Start free trial
Trending New Genres Authors
EnglishEnglish
EspañolSpanish
简体中文Chinese
繁體中文Chinese (Traditional)
FrançaisFrench
DeutschGerman
日本語Japanese
PortuguêsPortuguese
ItalianoItalian
한국어Korean
РусскийRussian
NederlandsDutch
العربيةArabic
PolskiPolish
हिन्दीHindi
Tiếng ViệtVietnamese
SvenskaSwedish
ΕλληνικάGreek
TürkçeTurkish
ไทยThai
ČeštinaCzech
RomânăRomanian
MagyarHungarian
УкраїнськаUkrainian
IndonesiaIndonesian
DanskDanish
SuomiFinnish
БългарскиBulgarian
עבריתHebrew
NorskNorwegian
HrvatskiCroatian
CatalàCatalan
SlovenčinaSlovak
LietuviųLithuanian
SlovenščinaSlovenian
СрпскиSerbian
EestiEstonian
LatviešuLatvian
فارسیPersian
മലയാളംMalayalam
தமிழ்Tamil
اردوUrdu
Searching...
SoBrief
Plain Bad Heroines

Plain Bad Heroines

A haunted-estate film traps three women between staged scares and a curse.
by Emily M. Danforth 2020 640 pages
3.63
30k+ ratings
Listen
Immersive
V2.3
Amazon Kindle Audible
Try Full Access for 3 Days
Unlock listening & more!
Continue

Plot Summary

Black Apples, Yellow Jackets

A family ultimatum drives Clara toward Flo

In 1902, Clara Broward7 returns to Brookhants after her family orders her to end her friendship with Florence Hartshorn6 and abandon the writings of Mary MacLane.15 Her cousin Charles16 pursues her through the woods, insisting he has the right to correct her defiance. Flo6 runs to help Clara,7 but Clara7 steps into an enormous yellow jacket nest hidden in the Tricky Thicket.

The insects engulf her; Flo6 reaches her and is stung as well, while Charles16 escapes. Rescuers burn the nest to recover the girls, found clasped together beside a red copy of MacLane’s book. Their deaths become the first chapter in Brookhants’ notorious history, and the book disappears from official custody.

The Red Book Returns

Eleanor steals the copy and loses herself inside

A Brookhants student named Eleanor Faderman watches a detective leave the missing book unattended and quietly takes it. She hides the volume in the Orangerie, where she works before dawn, then reads it in a secluded nook beneath an angel’s trumpet tree.

The book’s fierce account of wanting gives Eleanor language for feelings she has kept private, including her admiration for classmate Grace O’Connell. As Eleanor neglects her duties and grows increasingly detached, the Orangerie blooms with impossible abundance.

She dies after eating poisonous flowers from the tree, still clutching the book. Principal Libbie Brookhants4 removes it from Eleanor’s hand and conceals it, while faculty members argue over whether the book or the school itself is to blame.

Three Women, One Film

A struggling actor, a star, and an author converge

In modern Los Angeles, Audrey Wells1 has moved back in with her mother,10 Caroline,10 and has gone more than a year without an acting job. A role in The Happenings at Brookhants offers a chance to escape her mother’s10 shadow and revive her stalled career. The film’s star, Harper Harper,2 is home in Montana with her newly sober mother, younger brother, and girlfriend, while preparing to return to the project as both actor and producer.

Merritt Emmons,3 who wrote the book the film adapts, is traveling to Hollywood with Elaine Brookhants,8 the estate’s owner and Merritt’s longtime mentor.8 Each woman arrives carrying a different stake in the story: work, public identity, or a history she thought she had already written down.

The Audition Becomes Evidence

Bo turns Audrey’s fear into a secret production method

The production first drops Audrey1 from the smaller role of Eleanor, then offers her Clara, one of the leads and Harper’s2 romantic counterpart. During a chemistry read, Audrey’s1 performance falters and her kiss with Harper2 goes badly.

Bo9 later reveals that the awkward session was deliberately engineered to see how the women behaved under pressure. He is making two films at once: the period horror story and a secretly recorded account of the modern cast experiencing Brookhants. Audrey1 will know the plan and help manage it, while Harper2 and Merritt3 remain unaware.

Bo9 argues that Audrey’s1 natural reactions and Harper’s2 social-media reach will sell the curse as real. Audrey1 objects to the manipulation, but accepts after Bo9 admits he believes Brookhants is haunted and offers Caroline10 a small role.

A Marriage Built on Bargain

Libbie and Alex trade certainty for a shared future

Decades earlier, Libbie Packard4 meets Alexandra Trills5 at Wellesley and wins her attention with a comic performance. Their correspondence becomes intimate, and their reunion turns a playful campus courtship into a lasting love.

After college, however, Libbie4 wants a life of her own, while Alex5 fears that separation will destroy what they have. At the Chicago World’s Fair, Libbie4 tells Alex5 she is pregnant after a brief encounter with Simon Everett.

The wealthy, dying Harold Brookhants14 offers Libbie4 protection, an estate, and a school to run; a French medium, Madame Verrett, promises a ritual that will make the child Harold’s.14 Alex5 initially rejects the plan, then secretly persuades Libbie4 to accept it, because the school gives them a way to live together.

The Date and the Cut

Harper and Merritt connect before the film fractures them

At a Hollywood dinner, Harper2 arrives late and takes Merritt3 outside to smoke. They flirt in the restaurant’s herb-lined service courtyard, where Merritt3 notices Harper’s2 new yellow jacket tattoo and agrees to see Los Angeles with her the next day.

Their date becomes a first kiss outside a piercing shop, a motorcycle ride, and a night of exploring the city. The public kiss draws praise and vicious comments online. At Bo’s9 house, meanwhile, Merritt3 has watched Audrey1 struggle in the Clara audition and doubts the casting decision.

When she learns the studio is going forward with Audrey,1 she decides she cannot support the film and leaves Los Angeles. Elaine8 later persuades Merritt3 to return, citing both her declining health and Merritt’s3 stalled writing.

Back at Brookhants

Merritt returns as the crew enters haunted ground

Audrey1 reaches the coastal estate first and finds Harper2 already settled in one of three tiny production houses beside Spite Manor. Merritt3 arrives later with Elaine,8 who has brought her back despite her resistance.

The crew has rebuilt the Orangerie for filming, but a suspicious fire damages its new sets before production begins. Once filming starts, the old estate supplies no shortage of unnerving incidents: rooms feel watched, the woods change in appearance, and cast and crew trade stories about the curse.

Merritt,3 who knows the site from childhood research, resists treating every oddity as supernatural. Harper2 is more willing to believe, while Audrey1 struggles to tell whether what she sees belongs to the location, the production’s hidden equipment, or her own growing fear.

Stereo Cards Turn Black

Alex finds the past changing inside private images

In 1903, Alex5 begins examining erotic stereoscope cards that Sara Dahlgren brought to Libbie4 from Europe. She believes their images are changing after she used them as bookmarks in the recovered Mary MacLane book.

Flowers become poisonous trumpets, an orchard appears where healthy trees once stood, and the red volume shows up in scenes where it never belonged. Alex5 gathers evidence, convinced that the book has reawakened a curse already rooted in the estate.

Brookhants’ enrollment collapses after the deaths, and Alex5 grows suspicious of the girls who remain. She confronts Camille Andrews and Josephine Narse after seeing them return from the woods with a red book, but discovers only a horror novel. Her certainty deepens even as Libbie4 refuses to share it.

The Tower Takes Alex

A hidden page drives suspicion toward a fatal fall

At Spite Manor, Alex5 eats trifle prepared by Adelaide12 and discovers fragments of yellow jackets mixed into the fruit. Convinced Adelaide12 meant to poison her, Alex5 later destroys plants and burns the altered stereoscope cards in the Orangerie.

Libbie4 finds her disoriented and tries to lead her home, but Alex’s5 suspicion turns toward the Eckhart household and the missing page in the book. In the tower, Hanna and Adelaide12 produce the page, which bears a message Libbie4 had tried to conceal.

Alex5 reads the discovery as proof that Libbie4 and the servants have deceived her. She charges at Hanna on the narrow stairs, but Hanna slips into the book-lined wall. Alex5 plunges down the empty stairwell and dies. Libbie4 is committed after her grief and terror become unmanageable.

Apples on the Road

The trio find a swarm and trespassers at the estate

During production, Harper2 and crew member Kae discover delicate papier-mâché apples, a flower, and a yellow jacket buried in a soil shipment. On a later ride through the woods, Audrey,1 Harper,2 and Merritt3 find crates of Black Oxford apples stacked across the road.

Harper2 bites one, then notices a swarm of yellow jackets hovering in a shape she thinks resembles a beckoning woman. She posts the video, drawing local fans to the production. The same three fans later follow the women by boat to Spite Manor, forcing security to remove them from the beach.

The incidents deepen the tension between Harper’s2 belief in a curse and Merritt’s3 skepticism. They also draw Audrey1 closer to both women, even as she knows the crew may be recording every reaction.

Tea in the Thicket

A dangerous brew blurs staged horror with bodily terror

Delays mount when a landscaper is stung near a ground nest and allergic reactions require him to be taken for medical care. Cameras develop black growth between takes, and crew members keep finding reasons production cannot proceed.

During a break, Harper’s2 friend Eric brews tea from angel’s trumpet flowers, despite Merritt’s3 warnings about the plant’s toxicity. Audrey1 drinks some, hoping its sedative effect will help her sleep.

In the hot springs, she sees a woman on Harper’s2 phone feed who is not physically present, then finds what look like insect parts in her mouth and black growth in her water. She runs home, where the kitchen counter appears to contain a paper wasp nest. Harper2 and Merritt3 help her to bed, but Audrey’s1 fear and sleeplessness continue.

Ava’s Treehouse Secret

The child arrives knowing more than Libbie expects

In 1904, Libbie4 returns from the asylum to Spite Manor and meets Ava,13 the daughter13 she has mostly kept at a distance. Ava13 knows that Harold14 was her father14 and Libbie4 her mother,4 but has not told Libbie4 she knows. Raised in France by the Verrett family and later cared for by Adelaide,12 Ava13 spends her time climbing trees, reading, and making small papier-mâché figures.

While eating apples in her favorite tree, she drops her belongings and falls, breaking her arm. Libbie4 finds her and collects the red book and a handmade nesting doll from the ground. Ava’s13 calm attachment to Adelaide,12 along with her knowledge of the book and the family history, unsettles Libbie.4 The encounter establishes a new generation inside Brookhants’ old story.

Snow in the Orchard

The women choose tenderness before a night of exposure

After another failed day of filming, Audrey1 ignores Bo’s9 instructions and invites Harper2 and Merritt3 to the orchard. The three women share cider, eat Black Oxford apples, and talk about how the book and Brookhants shaped the girls who came before them.

They kiss and touch one another, finding a rare moment that feels chosen rather than staged. Snow begins falling despite the season, and Audrey1 drives Elaine’s8 convertible through the woods for the first time.

At the lawn screening, she discovers that the crew is showing a Caroline Wells10 horror film, with her mother’s10 young body projected across the school wall. Caroline10 has arrived early, too. Feeling exposed and overwhelmed, Audrey1 insists they leave for Noel’s11 concert in Providence, cutting short the intimacy she had hoped to protect.

The Concert Turns

Merritt names the deception as Elaine’s life collapses

At Noel’s11 Providence show, Audrey1 grows ill and sees the theater audience as a gathering of Brookhants students from the past. She escapes backstage, where Merritt3 joins her and admits she had learned about Bo’s secret filming plan after quitting the project.

Harper2 arrives and acknowledges that she had known the scheme from the beginning and helped Elaine shape it. Merritt3 calls out the women’s shared hunger for fame, while Audrey1 feels betrayed by the people she had trusted.

Bo9 and producer Heather interrupt with news that Elaine8 has fallen on the Spite Tower stairs and has been taken to hospital. Merritt3 rushes to her. Elaine8 dies from complications of the fall. Production pauses, then resumes, allowing Bo9 to finish the film after the estate’s future is settled.

Simone’s Story Surfaces

Adelaide claims the old curse and Libbie vanishes

After Elaine’s8 death, Libbie4 returns to Brookhants and tries to destroy the book and Ava’s13 nesting doll before the curse can claim another generation. Adelaide12 finds her on the beach and reveals that the estate’s history began before the Rash brothers: a woman named Simone lived there with her two mothers, until the brothers murdered her and took the land.

Adelaide12 connects Simone to the Verrett family and claims that Harold’s14 occult ambitions, the book, and the later tragedies all grew from that older violence.

She had wanted Libbie4 as a partner in raising Ava,13 but Libbie4 refuses her. Adelaide12 takes the book, while Libbie4 becomes paralyzed in the surf and is dragged out by black seaweed. Her body is never found, leaving her fate uncertain and the estate’s curse unresolved.

Cannes, Still Buzzing

The finished film reunites three women beside unresolved fear

At the film’s premiere in Cannes, Harper2 works the red carpet while feeling yellow jackets, hearing their hum, and sensing the old Brookhants imagery return. Audrey1 joins her, then Merritt3 appears unexpectedly, wearing a shirt she made for both Audrey1 and herself.

The three women link arms and refuse repeated requests to pose separately. They admit that the orchard’s impossible snow still matters to them, even if the film’s manufactured scares and private betrayals make it hard to know what was real.

Merritt3 reveals that Elaine8 left her the estate and that she has already approved the film’s completion there. When Bo9 is stung on the carpet, the women hear the buzzing again. They climb the premiere stairs together, connected but not certain they have escaped Brookhants.

Analysis

Plain Bad Heroines treats the past not as a closed archive but as a force repeatedly staged, edited, and inherited. The same deaths become a school legend, Merritt’s3 nonfiction, Bo’s9 film, and a set of frightening experiences for the cast. Each version offers a different claim to authority, yet none can fully separate truth from performance. The novel makes that uncertainty ethical as well as supernatural: Bo’s9 concealed cameras manufacture fear, but Audrey’s1 distress remains real; Merritt’s3 research preserves women’s stories, yet turns living friends into material; and Libbie’s4 efforts to protect her private life help bury the truth she most needs to face.

The women’s desires are not presented as a single triumph over convention. Clara7 and Flo6 find recognition in one another, while Libbie4 and Alex5 discover that love does not erase differences in what each wants from life. Harper2 and Merritt’s3 attraction is complicated by celebrity, competing obligations, and the unequal conditions under which they participate in the film. Audrey’s1 most consequential struggle is not simply to become a better actor, but to retain agency when a production converts her fear into footage. Their changing alliances create the book’s emotional movement from isolation toward chosen, if imperfect, connection.

The motifs of books, insects, plants, and images make that argument tangible. The red book can be a companion or an accusation; the yellow jackets can be a practical danger, a repeated haunting, or both. The Orangerie turns cultivated beauty into unruly growth, while the stereoscope and cameras expose how easily looking becomes a form of control. By tracing the curse to a woman erased from local history, the novel shows that haunting is not only an inexplicable event. It is also what happens when a community preserves the story of powerful men and loses the name of the person they harmed. Remembering her does not undo the violence, but it changes what the survivors believe they have inherited.

Summary in 60 Seconds
In 1902, Clara Broward and Florence Hartshorn die in a yellow-jacket nest at Brookhants, a girls’ school. Student Eleanor Faderman later takes a book that deepens her fixation on classmate Grace, and dies after eating poisonous flowers. Decades later, Libbie Brookhants and her lover Alex struggle to build a life together at the estate. Alex becomes convinced the book is changing images and causing danger, then falls to her death; Libbie is institutionalized. In the present, actor Audrey Wells joins a film about Brookhants, unaware that director Bo is secretly recording the cast to blur fiction and reality. Audrey, star Harper Harper, and author Merritt Emmons grow close, but Harper and Merritt knew about the deception. Elaine dies after falling at the estate. Adelaide reveals the story began with Simone, murdered by the men who took her home. Libbie disappears into the sea. At the premiere, the three women reunite, while the haunting remains unexplained.
Contains spoilers

Last updated:

Report Issue

Review Summary

3.63 out of 5
Average of 30k+ ratings from Goodreads and Amazon.

Reviews for Plain Bad Heroines are mixed, averaging 3.63/5. Praised elements include its ambitious dual timelines (1902 and present-day), rich queer representation, atmospheric gothic setting, and a distinctive omniscient narrator with playful footnotes. Many readers loved the sapphic relationships and Sara Lautman's illustrations. Common criticisms cite the 600+ page length feeling excessive, slow pacing particularly in the modern storyline, an unsatisfying/abrupt ending, insufficient horror despite the genre label, and underdeveloped characters. The 1902 Brookhants narrative was generally preferred over the Hollywood filmmaking storyline.

Your rating:
4.8
1 ratings
Want to read the full book?

Characters

Audrey Wells

The wary young actor

Audrey is a twenty-three-year-old actor who has spent much of her life working in her mother Caroline’s10 shadow. A childhood spent around film sets has taught her to recognize performance, but her own stalled career leaves her unsure whether she has the talent to carry a major role. She avoids driving, resists social media, and has learned to manage fear by anticipating what might go wrong. Her professional ambition is genuine, but so is her discomfort when people use her vulnerability as material. Audrey’s connection to her mother10 is loving and strained by old public scandal, financial dependence, and the question of whose career she is living. She wants to be taken seriously without surrendering her right to decide what her work costs.

Harper Harper

The magnetic film star

Harper is a Montana-born actor whose sudden fame has made her both a talented performer and a public image she must constantly maintain. Her casual charm began as a real part of her, but the demands of celebrity turn it into another job. She is loyal to the family and friends who knew her before Hollywood, especially her younger brother, while also learning to move among wealthy, culturally fluent people who do not share her background. Harper’s relationship with visibility is complicated: social media gives her community and influence, yet it can also make private feelings public property. She is drawn to people who share their enthusiasms freely and tries to make room for connection even when her own impulses create confusion.

Merritt Emmons

The prickly young author

Merritt is a young author whose first book made her briefly famous before grief and self-doubt stalled her writing. She is intellectually quick, deeply observant, and often uses sarcasm to keep other people from getting too close. Her research into Brookhants has given her a strong command of its documents and stories, but she is less comfortable with the living people drawn into them. Her father’s suicide and her reliance on Elaine’s8 guidance complicate her sense of authorship: she fears she may have been a conduit rather than the book’s true maker. Merritt longs for intimacy but distrusts the conditions under which it arrives. She can see manipulation clearly in others while remaining reluctant to admit her own appetite for recognition.

Libbie Brookhants

The school’s young founder

Libbie is a wealthy, socially capable young woman who becomes the founder and principal of Brookhants. She is bold in pursuit of desire and skilled at making herself noticed, yet she also knows how to present difficult choices as orderly bargains. Her relationship with Alex5 is shaped by genuine affection and a strong need to preserve her independence. Libbie wants a life of her own, not merely the respectable role available to a woman of her class, but her decisions repeatedly entangle her with family obligations, money, and the futures of other people. She is drawn to young women whose emotional honesty recalls her own youth, even when she cannot offer them a clear path through the strictures she has accepted.

Alexandra Trills

The devoted scholar

Alex is a gifted student and teacher whose reserved manner conceals a powerful capacity for attachment. Orphaned young, she grows up under relatives who treat her intelligence and unconventional appearance as liabilities. At college she discovers that other women desire her, but her relationship with Libbie4 changes courtship from a flattering game into something she fears losing. Alex values evidence and careful observation, qualities that make her both an excellent educator and a person vulnerable to fixation when what she observes cannot be explained. She has a strong sense of responsibility toward Brookhants’ students and a deep need to believe that her home with Libbie4 is secure. Her reserve is not indifference; it is a defense against the possibility of abandonment.

Florence Hartshorn

Clara’s daring beloved

Flo is a confident, worldly student who dresses for movement rather than convention and shares Clara’s7 devotion to Mary MacLane15. Her artistic mother allows her more freedom than Clara’s7 wealthy family permits, and Flo uses that freedom to test boundaries openly. Her intelligence, physical courage, and ease with desire make her a compelling presence among the Brookhants girls. She and Clara7 form a private world within the school, one built through reading, flirtation, and mutual recognition.

Clara Broward

The defiant schoolgirl

Clara is a wealthy student whose family expects her to obey its standards of respectable femininity. Her attachment to Mary MacLane’s15 writing helps her recognize that the thoughts she hides are not hers alone. Clara is perceptive, passionate, and more courageous in love than in public confrontation. The tension between inherited privilege and private self-knowledge shapes her relationship with Flo6 and drives her to resist the limits her family tries to impose.

Elaine Brookhants

The estate’s formidable keeper

Elaine is the wealthy owner of the Brookhants estate, a philanthropist, and Merritt’s3 longtime mentor. She is witty, opinionated, and accustomed to making her money and convictions move people toward the projects she values. Elaine believes in preserving Brookhants even when its history repels others, and she sees creative work as something that must be made rather than endlessly protected from risk. Her closeness to Merritt3 mixes affection with authority: she knows how to encourage the young writer, but her certainty can make that encouragement feel like a debt.

Bo Dhillon

The horror-film auteur

Bo is a celebrated horror director who wants to blur the line between a period film and the making of that film. He is ambitious, visually inventive, and convinced that fear produces truthful behavior that a scripted scene cannot reach. His professional confidence can become impatience when production resists his plans. Bo is interested in the tension between artifice and belief, but his methods raise ethical questions because he treats the cast’s emotional reactions as both performance and evidence. He wants the film to unsettle its audience while making the estate’s history impossible to dismiss.

Caroline Wells

Audrey’s former scream queen

Caroline is Audrey’s mother1, a former horror-film star rebuilding her life and career after a highly public crisis. She is warm, resourceful, and sometimes overinvolved, using wellness rituals and practical acts of care to manage her own anxiety. Her bond with Audrey1 is loving but burdened by the public attention that followed Caroline’s accident and addiction struggles. She wants her daughter1 to succeed, yet her wish to help can slide into managing Audrey’s1 choices for her.

Noel Shipler

Audrey’s lifelong confidant

Noel has known Audrey1 since childhood and shares with her a history of acting, music, and family closeness. He is a talented musician who works steadily for other artists while trying to make his own band succeed. His humor softens difficult moments, but his loyalty sometimes leads him to participate in plans he has not fully considered. Noel understands Audrey’s1 insecurities better than most people and can tell when her jokes are covering real distress.

Adelaide Eckhart

The watchful housemaid

Adelaide joins the Brookhants household as Max Eckhart’s wife and quickly becomes a source of care and curiosity for Libbie4. She is attentive, intelligent, and more perceptive than her position allows her to show. Her kindness toward Ava13 and her interest in Libbie4 create relationships that cross the usual boundaries between employer, employee, and family. Adelaide carries a private history and a distinct understanding of what Brookhants has been, though she rarely explains herself directly.

Ava Brookhants

The curious hidden heir

Ava is a bright, self-directed child raised in France and later brought to the Brookhants estate. She is an avid reader, a tree climber, and an enthusiastic maker of small objects, especially papier-mâché figures. Ava is comfortable with ideas and practices that other children might find strange, because her education has been shaped by adults who value mysticism as much as ordinary learning. She observes people closely and often understands more than she lets them know. Her arrival places a new generation inside a family history that has been carefully managed by others.

Harold Brookhants

The eccentric benefactor

Harold is a wealthy industrialist with an abiding interest in spiritualism, architectural oddities, and the life he hopes to leave behind. He uses his fortune to shape Brookhants into both a school and a home, convinced that the land has unusual power. Harold is generous when generosity serves his aims, and his plans for Libbie4 and the school combine sincere affection with a strong desire to control what follows his death. He approaches conventional limits as obstacles money and ritual might overcome.

Mary MacLane

The unsettling literary spark

Mary MacLane is the young author whose memoir gives Brookhants students a startling model of self-disclosure. Her writing is direct, self-dramatizing, and hungry for a life beyond the one she has been given. The book matters to the characters not simply because it is scandalous, but because it seems to recognize desires they have been taught to keep private.

Charles Broward

Clara’s controlling cousin

Charles is Clara’s7 wealthy cousin, accustomed to treating family authority as a license to correct her. He condemns Flo6 and the ideas Clara7 reads, then uses the family’s expectations to justify pursuing Clara7 through the Brookhants woods. His self-importance rests on a belief that social rank makes his judgments reasonable.

Plot Devices

Mary MacLane’s red book

A mirror passed between girls

The memoir travels from Libbie4 to Clara7 and Flo6, then disappears and resurfaces with Eleanor. Its passages about desire and discontent offer each student a way to recognize feelings she has not been encouraged to name. Marginal notes, missing pages, and the book’s repeated presence near the dead make it both a physical clue and an object onto which the adults project blame. The book is important because it can be read as literature, evidence, a talisman, or a scapegoat, depending on who holds it. Its force lies partly in the characters’ belief that it knows them.

The yellow jacket swarm

A living warning system

Yellow jackets link the historical deaths, the modern production, and the estate’s recurring disturbances. Their nests survive where they should not, their buzzing appears in moments of panic, and their bodies turn up in food, water, and handmade objects. The insect motif also echoes the characters’ fear of collective force: one sting calls many more, and private harm can quickly become a public swarm. Some appearances may be engineered or misread, but the novel repeatedly makes the sound and presence of the insects difficult to dismiss.

The film inside the film

Fear becomes recorded evidence

Bo’s9 production joins a scripted adaptation of the Brookhants history to hidden recordings of the modern cast. Audrey1 is told about the plan and participates, while Harper2 and Merritt3 initially believe they are simply working on a conventional film. Cameras, planted cues, online posts, and staged interruptions make the cast’s real reactions part of the intended movie. The device keeps the reader asking whether a disturbance was arranged, supernatural, or both. It also turns acting into an ethical problem: a frightened response may be emotionally genuine even when someone else has designed the situation.

The altered stereoscope cards

Private images become testimony

Alex5 uses stereoscope cards as markers in the Mary MacLane book, then believes their scenes are changing. Blooms, books, and signs of decay appear in images she remembers differently. The cards give Alex5 a concrete method for recording what she sees, but the evidence remains inaccessible to anyone who does not share her perception. Their deterioration parallels the school’s decline and deepens Alex’s5 conflict with Libbie4, who cannot confirm the changes. The device asks whether observation remains reliable when fear and grief shape what the observer expects to find.

The nested papier-mâché doll

A family history in miniature

The Russian nesting doll appears first in a vision at the Chicago World’s Fair, where its successive figures echo Brookhants’ doomed girls and a final child resembling Libbie4. Ava13 later makes a doll of her own with Adelaide12, and it becomes an object Libbie4 tries to destroy. Each layer suggests that one life contains another, while the doll’s painted scenes connect the old curse to the modern production’s handmade props. It works as a compact image of inheritance: stories and obligations can be hidden inside one another, but opening them does not guarantee control over what emerges.

About the Author

Emily M. Danforth is a fiction writer born and raised in Miles City, Montana, who now lives in Rhode Island with her wife Erica and two dogs. Her debut novel, The Miseducation of Cameron Post, a coming-of-age story, was adapted into a feature film in 2018. Her second novel, Plain Bad Heroines, is a sapphic-gothic-comedy set in Rhode Island. Danforth holds an MFA in Fiction from the University of Montana and a Ph.D in English-Creative Writing from the University of Nebraska-Lincoln. She has previously worked as a lifeguard, bartender, swim instructor, and briefly as a telemarketer.

Download PDF

To save this Plain Bad Heroines summary for later, download the free PDF. You can print it out, or read offline at your convenience.
Download PDF
File size: 0.27 MB     Pages: 17

Download EPUB

To read this Plain Bad Heroines summary on your e-reader device or app, download the free EPUB. The .epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.
Download EPUB
File size: 1.30 MB     Pages: 27
Want to read the full book?
Follow
Listen
Home
Swipe
Library
Get App
Try Full Access for 3 Days
Listen, bookmark, and more
Compare Features Free Pro
📖 Read Summaries
Read unlimited summaries. Free users get 3 per month
🎧 Listen to Summaries
Listen to unlimited summaries in 40 languages
—
❤️ Unlimited Bookmarks
Free users are limited to 4
—
📜 Unlimited History
Free users are limited to 4
—
📥 Unlimited Downloads
Free users are limited to 1
—
Risk-Free Timeline
Today: Get Instant Access
Listen to full summaries of 26,000+ books. That's 12,000+ hours of audio!
Day 2: Trial Reminder
We'll send you a notification that your trial is ending soon.
Day 3: Your subscription begins
You'll be charged on Nov 24,
cancel anytime before.
Consume 2.8× More Books
2.8× more books Listening Reading
Our users love us
1M+ readers
Trustpilot Rating
TrustPilot
4.6 Excellent
This site is a total game-changer. I've been flying through book summaries like never before. Highly, highly recommend.
— Dave G
Worth my money and time, and really well made. I've never seen this quality of summaries on other websites. Very helpful!
— Em
Highly recommended!! Fantastic service. Perfect for those that want a little more than a teaser but not all the intricate details of a full audio book.
— Greg M
Save 62%
Yearly
$119.88 $44.99/year/yr
$3.75/mo
Monthly
$9.99/mo
Start a 3-Day Free Trial
3 days free, then $44.99/year. Cancel anytime.
Unlock a world of fiction & nonfiction books
26,000+ books for the price of 2 books
Read any book in 10 minutes
Discover new books like Tinder
Request any book if it's not summarized
Read more books than anyone you know
#1 app for book lovers
Lifelike & immersive summaries
30-day money-back guarantee
Download summaries in EPUBs or PDFs
Cancel anytime in a few clicks

Why one summary?

Scanner
Find a barcode to scan

⭐
⭐
⭐
We have a special gift for you
Open
38% off
DISCOUNT FOR YOU
⭐
⭐
⭐
$79.99
$49.99/year
Only $4.16 per month
Continue
2 taps to start, super easy to cancel
Settings
General
Widget
Loading...