Start free trial
Trending New Genres Authors
EnglishEnglish
EspañolSpanish
简体中文Chinese
繁體中文Chinese (Traditional)
FrançaisFrench
DeutschGerman
日本語Japanese
PortuguêsPortuguese
ItalianoItalian
한국어Korean
РусскийRussian
NederlandsDutch
العربيةArabic
PolskiPolish
हिन्दीHindi
Tiếng ViệtVietnamese
SvenskaSwedish
ΕλληνικάGreek
TürkçeTurkish
ไทยThai
ČeštinaCzech
RomânăRomanian
MagyarHungarian
УкраїнськаUkrainian
IndonesiaIndonesian
DanskDanish
SuomiFinnish
БългарскиBulgarian
עבריתHebrew
NorskNorwegian
HrvatskiCroatian
CatalàCatalan
SlovenčinaSlovak
LietuviųLithuanian
SlovenščinaSlovenian
СрпскиSerbian
EestiEstonian
LatviešuLatvian
فارسیPersian
മലയാളംMalayalam
தமிழ்Tamil
اردوUrdu
Searching...
SoBrief
The Broken Girls

The Broken Girls

A journalist revisiting her sister's murder finds a long-buried student at a haunted school.
by Simone St. James 2018 336 pages
4.05
100k+ ratings
Listen
Immersive
V2.3
Amazon Kindle Audible
Try Full Access for 3 Days
Unlock listening & more!
Continue

Plot Summary

Prologue

In November 1950, fifteen-year-old Sonia Gallipeau hurries along Old Barrons Road with her suitcase, trying to reach Idlewild Hall before dark. She has escaped one kind of terror already, but a veiled figure in a long black dress follows her from the ridge.

Sonia abandons the road and runs through the trees toward the school’s field. The figure’s song and the rhyme the girls know by heart pursue her. Sonia understands that speed cannot save her. She screams into the night.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The opening makes the school’s ghost story a physical danger before the reader knows Sonia’s history or the identity of the figure. Her flight also establishes the novel’s central pattern: a vulnerable girl tries to escape danger, while adults and institutions later misread what happened to her. The suitcase matters because it marks Sonia as a person in motion, not simply a runaway. By ending with her scream rather than her fate, the prologue creates an unanswered question that the two timelines will gradually fill in.

Fiona Returns to Old Barrons

A restoration threatens the ground where Deb died

On the twentieth anniversary of her sister Deb’s murder, journalist Fiona Sheridan drives to Old Barrons Road and tests an old question: could someone have left a car there unseen? During half an hour on the shoulder, no traffic passes.

Her police officer boyfriend, Jamie Creel, reminds her that a drive-in still operated nearby in 1994, weakening her theory but not her need to understand how Deb’s body reached Idlewild Hall. At the school gates, Fiona discovers a construction sign.

The property has been sold to a wealthy widow, Margaret Eden, who plans to restore the abandoned girls’ school. The news makes Fiona fear the landscape of Deb’s death will soon be changed beyond recognition, so she pitches a story on Idlewild and asks to research its history.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Fiona’s first act of investigation is not a fresh discovery but a return to a place she has tried to keep mentally contained. Her roadside experiment converts grief into a testable question, giving her a temporary sense of control over an event that has governed her life for twenty years. The construction project makes that private ritual urgent: the physical site is about to be altered, and with it the evidence Fiona has used to organize her loss. Her decision to write shifts her from silent mourner toward public investigator, although she has not yet separated those roles.

Four Girls, One Dormitory

Idlewild’s roommates recognize pain before they know its source

In 1950, Katie Winthrop, CeCe Frank, Roberta Greene, and Sonia Gallipeau share a room at Idlewild, a school where families send girls they do not know how to manage.

Katie masks fear with bravado; Roberta has recently regained speech after witnessing her uncle’s suicide attempt; CeCe is warm and eager to belong; Sonia, a French refugee, keeps most of her past to herself. When Katie finds old textbook notes about Mary Hand, the school’s veiled ghost, the girls trade stories of strange sounds and sightings.

Roberta hears a song associated with her uncle’s trauma, while Sonia freezes during a bloody dining-hall fight. The other three escort her back to their room rather than expose her to punishment, beginning a fragile trust built on practical care.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The girls are not bonded by sameness. Each has been sent away for a different reason, and each has learned a distinct survival strategy: Katie controls the room, Roberta retreats into motion, CeCe offers attachment, and Sonia guards her memories. Their response to Sonia’s episode is consequential because they protect her from the school’s disciplinary machinery without demanding an explanation. The ghost stories provide a shared language for experiences the adults around them would dismiss. Idlewild’s informal culture, carried in marginal notes and whispered accounts, becomes the first place where these girls can recognize one another without requiring disclosure.

A Body Beneath Idlewild

Construction uncovers a girl missing since 1950

Fiona’s first tour of Idlewild shows a building still furnished with desks and textbooks, though water damage and rot have hollowed it out. In a classroom, she finds a fresh message scratched into a dirty window, an unsettling reminder of Deb’s death.

Outside, workers digging up an old well stop and gather in alarm. Fiona follows Anthony Eden to the opening and sees the remains of a small teenage girl, curled in the darkness with her skull broken. Jamie arrives with the coroner and estimates that she died decades ago.

A name tag sewn into the girl’s blouse points to Sonia Gallipeau, a fifteen-year-old Idlewild student reported missing in 1950. Fiona realizes that another girl has lain on these grounds since before Deb was killed, and Jamie agrees to investigate the old disappearance.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The well makes the school’s past materially present: its history is not a set of rumors but a body concealed within the property being prepared for reuse. Fiona’s response is shaped by her own experience of losing Deb to public scrutiny, so she insists that Sonia’s remains be handled with care even as she recognizes their news value. The discovery also alters the investigation’s scale. Fiona came to examine the restoration and revisit her sister’s murder; she now has a second death, a name, and a decades-old failure to explain. The two cases are physically close, but their connection remains an open question.

The Veiled Girl Appears

A ghost leads Fiona toward Margaret Eden

After climbing the new fence to revisit Idlewild, Fiona sees a still figure in a black dress on the field where Deb’s body was found. Deb’s favorite song seems to come from the trees, and old memorial flowers reappear around the figure before vanishing when Anthony interrupts.

He warns Fiona that the presence listens. He also reveals that his mother has agreed to meet her. At Margaret Eden’s townhouse, the widow explains that she intends to restore the school despite her late husband’s objections and Anthony’s doubts.

Margaret knows Fiona saw the veiled woman and names her as Mary Hand, a figure from Idlewild legend. She admits she has searched for Mary’s identity and wants the school’s missing records, leaving Fiona uncertain whether Margaret is pursuing education, history, or something more personal.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The apparition complicates Fiona’s journalistic method by presenting an experience that cannot be verified in the ordinary way, yet is shared by people who have lived or worked near Idlewild. Anthony’s fear and Margaret’s precise recognition make it harder for Fiona to dismiss the sight as exhaustion. Margaret, meanwhile, redirects the interview from the school’s finances to Fiona’s perception, establishing a relationship in which both women withhold information. The scene’s uncertainty is productive: Mary is not yet an explanation but a pressure on the investigation, forcing Fiona to consider that memory, place, and supernatural experience may be entangled.

Sarah London Kept the Files

A retired teacher reveals how Sonia was dismissed

Fiona and Jamie trace a 1952 field-hockey photograph to Sarah London, a retired Idlewild teacher. Sarah remembers Sonia as a quiet girl who had little reason to run away, yet the school and police accepted that explanation after finding Sonia’s suitcase in the woods near the gates.

Sarah also recalls Sonia’s three roommates: Katie, Roberta, and CeCe. Before Fiona can learn more, Sarah’s niece Cathy reveals that Sarah secretly saved the school records when they were headed for a landfill.

Fiona and Jamie collect twenty-one boxes from the shed. Sonia’s file confirms her intelligence, her French background, and her disappearance after a visit to relatives in Burlington. The file records no serious search, only the headmistress’s assumption that Sonia had left with a boy.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The records expose neglect through their very thinness. Sonia’s file contains measurements, grades, and a routine note about fainting, but little curiosity about who she was or what she had survived. The adults’ runaway theory does not arise from evidence so much as from institutional convenience: a missing, foreign girl without nearby family can be categorized and forgotten. Sarah’s decision to save the files quietly reverses that erasure, though her long silence shows how fear and self-preservation can preserve wrongdoing as effectively as they preserve evidence. The archive gives Fiona facts, but its gaps become evidence in their own right.

Sonia Leaves Her Testimony

Her roommates turn wartime memories into a bond

The recovered records and Sarah’s memories lead back to the girls’ room. After fainting in Idlewild’s garden, Sonia tells Roberta that she and her mother were imprisoned at Ravensbrück, where forced digging and roll calls killed prisoners around them.

When CeCe gives Sonia an unused notebook, Sonia begins recording and drawing the camp, her family, and the people she remembers. The other girls listen, share their own painful histories, and sneak food to the malnourished Sonia.

Sonia hopes her visiting great-aunt and great-uncle may take her in, so she packs her few belongings, including the notebook. She leaves for Burlington and returns early by bus, intending to go back to her friends. She never arrives. The girls later learn that the adults have called her a runaway.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Sonia’s writing turns memory from an involuntary assault into an act she can shape, though it does not erase the trauma. The notebook is both personal testimony and the material record that official institutions failed to create. Her friends’ response matters as much as the writing: they feed her and listen without forcing disclosure, offering a model of care absent from the school’s files. Her departure is not a rejection of them. She is trying to find a home beyond Idlewild while carrying the objects that connect her to it. The false runaway story will later erase precisely this distinction between flight and return.

The Ice Cream Alibi Shifts

A former employee contradicts the murder timeline

While reading Lively Vermont’s 1994 coverage of Deb’s murder, Fiona finds an overlooked account placing Deb’s boyfriend, Tim Christopher, at Pop’s Ice Cream on the night she died. She contacts Mike Rush, whose father owned the shop.

Mike remembers Tim arriving at four in the afternoon, not nine at night, and says his father changed the time after speaking with then-chief Garrett Creel. The supposed evening alibi was never presented at trial. At dinner with Jamie’s parents, Fiona challenges Garrett about the missing testimony and his defense of Tim.

Garrett needles her about the conviction, while Jamie urges her to stop accusing his father. Fiona leaves furious and the couple separates for the moment. She now suspects that the original investigation may have been compromised, not merely incomplete.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The discrepancy destabilizes Fiona’s settled understanding of Deb’s case without yet disproving Tim’s guilt. The altered time does not exonerate him; it shows that evidence was manipulated and that the conviction rested within a system willing to protect powerful local interests. Fiona’s confrontation turns a professional question into a family conflict, since Garrett is both a witness from the old case and Jamie’s father. Jamie’s instinct to defend his father and Fiona’s insistence on scrutiny reveal how loyalty can mimic certainty. Their separation is not simply romantic friction; it marks the cost of investigating institutions that shape people’s closest relationships.

Roberta Remembers Sonia

A cryptic note leads Fiona to Helen Heyer

Fiona meets Roberta Montgomery, formerly Roberta Greene, who confirms that Sonia would never have abandoned her suitcase or her friends. Roberta believes Mary Hand still haunts Idlewild, appearing to expose what people most fear.

She is genuinely grieved by Sonia’s death but gives Fiona little about the girls’ later lives, leaving Fiona suspicious of what she has withheld. A note on Fiona’s car directs her to Stephen Heyer, an addict whose sister Helen was nearly beaten to death in 1993. Stephen says Tim was Helen’s secret boyfriend.

When Fiona raises the assault with Jamie, he initially rejects the claim and the couple’s argument sharpens. Jamie checks the old file and finds that police questioned Helen’s friends but not Tim’s, despite Garrett’s role in the case. He admits the omission and returns to Fiona, resolved to pursue it.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Roberta’s measured silence teaches Fiona that a truthful witness can still be selective, and that grief does not automatically make memory transparent. Stephen supplies a second case in which Tim may have harmed a young woman before Deb, but his addiction gives Jamie a reason to question the account. Jamie’s subsequent file review changes the dispute: he cannot prove Stephen’s claim, yet he finds a procedural failure tied to his own father. His return to Fiona marks a shift from inherited loyalty toward professional and moral independence. Their reconciliation begins not with certainty about Tim, but with Jamie accepting that the unanswered question deserves investigation.

The Guard in Burlington

Sonia may have recognized a former Ravensbrück guard

Fiona follows the wartime records and finds Rose Albert, a Burlington resident once accused of being Ravensbrück guard Rosa Berlitz. Rose was acquitted in 1973 after survivors identified her, but the evidence was judged insufficient.

Fiona maps Sonia’s last movements and realizes the two could have crossed paths at the travel agency where Rose worked. Sonia had changed her bus ticket there before boarding the bus back toward Idlewild. Fiona suspects Rose recognized her former prisoner and followed her to the isolated roadside, where Sonia was killed.

Before taking that theory further, Fiona meets Roberta at Idlewild’s old drive-in. Its owner, Lionel Charters, confirms that Garrett Creel arrived the night Deb died and drove away in a police cruiser with Tim inside. Garrett has been watching Fiona and soon arrives to take her away.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Fiona’s theory emerges from a chain of ordinary records: a job address, a changed bus ticket, and the timing of Sonia’s journey. The horror is not that the killer was invisible, but that the institutions around Sonia had failed to preserve or connect the evidence. Lionel’s account then links the old cold case to Fiona’s present danger and gives her first-hand testimony against Garrett. His willingness to speak after decades of silence suggests that the passage of time has not neutralized complicity; it has only made the witness harder to reach. Fiona’s investigation now has a plausible answer for Sonia and a direct threat from the person who helped conceal Deb’s murder.

Garrett Admits the Cover-Up

He confesses before Fiona jumps from his car

Garrett drives Fiona away from Lionel’s property and demands to know what she learned. When she names the police cruiser, he admits that Tim killed Deb and that he moved her body into the cruiser, distracted the teenagers at the drive-in, and later helped erase evidence.

He had also pressured Richard Rush to alter Tim’s ice-cream timeline and frightened witnesses into silence. Garrett says he could not stop Tim’s earlier attack on Helen because no one had seen them together.

He blames the Christophers for abandoning him after Tim’s conviction, then decides Fiona threatens his remaining power and Jamie’s career. When Garrett refuses to let her out, Fiona opens the moving car door and jumps onto the rough road. She lands hard, gets up, and runs toward Idlewild.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Garrett’s confession recasts the original conviction without reversing its central fact: Tim did kill Deb, while the police chief helped hide the circumstances and distort the evidence. The corruption operates through favors, threats, and selective attention rather than a single elaborate conspiracy. Garrett’s language of obligation reveals how he has made self-interest sound like civic duty and family loyalty. His attack on Fiona is the final extension of that logic: he treats a witness as a problem to remove. Fiona’s jump is a decisive refusal to remain inside his version of events, even though escape leaves her injured and exposed.

Fiona Runs Through Idlewild

Sonia guides her toward shelter as Jamie closes in

Injured and pursued, Fiona crosses the school grounds while Garrett follows in his car. Inside the main hall, she sees a girl in an Idlewild uniform and recognizes her as Sonia. Sonia leads Fiona through the building toward the old dorm, while Mary Hand appears again behind them.

Gunshots sound outside as Jamie and other officers confront Garrett. In the former room shared by Sonia, Katie, Roberta, and CeCe, Fiona loses consciousness and sees Deb sitting by the window, still carrying the fear of her last night.

Mary enters, and Fiona cannot tell whether the visions are supernatural or fevered memory. Jamie and the officers reach her before Garrett can. Jamie has been grazed in the hand; Fiona is hospitalized with flu, hypothermia, and bruising around her throat. Garrett is arrested.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The school becomes both danger and refuge. Fiona’s visions do not provide conventional evidence, but Sonia’s appearance gives her a path through a building whose history she has been trying to understand. Deb’s brief presence also changes Fiona’s relationship to the memory of her sister: the image is no longer only the body on the field or the trial record, but a frightened person whose experience Fiona could not access at the time. The physical rescue depends on Jamie and the officers, while the emotional movement depends on Fiona remaining conscious long enough to seek help. The novel leaves the visions unresolved, preserving their force without making them a simple investigative tool.

The Roommates Name the Killer

Katie reveals why she bought Idlewild Hall

At the hospital, Margaret arrives with Roberta and CeCe, and Fiona recognizes her as Katie Winthrop, Sonia’s former roommate. Katie explains that she married her half-brother Joseph Eden, took the name Margaret, and eventually bought Idlewild to search for Sonia’s body.

The three friends had kept Sonia’s suitcase and diary. In 1973, CeCe recognized Rose Albert from Sonia’s drawing; the women confronted Rose, who admitted killing Sonia with a piece of fence after recognizing her at the travel agency.

Rose suffered a genuine heart attack before revealing where she hid the body. Katie, Roberta, and CeCe did not kill her. With Sonia’s remains now recovered, Katie intends to give her a proper burial and dismantle Idlewild rather than reopen it as a school.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The identity revelation makes the restoration a long private search disguised as philanthropy. Katie’s chosen name allowed her to build a life beyond the shame and confinement of Idlewild, but it also separated her public self from the girl who lost Sonia. The friends’ account complicates easy ideas of justice: they found the murderer, but their confrontation ended without a confession to authorities or recovery of the body. Their silence protected the only history they possessed while leaving Sonia literally unburied. The diary’s drawing succeeds where official identification failed, showing how intimate testimony can outlast both a destroyed archive and a failed trial.

The Cases Return to Public View

Fiona and Jamie choose investigation over inherited loyalty

After Fiona recovers, Katie arranges a proper burial for Sonia and offers to lend Sonia’s diary to a Ravensbrück historian. Fiona writes about the discovery and the failed search, while her father, Malcolm, returns to journalism after years of withdrawal.

He helps publicize the evidence that Garrett protected Tim and compromised the investigations of both Deb’s murder and Helen’s assault. State investigators open an internal inquiry into Garrett and other officers. Jamie cooperates, accepts that he may no longer serve on the force, and meets Fiona again after his father’s arrest.

They agree to try coffee rather than pretend their differences have disappeared. Fiona plans to report on cold cases with Jamie’s investigative knowledge, and Katie turns from rebuilding Idlewild to removing the institution from the ground.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The resolution does not promise that exposure can repair every loss. Sonia’s burial restores a name and a place in the community; public reporting gives scrutiny to crimes and institutional choices that were once kept local and quiet. Malcolm’s renewed work and Jamie’s cooperation show two different responses to inherited silence: one uses public networks, the other breaks with a professional culture that rewarded deference. Fiona’s new direction does not erase her grief or guarantee a future with Jamie. It does give her a way to act that is not limited to revisiting Deb’s death, extending the book’s demand for accountability to people whose families never had the power to insist.

Epilogue

In December, Katie brings Fiona, Roberta, and CeCe to the garden at Idlewild, where workers search for Mary Hand’s grave. They uncover a small, homemade coffin beneath the soil. As the crew opens it, Fiona sees Mary at the edge of the trees, holding a swaddled baby.

Katie and Roberta recognize the figure too. Mary watches the women who have spent years carrying other girls’ stories, then disappears into the trees. The school’s final hidden burial is no longer hidden, and Katie plans to bury Mary and her child beside Sonia.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The last discovery makes the garden’s old rumor both true and incomplete: Mary’s baby was buried there, but Mary herself was buried with the child. Her appearance at the excavation is witnessed by several women, so the haunting cannot be reduced to Fiona’s fever or grief. Yet the apparition does not explain itself or offer a tidy supernatural justice. The living must still arrange the burial and decide what to do with the land. The ending’s small act of recovery mirrors the search for Sonia: names and bodies matter because someone chooses not to leave them beneath the ground.

Analysis

The novel builds its mystery from a repeated social error: vulnerable girls are treated as unreliable, troublesome, or disposable before anyone asks what happened to them. Sonia is labeled a runaway despite the suitcase left near Idlewild; Roberta is treated as damaged after witnessing her uncle’s suicide attempt; CeCe is reduced to her illegitimacy; and Fiona’s grief is dismissed as an obsession. In each case, the label replaces inquiry. The book’s most consequential evidence therefore comes from forms of attention that official systems overlook: marginal notes, a saved school archive, a witness’s memory, and Sonia’s drawings.

Idlewild is both an institution and a landscape of accumulated testimony. The girls inhabit a school that claims to educate them while preparing them for narrow roles, yet they create their own education through listening, shared food, and books. Their friendship is not sentimental rescue. It is a practiced response to neglect, giving each girl a witness when adults will not provide one. Sonia’s notebook embodies this alternative record keeping: her private memories eventually identify the person who killed her, after legal and police processes fail.

The parallel investigations also distinguish guilt from institutional complicity. Tim is responsible for Deb’s murder, but Garrett’s intervention bends evidence and protects him from accountability for Helen’s assault. The conviction does not undo that corruption. The book resists the comforting idea that one successful prosecution proves a system worked; it asks what the system ignored before the conviction and who paid for that ignorance.

Fiona’s work becomes a form of mourning that produces action rather than closure. She cannot recover Deb or undo Sonia’s abandonment, but she can restore names, expose official failures, and create a public record. The supernatural thread sharpens rather than replaces this argument: Mary makes hidden fear visible, while the living must still decide what to do with what they see. Memory becomes useful only when someone accepts responsibility for it.

Summary in 60 Seconds
On the twentieth anniversary of her sister Deb's murder, journalist Fiona Sheridan returns to Old Barrons and discovers that construction at the abandoned Idlewild school has unearthed Sonia Gallipeau, a student missing since 1950. Investigating Sonia's disappearance alongside Deb's case, Fiona learns Sonia was a French survivor of Ravensbrück, and that a former guard, Rose Albert, killed her after recognizing her. Sonia's old roommates had uncovered the truth decades earlier but kept it quiet after Rose died of a heart attack. Fiona also finds evidence that Tim Christopher killed Deb and that police chief Garrett Creel moved the body and suppressed evidence to protect him. Garrett abducts Fiona, but she escapes and he is arrested. Her reporting prompts an inquiry, while Sonia receives a proper burial. Workers later uncover Mary Hand's grave and her baby's coffin at Idlewild.
Contains spoilers

Last updated:

Report Issue

Review Summary

4.05 out of 5
Average of 100k+ ratings from Goodreads and Amazon.

The Broken Girls is a gripping gothic mystery with dual timelines set in 1950 and 2014. Readers praised the atmospheric setting of Idlewild Hall, a boarding school for troubled girls, and the haunting ghost story element. Many found the 1950s timeline more engaging, following four roommates with dark pasts. The present-day storyline focuses on journalist Fiona investigating her sister's murder. While some felt the ending was muddled, most readers enjoyed the suspenseful plot, well-developed characters, and skillful blend of supernatural and mystery elements.

Your rating:
4.51
104 ratings
Want to read the full book?

Characters

Fiona Sheridan

The relentless local journalist

Fiona is a thirty-seven-year-old freelance journalist and the younger sister of Deb Sheridan. For two decades she has carried unanswered questions about Deb’s murder, disguising her grief as a private habit of revisiting Idlewild and studying the old case. Her work has settled into safer lifestyle assignments, but the discovery of another dead girl draws her toward the investigative reporting she has avoided. Fiona is observant, stubborn, and willing to challenge authority, though personal grief can make her impulsive and suspicious. Her relationships with Jamie and her father are shaped by shared knowledge of the past, even when their loyalties and methods differ. She is driven by the conviction that a forgotten person still deserves someone to ask what happened.

Jamie Creel

The conflicted small-town cop

Jamie is a young Barrons police officer, the son of a retired chief and the grandson of another. His local roots give him an intimate knowledge of the town, while his profession makes him cautious about evidence and procedure. He and Fiona have been dating for about a year, drawn to each other partly because neither has to explain the history of Deb’s case. Jamie values loyalty and order, but he is not blind to the possibility that those values can be used to excuse misconduct. His restraint can steady Fiona, though it can also look like defensiveness when the investigation touches his family. He wants to serve his community without becoming a copy of the authority figures who shaped him.

Sonia Gallipeau

The silenced French refugee

Sonia is a quiet French teenager at Idlewild Hall, where she lives with Katie, Roberta, and CeCe. She has survived wartime imprisonment and the loss of her family, but the other girls initially know only her reserve and her difficulty adjusting to life in America. Books and drawing offer her ways to order memories she cannot easily speak aloud. She is intelligent, observant, and physically slight after years of deprivation, though her strength is evident in her survival. Sonia longs for safety and belonging more than adventure or rebellion. Her relationship with her roommates gradually gives her a place where she can share parts of her past without being treated as a problem to manage.

Katie Winthrop

The defiant Idlewild strategist

Katie is a beautiful, forceful teenager who has learned to use confidence as armor. At Idlewild she watches social dynamics closely, challenges adults, and protects the few girls she trusts. Her boldness is not simple fearlessness: it grows from a home life in which adults failed to protect her, leaving her determined to control her own future. Katie can be cruel when frightened and generous when she chooses to be, with a sharp instinct for turning limited opportunities into leverage. Her friendship with Sonia and the other roommates lets her practice loyalty without giving up her independence. She is driven by a fierce refusal to let other people decide what becomes of her.

Roberta Greene

The quiet, resilient athlete

Roberta is a gifted field-hockey player whose silence began after she witnessed her uncle’s suicide attempt. At Idlewild she gradually finds that movement and the company of her roommates help her feel present again. She appears composed, but her reserve protects a deep capacity for empathy and a close attention to other people’s distress. Roberta is especially attuned to Sonia, perhaps because both girls carry experiences that adults around them do not know how to address. Her loyalty is practical rather than showy: she stays beside a friend, listens, and takes action when others hesitate. She is motivated by a desire to make life more humane for people whom families and institutions have treated as burdens.

CeCe Frank

The tender-hearted roommate

CeCe is a warm, sociable girl sent to Idlewild because she was born outside her wealthy father’s marriage. She is often underestimated because of her softness and eagerness to please, but she is perceptive about the people she loves and capable of courage when they need her. Her longing for family makes her receptive to kindness, even when that kindness comes with painful truths about her childhood. CeCe’s generosity helps create the closeness among the four roommates, and her small radio gives them access to music and stories beyond the school. She wants affection and a future that does not require her to be ashamed of her origins.

Deb Sheridan

Fiona’s vivid older sister

Deb is Fiona’s older sister, a lively young woman who wanted friends, romance, and a life that felt less provincial than the one her intellectual parents offered. Her relationship with Fiona gave her younger sister a model for how to move through the world. Deb’s murder in 1994 reshapes the Sheridan family and becomes the unanswered event around which Fiona organizes much of her adult life. She is remembered not only as a victim but as a person with music, humor, and a desire to belong.

Malcolm Sheridan

The journalist who withdrew

Malcolm is Fiona’s father, a celebrated journalist and photographer whose public life once carried him from war reporting to activism. After Deb’s murder, he withdrew from the work and relationships that had animated him, leaving Fiona to carry many questions alone. He remains intellectually energetic beneath his isolation, with a gift for connecting people, archives, and forgotten histories. His bond with Fiona is affectionate but complicated by his absence during her youth and by the grief they share. He is driven by a belief that careful inquiry can restore attention to people whom powerful institutions would prefer to forget.

Margaret Eden

Idlewild’s guarded benefactor

Margaret is a wealthy widow who buys the abandoned Idlewild property and insists on restoring it as a girls’ school. Her son Anthony questions the project’s cost, but Margaret is not deterred by financial objections or local unease. She is private, perceptive, and unusually interested in the school’s past, especially its stories of a veiled figure. Margaret’s manner makes it difficult to tell whether she is acting from idealism, personal history, or a purpose she has not disclosed. She is driven by a determination to pursue the project on her own terms.

Anthony Eden

The uneasy project manager

Anthony is Margaret Eden’s son and the practical manager of Idlewild’s restoration. He arranges Fiona’s tour, oversees security and construction, and worries that the discovery of a body will destroy the project. His formal manner conceals discomfort with the building and with his mother’s plans. Anthony is not simply an obstacle to Fiona; he provides access, relays information, and recognizes that something unsettling may be happening on the grounds. He is motivated by responsibility to his mother, concern about the family’s resources, and a desire to keep a difficult project under control.

Garrett Creel

The formidable retired chief

Garrett is Jamie’s father and a long-serving former police chief in Barrons. Broad, confident, and accustomed to being listened to, he represents a local authority that has operated through personal ties as much as formal procedure. His relationship with Jamie carries both affection and pressure: he wants his son to value the same loyalties and instincts he does. Garrett sees himself as practical and protective of the town, but his certainty about who deserves protection makes him difficult to challenge. His character is driven by power, reputation, and a strong belief that family and civic order require loyalty.

Mary Hand

Idlewild’s veiled presence

Mary Hand is the figure in Idlewild’s ghost stories, said to wear a dark dress and veil and to call girls outside. Students pass accounts of her through textbook margins and whispered warnings. She is associated with the school’s neglected garden and with moments when a girl’s private fear becomes difficult to ignore. Whether treated as a haunting or as something the living cannot explain, Mary unsettles the boundary between memory and place. Her presence is feared, but the reason she appears to different people remains uncertain.

Stephen Heyer

The haunted brother

Stephen is Helen Heyer’s brother, a man struggling with addiction and a long fixation on the attack that changed his sister’s life. He approaches Fiona because he believes she is still searching for answers about Tim Christopher. His manner is erratic, but he is capable of clear, painful observation about how grief can trap a person in repeated thoughts. Stephen is motivated by a wish to make someone answer for Helen’s suffering, and by the hope that Fiona will take the case seriously when others have stopped looking.

Lionel Charters

The drive-in’s watchful owner

Lionel owns the former drive-in beside Old Barrons Road and has spent much of his life apart from Barrons’ respectable civic circles. After his son died, he began letting people in recovery use a trailer on his property. He is wary of the police and protective of his land, but he has a strong memory for what he has witnessed. Lionel is not eager to become involved in Fiona’s investigation, yet his sense of fairness eventually outweighs his fear of powerful local figures.

Sarah London

Idlewild’s long-serving teacher

Sarah London taught at Idlewild for nearly three decades, beginning as a young teacher known to the girls as Lady Loon. In old age she retains a strong memory and an instinctive unease about the school. She can recall the students’ habits and friendships, but her years at Idlewild taught her caution around truths that might make life harder. Sarah is practical, proud of her work, and shaped by the limited choices available to women of her generation.

Rose Albert

The Burlington recluse

Rose Albert is a former Burlington travel-agency clerk whose wartime past became the subject of a local trial. She built a quiet life in America and resisted claims that she had worked at a Nazi camp. Her guarded public manner reflects the precariousness of a life built around an identity no one could fully verify.

Joseph Eden

CeCe’s attentive half-brother

Joseph is CeCe’s half-brother and the favored son of their wealthy father. He visits CeCe at Idlewild and tries to offer her the familial attention she has rarely received. His kindness and financial privilege give him opportunities the girls at school lack, though he is not always aware of how painful their circumstances are.

Plot Devices

Idlewild Hall

The ground that remembers

The abandoned Vermont boarding school joins the book’s timelines and concentrates its mysteries. Its classrooms preserve old furniture and marginal notes; its field holds the site of Deb’s murder; its well conceals Sonia; and its garden hides an older burial. The proposed restoration forces Fiona to investigate before the buildings and landscape are altered. Idlewild functions not merely as a spooky setting but as an archive that has been physically neglected, where successive generations of girls leave traces the adults fail to interpret.

Mary Hand

Fear made visible

The veiled figure appears across decades, and girls pass warnings about her through stories and textbook margins. Her manifestations are linked to the fears and memories of those who encounter her, making the haunting both an external threat and a form of psychological exposure. Mary’s history as a girl who died on the property and her appearance at the final excavation connect the school’s ghost lore to a real buried past. The novel leaves room for supernatural belief while showing how trauma shapes what each character sees.

The Idlewild Records

A neglected paper trail

Old student files, staff records, maps, and handwritten textbook notes provide the investigation with clues that were absent from the official police files. Saved by Sarah London rather than destroyed, the archive restores Sonia’s name, confirms friendships, and reveals the school’s earlier landscape. Its incomplete and bureaucratic entries also show how institutions reduce vulnerable girls to categories such as runaway or problem student. The records make private memory usable as evidence, while their omissions force Fiona to seek living witnesses.

Sonia’s Notebook

Memory preserved by drawing

Sonia uses a notebook given to her by CeCe to write about Ravensbrück and draw the people she remembers. Her roommates keep the notebook with Sonia’s suitcase after she disappears. Decades later, a portrait helps them recognize a woman associated with the camp, giving the friends a lead that official records and a failed trial could not provide. The notebook is personal testimony, a record of a life beyond the school’s sparse file, and a physical bond between Sonia and the three girls who refuse to forget her.

The Two Cold Cases

One town, linked failures

Sonia’s disappearance and Deb’s murder initially seem separate, divided by decades. Fiona’s investigation brings them together through Idlewild, the failures of local police, and the people who were dismissed or silenced. A third case, Helen Heyer’s assault, reveals that the handling of Tim Christopher had earlier warning signs. The linked cases turn the mystery from a search for one killer into an examination of how status, family loyalty, and assumptions about girls shaped what authorities chose to investigate.

About the Author

Simone St. James is a bestselling author known for her gothic mystery novels. Her works include The Book of Cold Cases, The Sun Down Motel, and The Broken Girls. St. James has received multiple awards for her writing, including two RITA awards and an Arthur Ellis Award. She began writing ghost stories in high school and spent two decades working in television before becoming a full-time author. Her debut novel, The Haunting of Maddy Clare, garnered critical acclaim. St. James resides near Toronto, Canada, with her husband and cat. Her books often feature supernatural elements and explore themes of past secrets and haunted locations.

Download PDF

To save this The Broken Girls summary for later, download the free PDF. You can print it out, or read offline at your convenience.
Download PDF
File size: 0.37 MB     Pages: 25

Download EPUB

To read this The Broken Girls summary on your e-reader device or app, download the free EPUB. The .epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.
Download EPUB
File size: 1.42 MB     Pages: 35
Want to read the full book?
Follow
Listen1 mins
Home
Swipe
Library
Get App
Try Full Access for 3 Days
Listen, bookmark, and more
Compare Features Free Pro
📖 Read Summaries
Read unlimited summaries. Free users get 3 per month
🎧 Listen to Summaries
Listen to unlimited summaries in 40 languages
—
❤️ Unlimited Bookmarks
Free users are limited to 4
—
📜 Unlimited History
Free users are limited to 4
—
📥 Unlimited Downloads
Free users are limited to 1
—
Risk-Free Timeline
Today: Get Instant Access
Listen to full summaries of 26,000+ books. That's 12,000+ hours of audio!
Day 2: Trial Reminder
We'll send you a notification that your trial is ending soon.
Day 3: Your subscription begins
You'll be charged on Nov 25,
cancel anytime before.
Consume 2.8× More Books
2.8× more books Listening Reading
Our users love us
1M+ readers
Trustpilot Rating
TrustPilot
4.6 Excellent
This site is a total game-changer. I've been flying through book summaries like never before. Highly, highly recommend.
— Dave G
Worth my money and time, and really well made. I've never seen this quality of summaries on other websites. Very helpful!
— Em
Highly recommended!! Fantastic service. Perfect for those that want a little more than a teaser but not all the intricate details of a full audio book.
— Greg M
Save 62%
Yearly
$119.88 $44.99/year/yr
$3.75/mo
Monthly
$9.99/mo
Start a 3-Day Free Trial
3 days free, then $44.99/year. Cancel anytime.
Unlock a world of fiction & nonfiction books
26,000+ books for the price of 2 books
Read any book in 10 minutes
Discover new books like Tinder
Request any book if it's not summarized
Read more books than anyone you know
#1 app for book lovers
Lifelike & immersive summaries
30-day money-back guarantee
Download summaries in EPUBs or PDFs
Cancel anytime in a few clicks

Why one summary?

Scanner
Find a barcode to scan

⭐
⭐
⭐
We have a special gift for you
Open
38% off
DISCOUNT FOR YOU
⭐
⭐
⭐
$79.99
$49.99/year
Only $4.16 per month
Continue
2 taps to start, super easy to cancel
Settings
General
Widget
Loading...