Key Takeaways
Stop waiting for outside investment; redirect wealth already flowing through town
Start with what exists. Community wealth-building is a local economic strategy that uses institutions, spending, businesses, and assets to keep more wealth under democratic local control. Instead of relying on tax breaks to attract distant corporations, communities can coordinate public bodies, local employers, cooperatives, and residents to build a more inclusive and resilient economy. The approach grows from a practical question: who already spends money here, and who benefits from it leaving? In Preston, this question became a new strategy after decades of failed regeneration and cuts had left residents with little reason to trust promises of outside rescue.
Work from local resources. The goal is not to wall off a town from wider markets. It is to make local economic activity serve local needs, while linking it to wider regional and national change. The book presents community wealth-building as one part of a larger response to inequality, insecure work, and environmental risk.
What's powerful here is the shift from treating a town as a passive applicant for investment to treating it as an economic system with assets and decision-makers. That resembles systems thinking: change the connections between existing parts, and the whole system can behave differently without waiting for a single outside benefactor. The approach also makes power visible in ordinary transactions, such as who receives a public contract. Its promise depends, however, on defining local benefit carefully. A locally headquartered business can still pay poorly or extract profit, so proximity alone is not a reliable test of fairness.
Turn regeneration failure into a map of money leaking away
A broken promise prompted a pivot. Preston had spent years pursuing a proposed £700 million shopping development called Tithebarn. When its corporate backers withdrew after the 2008 banking crash, the city abandoned the plan in 2011. The failure exposed the weakness of regeneration built around developers and outside investment: when the outside partner leaves, the promised jobs and renewal disappear with it. Preston's council began asking what it could do with resources already present in the city.
Count where spending goes. In 2013, six local institutions spent about £750 million on goods and services, but only 5% went to Preston-based organisations. Just 39% stayed within wider Lancashire, meaning more than £458 million left the county economy. These figures turned a general feeling of decline into a specific problem officials and institutions could address: their purchasing decisions were exporting wealth.
The procurement audit is an unusually useful political tool because it converts a broad complaint into a measurable flow. In economic terms, it resembles tracing leakage from a system: a town can spend heavily yet retain little capacity if suppliers, profits, and jobs are based elsewhere. The numbers also help build a coalition around a shared diagnosis, rather than requiring every partner to agree on an entire political philosophy. Still, tracking location is only a first measure. A full account of local value would also ask who owns firms, where workers live, what they are paid, and whether contracts deliver quality.
Make hospitals, universities, and councils buy from local firms
Use anchor institutions. An anchor institution is a large organisation with a lasting presence in a place, such as a university, hospital, college, or housing association. Because it employs people and regularly buys goods and services, it can shape local economic life even when private industry has declined. Preston worked with public institutions to find purchases that local suppliers could provide, then made those opportunities easier to bid for.
Change the purchasing rules. Progressive procurement means evaluating contracts for social and environmental value, not just the immediate price. Preston broke a £1.6 million school-meal contract into smaller tenders, allowing regional suppliers to compete. Across six institutions, spending with Preston-based organisations rose from about £38 million in 2013 to £111 million in 2017. Spending within Lancashire rose from £292 million to £486 million over the same period. Local construction firms also won major public projects.
Anchors matter because they offer a relatively stable source of demand. In institutional economics, predictable demand can help smaller producers invest, hire, and train, instead of competing only for sporadic sales. Breaking a large contract into smaller lots is a design change with distributive consequences: it changes who can realistically participate in a market. The test is not simply whether a supplier is nearby, but whether the procurement process secures good work, reliable service, and meaningful community benefit. Local sourcing can fail if it becomes a closed circle of familiar contractors, so transparency and open competition remain essential.
Build worker ownership where local supply chains have empty slots
Fill gaps deliberately. When Preston found categories with too few local suppliers, it looked beyond buying from existing businesses. The council and the University of Central Lancashire helped create support networks for cooperatives, including training, advice, and connections to potential contracts. New enterprises included an educational psychologists' cooperative, a digital media cooperative, a cafe and catering venture, and a taxi-driver cooperative.
Share control and returns. A worker cooperative is a business owned and governed by its workers, who share influence over decisions and the value the business creates. The book reports that 80% of cooperatives survive their first five years, compared with 41% of businesses using other ownership models. That advantage does not remove the difficulty of raising start-up capital or designing workable governance. Preston's approach is strategic: identify a real need in an anchor institution's supply chain, then help a cooperative develop to meet it.
This is more than a preference for one legal form. It connects market creation with ownership: public demand can help create viable alternatives, while shared ownership changes who has a voice in the workplace. That is a valuable correction to the assumption that entrepreneurship must mean individual founders and outside shareholders. The reported survival comparison is encouraging, but survival alone does not establish high productivity, worker satisfaction, or long-term financial health. Cooperative support therefore needs patient funding, sound business advice, and governance that gives members genuine influence rather than adding meetings without meaningful authority.
Keep finance, services, and public assets accountable to residents
Ownership extends beyond firms. Community wealth-building can involve bringing outsourced services back into public control, investing pension funds locally, supporting credit unions, and owning land or commercial assets collectively. Insourcing means returning a service previously contracted to a private provider to the public body that oversees it. The book cites Islington Council, which brought more than £400 million of contracts in-house after 2010, reporting savings of about £14 million and improved conditions for over 1,400 frontline workers.
Finance can serve place. Preston backed a credit union to offer an alternative to high-cost lenders and explored a regional customer-owned bank. The bank was a plan, not an established institution: its proposed start-up cost was £20 million, and the council had earmarked £1 million. Such institutions could direct savings toward local households and businesses, but require sufficient capital, expertise, and trust to operate safely.
This wider ownership lens is important because procurement alone cannot alter who controls credit, housing, or essential services. It treats finance as infrastructure: the rules and institutions that decide which activities can grow. The proposal also exposes a real tension. Local control can make decision-makers more answerable to residents, but banks and public services need rigorous oversight, professional capacity, and resilience to political turnover. Community purpose cannot replace prudential standards. The strongest case is for democratic accountability alongside technical competence, not for assuming that a local institution is automatically more trustworthy or effective.
Borrow Preston's principles, never its exact blueprint
Adapt, do not copy. Preston drew inspiration from Mondragón's cooperative economy in Spain and the Evergreen cooperatives in Cleveland, but it did not reproduce either model. Its approach relied heavily on the spending power of local public institutions and the council's ability to coordinate procurement. Other places may have different resources. A rural area without a large university or hospital might begin with community-owned land, energy, or finance instead.
Build a mosaic. The book describes community wealth-building as a collection of locally fitted initiatives rather than a universal package. North Ayrshire explored commitments from public bodies, a local football club, and its supporters' trust. In Wales, policy focused on essential services and locally rooted firms. Localism must also be inclusive: a community is made up of people who live and work there, not a supposedly uniform culture or ancestry.
The insistence on adaptation guards against a familiar policy error: treating a successful case as a recipe rather than evidence of a principle. The transferable idea is to identify local assets and decision points, then connect them to the needs of residents. This is similar to design thinking, where a solution is shaped by users and constraints rather than imposed from a standard template. Yet flexibility makes evaluation harder. If every place defines success differently, comparison can become vague. Shared measures for job quality, local ownership, participation, and environmental impact could preserve learning without forcing every town into the same institutional design.
Give residents real budget power, not another consultation meeting
Participation needs authority. Participatory budgeting lets residents help decide how a defined portion of public money is spent. It began in Porto Alegre, Brazil, in 1989, partly to direct services and infrastructure toward poorer neighbourhoods. In the UK, Tower Hamlets gave residents influence over £5 million in 2009 and 2010; more than 800 people attended the events. North Ayrshire used public input to shape the council's grounds-maintenance programme.
Design for access. Residents often know which local problems are most pressing, but participation takes time, confidence, and accessible formats. Informal events, online options, and outreach through existing community networks can widen involvement. Mutual-aid groups during the Covid-19 crisis showed how quickly people can organise help. But voluntary action should be supported by public resources, not used as an excuse to withdraw state services.
The distinction between consultation and decision power is central. Consultation asks residents to comment on choices made elsewhere; participatory budgeting gives them a bounded but consequential choice. That can build civic capacity through practice, as people learn how trade-offs are made and see the results. The process must still account for unequal time, confidence, digital access, and representation. Those who attend meetings are not automatically representative of everyone affected. Good design therefore combines open participation with deliberate outreach, transparent rules, and clear reporting on which voices shaped the final allocation.
Judge jobs by security and pay, not the employment headline
A job is not enough. The book challenges regeneration strategies that count positions without asking whether they offer decent pay, secure hours, training, or a future. Preston became a Living Wage employer in 2012 and encouraged other institutions to do the same. The book reports that Preston later had Lancashire's lowest share of workers paid below the Living Wage, and that about a quarter of low-paid workers in Preston and surrounding areas received a pay increase when their employers became accredited.
Protect everyday essentials. The foundational economy is the network of goods and services people rely on, including care, health, education, utilities, food, and retail. In Wales, health, education, and welfare employed about 30% of the workforce, with utilities, retail, and food production accounting for roughly another 10%, rising to around half the workforce in former industrial areas. These sectors may lack glamour, but they are central to daily security.
This focus corrects a common measurement problem: job totals are easy to announce, while job quality is harder to capture. A more complete scorecard would track wages, security, worker voice, progression, and the distribution of jobs across neighbourhoods. The foundational-economy lens also makes policy attentive to services whose value is partly preventative: reliable care or transport can support wellbeing without appearing as a dramatic new development. One caution is that locally rooted employment is not inherently good employment. Labour standards and worker representation need to apply across sectors, including small firms and cooperatives.
Treat land and energy as shared assets, not scenery
Control shapes access. Land determines who can build homes, use green space, and benefit from local resources. Community land trusts are community-led organisations that hold or manage land over the long term, with local involvement in deciding its use and with community benefits protected. They can support affordable housing, community facilities, farming, or energy projects. The book describes Granby in Liverpool, where residents used a trust to take control of derelict homes and develop affordable housing and shared spaces.
Connect ecology and livelihoods. The Isle of Eigg's community-owned energy system provides about 95% of the island's electricity from renewable sources. In Wales, the proposed Skyline project explored community stewardship of valley land for activities such as forestry, food production, and hydropower. These models can join environmental care with local economic activity, though they require expertise, funding, and durable community involvement.
Land stewardship makes economic democracy tangible: ownership determines who can use a place, collect its returns, and shape its future. It also widens climate action beyond individual consumption toward collective control of energy and land. The challenge is to balance income generation with ecological limits and public access. A project that earns revenue can fund shared benefits, but commercial pressure may eventually narrow the original purpose. Clear governance, ecological expertise, and community-defined protections help prevent stewardship from becoming a new form of extraction under local ownership.
Use council procedure as an entry point to economic change
Start with a practical opening. The book's guide begins by identifying anchor institutions and examining their spending. It then asks where local suppliers can compete, where cooperatives could fill gaps, and how jobs and training can reach residents who face the greatest barriers. Councillors and residents can build support among unions, community groups, employers, and public bodies before proposing changes.
Turn support into a decision. Councils publish meeting papers, budgets, and procurement plans, and residents can attend many meetings. A councillor can introduce a motion that sets out evidence, explains why change is needed, and specifies what the council should do. Preston began with procurement, a concrete area of council activity, then expanded its ambitions. Local initiatives can produce practical gains, but councils remain constrained by funding, law, and national policy, so local action is a starting point, not a substitute for wider change.
The practical guidance demystifies local government by locating leverage in routine processes rather than only in elections or headline campaigns. Procurement decisions, budget motions, pension committees, and contract design are technical, but they are also political choices with distributional effects. A small, specific proposal can create a coalition and demonstrate competence more persuasively than an abstract promise. The broader lesson is not that local authorities can solve structural inequality alone. Their capacity depends on national rules and resources, which makes local organising most effective when it also argues for powers and funding that let communities act.
Analysis
The book's most consequential claim is that economic power is not located only in national policy or private investment. It is also embedded in everyday institutional decisions: where a hospital buys food, who maintains public housing, what a pension fund finances, and who owns land. Preston's experiment makes those decisions visible and shows how they can be coordinated. Its story is compelling partly because it begins with failure. The collapse of the Tithebarn development did not merely disappoint residents; it challenged the premise that a town must wait for external capital to revive it.
The model's strongest mechanism is procurement. Public institutions already spend money, so redirecting a portion toward local suppliers can build demand without requiring a wholly new spending programme. But local retention is not the same as justice. The relevant outcomes include wages, job security, ownership, worker voice, environmental effects, and whether disadvantaged residents gain access to new opportunities. The book recognises this measurement problem, and it matters because attractive local statistics can conceal unequal benefits.
A second tension is democratic control. Council-led coordination can move quickly and marshal institutional resources, but a strategy that depends on particular leaders may weaken when politics changes. Resident participation is therefore not decorative. It is a source of legitimacy, knowledge, and durability. Yet participation itself can privilege those with more time and confidence, so inclusive design requires resources and active outreach.
Finally, localism is best understood as a scale of action, not a theory of self-sufficiency. A town cannot independently resolve every constraint on housing, banking, climate policy, or public finance. The book's most persuasive position is connective: local experiments can demonstrate alternatives, build institutions, and generate pressure for broader reform. Its practical challenge is to make those experiments accountable, measurable, and linked across places rather than leaving each community to improvise alone.
Review Summary
Paint Your Town Red receives mixed reviews, with an average rating of 3.70/5. Readers appreciate its overview of community wealth-building strategies and the Preston Model. Many find it inspiring and informative, praising its practical advice for local economic transformation. Critics note its shallow treatment of some topics and dry writing style. The book is seen as a good starting point for those interested in progressive local governance, though some feel it lacks depth and concrete measures of success. Overall, it's recommended for readers interested in alternative economic models and local activism.
People Also Read
Glossary
Community wealth-building
Locally controlled economic developmentA local economic strategy that builds inclusive, sustainable economies through democratic ownership and coordinated use of local resources. It can include worker cooperatives, community land trusts, local public enterprises, community finance, and procurement by anchor institutions. Its aim is to keep more economic value circulating in a place and to give residents greater influence over how that value is created and used.
Preston Model
Preston's local wealth strategyPreston's locally adapted approach to community wealth-building. It began by coordinating public institutions to spend more with local and regional suppliers, then developed related work on living wages, cooperatives, local investment, community finance, and public ownership. The model relies on the city's particular institutions and resources, so its principles are intended to be adapted rather than copied as a fixed package.
Anchor institution
A lasting local employerA large organisation with a stable presence in a place and significant influence through its employment, purchasing, land, or services. Universities, hospitals, colleges, and housing associations are common examples. Because they are unlikely to relocate easily, anchor institutions can use their spending and employment practices to support local suppliers, better jobs, and community economic development.
Progressive procurement
Purchasing for wider public valueA purchasing approach that weighs social, ethical, and environmental effects alongside the immediate price of a good or service. Public bodies can make contracts more accessible to local suppliers, split oversized contracts into smaller opportunities, and set requirements related to wages, training, or environmental impact. The intention is to use existing purchasing budgets to create broader benefits.
Foundational economy
Essential everyday goods and servicesThe part of the economy that supplies basic infrastructure and services people rely on in daily life. It includes care, health, education, utilities, food, retail, and the networks that connect households. The concept shifts attention away from economic growth alone and toward the reliable, socially responsible provision of essentials and the resilience of the firms and workers that provide them.
Participatory budgeting
Residents allocate public fundsA process in which residents help decide how a defined portion of a public budget is spent. It gives people influence over local priorities and draws on their knowledge of conditions in their neighbourhoods. The scale can range from small community grants to significant portions of a city budget. Accessible design and outreach matter so that participation is not limited to already influential groups.
Community land trust
Community control of landA community-led organisation that owns, stewards, or manages land over the long term and gives local people a role in deciding how it is used. It can support housing, community facilities, energy, or farming. The trust's structure is intended to protect defined community benefits over time, rather than leaving land use entirely to short-term private decisions.
People's bank
A locally focused mutual bankA larger customer-owned financial institution intended to provide a broad range of banking services while directing lending toward a local or regional economy. Like a cooperative, it is accountable to its members rather than outside shareholders. The book distinguishes it from a credit union by its wider scale and services, while noting that establishing one requires substantial capital and regulatory preparation.
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.