Key Takeaways
Treat apathy, not hatred, as love and will’s deepest enemy.
Disconnection is the crisis. May describes a culture that is “schizoid” in his broad, non-diagnostic sense: people feel detached from one another and doubt that their actions matter. When people cannot affect the world or be affected by it, they may stop wanting and feeling. May argues that apathy can then feed violence, as people reach for any response that breaks through their sense of invisibility.
A disturbing emblem. He points to a 1964 murder in Queens, reported at the time as having been witnessed by 38 people who did not intervene. For May, the episode captures withdrawal from shared responsibility, not simply individual coldness. He also sees apathy as a temporary defense against overwhelming demands, one that becomes damaging when it hardens into a way of life.
What's striking is May’s insistence that indifference can be more dangerous than open hostility: hostility still acknowledges a relationship, while apathy refuses one. Social psychology offers a useful connection in the bystander effect, where responsibility can feel dispersed across a crowd. However, later investigations complicated the popular account of the Queens murder, so it should not be treated as a clean experiment proving public indifference. The broader insight survives that caveat: people need social conditions and shared expectations that make intervention possible, not just private exhortations to care.
Let sex serve eros, rather than using performance to escape intimacy.
Sex is not the whole of love. May distinguishes sex, the bodily drive toward stimulation and release, from eros, the longing for union, meaning, and creative growth. He also draws on three other traditional forms of love: philia, friendship; and agape, concern for another’s good. In lived relationships, he argues, these forms overlap. Trouble starts when sex is expected to carry all the emotional meaning of love by itself.
Performance can crowd out presence. May describes couples counting encounters, worrying about orgasm, and judging whether they performed well. He recounts a man using an anesthetic to delay climax, even though the treatment reduced sensation. Such methods can make intimacy resemble a test. His point is not that sexual knowledge is useless, but that technique cannot manufacture personal connection.
May’s distinction helps explain why better mechanics do not automatically produce greater closeness. Contemporary sexual medicine can make technique valuable, especially when it reduces pain, anxiety, or dysfunction. The limit is treating measurable performance as a complete account of an intimate encounter. Research on sexual satisfaction also points to communication, emotional safety, and responsiveness as important influences. May’s argument is strongest when it challenges performance as the sole measure, not when it risks making spontaneous passion sound like the only authentic form of sex.
Give powerful impulses a form; repression leaves them in charge.
The daimonic is human power. May uses this term for natural forces, such as anger, sexuality, and the drive for power, that can seize a person. They may fuel creativity and self-assertion, or become destructive when one impulse dominates the whole personality. The task is not to label these forces evil or pretend they can be erased. It is to bring them into awareness and integrate them with concern for oneself and others.
A communal ritual illustrates the idea. May recounts a Yoruba healing ceremony studied by psychiatrist Raymond Prince. A man troubled by impotence danced dressed as his mother, while a young woman struggling with authority wore clothing associated with a census official. May interprets their role-playing as a way to face feared parts of experience with the community’s support, rather than disown them.
This account has a useful modern parallel in approaches that help people notice an emotion without automatically acting on it. Naming anger, for example, can make a pause possible between impulse and behavior. The community setting also matters: difficult feelings are easier to face when they are met without immediate exile or shame. May’s interpretation of a Yoruba practice remains his interpretation, not proof that the ritual works by the psychological mechanism he proposes. Still, his central distinction is valuable: accepting an impulse is not the same as obeying it.
Let mortality deepen love instead of anesthetizing it with conquest.
Love makes people vulnerable. May argues that loving someone brings the possibility of loss into sharper focus. A parent, for instance, may become more aware of death after having a child because another person’s safety now matters so deeply. The awareness of life’s limits can intensify attention to the living relationship; it can also make intimacy frightening, since love exposes people to grief and change.
Sex can become a defense. May suggests that a culture obsessed with sexual potency may use sex to reassure itself that it is alive and powerful, while avoiding thoughts of death. He does not argue against contraception. Instead, he says that preventing pregnancy can remove one immediate biological risk without removing the personal choices and emotional consequences involved in sexuality. Greater control may shift responsibility rather than abolish it.
The connection between mortality and attachment has a modern counterpart in terror-management research, which studies how awareness of death shapes people’s beliefs and behavior. May’s contribution is to bring that abstraction into intimate life: love makes another person’s finite existence matter personally. Yet sexual preoccupation can have many causes, and it cannot be reduced to fear of death. The strongest reading is therefore interpretive rather than diagnostic. Mortality may deepen love when it sharpens attention, but it can also provoke avoidance, control, or denial.
Build will from wishes, not from self-punishing discipline.
A wish gives will its content. May treats wishing as more than childish fantasy or a bodily urge. A wish begins to imagine what might be possible; will organizes a person to move toward it. In therapy, he describes a progression from noticing a desire, to recognizing it as one’s own, to making choices that take other people and consequences into account.
Helen’s discipline concealed need. One patient prized a forceful motto about will, yet felt driven to sex, food, and punishingly long work hours. May understood these patterns as connected to loneliness and an early longing for maternal care. Her case does not show that discipline is always false. It shows how a polished ideal of self-control can conceal needs that have never been acknowledged, leaving behavior compulsive rather than freely chosen.
This account resonates with motivation research distinguishing internally endorsed goals from behavior driven by pressure or approval. A person can appear highly disciplined while feeling little ownership of the actions involved. May’s emphasis on recognizing desire is a useful corrective to moralizing self-control, but a wish is not automatically wise or harmless. Reflection, realistic constraints, and attention to other people remain necessary. The point is not to grant every impulse authority; it is to understand what a person is trying to achieve before deciding how to act.
Read your actions as meanings, not just outputs of causes.
Intentionality gives experience its shape. May distinguishes intentionality from a conscious intention, such as planning to visit a house. Intentionality is the deeper structure of meaning that guides what a person notices, values, and does. The same house may appear as shelter to someone seeking a summer rental, an investment to a speculator, or a composition to a painter. The object is real, but attention meets it through a meaningful purpose.
Choice is neither magic nor illusion. May revisits William James’s example of getting out of a cold bed. James attributed the movement to a fortunate break in indecision. May argues that attention to the day’s possibilities helps explain the shift. Past causes still matter, but people also respond to futures they can imagine. This is his way of describing agency without pretending that people control every force shaping them.
May’s account anticipates ideas in embodied and situated cognition: perception is not simply a camera recording neutral facts, because goals and contexts shape what becomes salient. The house example makes that point unusually clear. His account also resists the false choice between total freedom and total determination. A caution is needed, though: meanings do not make the external world whatever a person wishes. Intentionality describes how a person engages reality, not a license to ignore evidence or material limits.
Name the conflict in relationship before demanding that insight produce change.
The present encounter can reveal the problem. May describes Preston, a writer whose severe block persisted despite years of earlier analysis. In one session, Preston insisted he could not write and seemed to place the task in his therapist’s hands. May sensed that anger was shaping their interaction and drew attention to it. As Preston confronted that conflict, he recognized that staying ill protected him from feared rejection: success seemed to threaten the care he wanted from his father.
Explanation alone was not enough. The session joined what Preston said he wanted with the way he was relating in the room. May’s method was to help him experience that contradiction, not merely discuss it as an abstract diagnosis. The point is not that every therapist should challenge a patient in the same way. It is that insight becomes more consequential when it connects a person’s account of a problem to the choices and relationships unfolding now.
The case illustrates a relational view of therapy: patterns are not only recalled as stories about the past, they can appear in how people seek help, resist it, or test whether another person will stay engaged. This can make therapy more vivid than explanation alone. It also places real power in the therapist’s hands. A therapist’s interpretation can clarify an interaction, but it can also impose a story. Collaboration, attention to the patient’s response, and willingness to be wrong are essential safeguards.
Pair love’s openness with will’s commitment, or each turns destructive.
Each needs the other. May treats love and will as ways of reaching toward the world, affecting others, and remaining open to being affected in return. Will without love becomes manipulation: May’s example is a successful corporate father who manages his son’s treatment and life as if they were company operations, but struggles to listen to him. Love without will can become fleeting or indiscriminate, avoiding the choices and effort through which a relationship develops.
Commitment is not control. May’s contrast is not between strictness and permissiveness. Love requires the capacity to choose, to stay attentive through conflict, and to shape a shared life without treating the other person as an object. Will gives love continuity; love keeps will responsive. Their union is an achievement, not an automatic result of desire or good intentions.
The pairing offers a useful way to distinguish commitment from domination. In relationship science, responsiveness and autonomy are both associated with healthier bonds: people need to feel understood without being absorbed into another person’s agenda. May’s account supports that balance, although his historical examples sometimes treat lasting partnership as the default measure of mature love. Commitment can also mean setting boundaries or leaving a harmful relationship. The key is not permanence at any cost, but deliberate care that respects both people’s agency.
Practice care as attention that moves toward another person.
Care makes something matter. May presents care as more than sentimental feeling. It means recognizing another person, being affected by their situation, and responding to it. He describes a wartime image of a marine looking at a soot-covered, crying child after a gas attack. The two faces seem bewildered by the same human situation. For May, that moment of recognition interrupts the abstraction of casualty counts and political categories.
Shared forms help care endure. Art, language, and social traditions can give people ways to recognize experiences they might otherwise leave unspoken. May sees love and will as forms of communion: people shape one another’s awareness while remaining distinct. Care opposes apathy because it joins feeling to attention and action, rather than stopping at the pleasure of feeling compassionate.
May’s account connects private feeling to public attention. A photograph can make an unfamiliar person visible as a person, a function also studied in work on media framing and moral concern. But recognition in an image does not by itself change the systems producing suffering. Care needs both emotional attention and durable practices, including collective responsibility. The distinction from sentimentality remains sharp: compassion that never alters attention or action can become another way to feel virtuous without becoming involved.
Analysis
Love and Will is an existential psychology book that treats intimate distress as evidence about a wider historical predicament. Its movement is deliberate: May begins with alienation and apathy, examines how sex can be stripped of personal meaning, then develops concepts for understanding impulse, agency, and relationship. Clinical stories give the argument a human scale, while Greek myth and modern art supply a language for experiences that May believes technical psychology alone cannot capture.
The book’s lasting strength is its resistance to easy oppositions. Desire is neither pure instinct nor a sovereign choice. Powerful emotion is neither evil nor automatically trustworthy. Freedom is not escape from causes, and love is not mere comfort. May’s concepts of the daimonic and intentionality help readers notice how a person’s actions carry meaning before that person can explain them. His account of care then joins inner life to responsibility for others.
Its limitations follow partly from its ambition. May moves from therapy cases to sweeping claims about Western society, sometimes treating selected anecdotes as signs of cultural direction without enough evidence to establish that direction. His use of the reported Queens murder, for example, is evocative but should not be taken as a reliable measure of public character. Some gender claims also reflect the assumptions of his period, presenting male and female differences as more fixed than contemporary evidence warrants. Those limits do not erase the book’s central questions, but they counsel against adopting every historical diagnosis as fact.
Read today, the book is most useful as a vocabulary for examining the quality of involvement. Does a person’s discipline express a chosen purpose or conceal fear? Does sexual freedom widen intimacy or become performance? Does care lead to attention and action? May does not offer a simple technique for answering these questions. He argues that mature love and will require people to face ambiguity together, without handing responsibility to either impulse, authority, or machinery.
Review Summary
Love and Will receives mostly positive reviews for its insightful exploration of modern society's struggles with intimacy, apathy, and meaning. Readers appreciate May's blend of psychology, philosophy, and literature, finding his ideas on love, sex, and intentionality thought-provoking. Some criticize the book's complexity and occasional verbosity, but many consider it a seminal work in existential psychology. Readers value May's critique of contemporary culture and his emphasis on rediscovering genuine human connection and purpose in an increasingly mechanized world.
People Also Read
Glossary
Daimonic
Power that can create or destroyMay’s term for powerful natural forces within human experience, including sexuality, anger, and the drive for power. These forces can support creativity and self-assertion, or become destructive when one takes over the person’s whole life. The aim is not to eliminate them but to recognize and integrate them through awareness, responsibility, and relationship.
Intentionality
Meaning that organizes experienceThe underlying structure through which a person’s concerns shape perception, feeling, and action. May distinguishes intentionality from a conscious intention, such as planning a particular act. Intentionality includes the person’s broader orientation to the world, including bodily and less conscious elements, and helps explain how people make meaning while responding to real conditions.
Eros
Desire for meaningful unionMay uses eros for a longing that reaches beyond bodily release toward union, personal relationship, and creative growth. It may appear in sexual love, friendship with ideas, artistic work, or the pursuit of truth. Unlike sex understood as a physiological drive, eros involves meaning and imagination, and draws a person toward possibilities that enlarge experience.
Schizoid
Culturally detached and out of touchMay uses this term broadly for a cultural tendency toward emotional distance, withdrawal, and difficulty forming close relationships. He explicitly does not use it here as a diagnosis of schizophrenia. He also argues that detachment can sometimes protect a person’s inner life from overwhelming stimulation, though prolonged apathy can become damaging.
Mythos of care
A shared story of what mattersMay’s term for a meaningful structure of life that places human concern, love, grief, and responsibility at its center. A mythos is not simply a false story or a set of explanations. It is a shared way of interpreting experience that can help people face suffering and mortality without becoming isolated or indifferent.
Wish
Imaginative desire for possibilityIn May’s account, a wish is more than an impulse seeking immediate satisfaction. It combines bodily energy with personal meaning and imagination, allowing someone to picture a possible future. A wish supplies content and vitality for will, but does not by itself constitute a decision or guarantee that acting on it is wise.
FAQ
What's Love and Will about?
- Exploration of Love and Will: Love and Will by Rollo May examines the interdependence of love and will in human existence, arguing that both are essential for personal fulfillment and societal connection.
- Crisis of Modern Existence: May discusses how contemporary society has lost sight of the true meanings of love and will, leading to a sense of disconnection and apathy.
- Integration of Concepts: The book integrates psychological insights with philosophical reflections, using historical and literary examples to illustrate the complexities of love and will.
Why should I read Love and Will?
- Understanding Human Experience: The book provides valuable insights into the fundamental aspects of human relationships and personal identity.
- Addressing Modern Issues: It tackles contemporary issues such as apathy, anxiety, and the loss of personal responsibility, making it relevant for today's readers.
- Psychological and Philosophical Depth: May combines psychological theories with philosophical inquiry, offering a rich, multidimensional perspective on love and will.
What are the key takeaways of Love and Will?
- Interdependence of Love and Will: Love and will are interdependent processes that shape our interactions and personal growth.
- Crisis of Identity: The book highlights the modern crisis of identity, where individuals feel powerless and disconnected due to a lack of meaningful relationships.
- The Daimonic: May introduces the concept of the daimonic, which refers to natural functions that can lead to both creativity and destruction.
What are the best quotes from Love and Will and what do they mean?
- “Love and will are interdependent.”: This quote emphasizes that both love and will must work together for a fulfilling life.
- “Apathy is a withdrawal of feeling.”: May argues that apathy represents a lack of engagement with life and relationships.
- “Eros is a daimon.”: This statement connects love with the daimonic, suggesting that love is a powerful force that can drive both creativity and destruction.
How does Rollo May define will in Love and Will?
- Crisis of Will: May describes the modern crisis of will as a loss of personal responsibility and the ability to make meaningful choices.
- Will as Assertion of Self: He defines will as the capacity to assert oneself and make choices that reflect one’s true desires and values.
- Integration with Love: May emphasizes that will must be integrated with love to be effective, preventing manipulation or passivity.
What is the daimonic in Love and Will?
- Definition of the Daimonic: The daimonic refers to natural functions that can take over a person, leading to both creative and destructive outcomes.
- Role in Love and Will: It is crucial for understanding the dynamics of love and will, representing powerful urges that can enhance or undermine relationships.
- Integration and Awareness: The book stresses the importance of integrating the daimonic into one’s consciousness for greater self-awareness and personal growth.
How does Love and Will address the crisis of modern existence?
- Cultural Disconnection: May discusses how modern society has lost its connection to meaningful relationships, leading to feelings of apathy and disconnection.
- Fear of Commitment: The book highlights the fear of commitment stemming from insecurity and the belief that choosing one path means losing others.
- Call for Inner Exploration: May encourages readers to explore their inner selves to find the sources of love and will, overcoming the crisis of identity.
What is the significance of intentionality in Love and Will?
- Foundation of Consciousness: Intentionality is described as the structure that gives meaning to our experiences, directing our attention and desires.
- Link Between Will and Action: It is crucial for translating wishes into actions, allowing meaningful engagement with desires.
- Role in Therapy: Intentionality helps patients articulate their feelings and desires, facilitating personal growth in psychotherapy.
How does Love and Will suggest overcoming apathy?
- Engagement with Feelings: Overcoming apathy requires individuals to engage with their feelings and confront their emotional experiences.
- Reclaiming Personal Responsibility: The book emphasizes the importance of reclaiming personal responsibility in relationships and decision-making.
- Cultivating Meaningful Relationships: Building meaningful relationships is crucial for overcoming apathy and finding purpose and fulfillment.
How does Rollo May suggest we overcome the crisis of will?
- Embrace Consciousness: May advocates for a deeper integration of consciousness, encouraging awareness of desires and intentions.
- Take Responsibility: He emphasizes the importance of personal responsibility in reclaiming one's will.
- Cultivate Meaningful Relationships: Building connections with others through love and care is essential for overcoming feelings of isolation and powerlessness.
What role does love play in Rollo May's concept of will?
- Love as a Motivating Force: Love enriches and informs our will, providing emotional depth for decision-making.
- Interdependence of Love and Will: Love and will are interdependent, essential for personal fulfillment and growth.
- Love as a Source of Courage: Love empowers individuals to confront fears and uncertainties, aiding in the assertion of will.
What is the relationship between love and care in Love and Will?
- Care as a Foundation for Love: Care provides the emotional groundwork necessary for meaningful relationships.
- Interpersonal Connection: Love involves a deep connection to others, where their well-being matters to us.
- Mutuality in Love: The relationship between love and care is characterized by mutuality, essential for sustaining love over time.
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.