Start free trial
Trending New Genres Authors
EnglishEnglish
EspañolSpanish
简体中文Chinese
繁體中文Chinese (Traditional)
FrançaisFrench
DeutschGerman
日本語Japanese
PortuguêsPortuguese
ItalianoItalian
한국어Korean
РусскийRussian
NederlandsDutch
العربيةArabic
PolskiPolish
हिन्दीHindi
Tiếng ViệtVietnamese
SvenskaSwedish
ΕλληνικάGreek
TürkçeTurkish
ไทยThai
ČeštinaCzech
RomânăRomanian
MagyarHungarian
УкраїнськаUkrainian
IndonesiaIndonesian
DanskDanish
SuomiFinnish
БългарскиBulgarian
עבריתHebrew
NorskNorwegian
HrvatskiCroatian
CatalàCatalan
SlovenčinaSlovak
LietuviųLithuanian
SlovenščinaSlovenian
СрпскиSerbian
EestiEstonian
LatviešuLatvian
فارسیPersian
മലയാളംMalayalam
தமிழ்Tamil
اردوUrdu
Searching...
SoBrief
What Have You Done?

What Have You Done?

A Vermont teenager's murder fractures her small town as friends and teachers become suspects.
by Shari Lapena 2024 384 pages
3.75
100k+ ratings
Listen
Immersive
V2.3
Amazon Kindle Audible
Try Full Access for 3 Days
Unlock listening & more!
Continue

Plot Summary

Vultures Over Fairhill

A farmer finds Diana Brewer stripped in a field

Roy Ressler is driving his tractor across his Vermont farm when vultures draw him toward a patch of flattened grass. Beneath them lies Diana Brewer, a seventeen-year-old student, naked and mutilated. Roy keeps the birds away until Fairhill’s police chief, Mike Hall, and Officer Chris Shepherd arrive. They find a ligature bruise around her throat, but no clothes, weapon, or visible tracks.

At school, Diana’s friends wait for her, unaware she is dead. Riley Mead grows alarmed when Diana stops answering messages, then recognizes that police have come for her teacher. The narrative also slips into Diana’s disembodied point of view: she sees the body in the field and cannot yet understand how she is looking at herself.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The discovery turns Fairhill’s reputation for safety into evidence of its vulnerability. The body is not merely found in a field; it has been carried into a private landscape where ordinary routines, like Roy’s work, continue around violence. Diana’s detached, ghostlike awareness introduces a second uncertainty alongside the police mystery: the dead girl herself cannot yet assemble the facts. Her apparent distance is not supernatural omniscience, but the shape trauma takes when memory has been broken apart.

The First Alibis Fray

Cameron’s account leaves his mother quietly alarmed

State detectives question Diana’s boyfriend, Cameron Farrell, after finding him at home. He says he drove her around, had sex with her, and left her at her house around eleven. His parents arrive at the station to support him, while Diana’s mother, Brenda, learns that her daughter has been murdered. Brenda tells investigators Diana once felt uneasy about a customer at the Home Depot where she worked.

She also confirms the clothes Cameron described are missing, although Diana’s jacket and shoes remain inside the house; her phone is gone too. Cameron’s mother, Shelby, remembers that her son did not actually come home until 1:11 a.m. She keeps this from the detectives, unsure whether he stayed out past curfew or concealed something worse.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The early investigation is built from partial truths rather than clean evidence. Cameron’s lie is small enough to seem explainable, yet it makes his parents complicit in maintaining uncertainty. Brenda’s ordinary precautions, including asking staff to walk Diana to her car, reveal the limits of protective routines: they can reduce risk without making a young woman safe. The missing phone and clothing turn absence into evidence, while the family’s silence shows how quickly love can become a reason to obstruct knowledge.

Friends Keep One Secret

Riley exposes Diana’s planned break from Cameron

Riley and Evan Carr, two of Diana’s closest friends, initially tell police that she and Cameron seemed happy. Alone together, they admit they concealed the relationship’s strain. Diana had told Riley she did not want to follow Cameron to college and was considering ending the relationship; Riley urged her not to postpone the conversation.

Riley then tells Detective Stone, feeling guilty that her advice may have preceded the fatal argument. Evan admits he noticed Cameron’s possessiveness but had hidden that too.

At Home Depot, manager Aaron Bolduc helps detectives review security footage of a red-haired customer who repeatedly waited at Diana’s checkout, despite other registers being open. The footage gives police a face for the man, Joe Prior, but no vehicle or proof that he left the store with her.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The friends’ omissions grow from ordinary loyalties: Riley does not want to betray Cameron, and Evan does not want to accuse someone he has known since childhood. Their silence protects their social world until Diana’s death makes that protection morally costly. Riley’s guilt also exposes a common distortion in grief: she treats advice as possible causation, though Cameron and the killer make their own choices. The surveillance footage shifts the investigation from intimate relationships toward a stranger, inviting the town to mistake a visible pattern of harassment for proof of murder.

The Teacher’s Hidden Complaint

Paula forces the principal to disclose Diana’s warning

Paula Acosta, Diana’s English teacher, knows that Diana previously complained to Principal Graham Kelly about gym teacher Brad Turner. Kelly had treated the matter as a misunderstanding and kept it out of the official record.

Paula presses him to tell the detectives, arguing that Diana’s death changes the stakes. Kelly reluctantly agrees, while Brad prepares a mild account of unwanted touches and looks that he claims Diana misread. Investigators question him but have no reason yet to connect him to the killing.

At home, Paula’s attention turns to her thirteen-year-old daughter, Taylor, who seems isolated and withdrawn. She urges Taylor to stay close until the killer is caught, not knowing that her daughter has her own reasons to fear what happens at school.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Kelly’s choice to keep Diana’s complaint informal is an institutional failure disguised as discretion. By treating a student’s request for privacy as permission to avoid documentation, he leaves her without a reliable record or protection. Paula’s insistence marks a shift from reputation management toward safeguarding, though she still lacks the full facts. Taylor’s withdrawal quietly complicates the town’s adult confidence: children may be living with harms that their parents and school leaders cannot see, or have chosen not to see.

Cameron Returns After Midnight

A neighbor’s truck sighting exposes his omission

Cameron eventually tells his father, Edward, that he returned to Diana’s house after their argument. He says he sat in his truck, knocked, went around to the backyard, and tried to get her attention, then drove away. He insists he never entered. A neighbor’s report of a pickup outside the Brewer home after midnight confirms that he lied about leaving for the night.

When detectives confront him, Cameron first denies the argument, then admits he went back, but refuses to say more without his lawyer. His parents are divided between protecting their son and fearing what he may have done. Police search his home and truck, but find no trace of Diana’s phone or other decisive evidence.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Cameron’s account becomes more incriminating each time he revises it, even though the revision does not establish that he killed Diana. His father’s private knowledge turns parental support into active interference when Edward helps him preserve the original lie. The episode captures how suspicion feeds on concealment: a person may hide a humiliating argument, but once that concealment concerns a murder, it takes on a darker meaning. The empty search does not resolve the case; it leaves Cameron both emotionally exposed and evidentially uncertain.

A Message From Diana’s Phone

The killer answers Riley after she writes

Riley and Evan build a simple white cross beside the field where Diana was found, and Brenda accepts their help as grief makes everyday tasks impossible. They learn that Diana’s jump rope is missing from the house, suggesting the murder may have happened there before her body was moved. Late Sunday, Riley sends Diana another message.

Someone replies from Diana’s missing phone, warning Riley that she will not find the killer. Detective Stone confirms that police do not have the device and treats the response as evidence that the murderer kept it. He arranges a patrol near Riley’s home and asks the family to keep quiet. The taunt changes the investigation from a search for clues into an immediate threat against one of Diana’s friends.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The phone makes intimacy dangerous: a private channel between friends becomes a tool for the killer to reach into Riley’s mourning. The message is not a confession, but an act of control that converts grief into fear. The cross offers a countergesture, an effort to give Diana a public place in a field where the murderer tried to erase her identity. Against that deliberate memorial, the anonymous text asserts possession. Riley and Evan are no longer only witnesses; their closeness to Diana makes them vulnerable.

Joe Crosses the Border

Riley and Evan follow the unsettling customer north

Riley obtains Joe Prior’s address by posing as a reporter, then persuades Evan to watch his apartment. When Prior drives away carrying a canvas bag, they follow him for more than an hour, stopping at the Canadian border when he crosses into Quebec. Riley believes his flight proves he killed Diana, but the detectives have only a lead, not a conviction.

Their investigation later finds that Prior’s alibi was false: he asked his friend and coworker Roddy Donnelly to claim they spent the night together. That lie draws attention to an older case. Police discover that Prior had been questioned about missing teenager Katie Cantor, whose body has now been found in New York. Prior is arrested for Katie’s murder, a separate crime, not Diana’s.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Riley and Evan’s pursuit of Prior shows grief trying to become action. Their amateur surveillance gives them a sense of agency, but their conclusion outruns the evidence. Prior’s real guilt, revealed through the older case, confirms that his behavior was dangerous while separating that danger from Diana’s murder. The distinction matters: a suspicious person can be guilty of one crime and innocent of another. By letting the town’s fear settle on Prior, the story demonstrates how easily a plausible suspect can temporarily satisfy the need for certainty.

Turner’s Other Victims

A second student and Taylor deepen the case

As reporters expose Diana’s complaint, another student, Zoe Simpson, tells police that Turner entered the girls’ changing room while she was undressed and lingered after claiming he thought it was empty. Turner denies it, and the school suspends him.

His fiancée, Ellen Ressler, reads Kelly’s incomplete notes and tries to believe that the accusations are exaggerations. Paula eventually asks Taylor directly about Turner. Taylor admits he stared at her chest when they were alone, and that Sadie Kelly, the principal’s daughter, has bullied her at school and online.

Meanwhile, Turner has no alibi for the night Diana died and pressures Kelly to keep the fuller complaint hidden by threatening to reveal Kelly’s affair. Kelly’s fear of scandal delays the truth again.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The allegations against Turner widen the story from one girl’s account to a pattern of adult misconduct and institutional neglect. Each student has faced a different barrier to speaking: embarrassment, fear of disbelief, or the threat of social retaliation. Kelly’s affair gives Turner leverage, but the deeper mechanism is Kelly’s wish to protect his career and family from scrutiny. Ellen’s uncertainty shows how charisma and romantic attachment can distort judgment, while Taylor’s disclosure forces Paula to recognize that her daughter’s silence was not evidence of safety.

Simon in Macklin Cemetery

Riley finds the boy from their homemade séance

Months earlier, Diana, Riley, and Sadie had used paper letters and an overturned wineglass to contact a spirit who called himself Simon, a boy who died at twelve. Evan dismissed the séance as a prank, but Riley remembers the glass moving and the spirit identifying Fairhill as home.

On the morning of Diana’s funeral, Riley searches an abandoned cemetery outside town and finds a grave for Simon Foster, born in 1861 and dead in 1873. The matching dates deepen her belief that Diana may still be present, unable to rest until her killer is known. Evan remains skeptical, and Sadie refuses to revisit the séance. Riley carries the discovery alone, just as she prepares to face Diana’s burial.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The séance offers Riley a vocabulary for grief when ordinary explanation seems emotionally insufficient. Simon’s matching grave does not prove that Diana can communicate, but it unsettles the boundary between coincidence and belief for her. The discovery is psychologically consequential because it makes the dead seem reachable, not safely past. Evan’s skepticism protects him from supernatural fear but also leaves Riley isolated in an experience she considers real. The cemetery’s historical evidence gives the ghost story material weight without resolving its truth.

A Funeral Reopens Memory

Diana recalls Turner entering her home

Fairhill gathers at the United Church to bury Diana. Cameron attends with his parents, while Riley struggles through the graveside service and faints as earth strikes the coffin. From her ghostly vantage, Diana watches her mother, friends, teachers, and the men she distrusts.

The funeral revives a fragment of memory: a man came through her back door, wore black gloves, and forced her to undress. She recognizes Turner and believes he is her killer, but the recollection ends before she can reconstruct what happened afterward.

In the hours around the service, Kelly finally tells police the fuller account of Diana’s complaint. Prior is arrested for Katie Cantor’s murder, while Turner faces renewed questioning and is arrested in connection with Diana.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The funeral gives grief a public ritual, but it does not provide emotional closure. Riley’s collapse makes the burial’s physical reality unbearable, while Diana’s partial memory turns the ceremony into a trigger rather than an ending. Her identification of Turner is understandable but incomplete: trauma returns as a vivid fragment, not a dependable chronology. The parallel arrests create competing forms of apparent resolution, one grounded in a separate murder and one in Diana’s final remembered encounter. The reader must hold suspicion and truth apart.

The Phone Under Evan’s Bed

Riley finds evidence that overturns her suspicion

After the funeral, Riley visits Evan, exhausted and shaken by the arrest of Turner. When she tries to rest in Evan’s room, she notices a bright phone case beneath his bed and recognizes Diana’s missing phone. Evan had insisted he would not contact Diana’s spirit, and Riley now understands why: he already knows who killed her.

She leaves the device untouched and calls emergency services from her own phone. Evan comes upstairs, sees that she has called, and realizes the police are on their way. Sirens approach before he can stop her or conceal the evidence. Riley’s discovery overturns her belief that Turner killed Diana and exposes the friend whose grief journal had seemed to make him the most sympathetic witness.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The phone’s location transforms a private bedroom into the final crime scene of the investigation. Riley’s recognition depends not on forensic expertise but on years of friendship and attention to a familiar object. The reveal also recasts Evan’s diary: its detailed grief had appeared to certify his innocence, when it was instead a carefully controlled performance. His refusal to attempt contact with Diana’s spirit was not simply skepticism; it reflected knowledge he could not risk having tested. Riley’s decision to call rather than confront him preserves the boundary between courage and recklessness.

Evan’s Story Comes Apart

A rejected confession explains the staged killing

In custody, Evan reconstructs what his journal concealed. He had gone to Diana’s house to retrieve Moby Dick and confess his love. When Diana laughed and tried to end the visit, he struck her with the book, then strangled her with her own jump rope.

He changed her phone code, carried her body through the backyard to a waiting vehicle, stripped her clothes to suggest a sexual attack, and buried the clothes and rope, keeping the phone as a trophy. The next day, he wrote as though he were a grieving friend. Police have arrested him; the book ends before a plea or sentence. Ellen abandons the wedding and her plans with Brad, while Brenda must begin life without Diana.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Evan’s violence grows from a collapse between affection and entitlement: he experiences rejection not as another person’s boundary but as an injury that authorizes retaliation. His staged crime exploits familiar assumptions about sexual violence, making investigators look toward a predatory stranger or the boyfriend. The journal extends that deception inward. It lets him inhabit a decent, grieving self while concealing the person who acted. The ending refuses a neat restoration: the murderer is identified, but justice is still pending, and the people who loved Diana must continue with lives permanently altered.

Analysis

What Have You Done? makes a small town’s intimacy double-edged. People know one another’s routines, families, vehicles, and reputations, which helps investigators gather leads, but that same familiarity encourages premature certainty. Cameron’s truck, Prior’s harassment, and Turner’s misconduct each offer a plausible story before they offer proof. The suspense depends on separating evidence from emotional convenience: each suspect is dangerous in a different way, but only one is responsible for Diana’s murder.

The novel also treats secrecy as more than a private habit. Diana conceals Turner’s behavior because she fears disbelief and worries about Cameron’s reaction. Kelly keeps her complaint informal to avoid conflict. Cameron lies to avoid suspicion, while his parents help preserve that lie. Evan’s journal makes concealment the most elaborate form of all, presenting the language of grief while withholding the act that produced it. Across these examples, silence protects the person with more power or the person closest to the speaker, not necessarily the person most at risk.

Diana’s ghostly perspective and the séance story give grief a form that the police investigation cannot provide. The dead girl can witness but cannot intervene; her memory returns in pieces, and even she mistakes a vivid fragment for the whole truth. Riley’s belief in a continuing presence is less a puzzle to solve than an attempt to keep friendship alive after death. The final discovery is therefore both forensic and intimate: Riley recognizes Diana’s phone because she knows her friend, and that recognition breaks through the false account Evan has constructed.

The ending offers identification without repair. Evan is exposed, but the book stops before punishment is settled. Brenda has lost her daughter, Riley and Evan’s friendship has been destroyed, Ellen’s imagined future collapses, and Fairhill must live with the knowledge that familiar faces were not reliable measures of safety. The title’s question finally points beyond the murderer toward every adult and friend who saw enough to worry, yet hesitated to act.

Summary in 60 Seconds
When farmer Roy Ressler discovers seventeen-year-old Diana Brewer dead in a Vermont field, police question her boyfriend Cameron, who lied about returning to her house after an argument. Her friends Riley and Evan reveal Diana planned to leave him, while a customer who stalked her at work becomes another suspect. Diana's mother had also reported unwanted attention from gym teacher Brad Turner, but the school principal concealed the complaint. After Diana's phone sends Riley a threatening message, Riley follows the customer across the Canadian border. He is arrested for another teenager's murder, while Turner is arrested for Diana's. At Diana's funeral, she recalls Turner entering her home, but Riley finds Diana's phone beneath Evan's bed. Evan confesses: he struck Diana with a book, strangled her with her jumprope, staged a sexual attack, and hid the evidence. He is arrested; Diana's mother is left to grieve, and Evan's friend Riley learns the truth.
Contains spoilers

Last updated:

Report Issue

Review Summary

3.75 out of 5
Average of 100k+ ratings from Goodreads and Amazon.

"What Have You Done?" is a fast-paced thriller set in a small Vermont town. Readers found it engaging and easy to read, praising Lapena's ability to keep them guessing. Many appreciated the multiple perspectives and paranormal elements. Some criticized the predictable ending and excessive characters. The book received mixed ratings, with most falling between 3-4 stars. Readers noted it wasn't Lapena's best work but still enjoyed it as a quick, entertaining read. Several reviewers mentioned figuring out the killer early on.

Your rating:
4.38
264 ratings
Want to read the full book?

Characters

Diana Brewer

Fairhill’s bright-hearted runner

Diana is a seventeen-year-old student, a talented runner, and the daughter of Brenda Brewer. She is warm and socially generous, often the person who gathers Riley and Evan into a shared plan. Her ambition to become a veterinarian points toward a life she intends to shape beyond the limits of Fairhill. That kindness does not make her simple or entirely transparent: she keeps painful experiences private and sometimes manages other people’s feelings at the expense of her own. Her relationships reveal a young woman balancing loyalty with a growing need for independence. She wants friendship and love, but she also wants room to choose her own future.

Evan Carr

The observant aspiring writer

Evan is Diana and Riley’s longtime friend, an academically driven teenager who hopes to study English and creative writing. He is more comfortable observing people than competing in sports, and he often processes events by writing privately. His friendship with Diana gives him access to the close-knit group, while his bond with Riley is sharpened by their shared intelligence and academic rivalry. Evan’s home life is strained by a father he resents and a mother who offers him books and quiet support. He is drawn to stories because they let him organize other people’s motives, even when his own feelings are harder to face.

Riley Mead

Diana’s fiercely loyal best friend

Riley has been Diana’s closest friend since childhood. She is bright, competitive, and attentive to details, though she is uncertain about her appearance and often measures herself against others. Her loyalty makes her protective, but it can also make her hesitate to disclose information that might hurt someone in their circle. When crisis strips away the ordinary routines of school and friendship, Riley turns her analytical nature toward the people and clues around her. Her relationship with Evan shifts from friendly academic rivalry toward a deeper shared reliance, while her bond with Diana remains the emotional center of her decisions.

Cameron Farrell

The popular high school athlete

Cameron is a handsome football player and Diana’s first serious boyfriend. He and Evan have been friends since childhood, though their closeness changes as Cameron’s relationship with Diana becomes more consuming. He is affectionate and devoted, but his investment in the couple’s future can become possessive, especially when Diana’s plans do not match his. Cameron is accustomed to being admired and is not skilled at hearing rejection without taking it personally. His relationship with his parents is loving, yet his instinct to hide mistakes places them under pressure to choose between protecting him and facing difficult truths.

Brad Turner

The school’s confident coach

Brad teaches physical education and coaches the cross-country team at Fairhill High. He is engaged to Ellen Ressler and presents himself as an easygoing, supportive teacher. His sense of self depends heavily on being liked and admired, particularly by the young women around him. He is skilled at reframing uncomfortable behavior as harmless friendliness, which lets him avoid examining the imbalance of power between a teacher and a student. His relationship with Ellen gives him a picture of the stable future he wants, while his conduct at school reveals how carefully that self-image can be protected.

Brenda Brewer

Diana’s devoted single mother

Brenda is a nurse who works nights at a hospital outside Fairhill. She raised Diana largely on her own after her husband left, and she takes pride in her daughter’s intelligence, kindness, and independence. Brenda is practical and protective, setting rules around Diana’s work and making sure someone walks her to her car. She believes she and Diana are close, though her daughter’s private troubles do not always reach her. Their relationship is shaped by deep affection and by the difficult tension between a mother’s desire to protect and a teenager’s need to keep some experiences her own.

Paula Acosta

The vigilant English teacher

Paula teaches English at Fairhill High and is Taylor’s mother. She takes her responsibility toward students seriously, expects them to work, and worries about the effects of social media on young people. Her concern for Diana and unease about the school’s handling of student complaints lead her to press Principal Kelly for greater honesty. At home, Paula struggles to distinguish her daughter’s need for privacy from signs that she may need help. She is perceptive about institutional failures, but must learn that being an attentive parent does not mean she automatically knows what her child is enduring.

Graham Kelly

Fairhill High’s conflict-averse principal

Graham Kelly is the principal of Fairhill High and the father of Sadie and two other teenagers. He is often harried by school and family pressures, but he tries to appear measured and fair. His instinct is to avoid conflict and keep problems from spreading, a habit that shapes how he responds when a student raises a serious concern. He trusts his own judgment and is uncomfortable when the evidence challenges it. His friendship with Paula gives him someone willing to confront him, while his responsibilities to students and staff expose the cost of choosing institutional calm over documented accountability.

Taylor Acosta

Paula’s guarded teenage daughter

Taylor is thirteen and attends the high school where her mother teaches. She is increasingly private with Paula, spends much of her time alone, and is sensitive to the social pressure of having a parent on staff. Her quietness is easy for adults to mistake for ordinary teenage distance. She wants control over what others know about her, while also needing the protection she is not yet sure how to ask for. Her relationship with Paula reflects a common adolescent bind: the wish to be independent can make it harder to seek help when school becomes unsafe.

Ellen Ressler

Brad’s devoted fiancée

Ellen is Roy and Susan Ressler’s daughter, a bakery worker with a college education and plans for a career in early childhood education. She is engaged to Brad and has imagined a home and future with him. Optimistic by temperament, she tries to interpret his guardedness generously and believes people deserve a fair hearing. Her parents’ doubts about the marriage unsettle her, but she does not want to abandon a life she has already begun planning. Ellen’s struggle centers on the difference between loyalty to a partner and loyalty to her own judgment.

Joe Prior

The unsettling Home Depot customer

Joe Prior is a construction worker who moves between jobs and lives alone in Fairhill. At Home Depot, he repeatedly seeks Diana’s attention despite her discomfort, and he does not seem to recognize her right to refuse it. He is wary of scrutiny and easily resentful when other people challenge him. His rough manner and solitary habits make him an obvious focus for suspicion, but a person’s unsettling presence is not proof of a particular crime. Joe’s role tests the difference between a genuine warning sign and evidence strong enough to establish what happened.

Edward Farrell

Cameron’s protective father

Edward is Cameron’s father and Shelby’s husband. He wants to be a steady presence for his son, especially when Cameron is grieving and under police scrutiny. His protective instinct initially reassures Cameron, but it also tempts Edward to keep information from investigators. He is forced to confront the difference between supporting a child and shielding him from consequences. Edward’s anxiety grows from a belief that his family can endure a crisis if they manage it privately, a belief that becomes harder to sustain as the investigation uncovers more omissions.

Shelby Farrell

Cameron’s fiercely protective mother

Shelby is Cameron’s mother and Edward’s wife. She has doted on her only child and takes pride in his athletic success and popularity. After noticing that Cameron came home later than he told police, she wrestles with whether a mother’s loyalty requires silence or honesty. Her instinct is to explain away his behavior as ordinary teenage rule-breaking, but her fear makes that reassurance unstable. Shelby’s relationship with Cameron reveals how parental love can make inconvenient evidence feel less real, even to a person who senses that something is wrong.

Roy Ressler

The farmer who finds Diana

Roy is an experienced farmer, volunteer firefighter, and father of Ellen. His morning work takes him into the field where he discovers Diana. He reacts by keeping the vultures away and guiding police to the body. Roy is practical and protective of his land, but the discovery makes the danger in Fairhill personal through his concern for his daughter.

Sadie Kelly

The principal’s rebellious daughter

Sadie is Principal Kelly’s daughter and one of the teenagers who takes part in Diana’s homemade séance. At school, she has social influence and sometimes uses it cruelly, including against Taylor. Her behavior reflects a young person testing the protection and power that come with being the principal’s child.

Detective Stone

The persistent Major Crimes investigator

Stone is a Vermont State Police Major Crimes detective assigned to investigate Diana’s murder. He interviews students, parents, and staff without treating any single account as conclusive. His questions about timelines, missing objects, and changing alibis steadily narrow the field of possibilities. He is patient with grieving witnesses but persistent when they withhold information.

Detective Godfrey

Stone’s methodical investigative partner

Godfrey is Stone’s partner in the Major Crimes investigation. She assists with interviews and evidence review, offering a calm presence to witnesses who are frightened or grieving. Her work helps turn scattered statements into a case the detectives can test.

Plot Devices

Evan’s journal and shifting viewpoints

Conceals the narrator’s truth

The story moves among the perspectives of Fairhill residents, Diana’s disembodied observations, and Evan’s private journal entries. The journal initially reads as a grieving teenager’s attempt to make sense of a friend’s murder. Its detailed observations make the reader feel close to the investigation while also limiting what can be trusted. When the narrative later reveals what Evan has hidden, the diary becomes an instrument of self-deception as well as deception of the reader. It shows how a narrator can record real emotion while omitting the action that gives those emotions their darkest meaning.

Diana’s missing phone

A trophy becomes evidence

Diana’s absent phone frustrates police because it could contain messages and help reconstruct her final hours. When a reply arrives from her number, the device becomes an active threat to Riley and confirms that someone has kept it. Its later discovery beneath Evan’s bed gives Riley a concrete reason to call the police. The phone binds the private intimacy of Diana’s friendships to the physical evidence of the crime, and its journey from the murder scene to Evan’s room exposes the distance between his performed grief and his actions.

The missing jump rope

A household object hides violence

Brenda notices that Diana’s jump rope is missing from its usual place in the living room. The absence suggests that the murder may have happened inside the Brewer home, not in the field where Roy found the body. It also links the familiar domestic setting to a weapon that would not immediately appear suspicious in a teenager’s house. The jump rope’s ordinary purpose contrasts with its use in the crime, while its removal with Diana’s clothes helps explain why investigators initially lack decisive physical evidence.

Home Depot surveillance footage

A face creates a false lead

Store cameras capture Joe Prior repeatedly approaching Diana’s checkout and continuing to engage her after his purchase is complete. The footage corroborates her discomfort and gives detectives a recognizable image of the customer who bothered her. Yet the cameras do not show the parking lot or identify his vehicle, leaving a gap between harassment and murder. The footage gives investigators a legitimate lead while also encouraging the community and Riley to leap from threatening behavior to certainty about Diana’s killer.

The homemade spirit board

Grief searches for contact

Diana, Riley, and Sadie make a séance board from paper letters and an overturned wineglass. The spirit identifies himself as Simon, a twelve-year-old boy from Fairhill, and Riley later finds a grave matching his name and dates. The episode gives Riley a reason to imagine that the dead may remain near the living, shaping her hope that Diana might somehow reveal her killer. The scene never provides a simple explanation of whether the glass moved through supernatural force or the girls’ influence, preserving the story’s uncertainty around belief and loss.

FAQ

Synopsis & Basic Details

What is What Have You Done? about?

  • Small town, big crime: The story centers on the murder of a young woman, Diana Brewer, in the seemingly peaceful town of Fairhill, Vermont, and the subsequent investigation that uncovers hidden secrets and complex relationships within the community.
  • Unreliable narrators, shifting perspectives: The narrative explores the perspectives of various characters, including Diana's friends, family, and potential suspects, revealing their individual biases and motivations as the truth behind her death is slowly revealed.
  • Psychological thriller, suspenseful plot: The novel is a suspenseful psychological thriller that focuses on the emotional impact of the crime on the community and the unraveling of the truth through a series of twists and turns.

Why should I read What Have You Done??

  • Intricate plot, suspenseful pacing: Shari Lapena masterfully crafts a suspenseful plot with unexpected twists and turns, keeping readers engaged and guessing until the very end.
  • Complex characters, hidden motivations: The novel features a cast of complex characters with hidden motivations and secrets, making it a compelling exploration of human nature and the darkness that can lie beneath the surface.
  • Exploration of community, social dynamics: The story delves into the dynamics of a small town, highlighting the impact of a crime on the community and the way it exposes the hidden tensions and secrets within.

What is the background of What Have You Done??

  • Rural Vermont setting: The story is set in the fictional small town of Fairhill, Vermont, a rural community surrounded by farmland and mountains, which creates a sense of isolation and amplifies the impact of the crime.
  • Contemporary context, social media: The novel is set in a contemporary time, with references to social media and technology, which play a role in the lives of the characters and the spread of information.
  • Small-town dynamics, interconnected lives: The story explores the dynamics of a close-knit community where everyone knows everyone else, and how a crime can disrupt the sense of safety and trust.

What are the most memorable quotes in What Have You Done??

  • "Nothing ever happens in sleepy little Fairhill, Vermont. Until it does.": This opening line sets the stage for the story, highlighting the contrast between the town's peaceful facade and the shocking events that unfold.
  • "She's been strangled...With what, though? And where are her clothes?": This quote underscores the brutality of the crime and the mystery surrounding it, emphasizing the lack of clues and the unsettling nature of the discovery.
  • "It's quite possible that it was someone that she knew.": This line foreshadows the revelation that the killer is someone close to Diana, adding to the suspense and highlighting the betrayal at the heart of the story.

What writing style, narrative choices, and literary techniques does Shari Lapena use?

  • Multiple perspectives, shifting viewpoints: Lapena employs a multi-perspective narrative, shifting between the viewpoints of various characters, which creates suspense and allows readers to see the events from different angles.
  • Foreshadowing, subtle clues: The author uses subtle foreshadowing and clues throughout the story, which keeps readers guessing and adds to the suspenseful atmosphere.
  • Psychological realism, emotional depth: Lapena focuses on the psychological tension and emotional states of her characters, creating a sense of realism and allowing readers to connect with their inner conflicts and motivations.

Hidden Details & Subtle Connections

What are some minor details that add significant meaning?

  • The jump rope, a symbol of innocence lost: The detail of Diana's jump rope, usually hanging on her doorknob, being missing after her death, becomes a significant clue, later revealed to be the murder weapon, symbolizing the loss of her innocence and the brutality of her death.
  • The black leather gloves, a sign of premeditation: The detail of the black leather gloves worn by the killer, as remembered by Diana, highlights the premeditated nature of the crime and the coldness of the perpetrator.
  • The abandoned road, a hidden path: The mention of an abandoned road near the field where Diana's body was found, a place known to Cameron, becomes a crucial detail, suggesting a planned route for the killer to transport her body.

What are some subtle foreshadowing and callbacks?

  • The vultures, a grim omen: The opening scene with the vultures circling over Roy Ressler's field foreshadows the discovery of Diana's body and the grim events that follow, creating a sense of unease from the beginning.
  • The ghost stories, a hint of the supernatural: The characters' discussion of ghost stories and the local legend of Emily at the covered bridge foreshadows the later revelation of Diana's spirit and the possibility of a supernatural presence.
  • Cameron's possessiveness, a warning sign: Cameron's possessive behavior towards Diana, constantly touching her and following her, foreshadows his controlling nature and his potential for violence, which is later revealed.

What are some unexpected character connections?

  • Brad Turner and the Ressler family: The connection between Brad Turner and the Ressler family, through his engagement to their daughter Ellen, adds a layer of complexity to the story, as it places him in close proximity to the location where Diana's body was found.
  • Joe Prior and Katie Cantor: The revelation that Joe Prior was previously questioned in connection with the disappearance of Katie Cantor, another young woman, creates a chilling parallel and suggests a pattern of behavior.
  • Graham Kelly and Cally Desjardins: The revelation of Graham Kelly's affair with Cally Desjardins, a young teacher, adds a layer of complexity to his character and highlights his hypocrisy, as he is also the one who is supposed to be protecting the students.

Who are the most significant supporting characters?

  • Shelby and Edward Farrell, Cameron's parents: Cameron's parents, Shelby and Edward, are significant supporting characters, as their reactions to the investigation and their attempts to protect their son reveal the complexities of parental love and denial.
  • Sadie Kelly, a minor character with major impact: Sadie Kelly, Principal Kelly's daughter, is a minor character, but her role in bullying Taylor and her presence at the Ouija board session with Diana and Riley, adds to the complexity of the story.
  • Rodney Donnelly, a false alibi: Rodney Donnelly, Joe Prior's friend, is a significant supporting character, as his false alibi for Prior becomes a crucial element in the investigation and highlights the deception surrounding Diana's death.

Psychological, Emotional, & Relational Analysis

What are some unspoken motivations of the characters?

  • Evan's unrequited love, a hidden motive: Evan's unspoken love for Diana and his jealousy of Cameron are revealed as the underlying motivations for his actions, highlighting the destructive power of unrequited feelings.
  • Brad's desire for control, a dark secret: Brad's unspoken desire for control over his students, particularly the young girls, is revealed as a key aspect of his character, highlighting his predatory nature and his need for power.
  • Kelly's fear of exposure, a driving force: Graham Kelly's unspoken fear of exposure and the potential damage to his career and reputation drive his actions, leading him to cover up Diana's complaint and ultimately contribute to the tragedy.

What psychological complexities do the characters exhibit?

  • Cameron's possessiveness, a sign of insecurity: Cameron's possessiveness and controlling behavior towards Diana reveal his deep-seated insecurities and his inability to cope with the idea of losing her.
  • Brenda's grief, a mix of emotions: Brenda's grief is portrayed as a complex mix of sadness, anger, guilt, and a desperate need to connect with her deceased daughter, highlighting the psychological tension of loss.
  • Riley's anxiety, a manifestation of trauma: Riley's anxiety and her obsession with finding Diana's killer reveal the psychological tension of the trauma she has experienced, as she struggles to cope with the loss of her best friend.

What are the major emotional turning points?

  • Riley's discovery of the phone, a turning point: Riley's discovery of Diana's phone under Evan's bed is a major emotional turning point, as it shatters her trust in her friend and forces her to confront the truth about his involvement in Diana's death.
  • Ellen's reading of the file, a moment of truth: Ellen's reading of the file detailing Diana's complaint against Brad is a major emotional turning point, as it forces her to confront the possibility that her fiancé is not who she thought he was.
  • Edward's realization of Cameron's lies, a moment of despair: Edward's realization that Cameron has been lying to him about his whereabouts on the night of Diana's murder is a major emotional turning point, as it shatters his belief in his son's innocence and leads him to question everything.

How do relationship dynamics evolve?

  • Riley and Evan's friendship, a betrayal of trust: The relationship between Riley and Evan evolves from a close friendship to a deep betrayal, as Riley discovers that Evan is the murderer, highlighting the fragility of trust and the devastating impact of deception.
  • Ellen and Brad's engagement, a shattered illusion: The relationship between Ellen and Brad evolves from a seemingly loving engagement to a shattered illusion, as Ellen is forced to confront the truth about Brad's inappropriate behavior and his potential involvement in Diana's death.
  • Brenda and Lee's marriage, a history of neglect: The relationship between Brenda and her ex-husband, Lee, is revealed as a history of neglect and emotional distance, highlighting the impact of their failed marriage on their daughter's life.

Interpretation & Debate

Which parts of the story remain ambiguous or open-ended?

  • The extent of Brad's inappropriate behavior: The extent of Brad Turner's inappropriate behavior towards his students remains somewhat ambiguous, as the story leaves it open to interpretation whether he was a predator or simply made some bad choices.
  • The nature of Diana's spirit: The nature of Diana's spirit and her ability to communicate with the living remains ambiguous, leaving it open to interpretation whether her presence is real or a manifestation of the characters' grief and guilt.
  • The full truth of Cameron's actions: The full truth of Cameron's actions on the night of Diana's death remains somewhat ambiguous, as the story leaves it open to interpretation whether he was simply trying to cover up his lies or if he was more involved in her death.

What are some debatable, controversial scenes or moments in What Have You Done??

  • The Ouija board scene, a question of belief: The scene where Riley, Diana, and Sadie use a homemade Ouija board to contact spirits is a debatable moment, as it raises questions about the supernatural and the characters' beliefs in the afterlife.
  • The handling of Diana's complaint, a moral dilemma: The way Principal Kelly handles Diana's complaint against Brad Turner is a controversial moment, as it raises questions about his responsibility to protect his students and the consequences of his inaction.
  • The ending, a question of justice: The ending, with Evan's arrest, is a debatable moment, as it leaves readers to ponder whether justice has truly been served and whether the characters will ever be able to fully recover from the tragedy.

What Have You Done? Ending Explained: How It Ends & What It Means

  • Evan's arrest, a shocking revelation: The ending reveals that Evan Carr, Diana's friend, is the murderer, a shocking twist that subverts expectations and highlights the darkness that can lie beneath the surface of seemingly ordinary individuals.
  • Turner's downfall, a consequence of actions: The ending sees Brad Turner arrested for Diana's murder, a consequence of his inappropriate behavior and the lies he told, highlighting the importance of accountability and the impact of unchecked desires.
  • Community's grief, a lasting impact: The ending leaves the community grappling with the aftermath of the tragedy, highlighting the lasting impact of violence and the importance of truth and justice in the face of loss.

About the Author

Shari Lapena is a Canadian author known for her psychological thrillers. She has written eight novels, with "What Have You Done?" being her latest. Lapena's writing style is characterized by fast-paced narratives, multiple perspectives, and twist endings. Her books often explore themes of domestic suspense and small-town secrets. Lapena's debut novel, "The Couple Next Door," was well-received, and she has since established herself as a prominent figure in the thriller genre. Readers appreciate her ability to create compelling, page-turning stories, though some note a formulaic approach in her later works.

Download PDF

To save this What Have You Done? summary for later, download the free PDF. You can print it out, or read offline at your convenience.
Download PDF
File size: 0.45 MB     Pages: 29

Download EPUB

To read this What Have You Done? summary on your e-reader device or app, download the free EPUB. The .epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.
Download EPUB
File size: 1.43 MB     Pages: 41
Want to read the full book?
Follow
Listen
Home
Swipe
Library
Get App
Try Full Access for 3 Days
Listen, bookmark, and more
Compare Features Free Pro
📖 Read Summaries
Read unlimited summaries. Free users get 3 per month
🎧 Listen to Summaries
Listen to unlimited summaries in 40 languages
—
❤️ Unlimited Bookmarks
Free users are limited to 4
—
📜 Unlimited History
Free users are limited to 4
—
📥 Unlimited Downloads
Free users are limited to 1
—
Risk-Free Timeline
Today: Get Instant Access
Listen to full summaries of 26,000+ books. That's 12,000+ hours of audio!
Day 2: Trial Reminder
We'll send you a notification that your trial is ending soon.
Day 3: Your subscription begins
You'll be charged on Nov 25,
cancel anytime before.
Consume 2.8× More Books
2.8× more books Listening Reading
Our users love us
1M+ readers
Trustpilot Rating
TrustPilot
4.6 Excellent
This site is a total game-changer. I've been flying through book summaries like never before. Highly, highly recommend.
— Dave G
Worth my money and time, and really well made. I've never seen this quality of summaries on other websites. Very helpful!
— Em
Highly recommended!! Fantastic service. Perfect for those that want a little more than a teaser but not all the intricate details of a full audio book.
— Greg M
Save 62%
Yearly
$119.88 $44.99/year/yr
$3.75/mo
Monthly
$9.99/mo
Start a 3-Day Free Trial
3 days free, then $44.99/year. Cancel anytime.
Unlock a world of fiction & nonfiction books
26,000+ books for the price of 2 books
Read any book in 10 minutes
Discover new books like Tinder
Request any book if it's not summarized
Read more books than anyone you know
#1 app for book lovers
Lifelike & immersive summaries
30-day money-back guarantee
Download summaries in EPUBs or PDFs
Cancel anytime in a few clicks

Why one summary?

Scanner
Find a barcode to scan

⭐
⭐
⭐
We have a special gift for you
Open
38% off
DISCOUNT FOR YOU
⭐
⭐
⭐
$79.99
$49.99/year
Only $4.16 per month
Continue
2 taps to start, super easy to cancel
Settings
General
Widget
Loading...