstacle to it.
Trace elite art's decline to the loss of shared moral purpose
A crisis behind the theory. Tolstoy's argument grows from a broader spiritual struggle. The preface recounts his late-life search for a moral basis for living, echoed in Anna Karenina by Levin, a landowner haunted by death and the apparent meaninglessness of work. A peasant's plain account of living by truth and for God gives Levin a sense of moral direction grounded in shared life.
An elite substitute. Tolstoy argues that wealthy Europeans lost faith in Church Christianity but resisted the Christian demand for human equality. In his account, they replaced a common religious standard with personal pleasure and beauty. Art then became a privilege of the wealthy, detached from the feelings and lives of working people. This historical story explains why he treats aesthetics as a social and moral question.
Tolstoy's historical argument connects artistic taste to power: the people who fund and praise art can make their preferences appear universal. That anticipates sociology's account of cultural prestige as a marker of class. His account is also too neat. Religious authority, artistic change, and social privilege did not move in lockstep, and the Renaissance cannot be reduced to a single loss of faith. The lasting insight is less his chronology than his question: whose values become the official measure of art?
Ask whether a work's feelings widen solidarity or narrow it
Judge what art carries. Tolstoy separates a work's artistic force from the value of its feeling. A work may communicate sincerely and clearly yet promote feelings he considers harmful. To judge its content, he turns to what he calls the religious consciousness of an age: its highest shared understanding of human purpose and good.
His proposed standard. Tolstoy identifies that purpose with human brotherhood. Art that fosters compassion, self-denial, or ordinary shared joy can unite people; art that glorifies national superiority, class privilege, or sensual indulgence can divide them. He sees two valuable kinds: art expressing religious feelings of love and mutual responsibility, and everyday art expressing feelings accessible across social boundaries, such as tenderness or merriment.
This is a powerful ethical question for art: does a work expand sympathy beyond familiar allies, or tighten the boundary around a favored group? Research on social identity helps clarify the tension. Shared symbols can create solidarity within a community while making outsiders seem less worthy of care. Tolstoy's universal standard pushes against that exclusion. Its weakness is that he treats his own account of brotherhood as the settled measure, leaving little room for audiences who disagree about what moral progress requires.
Notice when art's institutions reward output over lived experience
The cost of the stage. Tolstoy opens with an opera rehearsal: workers labor in dusty passages while a conductor repeatedly berates singers and musicians over small errors. The production consumes time, labor, and money, yet he doubts that its contrived story and spectacle serve a meaningful human need. The scene makes the hidden costs of elite entertainment visible.
Three forces shape production. Tolstoy blames professional dependence, criticism, and art schools for encouraging imitation. Artists who must produce for buyers may manufacture subjects on demand. Critics can turn inherited reputations into rules, while schools teach established techniques and models. Tolstoy does not deny the value of skill; he argues that instruction can teach the craft around art, not the inner experience that gives a work its feeling.
The institutional critique still travels. Markets reward repeatable output, while critics and schools can make certain tastes look like neutral standards. At the same time, institutions preserve techniques, offer access to training, and give artists time and resources. Tolstoy's sharp distinction between craft and feeling is most useful as a warning, not a law: professional practice can support original work, even if it cannot guarantee it.
Demand accessibility, not insider credentials, from art
Understanding is part of the test. Tolstoy rejects the defense that good art is simply too advanced for ordinary people. If a work communicates a feeling, he argues, it should not require specialist knowledge or repeated exposure merely to produce its effect. Getting used to a work, he warns, is not the same as understanding it.
Shared stories endure. He points to the biblical story of Joseph and his brothers, which he considers moving across differences of age, education, and nationality. He also treats folk songs and stories as evidence that simple forms can carry powerful feelings. For Tolstoy, the ability to reach people broadly is not a bonus added to art. It is evidence that the work has communicated.
Accessibility is a democratic standard: it asks whether art communicates beyond the circle that already knows how to decode it. But difficulty can also be productive. An unfamiliar form may make an audience notice what familiar conventions hide, and interpretation can deepen rather than replace feeling. Tolstoy is strongest when he challenges the use of obscurity as a badge of superiority. He is less convincing when he assumes that broad comprehension is the only reliable measure of artistic achievement.
Restore jokes, songs, and household craft to art's center
Art is larger than galleries. Tolstoy sees art throughout ordinary life: lullabies, jokes, gestures, clothing, decoration, and ceremonies can all convey feelings between people. The narrow category of prestigious works in theatres, museums, and books captures only a small portion of this human activity.
Let more people make it. His vision of future art gives everyday forms greater respect and opens artistic activity to the whole population. He favors clear, concise expression and broad participation over elaborate technique reserved for professionals. In his view, a small story or tune that touches many people can matter more than an ambitious work that briefly entertains a wealthy few. Art's territory expands when ordinary experience counts as worthy material.
This broad definition resembles the idea that aesthetic life is embedded in everyday practice, not confined to institutions. It also changes the question from who is officially an artist to what acts of expression help people share experience. That shift can make culture more participatory without dismissing specialized work. The caution is that everyday art and professional art need not compete. A society can value a household song and a difficult symphony without pretending they serve identical purposes.
Use art to make brotherhood felt, not merely preached
Feeling moves what reason cannot. Tolstoy casts art as a partner to science: science clarifies ideas, while art carries them into people's feelings. A belief in human equality can remain abstract until stories, images, or songs make another person's suffering emotionally present.
A tool for social change. Tolstoy argues that shared artistic experience can teach habits of care without relying on punishment. Art has already helped societies pass on customs and loyalties; he wants it to cultivate respect for every person's dignity, compassion for animals, and shame about luxury built on others' deprivation. His aim is not entertainment for its own sake, but a culture in which mutual care becomes easier to feel and practice.
Tolstoy treats art as emotional rehearsal: imagining another person's experience can make a moral response more available in real life. That connects with education and civic life, where narratives can give abstract duties a human face. But art can rehearse cruelty and obedience as readily as compassion. Emotional power has no built-in moral compass. Tolstoy's account is most persuasive when its ethical direction stays explicit, and when audiences remain free to question who is included in the promised brotherhood.
Analysis
Tolstoy's most important move is to replace the question What is beautiful? with two harder questions: What feeling does this work transmit, and what kind of human relation does that feeling encourage? The first question makes art relational rather than a property of objects. The second prevents communication from becoming the sole measure of value. A work can communicate powerfully and still communicate contempt, vanity, or exclusion.
That double test gives the book unusual reach. Tolstoy links aesthetic judgment to labor, money, education, criticism, and class. The opera rehearsal is not merely an amusing attack on theatrical absurdity. It makes visible the workers and performers whose effort supports an entertainment system whose benefits, in his account, accrue to a narrow audience. His demand that ordinary songs, jokes, and stories count as art is therefore also a demand to widen cultural authority.
The theory's weakness lies in its confidence about moral consensus. Tolstoy calls brotherhood the religious consciousness of his time, but his account of that consciousness is a Christian interpretation he presents as universal. The principle is compelling; its claim to final authority is harder to accept. Similarly, emotional accessibility can be democratic, yet unfamiliar forms are not automatically empty, and specialist knowledge can deepen perception rather than merely mark status. Tolstoy sometimes treats his own taste as proof of general failure, especially in his denunciations of Wagner and late Beethoven.
The book remains valuable when read as a provocation rather than a reliable verdict on individual works. It asks audiences to notice who art serves, what feelings it normalizes, and whether formal sophistication masks an absence of lived experience. Its sharpest legacy is not that pleasure or beauty are irrelevant, but that neither can answer the ethical question of what shared feeling is for.
Review Summary
What Is Art? is a controversial work by Tolstoy that challenges conventional views on art. He argues that true art should be accessible to all, convey universal feelings, and promote Christian values. Tolstoy rejects much of classical and contemporary art as elitist and morally corrupt. While some readers appreciate his critique of commercialization and social inequality in art, others find his views extreme and dismissive of great works. The book stimulates debate on art's purpose and value in society, though Tolstoy's arguments are often seen as flawed or outdated.
People Also Read
Glossary
infectiousness
shared emotional impactTolstoy's measure of whether a work communicates a feeling from its maker to an audience. A work is infectious when people who encounter it experience a feeling related to the artist's own, and feel connected to the artist and to others who share the response. He also uses the strength of this effect to assess artistic force.
religious consciousness
shared sense of life's purposeTolstoy's term for a society's highest prevailing understanding of what life is for and what counts as good. It need not mean membership in a church or adherence to a formal creed. He argues that this shared moral orientation guides how a society should judge the feelings communicated by art.
counterfeit art
work that imitates artA work that resembles art through familiar subjects, realistic detail, dramatic effects, or intellectual puzzles, but does not communicate a feeling genuinely experienced by its maker. Tolstoy argues that such devices can produce excitement or interest that audiences mistake for artistic communication.
Christian art
art that unites humanityFor Tolstoy, art suited to the moral understanding of his time, centered on human kinship and mutual care. It communicates feelings that draw people toward unity rather than dividing them by class, nation, or religious faction. He includes both explicitly religious feelings and ordinary emotions broadly accessible to people.
universal art
art of shared everyday feelingsTolstoy's category for works that communicate simple feelings accessible across differences of class, education, and nationality. Examples include shared joy, tenderness, humor, and peacefulness. He treats such art as valuable because it can connect people without requiring specialized knowledge or belonging to a particular social group.
FAQ
What is "What Is Art?" by Leo Tolstoy about?
- Central Inquiry: The book investigates the fundamental question, "What is art?" and seeks to define its true nature and purpose in human life.
- Critique of Prevailing Views: Tolstoy challenges the common association of art with beauty, pleasure, and imitation, arguing that these definitions are vague and inadequate.
- Moral and Social Focus: He emphasizes art's role in uniting people, fostering moral development, and serving the highest ideals of society.
- Historical and Social Context: The work reflects Tolstoy's late-life spiritual crisis and his critique of upper-class culture, advocating for a more sincere, accessible, and morally grounded art.
Why should I read "What Is Art?" by Leo Tolstoy?
- Foundational Critique: The book offers a radical and influential critique of traditional aesthetics and the art world, challenging readers to reconsider what makes art valuable.
- Moral Perspective: Tolstoy’s focus on the ethical and social functions of art provides a unique lens for understanding the impact of art on society.
- Relevance Today: Many of Tolstoy’s concerns about elitism, accessibility, and sincerity in art remain relevant in contemporary debates about culture and creativity.
- Influence on Art Theory: The book has shaped discussions in philosophy, art criticism, and cultural studies, making it essential reading for anyone interested in the philosophy of art.
What are the key takeaways from "What Is Art?" by Leo Tolstoy?
- Art as Infectious Feeling: True art is the sincere transmission of feeling from artist to audience, creating a shared emotional experience.
- Rejection of Beauty as Criterion: Defining art by beauty or pleasure is misleading; art’s value lies in its ability to unite people and promote moral progress.
- Accessibility and Sincerity: Genuine art must be understandable and accessible to all, not just an elite few, and must be created with sincerity.
- Social and Religious Role: Art should align with the highest moral and religious ideals of its time, serving to elevate and unite humanity.
How does Leo Tolstoy define art in "What Is Art?"?
- Art as Communication: Tolstoy defines art as the conscious transmission of feelings from one person to others through external signs.
- Infectiousness as Essence: The defining feature of art is its ability to "infect" others with the artist’s feeling, creating a spiritual union.
- Beyond Beauty and Pleasure: He rejects the idea that art’s purpose is to manifest beauty or provide pleasure, focusing instead on its unifying and moral function.
- Necessity for Humanity: Art is as essential as language, enabling people to share experiences and emotions across time and space.
What is Tolstoy’s critique of defining art by beauty in "What Is Art?"?
- Subjectivity of Beauty: Tolstoy argues that beauty is a subjective and unstable concept, varying from person to person and culture to culture.
- Beauty vs. Goodness: He distinguishes between the good (an eternal aim) and the beautiful (subjective pleasure), warning that focusing on beauty can distract from moral values.
- Critique of Aesthetics: Tolstoy criticizes the tradition of aesthetics, especially since Baumgarten, for conflating beauty with the good and obscuring art’s true purpose.
- Misleading Foundation: He believes that using beauty as the criterion for art justifies exclusive, elitist, and often morally questionable works.
According to "What Is Art?" by Leo Tolstoy, what distinguishes true art from counterfeit art?
- Infectiousness as Test: True art infects the audience with the artist’s genuine feeling, while counterfeit art fails to do so.
- Three Conditions: The worth of art depends on the particularity of feeling, clarity of expression, and, most importantly, the sincerity of the artist.
- Counterfeit Methods: Counterfeit art relies on borrowing, imitation, effectfulness, and diversion rather than sincere feeling.
- Professionalism and Criticism: Professional artists, critics, and art schools often perpetuate counterfeit art by prioritizing technique and novelty over genuine emotion.
What role does religious consciousness play in Tolstoy’s definition of art in "What Is Art?"?
- Religious Criterion: The content of good art must align with the religious consciousness of the time, which defines the highest good and purpose of life.
- Christian Ideal: In Tolstoy’s era, this consciousness centers on brotherly love and the unity of all people, which art should promote.
- Historical Shifts: He traces how changes in religious consciousness have shaped the content and value of art throughout history.
- Art’s Purpose: Art should replace harmful feelings with those that foster kindness, unity, and spiritual progress.
How does Tolstoy critique the art of the upper classes in "What Is Art?"?
- Disconnection from the People: Tolstoy argues that upper-class art is exclusive, incomprehensible, and disconnected from the genuine feelings of the broader population.
- Counterfeit and Amusement: Much of this art serves only to amuse or distract a small elite, lacking sincerity and moral value.
- Loss of Religious Foundation: The decline of true art is linked to the loss of a shared religious consciousness among the upper classes.
- Social Consequences: This art perpetuates social divisions, wastes resources, and undermines the moral development of society.
What is Tolstoy’s view on professional artists, art criticism, and art schools in "What Is Art?"?
- Professionalism Weakens Sincerity: Making art a profession leads artists to create works for material gain, often at the expense of genuine feeling.
- Critics Set False Standards: Art critics, often lacking true sensitivity, promote cerebral and contrived works, distorting public taste.
- Art Schools Teach Technique, Not Feeling: Schools focus on technique and imitation, producing artists who lack sincerity and the capacity for true artistic infection.
- Multiplication of Counterfeit Art: These institutions contribute to the proliferation of counterfeit art and the public’s misunderstanding of what art truly is.
How does Tolstoy evaluate modern art movements and specific artists in "What Is Art?"?
- Critique of Symbolism and Decadence: Tolstoy condemns modern movements like symbolism and decadence for their obscurity, artificiality, and moral decline.
- Wagner as Counterfeit: He specifically criticizes Richard Wagner’s operas as masterful counterfeits, relying on spectacle and novelty rather than genuine feeling.
- Examples of True Art: Tolstoy praises simple, sincere works such as folk songs, children’s stories, and certain novels by Dickens and Dostoevsky.
- Contrast with Popular Art: He contrasts the infectious joy of popular art with the sterile complexity of much upper-class and modern art.
What does Tolstoy envision for the future of art in "What Is Art?"?
- Universal Accessibility: Art should be created by all gifted individuals, not just professionals, and be accessible to everyone through education.
- New Content and Form: Future art will focus on feelings aligned with brotherly love and simple, everyday emotions, emphasizing clarity and universality.
- Rejection of Professionalism: Artists will create out of inner need, not for profit, and art will cease to be a means of corruption or distraction.
- Role in Social Progress: Art will serve as a unifying force, promoting peace and the moral development of humanity.
How does Tolstoy relate the roles of science and art in human progress in "What Is Art?"?
- Interdependence of Science and Art: Tolstoy compares science and art to the lungs and heart, both essential for human progress.
- Science Introduces Truths: Science brings new truths into consciousness, while art transfers these truths into feeling, making them part of lived experience.
- Critique of Modern Science: He criticizes science that serves only curiosity or the status quo, arguing that it leads to false art.
- Call for True Science and Art: Both should be guided by the religious consciousness of the time, working together to promote brotherly union and the well-being of all.
What are the best quotes from "What Is Art?" by Leo Tolstoy and what do they mean?
- "Art is a human activity consisting in this, that one man consciously, by means of certain external signs, hands on to others feelings he has lived through, and that others are infected by these feelings and also experience them." This quote encapsulates Tolstoy’s definition of art as the sincere transmission of feeling.
- "The more we give ourselves to beauty, the more removed we are from the good." Tolstoy warns against prioritizing beauty over moral values, emphasizing the ethical purpose of art.
- "If the majority of men do not understand or feel what passes for art in their society, it is not because they are uneducated, but because this art is bad." He insists that true art must be accessible and understandable to all.
- "Science gives man the knowledge of life, art gives him the meaning of life." This highlights the complementary roles of science and art in human development.
- "The business of art consists precisely in making understandable and accessible that which might be incomprehensible and inaccessible in the form of reasoning." Tolstoy stresses art’s power to communicate complex truths through feeling.
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.