Start free trial
Trending New Genres Authors
EnglishEnglish
EspañolSpanish
简体中文Chinese
繁體中文Chinese (Traditional)
FrançaisFrench
DeutschGerman
日本語Japanese
PortuguêsPortuguese
ItalianoItalian
한국어Korean
РусскийRussian
NederlandsDutch
العربيةArabic
PolskiPolish
हिन्दीHindi
Tiếng ViệtVietnamese
SvenskaSwedish
ΕλληνικάGreek
TürkçeTurkish
ไทยThai
ČeštinaCzech
RomânăRomanian
MagyarHungarian
УкраїнськаUkrainian
IndonesiaIndonesian
DanskDanish
SuomiFinnish
БългарскиBulgarian
עבריתHebrew
NorskNorwegian
HrvatskiCroatian
CatalàCatalan
SlovenčinaSlovak
LietuviųLithuanian
SlovenščinaSlovenian
СрпскиSerbian
EestiEstonian
LatviešuLatvian
فارسیPersian
മലയാളംMalayalam
தமிழ்Tamil
اردوUrdu
Searching...
SoBrief
Killing Commendatore

Killing Commendatore

A painter's retreat is unsettled by a buried bell and a figure from a hidden painting.
by Haruki Murakami 2018 681 pages
3.91
72k+ ratings
Listen
Immersive
V2.3
Amazon Kindle Audible
Try Full Access for 3 Days
Unlock listening & more!
Continue

Plot Summary

Prologue

After a nap, the painter finds a tall, faceless man seated across from him. The visitor returns a small penguin charm and asks for a portrait, reminding the painter of a promise made earlier.

Though the painter fetches paper and pencil, he cannot give shape to the shifting blankness where a face should be. The visitor vanishes, taking the charm with him. The encounter frames the story’s central unease: whether an image can give form to what ordinary sight cannot hold.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The prologue turns portraiture into a test of whether attention can make the invisible legible. The painter’s skill depends on reading small, human particulars, yet the faceless visitor offers no features to interpret. His paralysis is not a failure of technique so much as a crisis of representation: the painter cannot simply project a recognizable identity onto absence. The penguin charm links this impossible commission to protection and attachment, while the visitor’s return foreshadows how the story’s images will acquire agency. The frame also unsettles chronology, placing a future encounter before the events that make it possible.

Rain Sends Him North

Yuzu ends their marriage without explaining her dream

At thirty-six, the unnamed painter learns that Yuzu, his wife of six years, is seeing another man and no longer wants to live with him. A vivid dream has clarified her decision, but she refuses to describe it. He leaves their Tokyo apartment that evening, drives north without a destination, quits portrait commissions, and throws his phone into a river.

For weeks he crosses Hokkaido and northeastern Japan, sleeping in cheap inns and a tent while memories of Yuzu crowd out the landscape. When his old Peugeot breaks down, he abandons it and returns to Tokyo. His art-school friend Masahiko Amada offers him his father’s vacant mountain house near Odawara, giving the displaced painter somewhere to begin again.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The separation is a rupture in the narrator’s sense of sequence as much as in his marriage. Yuzu’s dream supplies an explanation that he cannot inspect, leaving him with an event but no usable cause. His drive north converts that helplessness into motion: by discarding his phone and abandoning work, he removes the structures that once organized his days. Yet he does not find clarity on the road. The breakdown of the Peugeot ends the flight almost arbitrarily, suggesting that a new life begins not through a deliberate plan but when escape itself becomes unsustainable.

A Studio Without Images

A gifted portraitist cannot begin his own painting

The house belongs to Tomohiko Amada, Masahiko’s celebrated father, now living with dementia in a care home. The narrator teaches art twice a week and sleeps with two married students, searching for contact while his own canvas stays blank.

His successful commercial portraits had been built from interviews, photographs, and an ability to reconstruct a client from memory; he had learned to find what shone beneath a guarded face. Yet freedom from commissions brings no immediate inspiration.

His isolation also revives memories of Komi, his younger sister, whose childhood death left him fearful of confinement and unable to forget the face he once sketched repeatedly. Then nighttime rustling sends him into the attic, where he discovers a wrapped painting bearing an ominous title.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The narrator’s professional competence has depended on intimacy kept at a controlled distance. He listens closely to clients, then paints them after they leave, turning empathy into a reliable method of work. His own freedom disrupts that arrangement: without a paying subject, he cannot summon an image. The house offers a different model of artistic life, one shaped by Tomohiko Amada’s solitude and by the marks left in a room through repeated labor. Komi’s death explains why the narrator draws to preserve memory, but also why enclosed spaces and incomplete losses remain difficult for him to face.

The Attic's Bloody Scene

Amada’s hidden painting recasts Mozart as ancient violence

The narrator unwraps the painting and finds a Japanese-style scene of a young man stabbing an old commander while a woman and servant recoil. A strange, bearded watcher peers from a square opening in the ground.

The composition echoes the opening murder in Mozart’s Don Giovanni, with the killer, victim, daughter, and servant mapped onto the opera’s characters, though Amada has altered the scene and added the watcher. The narrator studies the work obsessively, unable to paint his own canvas.

Its violence differs sharply from Amada’s serene historical paintings, and its concealment suggests a private purpose. Across the valley, a white concrete mansion catches his attention. Its solitary occupant, like the hidden painting, seems to keep something important out of view.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The painting does more than quote an opera: it relocates a European story into an imagined Japanese past, making cultural translation itself part of the mystery. Its added underground observer breaks the balance of the familiar Don Giovanni scene and gives the image an unsettling second audience. The narrator’s decision to unwrap a work that was deliberately hidden is an ethical breach, but also the act that begins his creative return. He responds to the painting as both a work of craft and a sealed message, sensing that technical mastery cannot explain why Amada chose to keep it from the world.

Menshiki Across the Valley

A wealthy recluse demands a portrait painted from life

The mansion’s owner introduces himself as Wataru Menshiki, a wealthy former technology entrepreneur with striking white hair, a private life, and an appetite for opera. He has traced the narrator’s work, visited people who own his portraits, and paid an extraordinary fee to secure a sitting.

Unlike the narrator’s usual clients, Menshiki wants to pose in person and gives him freedom to paint beyond conventional flattery. Their first sketches capture Menshiki’s features but feel strangely shallow, so the painter asks to know him better.

Menshiki explains that he retired after selling his company, lives alone, and has never married. He speaks of transformation through Tomohiko Amada’s career, while the narrator senses that the client’s curiosity hides a private purpose.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Menshiki arrives as both patron and observer, reversing the usual portrait relationship. He has already studied the painter’s work and selected him for qualities the artist himself has undervalued, while asking to be watched closely in return. His willingness to surrender artistic control sounds generous, yet it also sharpens the question of what he wants from the encounter. The failed sketches matter because the narrator’s established technique reads visible structure but cannot reach Menshiki’s interior. Here portraiture stops being a service performed on a client and becomes a risky exchange between two people who each suspect the other is concealing something.

The Pit Opens

A midnight bell leads two men beneath the shrine

For several nights, a faint bell sounds after the mountain insects fall silent. The narrator traces it to a stone mound behind a small shrine and tells Menshiki, who comes to hear it himself. They hire a landscape designer, with Masahiko’s permission, to move the stones. Beneath them, workers uncover a carefully built chamber, but no buried monk or trapped person: only an old Buddhist bell.

Menshiki connects the site to a story about a priest buried alive in pursuit of enlightenment, though the chamber offers no proof. The bell has been rung by someone or something, yet no one is found. The excavation ends with the hole exposed, the bell moved into the studio, and the original mystery intensified.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The excavation turns curiosity into responsibility. The narrator and Menshiki cannot leave a possible distress signal unanswered, but their practical intervention destroys the mound that had contained it. Their search produces an object instead of an explanation, exposing the limits of rational investigation without making the evidence disappear. The empty chamber also resonates with the narrator’s fear of confinement and with Menshiki’s unexplained attraction to enclosed spaces. Their choice to open the pit is thus both ethical and hazardous: they act to relieve uncertainty, but their action changes the conditions that made the mystery possible.

The Commendatore Walks

A miniature Idea emerges after the bell is removed

After the bell is brought indoors, it rings in the studio at night. The narrator enters with a walking stick and finds the Commendatore from Amada’s painting sitting on the sofa, about two feet tall.

The figure explains that he has borrowed the painted character’s form and calls himself an Idea, constrained by rules about where and when he can appear. The narrator accepts that this is not a dream, though he cannot explain its reality. Meanwhile, painting Menshiki finally releases his stalled hand: using the white hair he had initially omitted, he completes an unconventional image that Menshiki recognizes as himself.

The Commendatore’s appearance and the new portrait restore the artist’s confidence, while warning him that the boundary between image and living presence has become unstable.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The Commendatore gives the novel’s central artistic question a body, but not a stable identity. He is neither simply the dead man in the painting nor a conventional ghost; he is an Idea using an image as a temporary shape. This distinction makes the supernatural less an escape from representation than its consequence. The narrator’s portrait of Menshiki works similarly: it becomes convincing only when he paints the conspicuous white hair he had overlooked. In both cases, what is missing from an image may be the feature that allows it to become psychologically complete, or dangerously active.

A Daughter Across the Valley

Menshiki chooses possibility over a paternity test

At a dinner in his mansion, Menshiki reveals that a former lover may have conceived a daughter, Mariye, during their last encounter fifteen years earlier. The woman later married another man and died; Menshiki received a letter after her death that strengthened his suspicion but could not prove it.

He refuses DNA testing because either answer would deepen his loss. He has bought the house across the valley to watch Mariye from afar, and now asks the narrator to paint her portrait so he can spend time near her. The narrator agrees only if the painting remains his artistic decision.

Their conversation also opens a second mystery: Menshiki and Masahiko describe Tomohiko Amada’s involvement in a failed anti-Nazi plot in Vienna, and Masahiko later links that silence to his uncle Tsuguhiko’s suicide after serving in China.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Menshiki’s choice is not simply a refusal of facts. He treats uncertainty as a livable relationship, preferring an unresolved possibility to a truth that could not repair the past. His surveillance of Mariye makes this strategy ethically troubling: he preserves distance to protect her existing life, yet his watching invades that life without her knowledge. The Amada history parallels Menshiki’s private uncertainty with a different form of silence, one shaped by political violence and family shame. Both men preserve what cannot be spoken, but one does so through deliberate observation and the other through art.

Mariye Takes the Chair

The quiet student begins shaping her own image

Mariye Akikawa, a reserved thirteen-year-old in the narrator’s children’s class, agrees to model, accompanied by her aunt Shoko. In the studio, she speaks more freely than she does at school: she misses her mother, who died after a hornet sting, and remembers her through rain, a mountain lookout, and a song. The narrator hears echoes of Komi and recognizes how grief can bind people whose losses are not the same.

Mariye also studies the painting of the man with the white Subaru Forester and urges him not to add to its ominous, unfinished surface. On a later visit, Menshiki meets Mariye face-to-face and is so overwhelmed that he struggles to speak. He invites her and Shoko to see his portrait, drawing the three households closer.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Mariye is not merely the subject of a portrait commission. She studies the act of being seen and insists that artistic exchange involves giving and receiving, not the passive extraction of someone’s essence. Her story of her mother comes in sensory fragments rather than a coherent biography, which makes memory a form of lived inheritance rather than a complete record. The narrator’s association of Mariye with Komi risks turning the girl into a substitute for the dead, but her sharp judgments and independent silences resist that projection. She remains a person who can alter the painter’s decisions, not simply inspire them.

The Telescope's Secret

Mariye suspects Menshiki is watching her home

Mariye secretly reaches the narrator’s house through a concealed passage across the mountain. She has noticed the binoculars on Menshiki’s terrace and believes he is watching her family. She also senses that he may be drawing close to Shoko, whose visits to his mansion have become frequent. The narrator cannot disclose Menshiki’s belief that Mariye may be his daughter, so he can offer no clean explanation.

When Mariye hears the bell near the shrine, the narrator discovers that the bell has vanished from his studio. Later, on the Friday she fails to return from school, Shoko reports that Mariye has not reached her art class or home. The narrator and Menshiki search the pit and find her penguin charm inside, proof that she had entered it.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Mariye’s suspicions are grounded in observation, not childish paranoia: she notices the telescope, reads her aunt’s changed behavior, and understands that adult motives may remain hidden beneath polite encounters. The narrator’s silence protects Menshiki’s secret but leaves Mariye to interpret the danger without essential context. Her disappearance transforms that uneasy triangle into an urgent crisis. The penguin charm links the plot’s intimate and fantastic strands: an object associated with protection is found in the pit, where no one can explain how it arrived. Its presence suggests that Mariye has already crossed into the mystery on her own terms.

The Commendatore's Last Request

A dying painter watches the narrator reenact his image

Masahiko takes the narrator to visit his father in a nursing home, where Tomohiko Amada lies near death. While Masahiko steps away to take a work call, the Commendatore appears and says Mariye’s location cannot be handed to the narrator directly. To draw Long Face into the room, the narrator must reenact the painting’s killing.

The Commendatore offers himself, and the narrator uses Masahiko’s fish knife to stab him through the heart. Tomohiko briefly regains consciousness, watching the scene with visible strain. Long Face then emerges from a square opening in the floor. The narrator captures him and learns that he is a Metaphor, unable to provide Mariye’s location, but able to point toward a path. The narrator enters it alone.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The killing forces the narrator to convert artistic interpretation into bodily action. Until now, the painting’s violence has been an image to study; at the nursing home, he must repeat its central gesture and accept that the knife meets something like flesh. The Commendatore’s consent does not make the act morally simple, especially for a man who fears his own capacity for violence. Tomohiko’s effort to watch gives the reenactment a second audience, linking private memory to historical trauma. Long Face’s emergence confirms that the painting is not merely symbolic, yet his limited knowledge prevents the symbols from becoming easy answers.

Across the Metaphor River

The painter follows a tunnel through fear and returns

Long Face directs the narrator to a path through the Land of Metaphor. He crosses a barren plain, drinks from a tasteless river, and pays its faceless ferryman with Mariye’s penguin charm. Beyond the river, he enters a silent forest and reaches a cave resembling the wind cave he once explored with Komi.

Crawling through a narrowing tunnel, he confronts his claustrophobia and a tentacled presence before emerging into the stone pit behind the shrine. The opening has been sealed, leaving him trapped until Menshiki hears the bell and lifts the covering. The narrator returns exhausted, muddy, and unable to account for his absence. He learns that Mariye also returned home safely, though neither yet knows the other’s full ordeal.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The journey makes psychological endurance inseparable from physical navigation. The narrator survives not by mastering a map but by using memories as anchors when the tunnel threatens to erase his sense of self. Komi’s voice and the recollection of the Peugeot help him move, while the penguin’s surrender makes the rescue costly rather than magical. The parallel return of Mariye and the narrator suggests a connection without reducing either experience to a single explanation. Both come back changed and unable to narrate everything plainly, so secrecy becomes not evasion alone but a way to preserve what ordinary language cannot yet contain.

The House Holds Its Secrets

Mariye explains her hiding place and the portrait stays unfinished

Mariye later tells the narrator that she spent the missing four days inside a hidden maid’s room in Menshiki’s mansion. She had entered to investigate his surveillance, but the Commendatore guided her into hiding when Menshiki returned.

A wardrobe of carefully preserved women’s clothes protected her from an unseen presence outside the closet; the clothes belonged to her mother, though the narrator keeps that knowledge from her. When the cleaners arrive, Mariye escapes, returns home, and claims amnesia to avoid exposing the passageway or Menshiki’s house.

She and the narrator keep their stories secret. He gives her his unfinished portrait, stores the other paintings in the attic, and avoids completing the image that might expose her to further danger.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Mariye’s account reveals that her survival depended on attention and restraint rather than force. She observes routines, hides when necessary, and uses the cleaners’ arrival as her opening. The mother’s clothes function as a material inheritance she cannot identify, protecting her without resolving the absence that shaped her childhood. The narrator’s decision not to explain their origin respects a boundary, but it also leaves an important truth with Menshiki alone. Likewise, the unfinished portrait is not an artistic failure: the painter recognizes that completion could make Mariye more vulnerable to being claimed, watched, or defined by others.

A Marriage Without Proof

Yuzu and the painter choose family without certainty

After returning from the pit, the narrator contacts Yuzu and asks to meet. She reveals that she never filed the divorce papers, so they remain legally married, and that she cannot be certain who fathered her pregnancy. The narrator accepts her uncertainty and asks whether they can try again.

Yuzu agrees, and he returns to their apartment. Their daughter, Muro, is born and receives her name from a dream Yuzu had. The narrator resumes commissioned portrait work while raising the child.

Years later, an earthquake devastates the coast he once traveled through, and the Odawara house burns with Amada’s hidden painting inside. The narrator grieves the lost work, but keeps its figures alive in memory and regards Muro as a grace that cannot be measured by biological proof.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The reunion does not resolve uncertainty by discovering a definitive biological truth. Instead, the narrator and Yuzu make a relational choice: they accept a family whose origins cannot be fully verified. This echoes Menshiki’s refusal to test Mariye’s parentage, though the narrator’s commitment rests on shared life rather than distant possibility. The later fire destroys the physical painting that initiated the supernatural sequence, leaving memory as the surviving medium. The ending does not claim that belief replaces fact in every circumstance; it shows these characters choosing which facts matter to their responsibilities, affections, and capacity to continue living together.

Epilogue

Years later, the narrator watches the earthquake and tsunami devastate the northeastern coast he once crossed, wondering whether the people and places he remembers survived. The Odawara house then burns, destroying Tomohiko Amada’s hidden painting and the portrait of the man with the white Subaru Forester.

Mariye, now older, tells him that her breasts have grown and that she may leave for college. The narrator raises Muro with Yuzu and accepts that her biological paternity may remain unknowable. The painting is gone, but its figures remain vivid in his mind, where he understands his daughter as a form of grace.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The epilogue makes loss literal: the landscape is altered by disaster, and the house that sheltered the novel’s images disappears in fire. Yet the narrator does not confuse preservation with possession. He cannot recover the painting or verify every memory, but he carries the images forward and continues caring for the family he chose. Muro’s uncertain paternity parallels Menshiki’s uncertainty about Mariye, while their responses diverge: Menshiki sustains an unresolved possibility at a distance; the narrator accepts an unresolved fact within daily life. The ending locates continuity in acts of attention and care, not in artifacts or biological certainty.

Analysis

Killing Commendatore asks what images can do when direct explanation fails. The narrator’s profession depends on turning remembered impressions into portraits, yet the novel repeatedly shows that likeness is not transparent access to a person. Menshiki’s face resists ordinary sketching; Mariye’s image is shaped by her own participation; the Subaru driver refuses completion; and Amada’s hidden painting communicates a history that the artist could not state openly. Representation is therefore an ethical act as well as an aesthetic one. To depict someone may preserve them, but it may also expose, appropriate, or summon what should remain protected.

The book’s supernatural figures make this problem concrete. The Commendatore is an Idea borrowing a painted form, while Long Face is a Metaphor who can connect events but cannot explain them fully. Their limited agency resists a tidy allegory in which every symbol has one stable meaning. The narrator must act without complete knowledge, and the plot repeatedly makes that uncertainty consequential: he opens the pit, kills the figure who asks him to, and enters a dangerous passage without knowing precisely what will follow. Responsibility here is not the reward for certainty. It is the burden of choosing while certainty is unavailable.

The family stories echo this structure. Menshiki declines to verify whether Mariye is his daughter because proof could deepen rather than repair his loss. The narrator accepts Yuzu’s uncertain pregnancy and becomes Muro’s father through care and shared life, not genetic confirmation. Their choices differ: Menshiki preserves possibility at a distance, while the narrator makes room for uncertainty inside a household. The novel does not present ignorance as automatically wise. Instead, it asks whether knowledge will serve the living people involved, or merely satisfy an observer’s hunger to classify them.

Finally, art and memory provide continuity without defeating loss. Amada’s painting burns, the mountain house disappears, and the narrator cannot recover every detail of his journey. Yet he retains the images and keeps painting. What survives is not a complete record but an active capacity to attend, to imagine, and to care. The story’s grace lies less in solving every mystery than in choosing relationships that can endure without a final answer.

Summary in 60 Seconds
After his wife Yuzu leaves him, an unnamed portrait painter retreats to a mountain house once owned by the renowned artist Tomohiko Amada. He finds Amada's concealed painting of a murder and hears a bell beneath a shrine. When the bell is brought inside, a small figure from the painting appears and calls himself an Idea. The painter befriends Wataru Menshiki, a wealthy recluse who suspects that thirteen-year-old Mariye may be his daughter, and begins painting her. Mariye disappears, and the painter follows a supernatural guide through a perilous underground passage to return. She is found safe after hiding in Menshiki's house. The painter reunites with Yuzu, accepts uncertainty about their child's paternity, and raises their daughter. Years later, fire destroys the painting, but he continues his work and family life.
Contains spoilers

Last updated:

Report Issue

Review Summary

3.91 out of 5
Average of 72k+ ratings from Goodreads and Amazon.

Killing Commendatore receives mixed reviews from readers. Many praise Murakami's signature surreal style and ability to blend reality with fantasy, while others find the novel overly long and repetitive. Some appreciate the exploration of art and creativity, while others criticize the treatment of female characters. The book is seen as a return to form by some fans, but others feel it lacks the magic of Murakami's earlier works. Overall, readers find the novel atmospheric and intriguing, albeit with flaws in pacing and character development.

Your rating:
4.73
10 ratings
Want to read the full book?

Characters

The narrator

The searching portraitist

An unnamed oil painter, he earns his living by making portraits that reveal more than their subjects consciously present. His visual memory is exceptional, but his own self-knowledge is incomplete: he often notices a feeling only after it has shaped his choices. Komi’s death left him with grief, claustrophobia, and a habit of preserving people through sketches. He is cautious, observant, and more comfortable listening than asserting himself, which makes others confide in him. Yet his passivity has costs; he can mistake silence for understanding and let others set the course. His movement toward painting for himself is inseparable from learning when to act, when to withhold judgment, and when another person’s story is not his to finish.

Wataru Menshiki

The white-haired watcher

A wealthy former technology entrepreneur, Menshiki lives alone in a conspicuous mansion across the valley. His striking white hair, immaculate habits, classical music, and measured speech suggest a man who has made self-control into a life structure. He gathers information as both a practical skill and a defense against uncertainty, yet his attachment to a possible daughter exposes a longing that cannot be managed by calculation. Menshiki avoids declaring what he cannot prove, preferring to preserve possibility rather than force a result that could injure everyone involved. His generosity is genuine but not uncomplicated: he plans carefully and can draw others into his designs, even when he believes his intentions are honorable.

Mariye Akikawa

The watchful young artist

A quiet thirteen-year-old student in the narrator’s art class, Mariye is observant enough to notice what adults hope to conceal. She speaks little in public, but painting gives her a way to test ideas about identity and see herself from another person’s perspective. Her mother’s early death and her father’s distance have made her unusually self-reliant; she knows the mountain paths around her home and trusts her own judgment. Mariye can be stubborn, curious, and startlingly direct, especially about bodies, art, and the motives of adults. She is not simply a symbol of lost childhood or a possible daughter: her independent intelligence repeatedly changes what the narrator and Menshiki are able to see.

Yuzu

The estranged wife

An architect with a social, quick-witted nature, Yuzu is the narrator’s wife of six years. She is attentive to dreams and private intuitions, and she can act on an inner conviction before she is able or willing to explain it to someone else. Her decision to leave exposes a mismatch in the marriage that the narrator had failed to recognize, including their unresolved disagreement about having children. Yuzu’s attraction to handsome men is something she understands as a weakness, but she is not reducible to that preference. She has her own developing account of agency, responsibility, and what kind of family she can live with. Her relationship with the narrator is shaped by affection, concealment, and the difficulty of translating private feeling into shared decisions.

Komi

The remembered younger sister

The narrator’s younger sister, Komi is remembered as bright, stubborn, sociable, and full of plans. Her congenital heart condition made the family watch her closely, but she remained more animated than fragile in her brother’s memories. She loved Alice in Wonderland and once described a hidden chamber in a wind cave as a place where the self could seem to disappear. Her death shaped the narrator’s grief, fear of enclosed spaces, and lifelong urge to draw faces before memory changes. Komi remains more than a lost person in his mind: her curiosity becomes a resource he draws on when confronting darkness, though he must also learn not to make other girls carry her place.

Tomohiko Amada

The reclusive painter

A celebrated Japanese-style painter and Masahiko’s father, Tomohiko Amada has spent much of his life working in solitude. As a young artist he moved from Western modernism to paintings of ancient Japanese history, developing a distinctive command of space and omission. He dislikes keeping paintings around him and leaves few personal records, making his life difficult for others to reconstruct. His son experiences him as distant and difficult to approach, while the narrator encounters his presence through the house, studio, records, and paintings. Amada’s story links artistic transformation to historical pressure, but his inner life remains partly inaccessible even to those who study his work closely.

Masahiko Amada

The painter's practical friend

The narrator’s longtime art-school friend and Tomohiko Amada’s son, Masahiko is a graphic designer with a clear eye for other people’s paintings. He gave up trying to match his father’s artistic stature and built a life in commercial design, though his father’s silence remains a source of hurt. He is practical, sociable, and generous, often helping the narrator with housing, work, and honest criticism. Masahiko also holds difficult information about his family and the narrator’s marriage, balancing loyalty with the cost of keeping secrets. His blunt humor makes serious conversations possible, but it can also conceal how much he carries alone.

Shoko Akikawa

Mariye’s devoted aunt

Shoko is Mariye’s aunt and guardian, having left her work in Tokyo to care for her niece after Mariye’s mother died. She is elegant, bookish, socially considerate, and more open to companionship than Mariye expects. Her affection for the girl is steady, although their temperaments differ: Shoko values warmth and social ease, while Mariye watches people closely and resists intrusion. She creates a stable home for Mariye without being able to answer every question about the child’s parents or grief. Her growing connection with Menshiki introduces a new emotional possibility into the household, while making Mariye protective of the aunt who has protected her.

The married student

The narrator's lover

A housewife in the narrator’s adult painting class, she becomes his lover during his separation from Yuzu. Their relationship is largely physical, and she speaks more openly in private than the narrator expects. She has a family and daughters, yet claims a space for desire outside her marriage. Her frankness about sex contrasts with the narrator’s tendency to observe and analyze rather than disclose. She also offers him fragments of local gossip about Menshiki, showing how informal social networks can penetrate the privacy he tries to maintain.

Yoshinobu Akikawa

Mariye's distant father

Mariye’s father is a wealthy landowner who manages inherited properties but becomes increasingly withdrawn after his wife’s death. He turns toward a religious group and spends less time at home, leaving his sister Shoko to raise Mariye. His grief takes a severe, outward form, including the destruction of the family plum grove after his wife’s fatal hornet sting. Mariye experiences him as distant and knows little about his work or beliefs. He illustrates how bereavement can harden into private rituals that reshape a whole family without making its members feel understood.

The Commendatore

The borrowed Idea

A small figure who appears in the form of the slain commander in Tomohiko Amada’s painting, the Commendatore identifies himself as an Idea rather than a ghost. He can take shape only under limits, depends on human perception, and speaks in an oddly formal, precise manner. His role is to connect images, choices, and consequences, though he cannot simply explain every mystery or reveal what another person must discover. He is comic in manner and serious in purpose, a guide whose assistance carries a cost. His presence tests whether an abstract idea can acquire agency without becoming morally simple.

Long Face

The stumbling Metaphor

A bearded, eggplant-faced figure who watches the murder in Amada’s painting from a square opening in the ground, Long Face later identifies himself as a Metaphor. He is an awkward, low-ranking connector between phenomena and language, more frightened than powerful. He cannot provide a direct route to Mariye, but he points the narrator toward the Path of Metaphor and warns him of its dangers. His clumsy attempts to explain his function are both comic and revealing: symbols can guide a person without possessing complete knowledge of what they connect.

Tsuguhiko Amada

The musician lost to war

Tomohiko Amada’s younger brother, Tsuguhiko is a gifted piano student whose military service exposes him to the violence of the Nanjing campaign. His family’s account, passed on through Masahiko, presents him as sensitive, devoted to music, and deeply affected by what he was ordered to do. His experience helps explain the weight of silence surrounding the Amada family, while his story underscores the distance between artistic life and the systems that conscript people into violence.

Muro

The dream-named daughter

The narrator and Yuzu’s daughter, Muro is named after a character Yuzu sees in a dream. As a young child, she is curious about the news and asks why her father shields her from images of disaster. Her presence gives the narrator a daily responsibility and a future not reducible to questions of biological certainty. He picks her up from nursery school, walks with her, and shares ordinary moments that contrast with the strange journeys of the earlier story. Muro becomes a loved child through care and time, not through a resolved test of paternity.

Plot Devices

Killing Commendatore

An image that opens doors

Tomohiko Amada’s hidden Japanese-style painting adapts the murder at the beginning of Don Giovanni into an ancient Japanese scene. It preserves a secret that Amada cannot or will not state directly, while its added underground watcher disrupts the opera’s familiar arrangement. The narrator’s discovery gives him a subject when his own painting has stalled, then leads to the Commendatore appearing in borrowed form. The painting also frames the later reenactment that draws Long Face out of the ground. It functions as artwork, coded memory, and an active passage between image and event. Its destruction in the fire leaves its meaning alive in the narrator’s memory. Spoiler status: true.

The shrine pit and bell

A signal from below

A bell rings at night beneath a stone mound behind the Amada house. Its sound leads the narrator and Menshiki to open a carefully built underground chamber, where they find the bell but no person. The pit becomes the Commendatore’s point of release and later the place from which the narrator returns after crossing the Land of Metaphor. The missing ladder and penguin charm connect it to Mariye’s separate disappearance. Although the chamber yields no conventional explanation, its repeated appearances organize the novel’s movement between ordinary investigation and fantastic events. Spoiler status: true.

Portraits and likeness

Painting makes absence visible

The narrator’s portraits begin as commercial likenesses built from memory, interviews, and careful attention to faces. His portrait of Menshiki breaks that method open: a single overlooked feature, the white hair, makes the image feel complete. Mariye’s portrait develops through conversation and observation, but the narrator leaves it unfinished when completion might expose or define her too forcefully. The portrait of the unknown man with the Subaru remains similarly resistant. Across these works, painting is not a neutral copy of a person. It can reveal, distort, preserve, or exert pressure on the subject and the artist alike. Spoiler status: true.

Mariye's passageway

A child's hidden route

Mariye knows a concealed path through the mountains that lets her reach the narrator’s house without her aunt noticing. It establishes her independence and familiarity with the terrain before she disappears, and allows her to visit the narrator privately. Her knowledge of the passage also shapes the adults’ search: the police and family do not know every route Mariye can take. The secret path mirrors the story’s other hidden channels, from Amada’s attic to the pit and the tunnel beneath the Land of Metaphor. It gives Mariye agency in a story otherwise dominated by adult secrets. Spoiler status: true.

The penguin charm

A small token of protection

Mariye’s tiny plastic penguin begins as a lucky charm attached to her phone. It disappears from the phone, is found in the pit, and later becomes the narrator’s fare for crossing the river in the Land of Metaphor. The charm links Mariye’s real-world danger to the narrator’s impossible journey, making his passage depend on surrendering something that belonged to her. Its meaning remains deliberately uncertain: it may protect, mark a passage, or simply carry emotional value. The faceless ferryman promises to return it if the narrator can someday draw his portrait. Spoiler status: true.

About the Author

Murakami Haruki is a renowned Japanese author known for his Western-influenced writing style. Born in Kyoto, he studied drama at Waseda University in Tokyo. Murakami's early career included running a jazz bar with his wife before becoming a full-time writer. His works often feature themes and titles inspired by classical music and popular songs. Murakami's novels are characterized by their accessibility and complexity, blending elements of magical realism with contemporary Japanese culture. His unique style and Western influences set him apart from other Japanese writers, earning him a dedicated international following.

Download PDF

To save this Killing Commendatore summary for later, download the free PDF. You can print it out, or read offline at your convenience.
Download PDF
File size: 0.29 MB     Pages: 25

Download EPUB

To read this Killing Commendatore summary on your e-reader device or app, download the free EPUB. The .epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.
Download EPUB
File size: 1.29 MB     Pages: 35
Want to read the full book?
Follow
Listen
Home
Swipe
Library
Get App
Try Full Access for 3 Days
Listen, bookmark, and more
Compare Features Free Pro
📖 Read Summaries
Read unlimited summaries. Free users get 3 per month
🎧 Listen to Summaries
Listen to unlimited summaries in 40 languages
—
❤️ Unlimited Bookmarks
Free users are limited to 4
—
📜 Unlimited History
Free users are limited to 4
—
📥 Unlimited Downloads
Free users are limited to 1
—
Risk-Free Timeline
Today: Get Instant Access
Listen to full summaries of 26,000+ books. That's 12,000+ hours of audio!
Day 2: Trial Reminder
We'll send you a notification that your trial is ending soon.
Day 3: Your subscription begins
You'll be charged on Nov 24,
cancel anytime before.
Consume 2.8× More Books
2.8× more books Listening Reading
Our users love us
600,000+ readers
Trustpilot Rating
TrustPilot
4.6 Excellent
This site is a total game-changer. I've been flying through book summaries like never before. Highly, highly recommend.
— Dave G
Worth my money and time, and really well made. I've never seen this quality of summaries on other websites. Very helpful!
— Em
Highly recommended!! Fantastic service. Perfect for those that want a little more than a teaser but not all the intricate details of a full audio book.
— Greg M
Save 62%
Yearly
$119.88 $44.99/year/yr
$3.75/mo
Monthly
$9.99/mo
Start a 3-Day Free Trial
3 days free, then $44.99/year. Cancel anytime.
Unlock a world of fiction & nonfiction books
26,000+ books for the price of 2 books
Read any book in 10 minutes
Discover new books like Tinder
Request any book if it's not summarized
Read more books than anyone you know
#1 app for book lovers
Lifelike & immersive summaries
30-day money-back guarantee
Download summaries in EPUBs or PDFs
Cancel anytime in a few clicks

Why one summary?

Scanner
Find a barcode to scan

⭐
⭐
⭐
We have a special gift for you
Open
38% off
DISCOUNT FOR YOU
⭐
⭐
⭐
$79.99
$49.99/year
Only $4.16 per month
Continue
2 taps to start, super easy to cancel
Settings
General
Widget
Loading...