Start free trial
Trending New Genres Authors
EnglishEnglish
EspañolSpanish
简体中文Chinese
繁體中文Chinese (Traditional)
FrançaisFrench
DeutschGerman
日本語Japanese
PortuguêsPortuguese
ItalianoItalian
한국어Korean
РусскийRussian
NederlandsDutch
العربيةArabic
PolskiPolish
हिन्दीHindi
Tiếng ViệtVietnamese
SvenskaSwedish
ΕλληνικάGreek
TürkçeTurkish
ไทยThai
ČeštinaCzech
RomânăRomanian
MagyarHungarian
УкраїнськаUkrainian
IndonesiaIndonesian
DanskDanish
SuomiFinnish
БългарскиBulgarian
עבריתHebrew
NorskNorwegian
HrvatskiCroatian
CatalàCatalan
SlovenčinaSlovak
LietuviųLithuanian
SlovenščinaSlovenian
СрпскиSerbian
EestiEstonian
LatviešuLatvian
فارسیPersian
മലയാളംMalayalam
தமிழ்Tamil
اردوUrdu
Searching...
SoBrief
You Shouldn't Be Here

You Shouldn't Be Here

A teacher hunting her vanished cousin finds a body in her rental's wall. What is buried?
by Lauren Thoman 2024 381 pages
3.69
11k+ ratings
Listen
Immersive
V2.3
Amazon Kindle Audible
Try Full Access for 3 Days
Unlock listening & more!
Continue

Plot Summary

Prologue

At the abandoned North Ridge construction site, Piper Carden slips into a trailer after discovering that Raymond Realty’s accounts conceal payments she cannot explain. She finds the records that make the suspicious figures suddenly add up, but before she can leave, Doug Raymond appears and blocks the door.

Piper throws the folder at him and runs. A gunshot cracks behind her. She reaches the outside steps, tumbles down them, then crawls toward her car, struggling to move as the ground turns cold and wet beneath her.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The prologue makes financial scrutiny physically dangerous before the reader knows what Piper has uncovered. Her accounting skill, ordinarily a tool of order, becomes the means by which she enters a space controlled by a man who treats information as property. The scene also plants a crucial uncertainty: Piper escapes the trailer, but the text does not establish that she escapes Raymond. Her fragmented insistence that she is probably all right gives the reader the same false foothold that sustains the larger mystery.

A Cousin Vanishes

Madelyn follows Piper's silence to East Henderson

In college, Madelyn Zhao uses a DNA test to find Piper Carden, a cousin she has never met. The two exchange messages and plan an in-person visit, but Piper suddenly stops responding. Two years later, a lawyer seeking help with a lawsuit against Raymond Realty tells Madelyn that Piper is missing.

Madelyn has little useful information to offer, yet Piper’s disappearance stays with her. When a choir-director job opens in East Henderson, Madelyn accepts and rents a small cottage from Doug Raymond, the wealthy developer whose company had employed Piper.

She tells herself the job comes first, but chooses a landlord who may offer access to answers. Raymond’s invasive questions and punishing lease terms make the arrangement feel less like a welcome than a test.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Madelyn’s investigation begins in the uneasy overlap between family longing and self-reproach. She had wanted a cousin, but their short correspondence left her with the painful suspicion that she failed to notice Piper’s distress. Moving to East Henderson turns that regret into an action, though her plan is still partly protected by denial: she calls it a career choice, even while arranging to live under the power of the man she suspects. The lease establishes the novel’s central asymmetry in miniature. Raymond controls the property, the paperwork, and the terms; Madelyn has a signature and a question he does not know she is asking.

The Shower Sings

Angie hears a woman no one else can hear

Ten years earlier, sixteen-year-old Angie Stewart begins hearing unexplained sounds in her house: footsteps, conversation, and finally a woman singing in the shower. Her best friend, Bas García, suspects Angie's father may have a new girlfriend, a possibility that sharpens her hurt over her mother’s absence.

Angie believes the voice is trying to reach her. She and Bas buy a camera to gather proof, but its footage has no sound. Later, while they watch a horror movie, the television switches off by itself and Angie hears the singing again.

Bas hears nothing. Angie replays their audio recorder and finds only her own voice describing what she heard, leaving her isolated with evidence that proves her experience but cannot make anyone else share it.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Angie’s haunting is intimate before it is frightening. The songs brush against her family’s fracture, so each unexplained sound can be misread as proof that her father is replacing her mother or that Angie herself is losing control. Bas’s skepticism does not come from indifference; he worries about her, but his care takes the form of explanation and restraint. Angie needs him to witness what she experiences, while he needs her to accept uncertainty. Their friendship is therefore placed under pressure by a question neither can answer: whether believing someone means accepting their account, or helping them test it.

Coffee and a Warning

A new school brings Alex, Kelsey, and danger closer

Madelyn arrives in East Henderson with her small dog, Potato, and begins her first teaching job in a middle school. She makes an awkward entrance at the staff meeting, then meets Alex García, a warm Spanish teacher who helps her find her classroom and brings her coffee.

Their easy attraction offers a welcome counterweight to her tense dealings with Raymond. After Madelyn spills coffee during a later conversation with Alex, a red-haired woman named Nat lends her a clean shirt and warns her to be wary of Raymond.

Soon an email from Kelsey O’Donnell, the former employee who pursued Piper’s case, asks Madelyn to meet. Her first days have already connected her to a possible romance, a local warning, and the person who knows most about Piper’s disappearance.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Madelyn’s social world expands through small acts of practical care: Alex gives up his seat, Nat lends clothing, Kelsey asks to meet. These gestures matter because Madelyn has trained herself to distrust her own judgments after a controlling relationship with Ralph. She wants connection but keeps testing it for hidden costs. The contrast with Raymond is sharp. He takes up space, presses for personal information, and controls access to documents; the others make room for her. The story uses these everyday exchanges to distinguish power from intimacy before Madelyn has enough evidence to name the danger around her.

Kelsey Breaks Silence

Piper's friend explains Raymond's method of intimidation

Kelsey tells Madelyn that Piper was an accounting specialist who loved untangling numbers, until she began avoiding talk about work. When Piper disappeared, Kelsey questioned the company’s claim that she had quit. Raymond Realty isolated Kelsey at work, fired her, sued her, and eventually pressured her into signing a nondisclosure agreement as part of a settlement.

Kelsey believes Piper found a financial discrepancy and kept digging after managers dismissed her concerns. She also admits that she noticed Piper’s change in mood but did not push hard enough to learn why. Madelyn cannot offer proof or comfort that erases this guilt. She does promise to keep investigating, accepting that doing so may draw the company’s attention toward her.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Kelsey’s account makes silence an engineered outcome rather than a passive absence. The company does not need to persuade everyone that Piper left willingly; it needs only to make asking questions costly, then let coworkers mistake fear for consensus. Kelsey’s self-blame shows how effectively that machinery works. She measures herself against the impossible standard of having acted sooner, while the people who controlled the workplace escape ordinary scrutiny. Madelyn’s promise is ethically important but also psychologically risky: she is trying to answer her own regret about Piper by taking on responsibility that belongs to the powerful people who harmed her.

The Debt at Home

Angie learns her father may lose their house

Angie’s attempt to investigate the haunting collapses into a fight with Bas. After he tells her father about the camera because he fears for her, Angie feels betrayed and confronts her father about his absence. She then secretly records a conversation between her father, Cameron, and Doug Raymond.

The recording reveals that Cameron sold their home to Raymond after his construction business struggled, then rented it back and fell five months behind. Raymond gives him two weeks to pay.

Angie also learns that Cameron has been taking McDonald’s shifts and doing jobs for Raymond while trying to protect her from the family’s financial trouble. The house she thought was secure is now a debt clock. When Cameron cannot explain what happens if he fails to pay, Angie decides she must act.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The supernatural mystery gives way to a material threat that Angie can understand more clearly: rent, wages, and a deadline. Her father’s secrecy is meant as protection, but it leaves her unable to participate in the danger shaping her life. Bas’s disclosure produces the same contradiction. He violates Angie’s confidence because he fears she may be unwell, yet his attempt to help confirms her belief that no one trusts her account. The scene links economic dependency to emotional isolation. Cameron’s exhaustion is not simply a private failure; Raymond has converted a family’s need for stability into leverage.

A First Date, Almost

Madelyn risks closeness while Raymond tightens control

Madelyn and Alex grow closer over coffee and a first dinner at a neighborhood cheesesteak restaurant. Their conversation ranges from the school’s frightening intruder drills to the influence Raymond holds over local politics and property.

Madelyn enjoys Alex’s attentiveness, but her past with Ralph makes her wary of mistaking charm for safety. She chooses to end the evening before they go home together, and Alex kisses her goodbye.

Meanwhile, Raymond refuses to fix a leaking sink in Madelyn’s rental unless she pays for the repair herself, confirming that his polished rental promises do not extend to responsibility. When Madelyn later meets Nat at the library, Nat helps her search local records and reinforces that people in East Henderson fear Raymond for good reason.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

This section places two kinds of risk beside each other. Madelyn’s decision to slow the romance is an exercise of agency, not a rejection of desire; she is trying to distinguish chosen intimacy from the appeasement she learned with Ralph. Raymond’s refusal to maintain the house shows the opposite pattern, a relationship in which one party takes money and transfers every cost downward. Nat’s presence at the library enlarges the local network of resistance, while also keeping Madelyn’s growing trust provisional. The town is not uniformly complicit, but its residents have learned to calculate what dissent may cost.

A Murder at Raymond Realty

Angie witnesses violence and flees with Cameron

After learning Raymond is demanding money, Angie drives alone to his office, hoping to ask for more time. Through the darkened front window, she sees a woman stagger out of the back room and collapse as Raymond strikes her repeatedly with a heavy planter.

Angie tries to call emergency services, but her phone locks before she can complete the call. At home, she tells Cameron what she saw. He believes her, but says Raymond’s money and political connections make the police an unsafe bet, especially while Cameron owes him rent.

They pack what they can, abandon their phones, and leave within minutes. Angie secretly records Raymond’s name as the person responsible if anything happens to her, hides the recorder in her ghost-hunting bag, and drops the bag at Bas’s house during their hurried escape.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The story’s first major crime is witnessed from outside, a view that captures both the violence and Angie’s lack of power to intervene. She has no functioning phone, no evidence she can immediately use, and no reason to trust institutions that Raymond may influence. Cameron’s choice to flee protects his daughter in the immediate moment, but it also removes them from their home and erases the ordinary channels through which anyone might search for them. Angie’s recorder becomes a fragile substitute for testimony. Her decision to leave it with Bas expresses trust even after their fight, but she cannot ensure he will find or understand it.

Bas Comes Back

Alex recognizes Angie's old home in Madelyn's address

When Alex arrives at Madelyn’s cottage to help with her sink, he reacts with anger because he recognizes it as the Stewart family’s former home. He explains that his best friend Angie and her father vanished ten years earlier, after Angie had been hearing a ghost. Alex once heard a voice in the house telling him to help her, but by then she was gone.

His mother later finds Angie’s canvas bag in the attic and gives it to him. Alex asks Madelyn to inspect it for clues, unable to face the contents himself. Madelyn finds an audio recorder tucked into a pocket. Listening to the files, she recognizes a song Angie could not have known in 2014, then hears a final recording naming Raymond as the threat.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Alex’s anger at Madelyn is misdirected grief, triggered by a place that makes his past feel immediate again. His disclosure reframes the romance: the same house that gives Madelyn a new life has been the site of an unresolved disappearance. The recorder then turns private memory into evidence. Its ordinary sounds preserve a friendship that Alex has kept alive through guilt and unanswered messages. Madelyn’s discovery is both investigative and intimate; she holds the only surviving account of the person Alex lost. Her hesitation about telling him reflects care, but also repeats the secrecy that has already distorted both their lives.

A Voice Through Time

Madelyn discovers Angie heard her future voice

Madelyn listens through Angie’s recordings in chronological order and traces the unexplained sounds to her own present-day actions. Angie heard Madelyn singing songs that had not yet been written, along with noises from Potato and the plumbing.

Madelyn realizes that she is the voice Angie heard, and that Alex’s memory of a message asking him to help Angie may also have come from her. Before she can explain this to Alex, Kelsey arrives at school with a warning: Raymond’s lawyers have threatened her again, and someone learned that she and Madelyn met.

Kelsey breaks off contact but urges Madelyn not to abandon Piper. Madelyn must now weigh a startling connection across time against the concrete danger Raymond poses to anyone who investigates him.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The time-crossing voice unsettles the usual boundary between evidence and explanation. Madelyn can identify the source of Angie’s sounds, but cannot control what crosses the divide or when. The discovery therefore does not give her mastery; it gives her a new obligation and a troubling possibility that her own actions helped shape the past. Kelsey’s warning grounds the speculative revelation in present danger. The story refuses to let wonder become an escape from material consequences: Raymond can still threaten a living witness, while Madelyn’s extraordinary connection to Angie remains difficult to prove or use.

North Ridge's False Activity

Piper's coordinates lead to Raymond's stalled development

Madelyn and Alex question Wyatt, a former schoolmate who worked at Raymond Realty and knew Piper. Wyatt says the company discouraged discussion of bad publicity, but he offers little about Piper’s departure and leaves when Madelyn presses him.

Madelyn later finds coordinates hidden beneath a photo Piper had sent her, and she and Alex follow them to North Ridge, an apparently abandoned business park. A contractor, Laird, explains that the project stopped during the pandemic, though Raymond paid to keep its permits current with occasional token work.

Laird confirms Piper once handled the project’s accounts. The discovery gives Madelyn a plausible reason for Piper’s concern: North Ridge remains active on paper despite looking deserted, and Raymond has made sure its paperwork continues to tell a different story.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The evidence here is bureaucratic rather than spectacular: a coordinate string, a permit, a contractor’s recollection. Its force comes from the mismatch between what the site looks like and what its records claim. Wyatt’s discomfort demonstrates how a culture of silence persists even after employment ends; people may not defend Raymond so much as avoid the cost of contradicting him. Laird’s account turns the abandoned site into a deliberate financial instrument, though its purpose remains unclear. The investigation advances by comparing records and testimony, not by finding a single confession, which makes Madelyn’s work feel both more credible and more precarious.

A Skeleton in the Wall

Potato uncovers a body hidden inside Madelyn's home

After Alex helps repair the drywall, Potato digs through the weakened patch and drags out a skeletal hand. The remains are concealed inside a space that had once been a linen closet, which means the body was hidden after Angie and Cameron left. Alex fears it may be Angie; Madelyn cannot rule out Piper.

They avoid calling the local police because Raymond’s influence could turn the discovery against them, but a courier soon delivers a cease-and-desist letter accusing Madelyn of damaging the house and defaming the company. She moves to Alex’s home. After she tells him she believes she is the voice Angie heard, he withdraws. The next day he disappears, and Madelyn learns he has taken the hand to North Ridge to confront Raymond.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The hidden remains collapse the distance between investigation and domestic life. Madelyn’s home is not merely a place she rents from Raymond; it contains evidence that someone used its architecture to erase a person. Potato’s digging, previously a comic nuisance and a threat to the deposit, becomes the means of discovery. The couple’s different responses reveal competing survival strategies: Alex seeks direct confrontation, while Madelyn fears a system already shaped by Raymond. Their emotional rupture is inseparable from the mystery. Madelyn’s confession about the temporal link asks Alex to trust something he cannot verify just as the evidence makes trust more urgent.

The North Ridge Trap

Raymond shoots Alex before Angie returns

Madelyn reaches North Ridge to find Alex bound to rebar and Raymond holding a gun. Raymond shoots Alex in the leg, and Madelyn uses her shirt and zip ties to slow the bleeding before binding herself beside him.

A woman Madelyn knows as Nat appears with a gun and reveals she is Angie, alive after ten years in hiding. Angie had returned after recognizing Madelyn as the person from her ghostly messages. Her gun is unloaded, but when Raymond seizes it, Angie and Madelyn fight him while Alex loses consciousness.

Raymond nearly strangles Angie, until Syzygy arrives using a siren app and a Taser disguised as a police weapon. Syzygy incapacitates him. Angie stays behind to deal with Raymond as Syzygy drives Madelyn and Alex to a Philadelphia hospital.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The confrontation brings the novel’s separate forms of testimony into one place: Madelyn’s present-day search, Angie’s eyewitness memory, Alex’s old guilt, and the physical body parts that led them here. Raymond relies on the same tactics he used in private, tying people down and making violence look like a matter he can manage. His control falters when the people he has isolated act together. Angie’s return is not a supernatural rescue but the result of a living person interpreting a message across time and choosing to come back. Syzygy’s improvised intervention adds a practical counterweight to the menacing machinery of money and guns.

The Evidence Goes Public

A viral video brings the FBI into Raymond's empire

At the hospital, Madelyn and Alex recover from broken fingers and a shattered leg while Syzygy helps give their account to investigators. Angie’s footage of Raymond’s threats and violence spreads online, and authorities take him into custody.

The FBI identifies the body in Madelyn’s wall as Abigail Norris-Graham, a liaison between Raymond and a property corporation. Piper’s message contains encrypted financial records, linking her disappearance to irregularities at North Ridge.

Investigators find Piper’s remains in a foundation there, along with four other bodies, including two missing employees whose departures had been falsely reported as resignations. The inquiry exposes money laundering, gunrunning, and Raymond’s corporate ties. His power does not vanish overnight, but the evidence makes it much harder for him to silence everyone separately.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The resolution depends on a change in scale. Raymond’s control worked locally because each victim’s evidence was isolated: a private recording, an unexplained disappearance, a lawsuit sealed by an agreement. Once those fragments are combined with video, digital records, and physical remains, the pattern becomes legible to institutions outside his immediate influence. The novel does not present justice as automatic or complete; the FBI’s involvement follows an accumulation of evidence, and Raymond’s resources remain a real concern. What changes is the distribution of credibility. People once dismissed as disgruntled or unreliable can now corroborate one another.

Epilogue

Three months later, Madelyn and Angie share an apartment, while Alex recovers from surgery and Syzygy and Angie begin a relationship. The FBI has identified Abigail, uncovered Piper’s financial records, and found several more victims at North Ridge. Raymond faces numerous criminal charges, though Angie still cannot know why he killed Abigail.

The four friends gather for a horror movie, and Angie suggests that Abigail may have connected her and Madelyn across time. No one can prove the theory. Madelyn calls it a ghost story anyway: two living women haunted by unfinished business, now sitting together in the same room.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The epilogue resolves the practical mystery while leaving the metaphysical one open. The FBI can identify bodies, trace money, and expose Raymond’s network, but it cannot explain why Madelyn’s voice reached Angie before Madelyn arrived. Angie’s theory about Abigail gives the haunting a possible agent, not a definitive answer. That uncertainty suits a story where accountability depends on evidence but emotional meaning exceeds what evidence can settle. The final gathering also shifts the image of haunting from isolation to relationship. The characters remain marked by what happened, but they are no longer forced to carry the past alone.

Analysis

The novel binds a domestic mystery to a corporate one, then refuses to treat either as merely metaphorical. A song heard through a shower wall may cross time, but rent arrears, sealed settlements, missing workers, and bodies embedded in construction are concrete mechanisms of power. Raymond’s influence is frightening because it is distributed across ordinary systems: a lease, a payroll, a permit, a local police force, a lawyer’s letter. His victims are not simply disbelieved; they are made expensive to believe.

Madelyn and Angie form an unusual pair of investigators because their connection is real before either understands its terms. Madelyn’s future voice reaches Angie, but it does not deliver a clear rescue plan. This limitation prevents the time-crossing device from becoming a shortcut. The women still have to interpret fragments, make mistakes, and act under pressure. The recordings show how easily ordinary sounds can be mistaken for haunting, while the unexplained songs preserve a genuine relation between lives separated by a decade.

The characters’ emotional injuries shape the investigation’s ethics. Madelyn’s past with Ralph has taught her to mistrust her own perception; Kelsey’s lawsuit has taught her that speaking can destroy one’s security; Alex’s guilt has turned an unanswered call into a lifelong verdict against himself. Angie, meanwhile, knows that surviving is not the same as being free. Each person has reason to withdraw, and the plot advances when they risk trusting one another despite that history.

Justice arrives not through a lone brilliant accusation but through convergence. Piper’s records, Angie’s memory, Madelyn’s recordings, the body in the wall, and the video of Raymond’s violence become persuasive together. The novel’s strongest claim is therefore about collective evidence: power thrives when each witness is isolated, while truth becomes actionable when their separate fragments can be placed side by side.

Summary in 60 Seconds
College student Madelyn Zhao tracks down her cousin Piper, who disappears after uncovering suspicious accounts at Raymond Realty. Two years later, Madelyn moves to East Henderson to investigate, renting a house from the powerful developer Doug Raymond. A decade earlier, teenager Angie Stewart heard a woman's voice in that same house before fleeing after witnessing Raymond kill someone. Madelyn discovers that her voice reached Angie across time, and finds a recorder linking Raymond to Angie’s disappearance. When a skeleton emerges from the wall, Madelyn learns it is a murdered corporate liaison. Raymond captures Madelyn and Alex at North Ridge, but Angie returns and, with help from a masked ally, stops him. Angie's video and Piper's records reach investigators, who find Piper and four other victims buried at North Ridge. Raymond faces criminal charges. Angie and Madelyn reunite, though the source of their connection remains unexplained.
Contains spoilers

Last updated:

Report Issue

Review Summary

3.69 out of 5
Average of 11k+ ratings from Goodreads and Amazon.

You Shouldn't Be Here receives mixed reviews, averaging 3.69/5. Praise centers on unexpected plot twists, compelling dual perspectives, engaging characters, and a satisfyingly hateable villain. Many readers enjoy chapter-opening social media excerpts that build atmosphere. Criticism focuses on slow pacing in the first half, an underdeveloped villain, and bland character reactions. A notable point of division involves the book's political undertones and a non-binary character, with some readers objecting strongly while others celebrate the representation.

Your rating:
4.63
7 ratings
Want to read the full book?

Characters

Madelyn Zhao

Reluctant amateur investigator

Madelyn is a new middle-school choir director who moves from Pennsylvania college life to East Henderson with a small dog, a modest salary, and a family mystery she has never been able to set aside. Her brief correspondence with her missing cousin Piper left her feeling that she had failed to ask enough questions. That regret makes her curious, but her history with Ralph also leaves her prone to doubting her instincts and apologizing for taking up space. Madelyn’s warmth shows in small, practical acts, while her anxiety makes every choice feel capable of becoming a mistake. She is drawn to puzzles because patterns promise order, yet the investigation forces her to act before she has certainty.

Angie Stewart

Haunted, sharp-eyed teenager

Angie is a horror-loving teenager whose curiosity makes unexplained events difficult to ignore. She is funny, stubborn, and observant, but her mother’s departure has made her sensitive to signs that she is unwanted or being left behind. Her friendship with Bas gives her a trusted witness and a source of friction: she wants him to believe her experiences, while he wants to protect her from conclusions he cannot verify. Angie’s resourcefulness is concrete rather than polished. She buys inexpensive recording equipment, follows her suspicions, and tries to leave useful evidence when events outrun her ability to explain them.

Alex García

Teacher carrying old guilt

Alex is a Spanish teacher and a longtime East Henderson resident. As a teenager, he was Angie’s closest friend, a relationship built on shared movies, teasing, and familiar family routines. His easy kindness helps Madelyn feel welcome at school, but his calm manner conceals a grief he has never fully resolved. He changed from going by Sebastián to Alex after Angie vanished, a small act that signals how thoroughly the loss altered his sense of himself. Alex is caring and observant, yet his guilt can turn into passivity: for years, he has treated the failed search as proof that he must accept not knowing what happened.

Doug Raymond

Untouchable local developer

Doug Raymond is a wealthy real-estate developer whose company and personal influence reach into housing, local politics, and employment. He presents himself as a self-made businessman who rewards success, while treating tenants and employees as people who should accept his terms. His control is not limited to money. He uses paperwork, reputation, access, and the threat of legal action to make resistance feel irrationally expensive. Raymond’s public geniality can coexist with private contempt, allowing him to appear ordinary to people who have not yet challenged him. He is driven by entitlement and an appetite for control, especially over people whose livelihoods depend on him.

Piper Carden

Missing numbers specialist

Piper is Madelyn’s newly discovered cousin and an accounting specialist at Raymond Realty. She is meticulous, curious, and unusually absorbed by the work of making figures reconcile. Her friendship with Kelsey gives her an everyday confidante, while her correspondence with Madelyn offers the possibility of a family connection she has long wanted. Piper’s messages reveal a person who is busy and capable, but also someone who keeps much of her work life to herself. Her disappearance leaves both women with different regrets: Madelyn fears she did not build their relationship quickly enough, and Kelsey wonders whether she should have pressed Piper about changes in her behavior.

Kelsey O'Donnell

Piper's stubborn advocate

Kelsey worked alongside Piper and refused to accept Raymond Realty’s claim that her friend had simply quit. Her persistence cost her a job, savings, and the freedom to speak openly about the case. She is perceptive about how institutions isolate dissenters, but the price of her own fight has left her wary and burdened by guilt. Kelsey believes she should have pushed Piper harder before she disappeared, even though she had no way to know what the questions would cost. Her warning to Madelyn comes from experience, not from a wish to discourage her.

Syzygy

Protective, irreverent friend

Syzygy is Madelyn’s former roommate and closest confidant, a psychology graduate student with a theatrical style and a dry, often apocalyptic sense of humor. They are emotionally perceptive without being solemn, able to interrupt Madelyn’s spirals with blunt questions and practical advice. Their loyalty is not abstract: they keep track of Madelyn’s safety, challenge her self-doubt, and remain ready to travel when she needs help. Syzygy’s irreverence is a form of care, but beneath the jokes is a clear understanding that powerful people can make danger real.

Cameron Stewart

Struggling contractor and father

Cameron is Angie’s father, a contractor whose business falters as costs rise and larger companies undercut his work. After Angie’s mother leaves, he tries to keep the household stable without telling his daughter how precarious their finances have become. His secrecy comes from shame and a protective instinct, but it leaves Angie carrying adult responsibilities without the information she needs. Cameron is hardworking and loving, yet his belief that he can solve everything alone narrows the family’s options.

Nat

Eccentric local ally

Nat is a red-haired East Henderson local with bold clothes, sharp humor, and an instinct for recognizing when someone needs help. She lends Madelyn a shirt after a coffee spill, warns her about Raymond, and assists with local research. Nat is cautious about what she reveals and watches people closely before deciding whether to trust them. Her unconventional manner makes her easy to underestimate, but she is more attentive to the town’s threats than she lets on.

Abigail Norris-Graham

Corporate dealmaker

Abigail is a skilled corporate liaison who negotiates agreements between a national property company and local businesses. She is ambitious, socially astute, and practiced at managing men who mistake her professionalism for personal interest. Her work puts her in rooms where money and influence are being arranged, while her sharp reading of power helps her plan a path upward.

Wyatt Schaeffer

Former company employee

Wyatt attended high school with Alex and later worked at Raymond Realty. He is socially awkward and eager for reconnection, but uncomfortable when a reunion turns into questioning about his former employer. His response reflects the ordinary pressures that help workplace silence endure: he wants to avoid conflict and sees the company’s problems as someone else’s concern.

Laird

Contractor with useful records

Laird is a contractor who once worked on Raymond Realty’s North Ridge project and later runs his own company. He speaks plainly about delayed payments and the odd arrangement that kept the project’s permits current after construction stopped. His practical knowledge helps Madelyn and Alex distinguish a real job from a paper trail maintained for another purpose.

Plot Devices

Angie's audio recorder

Preserves lost testimony

Angie records long stretches of household sound while trying to prove that a ghost is present. Years later, Madelyn receives the recorder through Alex and listens to its files. The recordings preserve ordinary conversations, the strange songs Angie heard, a conversation between Cameron and Raymond, and Angie’s warning about Raymond. They function as both a physical clue and a narrative bridge between the two timelines. The device cannot explain how the voices cross time, but it gives the characters something concrete to hear, replay, and compare.

Piper's hidden coordinates

Points toward North Ridge

Piper sends Madelyn a photograph with a string of geographic coordinates beneath it. Madelyn initially overlooks the numbers, then recognizes their location as North Ridge, Raymond Realty’s stalled business park. The site appears abandoned while permits remain current, creating a mismatch that directs the investigation toward the project’s accounts. The coordinates turn Piper’s otherwise casual message into a delayed clue and connect her financial work to the larger mystery.

Raymond's intimidation playbook

Makes witnesses disappear socially

Raymond Realty responds to questions with denial, isolation, dismissal, lawsuits, and nondisclosure agreements. Kelsey experiences the pattern first, losing her job and eventually her freedom to discuss Piper’s case. Madelyn later receives a legal threat after investigating the company. The tactics create a climate in which coworkers treat silence as safety and outsiders mistake the lack of public evidence for proof that nothing happened.

Potato's wall digging

Turns nuisance into evidence

Madelyn’s small dog repeatedly scratches and digs at the wall outside the bathroom. At first, Madelyn treats the behavior as a lease-damaging habit and tries to deter it. When the damaged drywall is opened for repair, Potato reaches into the concealed space and pulls out a skeletal hand. The dog’s fixation gives a comic domestic problem a literal scent trail, revealing that the house contains something its owner has hidden.

North Ridge's permits

Keeps a dead site alive

Although construction at North Ridge halted during the pandemic, Raymond pays a contractor to maintain the project’s permits through occasional token work. The current paperwork makes the site appear active to outsiders while the land remains largely deserted. That arrangement provides a plausible cover for unexplained vehicles, financial transactions, and hidden foundations. The permits first look like bureaucratic residue, then become a clue that Raymond has a reason to preserve access to the property.

About the Author

Lauren Thoman is a speculative fiction author writing for both teens and adults. Her debut novel, I'll Stop the World, was selected by Emmy-nominated actress and producer Mindy Kaling for her imprint, Mindy's Book Studio, in 2023. Beyond fiction, Thoman has contributed pop culture writing to prominent outlets including Parade and Vulture. She resides outside Nashville, Tennessee, with her husband, two children, and an assortment of dogs and fish. When not writing, she enjoys searching for tacos and coffee, tending to her garden, and spending time with her dogs.

Download PDF

To save this You Shouldn't Be Here summary for later, download the free PDF. You can print it out, or read offline at your convenience.
Download PDF
File size: 0.30 MB     Pages: 25

Download EPUB

To read this You Shouldn't Be Here summary on your e-reader device or app, download the free EPUB. The .epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.
Download EPUB
File size: 1.29 MB     Pages: 32
Want to read the full book?
Follow
Listen
Home
Swipe
Library
Get App
Try Full Access for 3 Days
Listen, bookmark, and more
Compare Features Free Pro
📖 Read Summaries
Read unlimited summaries. Free users get 3 per month
🎧 Listen to Summaries
Listen to unlimited summaries in 40 languages
—
❤️ Unlimited Bookmarks
Free users are limited to 4
—
📜 Unlimited History
Free users are limited to 4
—
📥 Unlimited Downloads
Free users are limited to 1
—
Risk-Free Timeline
Today: Get Instant Access
Listen to full summaries of 26,000+ books. That's 12,000+ hours of audio!
Day 2: Trial Reminder
We'll send you a notification that your trial is ending soon.
Day 3: Your subscription begins
You'll be charged on Nov 24,
cancel anytime before.
Consume 2.8× More Books
2.8× more books Listening Reading
Our users love us
1M+ readers
Trustpilot Rating
TrustPilot
4.6 Excellent
This site is a total game-changer. I've been flying through book summaries like never before. Highly, highly recommend.
— Dave G
Worth my money and time, and really well made. I've never seen this quality of summaries on other websites. Very helpful!
— Em
Highly recommended!! Fantastic service. Perfect for those that want a little more than a teaser but not all the intricate details of a full audio book.
— Greg M
Save 62%
Yearly
$119.88 $44.99/year/yr
$3.75/mo
Monthly
$9.99/mo
Start a 3-Day Free Trial
3 days free, then $44.99/year. Cancel anytime.
Unlock a world of fiction & nonfiction books
26,000+ books for the price of 2 books
Read any book in 10 minutes
Discover new books like Tinder
Request any book if it's not summarized
Read more books than anyone you know
#1 app for book lovers
Lifelike & immersive summaries
30-day money-back guarantee
Download summaries in EPUBs or PDFs
Cancel anytime in a few clicks

Why one summary?

Scanner
Find a barcode to scan

⭐
⭐
⭐
We have a special gift for you
Open
38% off
DISCOUNT FOR YOU
⭐
⭐
⭐
$79.99
$49.99/year
Only $4.16 per month
Continue
2 taps to start, super easy to cancel
Settings
General
Widget
Loading...